You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Hebdo vs Boris Johnson
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Charlie Hebdo vs Boris Johnson


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Stirlingsays Flag 11 Aug 18 2.26pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Hmm the China thing. Is that where you went off on one on the wrong point. To recap.

You: you're being so hard on Trump. Would you be so hard if the comments were made by the Russian or Chinese premiers?

Me: It's not the same. The US president has considerably more impact on world events than both those leaders. And as for the Chinese premier, even though he leads an autocratic nation at least he thinks about what he says and appreciates the impact of his views

You: I am supporting Chinese tyranny!

It was at that point I bowed out

I didn't say you were supporting tyranny, I was accusing you of ignorance and a lack of balance....Which aren't great attributes of someone who thinks they are more intelligent than the masses.

The US has considerably more impact on world events than China and Russia?

Yes, in a positive fashion it has. Yet you only had criticism for Trump when in reality he heads a state that is the pinnacle and is currently helping improve the world economy.

Explain to me how China doesn't have a massive impact on the world.

China, the second largest economy in the world, which is projected to overtake the US sits on the UN security council and has huge impacts around the world, especially in its region and Africa.

Russia, which I didn't focus upon, still has considerable impact.

You bowed out because your central point showed a lack of ability to acknowledge balance between Trump and the far far worst impacts of non western world leaders.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Aug 2018 2.38pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Aug 18 2.31pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Ok you two. It was you saying i think i am more intelligent. I was just expressing a view. You seem as erudite and informed as me, albeit you have reached a different destination.

This all seems to feed into what appears to be a world view that those who express views you deem "progressive" or "liberal" are all made by those who smugly look down on all you dumb proles.

You wrote, 'How do you deal with people who express opinions but are less intelligent than you? That is, when their views are clearly informed by ignorance or blind stupidity?'

So then are you suggesting our conclusions are wrong and that you weren't suggesting you are more intelligent than those you deem to support 'populist' ideas?

You seemingly ignored my offer to debate any of these 'populist' ideas. Cool, no problem.

The reality is that those policy ideas you mentioned are worldviews and cultural and have zero connection to the intelligence of the individual who believes in them.


Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Aug 2018 2.41pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 12 Aug 18 2.20am

Funny when the Guardian jokes about the Burka, it's OK? [Link]

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 12 Aug 18 9.21am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

Funny when the Guardian jokes about the Burka, it's OK? [Link]

Best some people complain that it is racist and islamaphobic then the guardian will get investigated and brought before a panel like boris.
I feel they might get away with it and it will be called 'banter'.

 

becky Flag over the moon 12 Aug 18 11.19am

Originally posted by cryrst

Best some people complain that it is racist and islamaphobic then the guardian will get investigated and brought before a panel like boris.
I feel they might get away with it and it will be called 'banter'.

.... but it has been written by a Moslem woman who wears a hijab, so it would be taken in the same way that blacks are permitted call each other by the 'n' word whilst the rest of us may not use it under any circumstances.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 12 Aug 18 1.01pm

Probably the Guardian's most notable columnist, Polly Toynbee, talks about the burqa in 2001. [Link]

"The top-to-toe burka, with its sinister, airless little grille, is more than an instrument of persecution, it is a public tarring and feathering of female sexuality. It transforms any woman into an object of defilement too untouchably disgusting to be seen. It is a garment of lurid sexual suggestiveness: what rampant desire and desirability lurks and leers beneath its dark mysteries? In its objectifying of women, it turns them into cowering creatures demanding and expecting violence and victimisation. Forget cultural sensibilities."

Is she an Islamaphobe for criticising the burqa? Does she have free speech here? Or is it one rule for the left and another for Tories?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 12 Aug 18 6.17pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

Probably the Guardian's most notable columnist, Polly Toynbee, talks about the burqa in 2001. [Link]

"The top-to-toe burka, with its sinister, airless little grille, is more than an instrument of persecution, it is a public tarring and feathering of female sexuality. It transforms any woman into an object of defilement too untouchably disgusting to be seen. It is a garment of lurid sexual suggestiveness: what rampant desire and desirability lurks and leers beneath its dark mysteries? In its objectifying of women, it turns them into cowering creatures demanding and expecting violence and victimisation. Forget cultural sensibilities."

Is she an Islamaphobe for criticising the burqa? Does she have free speech here? Or is it one rule for the left and another for Tories?

It is our duty as a nation to drag Britsh subjects of devout religious backgrounds into the 21st century. The idiot apologists seem to want the reverse.
Th influx of immigrants with devout religious beliefs are regressing this country. We have spent hundreds of years ridding ourselves of this sort of medieval nonsense and for what?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 13 Aug 18 10.11am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I didn't say you were supporting tyranny, I was accusing you of ignorance and a lack of balance....Which aren't great attributes of someone who thinks they are more intelligent than the masses.

The US has considerably more impact on world events than China and Russia?

