You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why The Deterioration In Pardew's Performance?
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why The Deterioration In Pardew's Performance?


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Inapickle Flag South West 31 Oct 16 11.18pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Don't think there's many who really think we should be finishing top eight although I must admit I fell into the trap of thinking that we might have a chance around last Christmas.

However, neither should we be happy with a season of struggle but at the moment I don't see anything else. Granted there are injuries but the team looks lacking in energy and ideas and is now shipping goals on set pieces which had previously been a relatively strong area.

We also now only have one player who looks capable of going round his man and Bolasie was always going to be a far bigger loss to the team than on paper IMO despite the money we got.

..I saw quite a lot of moves against liverpool that had them panicking when at 2-3 and us pressing, especially the last ditching tackle bits, you need to not panic about this team, liverpool will win this league this season because klopp with dosh will sort their defence and to me they are just too freaking scary to comprehend not doing it, please inform me of all the games where we have been knocked out flat and utterly outplayed?

 

Den1923 Flag 01 Nov 16 8.46am

We are 4 points, off the drop zone, how can that be safe with a run of fixtures in the next few weeks that include Man city, Southampton, Man U and Chelsea. In between we have must win games at Burnley, Swansea & Hull. Safe?, I think not if we keep leaking goals and I repeat based on our performance in 2016 we would be in a pretty dire position if this were the actual season!

 

cpj Flag Kent 01 Nov 16 8.56am

Originally posted by Den1923

We are 4 points, off the drop zone, how can that be safe with a run of fixtures in the next few weeks that include Man city, Southampton, Man U and Chelsea. In between we have must win games at Burnley, Swansea & Hull. Safe?, I think not if we keep leaking goals and I repeat based on our performance in 2016 we would be in a pretty dire position if this were the actual season!

... and 1 point off 17th.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 01 Nov 16 9.05am

And 4 points off 7th...

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 01 Nov 16 9.15am

If we don't get a result on Saturday then i think Pards has to go imo

 

Den1923 Flag 01 Nov 16 9.16am

Current form over full season 38 games would POSITION us as follows:-

20- Sunderland 36PTS
19- CP 36PTS
18- Swansea 41PTS
17-WBA 42PTS

This is reality at present lets hope its is not the final outcome 17 would be stressful but fine, lets not get carried away thinking we are better that we actually are!

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 01 Nov 16 6.37pm

Not a Pardew out member or a Pardew must stay member, more a, I'll support the manager until he's sacked or he really loses the plot member and I'll always defend anyone against unfair criticism.............. BUT!
Since 2010 took over we've had far more than our usual amount of good ball playing players, Joniesta, Moritz, Chamakh, Bolasie, Wilf,Townsend, Bannan, Cabaye, Chungy, Guediora to name a fair few of them and in all that time the movement off the ball under Dougie, Ollie, Pulis, Warnock and Pardew has been totally abysmal. No wonder Cabaye is struggling with the movement we have in front of him.
So my point is that I haven't fallen out of love with Pardew right now, but the English/British manager. I've always wanted a British manager to get a chance at the big jobs, but I'm now beginning to see why they don't. They basically are by the numbers managers, backs to the wall, grind it out experts with no real flair it would seem.
Would our flair players be more productive if they had a manager who taught them, insisted on, the art of movement, finding space, giving options? We don't have Liverpool's quality, but it doesn't mean we can't play a similar style, surely.
Just saying Frank De Boer's been sacked.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Podyonkers Flag Atlanta, Georgia 01 Nov 16 9.27pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Not a Pardew out member or a Pardew must stay member, more a, I'll support the manager until he's sacked or he really loses the plot member and I'll always defend anyone against unfair criticism.............. BUT!
Since 2010 took over we've had far more than our usual amount of good ball playing players, Joniesta, Moritz, Chamakh, Bolasie, Wilf,Townsend, Bannan, Cabaye, Chungy, Guediora to name a fair few of them and in all that time the movement off the ball under Dougie, Ollie, Pulis, Warnock and Pardew has been totally abysmal. No wonder Cabaye is struggling with the movement we have in front of him.
So my point is that I haven't fallen out of love with Pardew right now, but the English/British manager. I've always wanted a British manager to get a chance at the big jobs, but I'm now beginning to see why they don't. They basically are by the numbers managers, backs to the wall, grind it out experts with no real flair it would seem.
Would our flair players be more productive if they had a manager who taught them, insisted on, the art of movement, finding space, giving options? We don't have Liverpool's quality, but it doesn't mean we can't play a similar style, surely.
Just saying Frank De Boer's been sacked.

Bang on, in my opinion. The EPL is so direct, so frenetic. If you think about it, AP played in an earlier version of this league, which, if anything, was even more direct. He learned how to play with hard tackling and an awful lot of shoving and grinding. Not saying he was not an adept player - he was - but I'm not sure he learnt to value space as much as brute force. Moving into space is a given at any level but I doubt many British players have had to move off the ball at the level someone like Guardiola is used to.

 


Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987.

