You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 12 Mar 18 9.47am

Originally posted by steeleye20

We only stayed in the Premier League last season because of Benteke 16 goals.

..and Wickham is a superb striker with a good fitness record who suffered the Palace effect by becoming a permanent sick note AFTER he joined.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 12 Mar 18 9.49am

Originally posted by silvertop

..and Wickham is a superb striker with a good fitness record who suffered the Palace effect by becoming a permanent sick note AFTER he joined.

PS Sorloth all day. What Benteke did last season was superb, but we can't carry him through this confidence crisis.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 12 Mar 18 9.54am

Originally posted by silvertop

PS Sorloth all day. What Benteke did last season was superb, but we can't carry him through this confidence crisis.

Totally agree. Benteke of last season wouldnt even be a question. Problem is he is not that player any longer. Has to be Sorloth

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Mar 18 10.07am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Totally agree. Benteke of last season wouldnt even be a question. Problem is he is not that player any longer. Has to be Sorloth

Different sort of players.

The Benteke we have seen (But not this season) is a player who can compete aerially, is physically strong can hold the ball up and thrives on delivery from wide areas.When people think of Benteke these are the qualities they visualise but these same people would be surprised to see the player in his current form.

Sorloth doesn't appear to be a player who can compete aerially and is a player who likes the ball to feet where he can run at defences so he doesn't look like that traditional 'No 9'.

Also Benteke has a proven record of scoring goals in the PL whereas Sorloth is inexperienced and is making the step-up from the Danish league to the PL.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 12 Mar 18 10.12am

Originally posted by Willo

Different sort of players.

The Benteke we have seen (But not this season) is a player who can compete aerially, is physically strong can hold the ball up and thrives on delivery from wide areas.When people think of Benteke these are the qualities they visualise but these same people would be surprised to see the player in his current form.

Sorloth doesn't appear to be a player who can compete aerially and is a player who likes the ball to feet where he can run at defences so he doesn't look like that traditional 'No 9'.

Also Benteke has a proven record of scoring goals in the PL whereas Sorloth is inexperienced and is making the step-up from the Danish league to the PL.

So are you advocating to persevere with the experienced Benteke who is a shadow of his former self? I would rather cut our losses and continue with the only other striker available to us. Bentekes time is up for me. How long do we give him to come good? Theres only 8 games left.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Mar 18 10.23am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch


So are you advocating to persevere with the experienced Benteke who is a shadow of his former self? I would rather cut our losses and continue with the only other striker available to us. Bentekes time is up for me. How long do we give him to come good? Theres only 8 games left.

I'm not convinced that a Benteke/Sorloth combination up front is the way to go.I think there is a case which can be made for both players in terms of only 1 playing as a striker.

Significantly, Hodgson withdrew Benteke at half-time and left Sorloth on and later complained about a lack of effort in the first half.

Edited by Willo (12 Mar 2018 10.28am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Mar 18 10.27am

Bentenke got a kick up the a**e by being subbed against Chelsea. I say give him a chance to make amends against Huddersfield and if he doesn't up his game then we bring on the new lad. Whatever we do at least we finally have options, especially with RLC also returning to the club. Against those teams in and around us having options from the bench will be a big boost.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 12 Mar 18 12.54pm

Start the match with Sørloth (in a 433) and if still level or better at half time then give Benteke a run for the last half hour or so either with Sørloth in a 442 or replacing him in a 433. Not quite a must win but definitely a must not lose.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

JacksonEagle Flag Croydon 12 Mar 18 12.56pm

Haven't read the whole thread so not sure if this has been mentioned, but Benteke has been directly involved in 7 of our last 10 goals (6 assists and 1 goal) based on that Benteke... Sorloth looks a little out of his depth IMO, But taking into account hes been chucked in at the deep end against some top teams and he's not 100% fit, i'm looking forward to seeing what he will be like next season.

 

JtCpfc Flag 12 Mar 18 1.28pm

Originally posted by JacksonEagle

Haven't read the whole thread so not sure if this has been mentioned, but Benteke has been directly involved in 7 of our last 10 goals (6 assists and 1 goal) based on that Benteke... Sorloth looks a little out of his depth IMO, But taking into account hes been chucked in at the deep end against some top teams and he's not 100% fit, i'm looking forward to seeing what he will be like next season.

Yeah, I made this point previously.

I am hoping sorloth comes good but I don't have the highest of hopes.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 12 Mar 18 4.18pm

We should consider our strike force of Sorloth and Benteke an attacking unit (albeit a small one) and they need to be used as a unit to give options and competition for places up top. No doubting Benteke's past achievements but he needs some of the pressure taken off of him and that won't happen all the time he continues to start matches. Sorloth needs to start to not only give Benteke a kick up the 'arris but also to remove some of the pressure of scoring goals that he is so desperately succumbing to. Teams know how to deal with the 'threat' of Benteke, starting Sorloth will give them something else to think about, and then introducing Benteke later in matches does the same again.

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 12 Mar 18 4.32pm

Sorloth offers more effort but lack of experience in the Prem may count against him. Benteke just doesn't look like he's giving it his all, Saturday he just seemed to lollop around like a giraffe and on several occasions he ran way from the ball/action. Maybe a game on the sidelines will help him to get his desire back. So for me at the moment it would be Sorloth.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 12 Mar 18 4.39pm

Whatever Roy decides is good by me. He sees them in training and is best placed to make the correct call.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 12 Mar 18 4.57pm

Directly involved in 7 of our last 10 goals. If we weren't deep in a relegation battle I'd chance Sorloth but in spite his poor form I'd stick with Benteke for experience. Hauling him off at half time though suggests Roy thinks different and I trust his judgement.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 12 Mar 18 5.12pm

Hopefully Saturday will be a wake up call for tekkers. He can’t sleep walk through games anymore as we have another option.
I’d like to see him start on Saturday and see a reaction from him.

 

leejaneagles Flag 12 Mar 18 5.20pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Hopefully Saturday will be a wake up call for tekkers. He can’t sleep walk through games anymore as we have another option.
I’d like to see him start on Saturday and see a reaction from him.

Starting against Huddersfield makes most sense because he'd actually be in for harsher treatment at Selhurst.

Our first priority away will be to keep it tight so if we keep 0-0 but Benteke doesn't try in the first half then we can haul him off again.

If it was Huddersfield at home I'd actually start Sorloth because the second Benteke makes a tiny mistake he's getting booed and that'll be no good for anybody.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Mar 18 5.29pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Starting against Huddersfield makes most sense because he'd actually be in for harsher treatment at Selhurst.

Our first priority away will be to keep it tight so if we keep 0-0 but Benteke doesn't try in the first half then we can haul him off again.

If it was Huddersfield at home I'd actually start Sorloth because the second Benteke makes a tiny mistake he's getting booed and that'll be no good for anybody.

The only time he's been booed at SP is when he gave up chasing the ball and stopping it going out of play against utd. Despite an awful season I can't remember any other booing (oh there was that penalty too)...

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 12 Mar 18 6.36pm

you can't say Sorloth is head and shoulders above Benteke. that's daft.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 12 Mar 18 8.08pm

Start with Shotgun, and bring on a fuming and charged up 'Teke for the last 30.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 13 Mar 18 2.52am

Two goals all season and a record in missing chances. Says it all for me, really....Can't afford playing both Benteke & the Norwegian same time, so go for the rookie!

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?