You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back
November 16 2026 9.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back


Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 9.22am

Originally posted by Willo

Hogwash and then some.

Can we return to debating McArthur.Many thanks.

If in doubt turn it into another willo thread.

Edited by Dan89 (03 Jul 2017 9.23am)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Jul 17 9.24am

Originally posted by Dan89

If in doubt turn it into another willo thread.

Edited by Dan89 (03 Jul 2017 9.23am)

That's why I issued a plea to get back to debating about McArthur !!!!!

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 9.29am

Originally posted by Willo

That's why I issued a plea to get back to debating about McArthur !!!!!

Well should we sell him or should be keep him, because since the turn of the year. He wasn't the jimmy mac , we know.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Jul 17 9.32am

Originally posted by Dan89

Well should we sell him or should be keep him, because since the turn of the year. He wasn't the jimmy mac , we know.

Yes I agree his form in recent months is well below what he has produced.I have already said that he came on as substitute for Scotland v England and I don't recall him touching the ball.

Maybe some will remember the old McArthur and be disappointed if he was sold but others might take a different view.I am in the latter category.

Edited by Willo (03 Jul 2017 9.33am)

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 03 Jul 17 9.33am

Our squad is thin enough already, will probably be more expensive to replace him than keep him.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 9.59am

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Our squad is thin enough already, will probably be more expensive to replace him than keep him.

Players like mcarthur have done us a job for 2 years but personally if we can get better then should sell. Like when jedinak left. I was gutted but for 4m at 31. It makes sense, what if we used that money to buy Hughes for 8m. (Yes I know he's left to join Watford. It's an example)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

coulsdoneagle Flag London 03 Jul 17 10.09am

Originally posted by Dan89

Players like mcarthur have done us a job for 2 years but personally if we can get better then should sell. Like when jedinak left. I was gutted but for 4m at 31. It makes sense, what if we used that money to buy Hughes for 8m. (Yes I know he's left to join Watford. It's an example)

Can't agree that it was a good move to lose Jedinak. We absolutely could have done with him during our awful run. It was short sighted and we nearly paid the price we had absolutely no steel in midfield and he wasn't adequately replaced until January. If that's your model for a good bit of business I say we keep him.

Hughes hasn't played PL football he is as much of a risk as anyone else who isn't a proven quantity. Teams would also be able to hold us to ransom if we sold McArthur because they would know we would be short in the middle and would have to pay up.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Jul 17 10.11am

Jimmy like Scott Dann lost there first team spots for the Middlesbrough game.
They both then moved to the bench.
If Sakho does not sign Scott has a good chance to get back in.
Meanwhile Jimmy can cover for Cabaye and Luka,whilst endeavouring to get back in the first 11.
So I say keep him.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Jul 17 10.26am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Can't agree that it was a good move to lose Jedinak. We absolutely could have done with him during our awful run. It was short sighted and we nearly paid the price we had absolutely no steel in midfield and he wasn't adequately replaced until January. If that's your model for a good bit of business I say we keep him.

Hughes hasn't played PL football he is as much of a risk as anyone else who isn't a proven quantity. Teams would also be able to hold us to ransom if we sold McArthur because they would know we would be short in the middle and would have to pay up.

Jedinak was a fading force in the PL and not the Jedinak of old.We got £4 Mill for him and of course we got in Luka who was just what we needed.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 03 Jul 17 10.41am

Originally posted by Willo

Jedinak was a fading force in the PL and not the Jedinak of old.We got £4 Mill for him and of course we got in Luka who was just what we needed.

Jedinak may have been slightly on the wane and yes we did get £4m for him.
However we failed to replace him immediately and suffered badly until we eventually bought Milivojevi&#263;.
In hindsight we would have done better to keep Jedinak until we had found an ideal replacement.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 10.45am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Can't agree that it was a good move to lose Jedinak. We absolutely could have done with him during our awful run. It was short sighted and we nearly paid the price we had absolutely no steel in midfield and he wasn't adequately replaced until January. If that's your model for a good bit of business I say we keep him.

Hughes hasn't played PL football he is as much of a risk as anyone else who isn't a proven quantity. Teams would also be able to hold us to ransom if we sold McArthur because they would know we would be short in the middle and would have to pay up.

Jedinak was good business. The fact that we didn't replace him until January lies the problem. I'd sell mcarthur and dann. If we bought in sufficient replacements. Then there's no big drama. If we bought in another midfield ideally we want better than what we got. Mcarthur has 12 months left and if villa offered us anything above the 8m we spend a couple of seasons ago. We'd be foolish not sell. Fans talk about going to the next level. Imagine we bought in 2 midfielders Ziyech and yann m'villa for example . Where would this mcarthur, I'd say surplus to requirements.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Jul 17 10.49am

Dan what's the "next level " for you.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 10.58am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Dan what's the "next level " for you.?

Establishing top 10 finish and potential push for europa league places.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 11.03am

The problem lies with puncheon. Personally he should leave before mcarthur but due to him being well loved by the chairman and fans. Extremely unlikely to leave and contribution of 0 goals from midfield is disgusting. Therefore if 2 midfielder are bought in then mcarthur may have to leave.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

dreamwaverider Flag London 03 Jul 17 11.05am

What would he fetch ? £7....£8......mil??

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 11.07am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

What would he fetch ? £7....£8......mil??

In an inflated market maybe 10m . With villa still having parachute payments.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Aray Flag South London 03 Jul 17 11.12am

didn't realise he's only got 1 year on his contract. if we should either extend it or sell him. business is business.

 

si_1967 Flag Surrey 03 Jul 17 11.47am

Originally posted by Pierre

Jedinak may have been slightly on the wane and yes we did get £4m for him.
However we failed to replace him immediately and suffered badly until we eventually bought Milivojevi&#263;.
In hindsight we would have done better to keep Jedinak until we had found an ideal replacement.

I agree with all this except for the one point - highlighted. I think you'll find most people (except Pardew) were arguing for a decent replacement last August rather than hindsight and we got ... Flamini, who never played!!

 


... what

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 5.22pm

Imagine selling mcarthur to bring in hernadez who was a 13m release clause to leave Bayern Leverkusen.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Jul 17 5.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

Jedinak was a fading force in the PL and not the Jedinak of old.We got £4 Mill for him and of course we got in Luka who was just what we needed.

Yep, Jedi, much as I loved him, was going to have to be replaced. An Luka is exactly the player to do that - same kind of steel, more skill and more talent.

The only problem was probably the three months of so between selling Jedi and bringing in Luka. We lacked a good defensive midfielder and it probably cost Pardew his job (I can't imagine the Swansea 5-4 with Jedi or the 3-2 Burnley or 3-3 Hull).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back