You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Catalonia
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Catalonia


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 17 4.13pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

There still are a lot of Basque seperatists - its only ETA that have been reasonably quite in the last few years (largely due to arrests).

I suspect that denied political engagement and negotiation, Catalan nationalists will likely increasingly utilise militancy against the Spainish state, and that groups like ETA will start to re-appear and ally their cause with Catalonian independence.

Refusing to allow the referendum was a bad idea for Spain's central government, like the rise of Scottish Nationalism, an official state referendum would likely have been an effective means of establishing the degree of support Catalan independence has (bearing in mind that five or six years ago Catalan independence parties had minimal political support).

Otherwise, all that's going to happen, is that they state will render the voice of independence louder as they try to crack down on what has largely been a non-violent pursuit of democratic driven change (most of the violence has been through the Spanish states attempts to quell the referendum, and silence elected Catalonian officials).

The EU shouldn't intervene, its outside its political remit, it should pass the issue to the UN.

Well that, along with a ceasefire and subsequent disarmament.

Puigdemont is a belligerent fool, all the while Spain refused a referendum they could posit themselves as the hard done by side. Holding a referendum that everyone knows was illegal, was completely ignored by the opposition and not even conclusive has played right into the government's hands.

No one should intervene, it's a Spanish issue. We aren't going to give one to Cornwall or Canvey Island etc no matter how much some of them would like it, and we definitely wouldn't do it if the EU or UN attempted to force us to.

Edited by Stuk (31 Oct 2017 5.19pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

Barcelona eagle Flag Cubelles 31 Oct 17 5.10pm

Originally posted by eaglelad

Wow, so Catalonia have announced Independence today but Spain have refused it!

I remember there being Basque (North East Spain) separatists a few years ago wanting to break away, but have there been any Catalonian attacks over the years?

Things are going to get Messi in Spain :/ (lame pun intended).

Any Spanish/Catalan/Ex-Pat Palace fans there able to tell us the animosity/confusion amongst the people gente there?

Are there fascist Spanish right wingers ready for war and are there Catalonians for or against this?

Edited by eaglelad (27 Oct 2017 6.48pm)

The Catalan government has basically carried out a cuop d'état, which has been followed up by a reactive coup d'état by Spain on the Autonomous Catalan Government.

They held an illegal referendum. That being said and as touched upon by Jamie, the most 'democratic' way would have been to allow a referendum. I believe it should be the whole union that votes though, not just the region, as this is affecting many many people. 1500 businesses have left Cataluyna including the two biggest Catalan banks. The car manufacturer Seat has its plant near Barcelona, they are considering moving back to Navarra in the north, this will again create a loss of jobs in the region of 11,000 just at the two plants, plus all the supply chain (of which I am one of many). One grievance is show big do you have to be to want to become a republic, what is stopping the Catalan regions of Lleida or Tarragona who neighbour the regions of Huesca/Zaragoza and France and Huesca/Valencia respectively saying we want to separate from Cataluña to protect our interests with our neighbours?

A good percentage of the people voting and those in the streets are under 25 and have hardly worked either because of the financial crisis and high unemployment in Spain or because they are students. I am not saying that the Catalans are undeserving of independence, they were independent 300 years ago, however I just believe they are hearing all the wrong arguments a la Brexit, and some of the home truths are being left out of the discussions.

Lastly, I think Cataluña could be a successful autonomous state, but it would probably take a decade or two to recover fully. They have no Fiscal tax office, no defence and would not be allowed to join the single market or EU for the foreseeable future, maybe never.

Plus Puigdemont has such a punchable face.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 17 5.21pm

Originally posted by Barcelona eagle

The Catalan government has basically carried out a cuop d'état, which has been followed up by a reactive coup d'état by Spain on the Autonomous Catalan Government.

They held an illegal referendum. That being said and as touched upon by Jamie, the most 'democratic' way would have been to allow a referendum. I believe it should be the whole union that votes though, not just the region, as this is affecting many many people. 1500 businesses have left Cataluyna including the two biggest Catalan banks. The car manufacturer Seat has its plant near Barcelona, they are considering moving back to Navarra in the north, this will again create a loss of jobs in the region of 11,000 just at the two plants, plus all the supply chain (of which I am one of many). One grievance is show big do you have to be to want to become a republic, what is stopping the Catalan regions of Lleida or Tarragona who neighbour the regions of Huesca/Zaragoza and France and Huesca/Valencia respectively saying we want to separate from Cataluña to protect our interests with our neighbours?

