You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gender and sexuality
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gender and sexuality


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
johnfirewall Flag 24 Mar 16 5.11pm

Meta-identitary

 

johnfirewall Flag 29 Mar 16 1.44pm

I predict it will soon be a more managable acronym when they drop the G due to homosexual males no longer needing representation as an oppressed minority.

[Link]

 

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Mar 16 1.58pm

Being not your typical lefty teacher at secondary school I often get a little pissed off with the assumptions that other teachers make about what students to be encouraged to believe in.

They don't want independent thinkers what they want are conventional liberalised thinkers. I feel the emphasis is well intended but wrong.

Teachers teach equality but few actually practice in within their self interested lives. Also the teaching of equality as being 'right' is dubious because equality doesn't exist anywhere in the natural or most of the commercial world or relationships.

They teach sexual equality and gender equality, which as a parent I'd also be a bit pissed off about. These are highly sociopolitical concepts.

I don't like social engineering within the secondary school system or at least feel it should be light touch....It's really a job for parents not teachers.

But feck it....it isn't going to change and if you can't beat them, join them, so recently I'm been considering doing my own social engineering with my classes.


Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Mar 2016 2.01pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Mar 16 2.34pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Being not your typical lefty teacher at secondary school I often get a little pissed off with the assumptions that other teachers make about what students to be encouraged to believe in.

They don't want independent thinkers what they want are conventional liberalised thinkers. I feel the emphasis is well intended but wrong.

Teachers teach equality but few actually practice in within their self interested lives. Also the teaching of equality as being 'right' is dubious because equality doesn't exist anywhere in the natural or most of the commercial world or relationships.

They teach sexual equality and gender equality, which as a parent I'd also be a bit pissed off about. These are highly sociopolitical concepts.

I don't like social engineering within the secondary school system or at least feel it should be light touch....It's really a job for parents not teachers.

But feck it....it isn't going to change and if you can't beat them, join them, so recently I'm been considering doing my own social engineering with my classes.


Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Mar 2016 2.01pm)

Equality is unachievable, its an ideal and a hypothetical concept. However, the concept of equality does underpin a basic rule of human society - and that has been the desire of people to collectively obtain rights denied them by others. Ethically, its hard to deny the idea that people should defended inequality. The pursuit of equality is really the pursuit of social justice and freedom to decide for ones self, rather than have decisions made.

As for social engineering, its ever present, in all things. Its just that some social engineering is accepted as being 'the norm' or natural, whilst other forms of engineering are aimed at changing what is considered the norm or natural. Education in schools is the embodiment of the idea of social engineering - and it always has been.

Its interesting when you hear some of the complaints of the intersex, who object to the decisions their parents made on their behalf, to determine their gender. Its very valid, who are we to actually decide whether someone who is born intersex takes on the characteristics of 'male' or 'female'. I understand why parents do it, and probably think very little of it, but should it be their decision to make?

Why do we feel the need, in cases where children are intersex to make a decision that medically isn't necessary.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Mar 16 3.41pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Equality is unachievable, its an ideal and a hypothetical concept. However, the concept of equality does underpin a basic rule of human society - and that has been the desire of people to collectively obtain rights denied them by others. Ethically, its hard to deny the idea that people should defended inequality. The pursuit of equality is really the pursuit of social justice and freedom to decide for ones self, rather than have decisions made.

As for social engineering, its ever present, in all things. Its just that some social engineering is accepted as being 'the norm' or natural, whilst other forms of engineering are aimed at changing what is considered the norm or natural. Education in schools is the embodiment of the idea of social engineering - and it always has been.

Its interesting when you hear some of the complaints of the intersex, who object to the decisions their parents made on their behalf, to determine their gender. Its very valid, who are we to actually decide whether someone who is born intersex takes on the characteristics of 'male' or 'female'. I understand why parents do it, and probably think very little of it, but should it be their decision to make?

Why do we feel the need, in cases where children are intersex to make a decision that medically isn't necessary.

