You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax on pensioners proposed
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tax on pensioners proposed


Page 6 of 11 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 May 18 11.05am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Fair enough - I guess you must have a large sample of young people's savings accounts that you have access to in order to draw such a conclusion.

I doubt the study had. They probably had to take the word of the saver I expect. A bit like those surveys of how big your dick is.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 09 May 18 11.16am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Fair enough - I guess you must have a large sample of young people's savings accounts that you have access to in order to draw such a conclusion.

It’s a relevant point but of course neither would the studies have had such access. They are reliant on what they are told by who they ask and on the nature of the sample and the questions actually asked.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 11.19am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Is it not a bit of a contradiction to argue that people should be more willing to move out of London, but also should be more responsible for their parents care?

Both my parents live in London - if I was to move from the city, this obviously affects my ability to provide care as they get older.

I get your point on family values etc, and I agree, but it just seems a bit of a contradiction given you were advocating relocating earlier in the thread.


It's a fair point and it is if we were talking about everyone...but the property issue is largely aimed at the first time buyer...who a large swath do not yet have a family of their own and as such if they really wanted to fly the next and set up home and a family could quite easily do so by moving out of London....setting up their own family in their own house; not their grandparents.

Clearly for those not willing to move and therefore remaining in the family home then they would be around to assist and help out.

It's all about choices; but we can't have a cake and eat it....which is what people seemingly expect as a 'right' nowadays.

There's clearly no silver bullet to the situation and as others comments have suggested there are numerous influencing factors that if addressed would drastically reduce the reliance on the state....and ultimately our pockets...making us all richer in so many ways.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 May 18 11.39am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Given the unionist policies of the 70's where people where public sector workers were given massive state pensions based on the idea that the next generation was going to earn more than there parents, it's only fair pensioners pay more.

I don't remember that. It's my recollection that public sector workers had good pension rights to compensate for earning less than their private sector equivalents

Originally posted by jeeagles

Having said that, I don't think young people are as badly off its made out. Loads of my friends have spent fortunes travelling and on pointless trinkets. Some of their parents seemed to have bought new cars every year and funded ultra expensive holiday to Disneyland and now don't have a nest egg set aside for their kids.

My next door neighbours have their 29 year old son living with them as he claims that he cannot afford to move out yet he seems to be able to afford a brand new Jaguar XE.

 

OneMax Flag Maidstone 09 May 18 12.19pm

I retired early and was surprised to find how little tax I paid. While working I paid 20% income tax plus 12% National Insurance so 30% in total. Plus I paid an additional 7.5% into my pension scheme.

Once I retired no more National Insurance as there is no NI on pensions and stopped contributing to a pension.

As I had a company car and BUPA when working I also now have the full personal allowance.

National Insurance is a tax on work, Pensioners, Private Landlords, those living off trust funds or investments don,t pay NI.
It is wrong only those who work who sweat and earn between *£7,500 and £45,000 pay NI.
*Figs are approx but not far out.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 May 18 12.43pm

Originally posted by OneMax

I retired early and was surprised to find how little tax I paid. While working I paid 20% income tax plus 12% National Insurance so 30% in total. Plus I paid an additional 7.5% into my pension scheme.

Once I retired no more National Insurance as there is no NI on pensions and stopped contributing to a pension.

As I had a company car and BUPA when working I also now have the full personal allowance.

National Insurance is a tax on work, Pensioners, Private Landlords, those living off trust funds or investments don,t pay NI.
It is wrong only those who work who sweat and earn between *£7,500 and £45,000 pay NI.
*Figs are approx but not far out.

Do what? I assure you that people earning over 45k pay NI.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 May 18 1.46pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

The average Millennial complains about house prices... When I ask them how much property deposit have they built up so far, they answer "zero"! (They also insist on living in zones 1-2). Baby boomers and Generation X actually saved money, didn't go away on fancy holidays and didn't eat at expensive restaurants which they post on Instagram. It's easy to blame the market and the government, but what are YOU doing about your financial future? I'm planning for retirement now. The elderly have by and large been responsible with their finances and should not be punished. The government STEAL enough money as it is...

Edited by Penge Eagle (08 May 2018 11.02pm)

Rental prices in particular the SE are ridiculous. Kids going to University have no chance of saving (see my previous post), please don't blame them for not having any savings.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 09 May 18 2.12pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

My next door neighbours have their 29 year old son living with them as he claims that he cannot afford to move out yet he seems to be able to afford a brand new Jaguar XE.

Perhaps he's still getting "bitty" from his Mum

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 2.23pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Rental prices in particular the SE are ridiculous. Kids going to University have no chance of saving (see my previous post), please don't blame them for not having any savings.

Do they have to go to University though?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

becky Flag over the moon 09 May 18 2.32pm

There's something rather wonderfully ironic in the fact that Lord David Willetts, as Executive Chair of the Resolution Foundation who propose this grab from pensioners to help young people, including those burdened by student loan debt to get on in life, is the very same man who as Universities Minister introduced (and increase) the bloody student loans that blighted their chances in the first place.


You really couldn't make it up could you?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 2.34pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Do what? I assure you that people earning over 45k pay NI.

Don't be so full of yourself.

The people that are currently retired didn't pay NIC above £45k for most of their lives. The 1% above £45k only came in from 2003. It then moved to 2% from 2011.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 2.37pm

Originally posted by becky

Of course, if all those selfish Generation X and Millennials actually took care of their elderly relations themselves instead of expecting the State to to so, as previous generations have, there wouldn't be all those pesky old people bed-blocking and needing care home places.