A good percentage of the people voting and those in the streets are under 25 and have hardly worked either because of the financial crisis and high unemployment in Spain or because they are students. I am not saying that the Catalans are undeserving of independence, they were independent 300 years ago, however I just believe they are hearing all the wrong arguments a la Brexit, and some of the home truths are being left out of the discussions.

Lastly, I think Cataluña could be a successful autonomous state, but it would probably take a decade or two to recover fully. They have no Fiscal tax office, no defence and would not be allowed to join the single market or EU for the foreseeable future, maybe never.

Plus Puigdemont has such a punchable face.

Normally the ones most likely to chuck "Franco" into any soundbite they can give to the press too.

Good post.

 


Optimistic as ever

Beanyboysmd Flag 31 Oct 17 9.15pm

Catalonia is in an impossible situation, there is no way to have a legal referendum, so any ref is illegal. So even if its what the people want, how do they go about it?

What is not acceptable is "Well its what the people want but we cant give it to you, so...sorry...", that goes against the UN charter.

The annoying thing is if we were talking about some poor, African country, we would bbe all over this and calling it oppression, but if its in a nice, cultured place in Western Europe, somehow its fine to take away any road to self determination and smashing the eye socket of old ladies who want to vote to get away from a country that are prepared to smash the eye socket of people who want to vote...

Who thing has been horrifying to watch, those poor powerless people...

 

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 31 Oct 17 9.30pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Catalonia is in an impossible situation, there is no way to have a legal referendum, so any ref is illegal. So even if its what the people want, how do they go about it?

What is not acceptable is "Well its what the people want but we cant give it to you, so...sorry...", that goes against the UN charter.

The annoying thing is if we were talking about some poor, African country, we would bbe all over this and calling it oppression, but if its in a nice, cultured place in Western Europe, somehow its fine to take away any road to self determination and smashing the eye socket of old ladies who want to vote to get away from a country that are prepared to smash the eye socket of people who want to vote...

Who thing has been horrifying to watch, those poor powerless people...

I think the main challenge is to make sure governments are geared towards the values and outcomes that matter to the civilian population, rather than their own self-aggrandisement or that of the allies they tend to use (need?) to get into power. It often seems to be more about money than much else.

There should be a way to have more open government, with a mandate based on outcomes and values rather than missold technical solutions.

 


A one and a two...

Barcelona eagle Flag Cubelles 31 Oct 17 9.38pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Catalonia is in an impossible situation, there is no way to have a legal referendum, so any ref is illegal. So even if its what the people want, how do they go about it?

What is not acceptable is "Well its what the people want but we cant give it to you, so...sorry...", that goes against the UN charter.

The annoying thing is if we were talking about some poor, African country, we would bbe all over this and calling it oppression, but if its in a nice, cultured place in Western Europe, somehow its fine to take away any road to self determination and smashing the eye socket of old ladies who want to vote to get away from a country that are prepared to smash the eye socket of people who want to vote...

Who thing has been horrifying to watch, those poor powerless people...

I get what you are saying Beanyboysmd, but as I said in an earlier post where does self determination start and end. What if my town decides to stay, why should an almost majority (last count 49.3% want independence) decide for the rest of us.
They're main gripe boils down to Money. That being said, and as much as I love this country, it has serious institutionalised racism, severe and in your face corruption and a good percentage still think of Franco as a saint.

I have a feeling that it is self imploding a tad and that there are absolutely no winners in this, bar maybe a few politicians.

Have I mentioned how Puigdemont has such a
punchable face?

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 31 Oct 17 11.00pm

Originally posted by Barcelona eagle

I get what you are saying Beanyboysmd, but as I said in an earlier post where does self determination start and end. What if my town decides to stay, why should an almost majority (last count 49.3% want independence) decide for the rest of us.
They're main gripe boils down to Money. That being said, and as much as I love this country, it has serious institutionalised racism, severe and in your face corruption and a good percentage still think of Franco as a saint.