Equality is achievable as a concept if you have control over the system you apply it to. For example, equal pay for tennis players independent of gender despite the gender realities and expectations being different for both genders. So, in effect, equality being applied to an unequal system - men play five sets and women three - men attract more gate money yet their pay doesn't reflect it. Sometimes equality is ideological and unfair.

I don't defend equality as a 'correct' concept without defining factors. I regard it as a concept that has a limited but important usage within the areas it can be applied sensibly......unfortunately that approach isn't in current fashion within teaching....despite being the real world approach adopted within the majority of the commercial world and say human interactions.

Also I say again equality doesn't exist within the natural world and while I'm not averse to modifying nature to suit our own purposes...eg medicines and many other examples I do feel that it has to defend and prove its application without blindly being applied without consideration of rational opposition.

Men's children access rights, the law's attitude to rape and divorce, Women in military front lines, homosexual marriage within churches, the MOBOs identifying race as an originator of a music style....organizations that include a race within the title......All of these are examples where equality may or may not have a place within application.

Obviously equality has its place in the adoption of 'real world' human rights....But sometimes I feel this has been abused...like the word, 'assault' legally meaning practically anything.

Essentially, while I do value equality in many areas....to list them would lengthen this post significantly but to encapsulate I essentially believe that equality doesn't have a divine right to be adopted for everything and that it's a concept like any other that has to prove itself in every case it's applied.

School should push.....think independently....regard each situation on its factors....Defend your position rationally.

Instead when it comes to equality it's all......'Equality is good', smiley face.....It gets on my nerves.

Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Mar 2016 3.44pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Mar 16 3.57pm

I agree, to an extent, equality is something that must be earned, rather than just given. I don't think you can simply state that x is equal to y. X must demonstrate its right to be regarded as equal, otherwise you end up in a nightmare of trying to catagorise and legislate unnecessarily.

The law should reflect these rights and social justices only as they apply to the law. The equal pay act for example, makes sense, because it addresses a fundermental unfairness in society based on gender of all people.

Situations where 'mens tennis pays more' is driven by wider social dynamics, and its down to those involved in the sport to push the envelope and sporting body towards that ideal - not for the stage to step in and demand it. Here in the situation applies only to a small subset of gender, and factors such as commercial demand, popularity, sponsorship etc factor into the equation - Notably as well some women tennis players earn more than some men and the job they do is different.

I know that sounds a bit 'washy' but I think there is difference between the Equal Pay act and payments in sporting competitions.

I'd like to see a situation where women's football is as popular as men's football.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Mar 16 4.13pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I agree, to an extent, equality is something that must be earned, rather than just given. I don't think you can simply state that x is equal to y. X must demonstrate its right to be regarded as equal, otherwise you end up in a nightmare of trying to catagorise and legislate unnecessarily.

The law should reflect these rights and social justices only as they apply to the law. The equal pay act for example, makes sense, because it addresses a fundermental unfairness in society based on gender of all people.

Situations where 'mens tennis pays more' is driven by wider social dynamics, and its down to those involved in the sport to push the envelope and sporting body towards that ideal - not for the stage to step in and demand it. Here in the situation applies only to a small subset of gender, and factors such as commercial demand, popularity, sponsorship etc factor into the equation - Notably as well some women tennis players earn more than some men and the job they do is different.

I know that sounds a bit 'washy' but I think there is difference between the Equal Pay act and payments in sporting competitions.

I'd like to see a situation where women's football is as popular as men's football.

I don't think it's important that women's football is as popular as men's. I think women's football has a right to promote itself and that the public has a right to respond to the promotion. The balance of pay should reflect the interest gathered.

It shouldn't be about the gender or changing social attitudes within society.

The highest paid fighters in MMA (mixed martial arts) are women and that's fine and dandy. What they sell attracts the punters and the pay reflects that. I don't see male MMA stars moaning about it and nor should they.

The pay you earn should reflect the value you give to the person or organization paying you. Your gender is a sub note. If it helps you, great, if it doesn't tough cheese...chose another profession if you don't like it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Mar 16 4.23pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I don't think it's important that women's football is as popular as men's. I think women's football has a right to promote itself and that the public has a right to respond to the promotion. The balance of pay should reflect the interest gathered.