Yes, in a positive fashion it has. Yet you only had criticism for Trump when in reality he heads a state that is the pinnacle and is currently helping improve the world economy.

Explain to me how China doesn't have a massive impact on the world.

China, the second largest economy in the world, which is projected to overtake the US sits on the UN security council and has huge impacts around the world, especially in its region and Africa.

Russia, which I didn't focus upon, still has considerable impact.

You bowed out because your central point showed a lack of ability to acknowledge balance between Trump and the far far worst impacts of non western world leaders.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Aug 2018 2.38pm)

This one was in response to you saying that we were all being hard on Trump. We wouldn't be so hard if the Russian or Chinese premiers were shooting from the hip. I replied that they don't: even effective dictators like them measure their comments

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 13 Aug 18 10.17am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You wrote, 'How do you deal with people who express opinions but are less intelligent than you? That is, when their views are clearly informed by ignorance or blind stupidity?'

So then are you suggesting our conclusions are wrong and that you weren't suggesting you are more intelligent than those you deem to support 'populist' ideas?

You seemingly ignored my offer to debate any of these 'populist' ideas. Cool, no problem.

The reality is that those policy ideas you mentioned are worldviews and cultural and have zero connection to the intelligence of the individual who believes in them.


Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Aug 2018 2.41pm)

And this one was in reponse to an allegaton that I hate populist politics as those who follow it are (you say) my intellectual inferiors. My question was inferring that you attack plenty on this site based on your belief that thier views are based on ignorance or lesser intelligence i.e. that you know more than them. I was calliing you out for hypocrisy.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Aug 18 2.20pm

Originally posted by silvertop

This one was in response to you saying that we were all being hard on Trump. We wouldn't be so hard if the Russian or Chinese premiers were shooting from the hip. I replied that they don't: even effective dictators like them measure their comments

So trump is a dictator now.
Get some perspective. The USA are the one country I would IMO actually trust. The fact that trump says it how it is should be respected not vilified. Anyone can hide but it takes guts to put your head above the parapet. He knows that some things he has done or will do won’t be correct for some of the USA or the world but doing nothing is not an option.
Much like doing nothing about the issues in this country shouldn’t be an option but it appears that it is the way it is.
Apathy will be shown to be the wrong action taken.
Just waiting to let integration happen is wrong and it won’t happen.
I’m not buying the “give it time” mantra.
Time will not be a healer it will be the cause of pain and suffering in the years ahead.
Seeing what is happening now and stating it is not hypocrisy,it is fact.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Aug 18 2.31pm

Originally posted by silvertop

This one was in response to you saying that we were all being hard on Trump. We wouldn't be so hard if the Russian or Chinese premiers were shooting from the hip. I replied that they don't: even effective dictators like them measure their comments

I think anyone reading this exchange will observe you avoiding questions and re-framing conversations instead.

You are deserving of criticism in my view for viewing how discreet a dictator is as of any importance when comparing to Trump.....but that's the extent of that.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Aug 2018 2.57pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Aug 18 2.51pm

Originally posted by silvertop

And this one was in reponse to an allegaton that I hate populist politics as those who follow it are (you say) my intellectual inferiors. My question was inferring that you attack plenty on this site based on your belief that thier views are based on ignorance or lesser intelligence i.e. that you know more than them. I was calliing you out for hypocrisy.

Again, you were asked directly and again you avoid.

Unlike you I answer questions, whether they are implied or explicit.

I do attack those who I regard as making silly comments. This is not hypocrisy as I don't pretend otherwise. I debate anyone contending otherwise. I don't hide behind opaque statements.

I do believe some worldviews are better than others. I do not pretend otherwise and I'm more than willing to explain why in debates.

I criticise those who put forward significantly different worldviews....I don't connect them holding those views as meaning that they are less intelligent. That may or may not be the case. Intelligence is not the be and end all in the judgement of a person. Most people who engage in a political forum can hold their own on some level.

I tend to focus more upon the ideas than play the actual person, unless I perceive a personal attack or attack on a group for poor reasons. Serial, for example....I differ wildly from him but it's an ideas debate not a personal attack....beyond the odd jokey swipe I suppose.

I state why I believe something and I state why I would believe another worldview might be wrong (within the context of society working as best it can).

For example, I attack progressivism regularly and I give my reasons why I attack it. People are free to defend it and I fully recognise that many intelligent people are progressives. Intelligence does not lead to one particular political narrative.

You seem to prefer a style of making statements then when criticised for them adopt a style of not answering subsequent questions. Even ones asking for clarity and instead hiding behind reframes.

What is wrong with answering questions.


Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Aug 2018 3.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 13 Aug 18 2.52pm

Originally posted by silvertop

This one was in response to you saying that we were all being hard on Trump. We wouldn't be so hard if the Russian or Chinese premiers were shooting from the hip. I replied that they don't: even effective dictators like them measure their comments

Well the Philipine's President Duterte certainly shoots from the hip? & usually quite literally

 


Pro USA & Israel

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Aug 18 9.07pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Well the Philipine's President Duterte certainly shoots from the hip? & usually quite literally

Ha ha
I think he only tends to shoot low life scrum bags who have it coming.
I may be wrong.
It has been noted before

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 14 Aug 18 10.29am

Originally posted by cryrst

So trump is a dictator now.
Get some perspective. The USA are the one country I would IMO actually trust. The fact that trump says it how it is should be respected not vilified. Anyone can hide but it takes guts to put your head above the parapet. He knows that some things he has done or will do won’t be correct for some of the USA or the world but doing nothing is not an option.
Much like doing nothing about the issues in this country shouldn’t be an option but it appears that it is the way it is.
Apathy will be shown to be the wrong action taken.
Just waiting to let integration happen is wrong and it won’t happen.
I’m not buying the “give it time” mantra.
Time will not be a healer it will be the cause of pain and suffering in the years ahead.
Seeing what is happening now and stating it is not hypocrisy,it is fact.

I trust you are now winding me up? This is OBVIOUSLY not what I said.

I was saying - just to ram home the point one last time - that there is no-one alive whose words have more influence and impact. Yet he constantly shoots from the hip with little or no filter. I think that is irresponsible given his place in the world.

That's it!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 14 Aug 18 10.31am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Again, you were asked directly and again you avoid.

Unlike you I answer questions, whether they are implied or explicit.

I do attack those who I regard as making silly comments. This is not hypocrisy as I don't pretend otherwise. I debate anyone contending otherwise. I don't hide behind opaque statements.

I do believe some worldviews are better than others. I do not pretend otherwise and I'm more than willing to explain why in debates.

I criticise those who put forward significantly different worldviews....I don't connect them holding those views as meaning that they are less intelligent. That may or may not be the case. Intelligence is not the be and end all in the judgement of a person. Most people who engage in a political forum can hold their own on some level.

I tend to focus more upon the ideas than play the actual person, unless I perceive a personal attack or attack on a group for poor reasons. Serial, for example....I differ wildly from him but it's an ideas debate not a personal attack....beyond the odd jokey swipe I suppose.

I state why I believe something and I state why I would believe another worldview might be wrong (within the context of society working as best it can).

For example, I attack progressivism regularly and I give my reasons why I attack it. People are free to defend it and I fully recognise that many intelligent people are progressives. Intelligence does not lead to one particular political narrative.

You seem to prefer a style of making statements then when criticised for them adopt a style of not answering subsequent questions. Even ones asking for clarity and instead hiding behind reframes.

What is wrong with answering questions.


Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Aug 2018 3.14pm)

What have I dodged?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Aug 18 11.27am

Originally posted by silvertop

I trust you are now winding me up? This is OBVIOUSLY not what I said.

I was saying - just to ram home the point one last time - that there is no-one alive whose words have more influence and impact. Yet he constantly shoots from the hip with little or no filter. I think that is irresponsible given his place in the world.

That's it!

You included trump in the paragraph.
If you think he is a dictator then stick by your convictions.
Free speech and all that.
Like I said he tells it as it is.
Actually trying to make his country great again.
IE the Iran deal is crap. In two years they can just crack on how they were.he saw through the smokescreen and will now get a positive response.
Taxes on imports can only benefit the USA.
Wish some of ours would consider the UK first.
We even have the opposition leader lying his way out of a situation.
And he has a very short memory of the event.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 15 Aug 18 2.17am

Not sure if this link works... [Link]

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Aug 18 9.44am

Originally posted by silvertop

What have I dodged?


Do you regard yourself as more intelligent than those who follow populist policies? I think that was the gist of it.

Just to be clear, all this is only an exchange of views and I harbour no ill will. It's a problem with text sometimes.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

silvertop Flag Portishead 15 Aug 18 10.47am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


Do you regard yourself as more intelligent than those who follow populist policies? I think that was the gist of it.

Just to be clear, all this is only an exchange of views and I harbour no ill will. It's a problem with text sometimes.

The brain is a muscle like any other. I think many people just let their brain atrophy. So when it comes to thinking current affairs, they are not match sharp and opt for the easy route. We have both met many people like that. Not thick. But too lazy in the mind to connect with events that shape their lives.

Populist politics plays into that as it offers easy solutions for difficult problems.

In Victorian times few had the vote. But those who did had no TV or radio. They read "respectable" newspapers every day, poetry, philosophy, history, literature and actively engaged in the arts and intellectual debate. They were also directly involved in commerce, agriculture and industry. Politicians had to be on their toes then. Now I fear they see their role as more of a case of feeding the pond life.

That is why I see populist politics as dirty words. It insults us.

In some ways, even though I lost my career in the public sector because of it, I admire austerity as it was rightly seen as critical and went against mass support. Ditto direct negotiation with the IRA where Major defied his whole cabinet. More of that please.

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Hebdo vs Boris Johnson