I have a feeling that it is self imploding a tad and that there are absolutely no winners in this, bar maybe a few politicians.

Have I mentioned how Puigdemont has such a
punchable face?

You are absolutely right, the issue is where does self determination start and end? My opinion is that if your town wanted to become independent, then yes it should. There is no reason not to if that's what the people genuinely want and they think their government no longer suits them, and they identify themselves as a culture or group, then that wouldn't be a problem. It would be a hard sell to talk your town into it, but there is no reason they couldn't. It would be a stupid country and would be very reliant on the UK but that would be their problem, not ours...

And the 49.3% is the problem, the poll could be either way, but you wont know for sure unless you have a referendum, polls have up to a 5% margin of error so it could be 55%/45% or even 60% and it could be either way! They need a referendum just for that at least, even if its non binding.

Is it down to money? Yeah almost everything is, Barcelona has vast funds diverted on stupid projects around Madrid and a phasing project started in Spain a while ago to divert trading activity from Catalonia to Southern Spain. But 25 years ago polls were only 5% so it must be on a way bigger level than we think it is.

Is his face punchable? I thought he just had a proper vanilla face, like you could only describe it to the police as "a face" with no features whatsoever...

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 31 Oct 17 11.12pm

Worth knowing by the way because I hear this in certain, similar but in no way the same situations. A country is not allowed to vote for the separation of a part of its country. The UN consider it an atrocity. So in the case of Catalonia, Spain voting for Catalonia to be independent is a massive no-no...

If that rule wasn't in place, then governments could dispose of parts of the country that don't make them any money and could result in abject poverty for the dispelled area. I know that hardly applies when its parts of western Europe but it does make sense. Can you imagine if we forced Northumberland out of England against its will because the rest of us didn't want to fund it anymore?

Like I said thought I would bring it up because its interesting, and because its the reason Spain can't just vote for Catalonia to be independent, even if that's what they want...

 

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 01 Nov 17 10.02am

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Worth knowing by the way because I hear this in certain, similar but in no way the same situations. A country is not allowed to vote for the separation of a part of its country. The UN consider it an atrocity. So in the case of Catalonia, Spain voting for Catalonia to be independent is a massive no-no...

If that rule wasn't in place, then governments could dispose of parts of the country that don't make them any money and could result in abject poverty for the dispelled area. I know that hardly applies when its parts of western Europe but it does make sense. Can you imagine if we forced Northumberland out of England against its will because the rest of us didn't want to fund it anymore?

Like I said thought I would bring it up because its interesting, and because its the reason Spain can't just vote for Catalonia to be independent, even if that's what they want...

Yeah, that's a very interesting point. As you said before, much of it is about money - but if you look at the movements for autonomy or independence, it's generally the richer areas trying to pull away. That's not to say it's only about money, but Catalonia, Lombardy, Flanders, are often richer parts.

I think it's also one of these general movements, like a newton's cradle - moving between bigger and smaller entities.

 


A one and a two...

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Nov 17 1.41pm

Originally posted by tome

Yeah, that's a very interesting point. As you said before, much of it is about money - but if you look at the movements for autonomy or independence, it's generally the richer areas trying to pull away. That's not to say it's only about money, but Catalonia, Lombardy, Flanders, are often richer parts.

I think it's also one of these general movements, like a newton's cradle - moving between bigger and smaller entities.

Spain's issue probably is more about how dependent it is on the wealth generated in Catalonia.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

wordup Flag 01 Nov 17 1.56pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Spain's issue probably is more about how dependent it is on the wealth generated in Catalonia.

100%. It's all about the money.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 01 Nov 17 2.17pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

You are absolutely right, the issue is where does self determination start and end? My opinion is that if your town wanted to become independent, then yes it should. There is no reason not to if that's what the people genuinely want and they think their government no longer suits them, and they identify themselves as a culture or group, then that wouldn't be a problem. It would be a hard sell to talk your town into it, but there is no reason they couldn't. It would be a stupid country and would be very reliant on the UK but that would be their problem, not ours...

And the 49.3% is the problem, the poll could be either way, but you wont know for sure unless you have a referendum, polls have up to a 5% margin of error so it could be 55%/45% or even 60% and it could be either way! They need a referendum just for that at least, even if its non binding.