Me neither, I'd just like that to be the case, not that it should be. Women's football has come a long way in the last 10 years, and increasingly garnering fans and supporters (and income).

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It shouldn't be about the gender or changing social attitudes within society.

I don't think the two are ever separate, the rise in female rights and the rise of female empowerment / feminist movements and changes in attitude in society are so closely entwined as to be inseparable.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The highest paid fighters in MMA (mixed martial arts) are women and that's fine and dandy. What they sell attracts the punters and the pay reflects that. I don't see male MMA stars moaning about it and nor should they.

Quite agree, the sports and demographics are very different - and notably they're gender separated. Now if a woman entered the mens MMA and became champion, I wouldn't want to see her paid less for doing so.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The pay you earn should reflect the value you give to the person or organization paying you. Your gender is a sub note. If it helps you, great, if it doesn't tough cheese...chose another profession if you don't like it.

It should, but it doesn't.

I don't think its acceptable to pay someone less to do the same job because of their gender, sexual orientation / race etc. And by less, I mean a different pay grade (obviously you have to factor in for individual experience, the person I replace may well be paid less than me, or more for non-gender reasons).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Mar 16 1.33pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I don't think it's important that women's football is as popular as men's. I think women's football has a right to promote itself and that the public has a right to respond to the promotion. The balance of pay should reflect the interest gathered.

It shouldn't be about the gender or changing social attitudes within society.

The highest paid fighters in MMA (mixed martial arts) are women and that's fine and dandy. What they sell attracts the punters and the pay reflects that. I don't see male MMA stars moaning about it and nor should they.

The pay you earn should reflect the value you give to the person or organization paying you. Your gender is a sub note. If it helps you, great, if it doesn't tough cheese...chose another profession if you don't like it.

They aren't.

What you mean is Ronda Rousey for a very short period (a fight or two) got the most contracted pay, which makes up the smallest part of the overall pay.

She is not even in the top 50 for highest earners from UFC.

 


Optimistic as ever

coulsdoneagle Flag London 30 Mar 16 1.51pm

I realise I'm a couple of pages late to the party, was reading a discussion about teaching kids in school between Jamie and Stuk

I don't get why anyone would delay teaching kids about things like gender and sexuality. If they are learning that people have mummys and daddys they should be learning that some people have two mums or two dads etc.

By waiting till secondary school or till they have learnt what they perceive as 'normal' you are then abnormalising something completely normal. They are learning that these things directly counter what they understand and have done from such a young age.

Do I think kids should be forced to be educated in things like these to keep them as open minded as possible? Absolutely, I also think they should be forced to learn maths and English, am I forcing too much on kids stuk?

By the way I'm not talking about having classes on what a Trans person is, I'm just talking about not making it anything but normal. If your headmaster is Gay then he should be free when telling kids anecdotes as teachers do, to mention his husband or whatever. If they have questions, then they should be answered.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 30 Mar 16 2.03pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I agree, to an extent, equality is something that must be earned, rather than just given. I don't think you can simply state that x is equal to y. X must demonstrate its right to be regarded as equal, otherwise you end up in a nightmare of trying to catagorise and legislate unnecessarily.

The law should reflect these rights and social justices only as they apply to the law. The equal pay act for example, makes sense, because it addresses a fundermental unfairness in society based on gender of all people.

Situations where 'mens tennis pays more' is driven by wider social dynamics, and its down to those involved in the sport to push the envelope and sporting body towards that ideal - not for the stage to step in and demand it. Here in the situation applies only to a small subset of gender, and factors such as commercial demand, popularity, sponsorship etc factor into the equation - Notably as well some women tennis players earn more than some men and the job they do is different.

I know that sounds a bit 'washy' but I think there is difference between the Equal Pay act and payments in sporting competitions.

I'd like to see a situation where women's football is as popular as men's football.

Heaven f*cking forbid.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Mar 16 2.41pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

I realise I'm a couple of pages late to the party, was reading a discussion about teaching kids in school between Jamie and Stuk

I don't get why anyone would delay teaching kids about things like gender and sexuality. If they are learning that people have mummys and daddys they should be learning that some people have two mums or two dads etc.