Aray Flag South London 01 Nov 16 9.48pm

Originally posted by Den1923

your living in a dream world, just look at our results against the teams around us and since the start of 2016. That is not mid table form its downwards rather than upwards, its a bit like moving your deckchair around the Titanic to keep your feet dry!

Den...mate...sorry but Its a bit rich of you to say I'm living in a dream when you're the one pretending the season starts in January! Last season is done and dusted.

We're playing ok considering our massive hole on the defence. We have goals in us now - though Benteke needs to start taking his chances but that's another story.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Nov 16 10.26pm

Originally posted by Inapickle

..I saw quite a lot of moves against liverpool that had them panicking when at 2-3 and us pressing, especially the last ditching tackle bits, you need to not panic about this team, liverpool will win this league this season because klopp with dosh will sort their defence and to me they are just too freaking scary to comprehend not doing it, please inform me of all the games where we have been knocked out flat and utterly outplayed?

Not so much getting knocked out flat as disappointing and flat performances against the likes of Bournemouth, West Ham and West Brom. Typically a totally unacceptable first half followed by lots of huff and puff second half but ultimately defeat. Not just this season but also second half of last season.

Don't expect to beat the likes of Liverpool and thought we were far from terrible Saturday but failure against the so called lesser teams makes it all the more critical that we nick something from the other games.

There may well be three teams worse than us but don't think it's unreasonable to think that we should be doing a little better than that or have a slightly better points return after the games played so far.

 

Den1923 Flag 01 Nov 16 11.06pm

Aray, I'm not saying anything of the sort, what I am highlighting is that based on current form our projected points total for 2016/17 will be circa 36pts which is trap door form. The hole at the back is not down to one player it is the collective, with the next run of games we have to pick up points, which is going to be difficult because we have strikers who can't score and we are leaking big time at the back!

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 02 Nov 16 3.11pm

The absence of clean sheets is a major worry. I'd be more than happy with a few drab 1-0 wins right now instead of having to try to turn a game around after conceding first.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Nov 16 3.43pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Aray, I'm not saying anything of the sort, what I am highlighting is that based on current form our projected points total for 2016/17 will be circa 36pts which is trap door form. The hole at the back is not down to one player it is the collective, with the next run of games we have to pick up points, which is going to be difficult because we have strikers who can't score and we are leaking big time at the back!

Are you any good at maths or did you just make up 36 points. It cannot possibly be so, if we have 11 points from 10 games.

Try 41 points, that nearer the mark and no team in the current total of 20 teams has gone down with 41 points.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Nov 16 3.51pm

Originally posted by Painter

Are you any good at maths or did you just make up 36 points. It cannot possibly be so, if we have 11 points from 10 games.

Try 41 points, that nearer the mark and no team in the current total of 20 teams has gone down with 41 points.

W.Ham went down with 42 pts in 2002/03 but have a look at the link below :

[Link]

 

Den1923 Flag 02 Nov 16 5.46pm

I thought I was being quite kind, Palace have played 29 games in Premier league since 1/1/2016 and have earned just 22points, so on current rate they may not make 36!

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 02 Nov 16 6.20pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I thought I was being quite kind, Palace have played 29 games in Premier league since 1/1/2016 and have earned just 22points, so on current rate they may not make 36!

But the season started in August so its more like 41 this current season

 

Den1923 Flag 02 Nov 16 6.45pm

who knows, last term the first half produced 31 and the second 11, the trouble is we are struggling and we cannot be sure where we will end up, even with 41 you are not guaranteed your place in the top flight!

 

Aray Flag South London 02 Nov 16 8.07pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I thought I was being quite kind, Palace have played 29 games in Premier league since 1/1/2016 and have earned just 22points, so on current rate they may not make 36!

No you're just selecting the data that supports your misplaced view.

You really can't say on current form we're heading for 22pts based on our game time since January and retain any credibility.

its a different season

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Nov 16 9.19pm

Originally posted by Aray

No you're just selecting the data that supports your misplaced view.

You really can't say on current form we're heading for 22pts based on our game time since January and retain any credibility.

its a different season

... but unfortunately very similar results, despite vast sums being spent in the summer on 'upgrading the squad'. We have beaten Boro, Sunderland and Stoke - hardly cause for optimism. More significantly we have conceded first in 8 of our 10 league games. We can't keep doing that - AP has to get the team selection and tactics right in the first half.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 02 Nov 16 9.46pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Current form over full season 38 games would POSITION us as follows:-

20- Sunderland 36PTS
19- CP 36PTS
18- Swansea 41PTS
17-WBA 42PTS

This is reality at present lets hope its is not the final outcome 17 would be stressful but fine, lets not get carried away thinking we are better that we actually are!

Only if you look at results in a fashion that have no bearing on an actual football season. Based on your argument, teams like Chelsea and Southampton would have gone down if one looks at their seasons in snapshot and then extrapolated from there. They both had appalling runs.

By the way, we have 11 points from ten games. That is our current form. In case you hadn't noticed, the results from last season don't count towards the current one.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why The Deterioration In Pardew's Performance?