You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour’s workers dividends plan
November 21 2026 10.43pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour’s workers dividends plan


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 09 Sep 18 11.41am

If you want to see the difference between the two parties at the minute, look at their chancellors. Hammond has been conspicuously invisible for the past year, while in that time, John McDonnell has been offering some really inventive policy proposals. We’ve had UBI, more detail on the National Inveetment Bank, and now this [Link] offering workers in private companies dividends to shore up their declining wages.

It isn’t so much a left right issue for me. It is an issue with an inefficiency in how ur state is run. So much tax is paid to subsidise some of the biggest companies in the country through in work benefits. I’m supportive of subsidising start ups, but if your balance sheet has 8 or more 0s on it, you should pay your employees enough for them to live comfortably, and so they shouldn’t suffer the humiliation of taking state handouts.

Workers have been utterly shafted for the past 4 decades. That Labour are trying to reverse the tide while the media fulminate our Boris’ love life is a glimmer of hope in dark times.

Edited by serial thriller (09 Sep 2018 11.45am)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 09 Sep 18 11.59am

Originally posted by serial thriller

If you want to see the difference between the two parties at the minute, look at their chancellors. Hammond has been conspicuously invisible for the past year, while in that time, John McDonnell has been offering some really inventive policy proposals. We’ve had UBI, more detail on the National Inveetment Bank, and now this [Link] offering workers in private companies dividends to shore up their declining wages.

It isn’t so much a left right issue for me. It is an issue with an inefficiency in how ur state is run. So much tax is paid to subsidise some of the biggest companies in the country through in work benefits. I’m supportive of subsidising start ups, but if your balance sheet has 8 or more 0s on it, you should pay your employees enough for them to live comfortably, and so they shouldn’t suffer the humiliation of taking state handouts.

Workers have been utterly shafted for the past 4 decades. That Labour are trying to reverse the tide while the media fulminate our Boris’ love life is a glimmer of hope in dark times.

Edited by serial thriller (09 Sep 2018 11.45am)

If only............

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 09 Sep 18 1.55pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

If you want to see the difference between the two parties at the minute, look at their chancellors. Hammond has been conspicuously invisible for the past year, while in that time, John McDonnell has been offering some really inventive policy proposals. We’ve had UBI, more detail on the National Inveetment Bank, and now this [Link] offering workers in private companies dividends to shore up their declining wages.

It isn’t so much a left right issue for me. It is an issue with an inefficiency in how ur state is run. So much tax is paid to subsidise some of the biggest companies in the country through in work benefits. I’m supportive of subsidising start ups, but if your balance sheet has 8 or more 0s on it, you should pay your employees enough for them to live comfortably, and so they shouldn’t suffer the humiliation of taking state handouts.

Workers have been utterly shafted for the past 4 decades. That Labour are trying to reverse the tide while the media fulminate our Boris’ love life is a glimmer of hope in dark times.

Edited by serial thriller (09 Sep 2018 11.45am)

The first words in the headline
'He would FORCE companies to do this.
That must be like what happens in other socialist countries. Hence why they are shagged.
In a free society you cannot do that without major repercussions.
And what is living comfortably because until he also forces you to spend your money how he sees fit
People will always piss it up the wall on crap.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Sep 18 2.40pm

Spending other people's money is really easy.

It's a nonsense proposal.

 


Optimistic as ever

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 09 Sep 18 2.54pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The first words in the headline
'He would FORCE companies to do this.
That must be like what happens in other socialist countries. Hence why they are shagged.
In a free society you cannot do that without major repercussions.
And what is living comfortably because until he also forces you to spend your money how he sees fit
People will always piss it up the wall on crap.

But we already force companies to do many things, like pay corporation tax, implement employment laws and audit transparently. Why is this such a massive extension of that?