By waiting till secondary school or till they have learnt what they perceive as 'normal' you are then abnormalising something completely normal. They are learning that these things directly counter what they understand and have done from such a young age.

Do I think kids should be forced to be educated in things like these to keep them as open minded as possible? Absolutely, I also think they should be forced to learn maths and English, am I forcing too much on kids stuk?

By the way I'm not talking about having classes on what a Trans person is, I'm just talking about not making it anything but normal. If your headmaster is Gay then he should be free when telling kids anecdotes as teachers do, to mention his husband or whatever. If they have questions, then they should be answered.

But that's what Jamie and I were talking about and what the whole topic started with.

Nowadays primary school kids, for the most, are well aware there are gay couples. Maths and English will still be more important at that age though, as we all need them at that age.

And the parents should still have the choice of what additional things they're told/taught until secondary school IMO. This is the case when it comes to being taught/told about religion so to say that parents don't, or shouldn't, have any say over their kid's education is false.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Mar 16 4.17pm

Originally posted by Stuk

But that's what Jamie and I were talking about and what the whole topic started with.

Nowadays primary school kids, for the most, are well aware there are gay couples. Maths and English will still be more important at that age though, as we all need them at that age.

And the parents should still have the choice of what additional things they're told/taught until secondary school IMO. This is the case when it comes to being taught/told about religion so to say that parents don't, or shouldn't, have any say over their kid's education is false.

With greater reflection and thought, I also ended up agreeing with stuk.

I do find it odd that people wouldn't teach their children about more than just men and women, husbands and wives, but would teach them about a virgin birth the necessity of slowly torturing animals to death or slicing off foreskins for god. But c'est la vie, We all have to get along.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Mar 16 4.39pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

With greater reflection and thought, I also ended up agreeing with stuk.

I do find it odd that people wouldn't teach their children about more than just men and women, husbands and wives, but would teach them about a virgin birth the necessity of slowly torturing animals to death or slicing off foreskins for god. But c'est la vie, We all have to get along.

I belatedly saw that when this brought it back to the top.

 


Optimistic as ever

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 30 Mar 16 6.39pm

I'm not a fan of the word 'normal' in the context of educating children about diversity.

I haven't met a transgender person in my life. To say that experiencing feelings of being 'trapped' in a body of the wrong sex is not in my opinion 'normal'. I would say that it is a sign of being mentally dysfunctional.

Being gay is different. It is fundamentally about sexual attraction, a primal instinct that is shared by animals. Nor, according to studies is same-sex attraction confined to humans.

Transgenderism isn't in my view normal. As we are told every day by the experts and liberal proselytes, gender is a human construct. Certain, behavioural characteristics are associated with it. Therefore, I think that teaching children about transgenderism specifically at any stage of their schooling isn't necessary. With the internet they'll find out about it anyway.

What must be taught is a fundamental respect for the diversity in experiences and feelings that others have and that others must be treated with dignity and respect.

I personally think trans people need love and compassion. That can take many, many forms I'm not suggesting a particular one. But honestly, if you found out a girl/guy you thought looked alright was in fact trans would you still be interested. I think from about 95% of straight people, the honest answer/thought would be 'no'.

This last point is perhaps redundant, but would those people be transphobic because of their feeling? Surely not, because a person's biological sex has nothing to do with 'gender' (so we're told) so for example a transgender woman who is attracted to men is still technically homosexual.

Sorry for all my nonsense, it's probably pointless and boring.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Mar 16 7.32pm

Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles

I'm not a fan of the word 'normal' in the context of educating children about diversity.

I haven't met a transgender person in my life. To say that experiencing feelings of being 'trapped' in a body of the wrong sex is not in my opinion 'normal'. I would say that it is a sign of being mentally dysfunctional.

Being gay is different. It is fundamentally about sexual attraction, a primal instinct that is shared by animals. Nor, according to studies is same-sex attraction confined to humans.

Transgenderism isn't in my view normal. As we are told every day by the experts and liberal proselytes, gender is a human construct. Certain, behavioural characteristics are associated with it. Therefore, I think that teaching children about transgenderism specifically at any stage of their schooling isn't necessary. With the internet they'll find out about it anyway.