Is it down to money? Yeah almost everything is, Barcelona has vast funds diverted on stupid projects around Madrid and a phasing project started in Spain a while ago to divert trading activity from Catalonia to Southern Spain. But 25 years ago polls were only 5% so it must be on a way bigger level than we think it is.

Is his face punchable? I thought he just had a proper vanilla face, like you could only describe it to the police as "a face" with no features whatsoever...

When Barcelona had the Olympics did they pay for it solely out of the Catalan coffers or did it come out of the national budget? They also have, or did, the 2nd biggest regional amount of debt behind Valencia, which went bankrupt.

 


Optimistic as ever

Barcelona eagle Flag Cubelles 01 Nov 17 10.19pm

Originally posted by Stuk

When Barcelona had the Olympics did they pay for it solely out of the Catalan coffers or did it come out of the national budget? They also have, or did, the 2nd biggest regional amount of debt behind Valencia, which went bankrupt.


De la inversión pública, el Gobierno asumió la parte mayoritaria: un 37,37%. El consistorio, un 16,34% y la Generalitat, un 18,34%. Telefónica, entonces controlada por el sector público, un 15,43% y el COOB, un 5,33%.

Spanish government 37.37% Catalan government 18.34, Telefónica which was controled by the Spanish governent (BT) another 15.43%

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Nov 17 10.31pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd

Worth knowing by the way because I hear this in certain, similar but in no way the same situations. A country is not allowed to vote for the separation of a part of its country. The UN consider it an atrocity. So in the case of Catalonia, Spain voting for Catalonia to be independent is a massive no-no...

If that rule wasn't in place, then governments could dispose of parts of the country that don't make them any money and could result in abject poverty for the dispelled area. I know that hardly applies when its parts of western Europe but it does make sense. Can you imagine if we forced Northumberland out of England against its will because the rest of us didn't want to fund it anymore?

Like I said thought I would bring it up because its interesting, and because its the reason Spain can't just vote for Catalonia to be independent, even if that's what they want...

So we can’t actually get rid of Canvey Island?

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 01 Nov 17 11.23pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

So we can’t actually get rid of Canvey Island?

Only if they want to go... I would have voted for Fleet or Guildford if we get to choose...

 

Stuk Flag Top half 02 Nov 17 1.50pm

Originally posted by Barcelona eagle


De la inversión pública, el Gobierno asumió la parte mayoritaria: un 37,37%. El consistorio, un 16,34% y la Generalitat, un 18,34%. Telefónica, entonces controlada por el sector público, un 15,43% y el COOB, un 5,33%.

Spanish government 37.37% Catalan government 18.34, Telefónica which was controled by the Spanish governent (BT) another 15.43%

So they contributed 18% of approx. 70% of the costs?

Is fleeing to Belgium and refusing to be held accountable really going to be Puigdemont's fall back plan? How can Belgium even offer asylum from another EU country and it's laws?

 


Optimistic as ever

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Nov 17 2.10pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Is fleeing to Belgium and refusing to be held accountable really going to be Puigdemont's fall back plan? How can Belgium even offer asylum from another EU country and it's laws?

Belgium will probably pass him on to the UK where he will take up residence in the Ecuador embassy to keep Julian Assange company

 

Stuk Flag Top half 02 Nov 17 2.28pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Belgium will probably pass him on to the UK where he will take up residence in the Ecuador embassy to keep Julian Assange company

I'd almost forgotten about that prick until now. France might as well send Polanski over too. They can have a fugitive sleepover.

Edited by Stuk (02 Nov 2017 2.28pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 02 Nov 17 2.46pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I'd almost forgotten about that prick until now. France might as well send Polanski over too. They can have a fugitive sleepover.

Edited by Stuk (02 Nov 2017 2.28pm)

In the Cat's pyjamas.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Barcelona eagle Flag Cubelles 02 Nov 17 4.32pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I'd almost forgotten about that prick until now. France might as well send Polanski over too. They can have a fugitive sleepover.

Edited by Stuk (02 Nov 2017 2.28pm)

&#128513; Judge sent Catalan politicians to prison today, 50.000€ bail, more of my txes will be used for this farce.

Puigdemont on the run, all a bit latin if you ask me.

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Catalonia