This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Indirect free kick in the area
|
|
|
Didn’t get one
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!! |
|
|
All that said, the ref performance today was far from the worst we’ve had this year....or is that because we were not playing one of the “big six”?
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I think we would have been lucky to be awarded this. The spirit of this rule (within Law 12) is to prevent timewasting by goalkeepers handling the ball when they are not under pressure, not to stop them doing what they normally do. Foster did not waste time by handling the ball. As to the letter of the law, it says this: "The offense rests on three events occurring in the following sequence: The ball is kicked (played with the foot, not the knee, thigh, or shin) by a teammate of the goalkeeper, Now I don't think Wilf touched the ball between the back pass and the handling, but Foster didn't try to handle the ball before he was put under pressure by Wilf and he only did so because Wilf challenged him for it. Technically, you could argue that the three events occurred as listed above, if you agree that Wilf didn't touch the ball. But I would have been quite pi**ed off if it were given against us because the rule is meant to deal with quite a different situation.
That's Life |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
That is a quite different issue: did the keeper foul Zaha whilst he was doing what he was doing? If he did, it is a penalty and the other issues are moot. I couldn't convince myself that he did, but then look at the one that Seaweed got given today... If it had happened at the other end the ref might have given a penalty, but that would have nothing to do with handling the ball. I think the double-jeopardy rule would prevent a red card because the keeper was quite clearly attempting to play the ball. I've edited my previous post on the basis that technically it was an infringement of Law 12 but one that doesn't reflect the spirit of the rule. Edited by chateauferret (03 Dec 2017 12.18am) Edited by chateauferret (03 Dec 2017 12.20am)
============ |
|
|
Just seen it - would have been a harsh penalty and if given against us there would have been uproar
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I think we would have been lucky to be awarded this. The spirit of this rule (within Law 12) is to prevent timewasting by goalkeepers handling the ball when they are not under pressure, not to stop them doing what they normally do. Foster did not waste time by handling the ball, he handled it to get it away from the opponent (although the mess he was in was his own fault). As to the letter of the law, it says this: "The offense rests on three events occurring in the following sequence: The ball is kicked (played with the foot, not the knee, thigh, or shin) by a teammate of the goalkeeper, Now I don't think Wilf touched the ball between the back pass and the handling, but Foster didn't try to handle the ball before he was put under pressure by Wilf and he only did so because Wilf challenged him for it. Technically, we should have had an indirect free kick, but I guess refs don't apply it other than in the spirit in which the law was intended. Personally I think the issue would have been better dealt with as it used to be, i.e. you book the keeper for timewasting if that's what he's doing. Didn't it used to be the case that a keeper could only take x steps with the ball in his hands? Edited by chateauferret (03 Dec 2017 12.15am) Four steps it was, once the goalie had the ball in his hands. Trouble is, there was no rule about multiple passes between goalie and outfield players
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I think we would have been lucky to be awarded this. The spirit of this rule (within Law 12) is to prevent timewasting by goalkeepers handling the ball when they are not under pressure, not to stop them doing what they normally do. Foster did not waste time by handling the ball, he handled it to get it away from the opponent (although the mess he was in was his own fault). As to the letter of the law, it says this: "The offense rests on three events occurring in the following sequence: The ball is kicked (played with the foot, not the knee, thigh, or shin) by a teammate of the goalkeeper, Now I don't think Wilf touched the ball between the back pass and the handling, but Foster didn't try to handle the ball before he was put under pressure by Wilf and he only did so because Wilf challenged him for it. Technically, we should have had an indirect free kick, but I guess refs don't apply it other than in the spirit in which the law was intended. Personally I think the issue would have been better dealt with as it used to be, i.e. you book the keeper for timewasting if that's what he's doing. Didn't it used to be the case that a keeper could only take x steps with the ball in his hands? Edited by chateauferret (03 Dec 2017 12.15am) Ferret, whilst I understand the sentiment of your point, nowhere in the rules of the game does it say that the ref has the right to ignore an infringement in the circumstances that occurred. The ball was a back pass, which the keeper could have cleared, but didn't. Instead he chose to try and dribble out and only when he got in trouble did he go to ground and handle it. All 3 criteria for awarding the indirect free kick were met and he simply chose to ignore it which is wrong. If we were to follow your line of thinking to every scenario when a keeper gets in trouble then there would be no indirect free kicks for keepers who pick the ball up, which would make the law an arse. Sorry, but this is just another case of a ref making a poor decision in a dangerous area of the field and he shouldn't be vilified for making up his own interpretation of the laws. Unless of course it was just straightforward incompetence and he actually missed what was going on!
|
|
|
Just to confirm, the correct ruling should have been indirect free kick and yellow card for the keeper.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Ferret, whilst I understand the sentiment of your point, nowhere in the rules of the game does it say that the ref has the right to ignore an infringement in the circumstances that occurred. The ball was a back pass, which the keeper could have cleared, but didn't. Instead he chose to try and dribble out and only when he got in trouble did he go to ground and handle it. All 3 criteria for awarding the indirect free kick were met and he simply chose to ignore it which is wrong. If we were to follow your line of thinking to every scenario when a keeper gets in trouble then there would be no indirect free kicks for keepers who pick the ball up, which would make the law an arse. Sorry, but this is just another case of a ref making a poor decision in a dangerous area of the field and he shouldn't be vilified for making up his own interpretation of the laws. Unless of course it was just straightforward incompetence and he actually missed what was going on! I think I said technically it should have been an IFK and I dixn't comment on right or wrong. Did you read my post? As someone pointed out these are seldom given and I merely speculated as to why. I will leave judgement in the hands of God. I don't think we appealed for it, did we?
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I think I said technically it should have been an IFK and I dixn't comment on right or wrong. Did you read my post? As someone pointed out these are seldom given and I merely speculated as to why. I will leave judgement in the hands of God. I don't think we appealed for it, did we? Yes, I did read your post, what I am saying is that refs do not have the right to ignore infringements under such circumstances whereas your inference is that they do. Zaha went crazy at the ref who just brushed him away. My guess is the ref had completely forgotten it was a back pass that started the situation.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Ferret, whilst I understand the sentiment of your point, nowhere in the rules of the game does it say that the ref has the right to ignore an infringement in the circumstances that occurred. The ball was a back pass, which the keeper could have cleared, but didn't. Instead he chose to try and dribble out and only when he got in trouble did he go to ground and handle it. All 3 criteria for awarding the indirect free kick were met and he simply chose to ignore it which is wrong. If we were to follow your line of thinking to every scenario when a keeper gets in trouble then there would be no indirect free kicks for keepers who pick the ball up, which would make the law an arse. Sorry, but this is just another case of a ref making a poor decision in a dangerous area of the field and he shouldn't be vilified for making up his own interpretation of the laws. Unless of course it was just straightforward incompetence and he actually missed what was going on! This - The keeper handled it after playing the ball into trouble with his feet, and that looks like a clear infringement of the rules - same really as if an outfield player under pressure handles the ball surely? My guess is the referee wasn't sure if he handled the ball.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
What should've given the ref a clue was the lengths Foster was going to to not put a hand on the ball before deciding that the risk of Wilf scoring was too great.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.