What must be taught is a fundamental respect for the diversity in experiences and feelings that others have and that others must be treated with dignity and respect.

I personally think trans people need love and compassion. That can take many, many forms I'm not suggesting a particular one. But honestly, if you found out a girl/guy you thought looked alright was in fact trans would you still be interested. I think from about 95% of straight people, the honest answer/thought would be 'no'.

This last point is perhaps redundant, but would those people be transphobic because of their feeling? Surely not, because a person's biological sex has nothing to do with 'gender' (so we're told) so for example a transgender woman who is attracted to men is still technically homosexual.

Sorry for all my nonsense, it's probably pointless and boring.

Ignorance on a scale.

Kids who are born with too many 'bits' have to be assigned a gender before their 20th month or summat. The peeps involved do what they can to get it right and place the child under a 'male' or 'female' heading but they aren't infallible. They get it wrong sometimes.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


coulsdoneagle Flag London 30 Mar 16 8.24pm

Originally posted by Stuk

But that's what Jamie and I were talking about and what the whole topic started with.

Nowadays primary school kids, for the most, are well aware there are gay couples. Maths and English will still be more important at that age though, as we all need them at that age.

And the parents should still have the choice of what additional things they're told/taught until secondary school IMO. This is the case when it comes to being taught/told about religion so to say that parents don't, or shouldn't, have any say over their kid's education is false.

Have to say I disagree with you about the role of parents as sole decision makers in educating kids on things like religion and sexuality.

Bigot parents tend to breed bigot kids. I think that no matter what the age, if parents are saying gays are wrong and Muslims are bad there should be education in school that can counter that and inform people about religions and sexuality so the kids have more of a chance to grow with different opinions rather than having their views shaped by wrong views.

I speak from experience having worked in schools about the fact that you can make a pretty good judgement about a kids parents just by how the kid talks about certain things. I have heard 6 year olds repeat casually racist and homophobic statements because of things heard at home. Sometimes it's as seemingly innocuous as calling a kid gay, other time it's worse referring to brown kids as bloody pa*is. I think there needs to be a way to mediate what they take in at that age.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 30 Mar 16 9.24pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Ignorance on a scale.

Kids who are born with too many 'bits' have to be assigned a gender before their 20th month or summat. The peeps involved do what they can to get it right and place the child under a 'male' or 'female' heading but they aren't infallible. They get it wrong sometimes.

I am ignorant I think only as to what ignorant on a scale means.

You Sir are either ignorant of what I was describing, or attempting humour on a level I am ignorant (gettit!?) of.

You seem to be referring in your reply to my ignorance of the lives and rights of intersex people (formally known as hermaphrodites).

This is not the case. Do please refer to our wonderful nhs lovely explanation page about gender dysphoria:
[Link]

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

matt_himself Flag Matataland 30 Mar 16 9.41pm

.

Edited by matt_himself (31 Mar 2016 3.24am)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

johnfirewall Flag 30 Mar 16 11.30pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Why do you get a w*** on trying to be 'right on'?

The fact is that you probably met a very limited amount of trannies in your life. I speak from my experience, I think I can count the number of trannies I have met on one hand. There was one at my Mum's church on Sunday. Six foot four and looked like a bloke in a dress. The fact is that it isn't that common, however you dress it up. There should be no competition on how many trannies you know. I probably know the same amount as you. Why keep trying to educate the masses on your 'experiences'? No one really cares or thinks it's exceptional.

Shame the liberals aren't really in to western religion otherwise they'd be queueing up to hang out with a trans person.

Really though there are likely to be a number of people who can't be themselves because it's not perceived as normal. Not that I can get my head round a massive geezer in a dress and whether he actually thinks he's in the wrong body.

There's a transvestite (I think that's still the term for someone who dresses as the opposite sex) who goes round the Glades telling everyone about his paralysed hand, a strange fib which the shopkeepers have cottoned on to. I'm not saying everyone who disputes their birth gender has a personality disorder but what better way to assume another identity than to adopt one of the opposite sex.

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gender and sexuality