Tongue also very firmly in cheek

My experience is that the currently retired people were dreadful at looking after their parents. Very selfish generation from just post war. They were also rubbish at looking after their grandchildren

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 May 18 2.56pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Don't be so full of yourself.

The people that are currently retired didn't pay NIC above £45k for most of their lives. The 1% above £45k only came in from 2003. It then moved to 2% from 2011.

Yawn.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 May 18 3.03pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

My experience is that the currently retired people were dreadful at looking after their parents. Very selfish generation from just post war. They were also rubbish at looking after their grandchildren

As one of the group that you are referring to I must heartily disagree with you as the decline in family values started well after my generation

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 3.10pm

Originally posted by Badger11

But that is not what is proposed. It is a tax on working pensioners not all pensioners. I don't work and would be exempt yet I might be better off than those taxed.

For the record I actually agree with you it seems odd that the people who use the system most by and large don't contribute. All pensioners should contribute something unless they are really poor. As for free prescriptions the system is a joke and has been abused for years.


Edited by Badger11 (09 May 2018 8.08am)

Quite so.

I find the argument that people have a right to free NHS treatment when retired - as they contributed all of their lives - risible. The calculation is complex but let's say they mostly paid in - in today's money - around £2,000 to £2,500 per annum.

Currently the NHS spend is around £2,200 per person. 31.5m people are in work of a population totaling 66.5m. So the amount each working person would need to contribute per year to cover current needs is over £4,600.

Alternatively an individual that lives for 80 years and works for 50 would need to pay in £3,520 per annum to have 'banked' enough to pay for their inclusion in the system.

It's a well rehearsed point that our current retirees - if they have pensions - probably have defined benefit ones. These are crippling businesses like British Airways, BT and Royal Mail and allowing competitors to overtake them. Why shouldn't such people contribute for the increasing costs of their healthcare. The cost per head when the NHS started up was approx £230 in today's money. So in real terms it has risen nearly ten fold, including due to an increasingly aging population.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 09 May 18 3.12pm

hands up - I think I may have read the proposal wrong. Taking tax from money already earned - NO, but if, as I think I understand now, they are talking about taxing anything you earn (i.e. work for, earn, pay tax on, just like everyone else) - I'm fine with that. Age should make no difference to how much tax you are liable for (just how much you earn, i.e. if you're under the tax threshold)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 3.14pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

As one of the group that you are referring to I must heartily disagree with you as the decline in family values started well after my generation

My children have never benefited from an active grandparent, not one out of four. That is a common story from my age group, I hear it all the time. My children feel deeply saddened but also are not inclined to support their grandparents now when suddenly they want to engage for selfish reasons.

I expect coming generations to do better on this point, not worse, from all I hear from the young people around me. And I do think my generation has learned the lesson having watched the previous generation spend its time and money on holidays and cars instead of family.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 3.25pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Do they have to go to University though?

Yeah, selfish kids. Fancy wanting to prepare themselves to compete in the global market.

Should leave that to Canada, South Korea and Lithuania.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 09 May 18 3.50pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Quite so.

I find the argument that people have a right to free NHS treatment when retired - as they contributed all of their lives - risible. The calculation is complex but let's say they mostly paid in - in today's money - around £2,000 to £2,500 per annum.

Currently the NHS spend is around £2,200 per person. 31.5m people are in work of a population totaling 66.5m. So the amount each working person would need to contribute per year to cover current needs is over £4,600.

Alternatively an individual that lives for 80 years and works for 50 would need to pay in £3,520 per annum to have 'banked' enough to pay for their inclusion in the system.

It's a well rehearsed point that our current retirees - if they have pensions - probably have defined benefit ones. These are crippling businesses like British Airways, BT and Royal Mail and allowing competitors to overtake them. Why shouldn't such people contribute for the increasing costs of their healthcare. The cost per head when the NHS started up was approx £230 in today's money. So in real terms it has risen nearly ten fold, including due to an increasingly aging population.

Well for a start the post office screwed over the workers on their pensions,and that's before it was sold off.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

becky Flag over the moon 09 May 18 3.58pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Quite so.

I find the argument that people have a right to free NHS treatment when retired - as they contributed all of their lives - risible. The calculation is complex but let's say they mostly paid in - in today's money - around £2,000 to £2,500 per annum.

Currently the NHS spend is around £2,200 per person. 31.5m people are in work of a population totaling 66.5m. So the amount each working person would need to contribute per year to cover current needs is over £4,600.

Alternatively an individual that lives for 80 years and works for 50 would need to pay in £3,520 per annum to have 'banked' enough to pay for their inclusion in the system.

It's a well rehearsed point that our current retirees - if they have pensions - probably have defined benefit ones. These are crippling businesses like British Airways, BT and Royal Mail and allowing competitors to overtake them. Why shouldn't such people contribute for the increasing costs of their healthcare. The cost per head when the NHS started up was approx £230 in today's money. So in real terms it has risen nearly ten fold, including due to an increasingly aging population.

So, by your criteria, if contributions made do not permit retirees to free healthcare after retirement, I would ask where you stand on those who have NEVER made ANY contribution to the welfare system? Non-working spouses, benefit claimants & children - after all if one's contributions do not cover one's own costs why, by your precedent, should your children's be entitled either? Where do you draw the line on eligibility over contribution?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Page 6 of 11 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax on pensioners proposed