We are in crisis times, where income inequality is having observable negative effects on those being left behind, and where living standards have dropped at a faster rate than at any point in the past 200 years. For many in my generation, rent takes up 40%of your income in London, and after tax and food bills there is almost nothing left, even on the living wage. We are at crisis point, and we need radical solutions to solve it.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 09 Sep 18 2.59pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Spending other people's money is really easy.

It's a nonsense proposal.

But don't you see that this is what global corporations are doing to Britain. They are paying wages to employees which they know are too low to meet their needs, because they know the taxpayer will be forced to pay the rest.

If they paid their workers what was adequate not even to live comfortably, but to not live in need of in work benefits, we could spend those hundreds of millions we are wasting on, say, public water fountains, keeping local libraries open or subsidising small businesses.

As I say this is about efficiency, not communism.

Edited by serial thriller (09 Sep 2018 3.00pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

cryrst Flag The garden of England 09 Sep 18 3.22pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

But we already force companies to do many things, like pay corporation tax, implement employment laws and audit transparently. Why is this such a massive extension of that?

We are in crisis times, where income inequality is having observable negative effects on those being left behind, and where living standards have dropped at a faster rate than at any point in the past 200 years. For many in my generation, rent takes up 40%of your income in London, and after tax and food bills there is almost nothing left, even on the living wage. We are at crisis point, and we need radical solutions to solve it.


Income inequality is part of a capitalist environment. Unfortunatly.
Its not only rent but mortgages leave as many people potless. We get on with it. Like i said in another post.
Our methods for calculating poverty is way different to other countries.
Its a comparison to a mean average of incomes.
Personally i think the system for welfare does need changing whereby you are rewarded for working not penalised.
Ie if your benefits are say total with rent etc leaving you with £300 , if you get a job then the goverment should calculate you are left with say £500 after you have paid your own bills.
At the moment if you come off the chat and work you can be worse off. That isnt right, but going back on track it does no one any good to force a payment as then the cost of whatever service or manufacturer is supplying will rise to cover it.
Then your back where you started.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Sep 18 3.43pm

I don't agree with this I think it is a gimmick.

However I am in favour of making companies pay a reasonable amount of tax and if the minimum wage isn't enough then we should raise it.

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 09 Sep 18 4.07pm

Perpetual low wages are directly linked to our dreadful productivity.

At a recent chat-in of economists I caught on RT they all zoomed in on that problem as the UK's main defect.

The economy should be boosted by workers cash in their pockets to create demand.

I don't think the economy drops down from rich to poor, for me an economy must work for people, or what is the point of it.

 

becky Flag over the moon 09 Sep 18 5.04pm

Fine idea, taking a share of the profits as dividends during the good times, as long as, like any other recipient of a dividend, they are prepared to put money back into the company during hard times........

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 09 Sep 18 6.02pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I don't agree with this I think it is a gimmick.

However I am in favour of making companies pay a reasonable amount of tax and if the minimum wage isn't enough then we should raise it.

I think one of the major issues - from experience - is the emergence of flexible hours contracts in our economy, which in effect allows companies to get round the minimum wage via legal technicalities.

You may disagree with this proposal but at least Labour and McDonnell are trying to do something. The slide towards eroding workplace rights in this country has almost felt inevitable in recent times. It is a major crisis in my eyes, leading to worse conditions for many of us, higher mental health issues and ultimately a worse service.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

cryrst Flag The garden of England 09 Sep 18 8.17pm

Originally posted by becky

Fine idea, taking a share of the profits as dividends during the good times, as long as, like any other recipient of a dividend, they are prepared to put money back into the company during hard times........

Ha ha
Not goner happen.
The rich people can put that in.
As tax rises it can work surely!!!
T I C

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 10 Sep 18 12.06pm

Gimmick like PRP, if people remember. Funny that the TUC are finessing an ex-Tory idea to include voting rights.


I expect not as most on here nowadays seem to be ex-public sector on gold plated (ill health) pensions.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Sep 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by pefwin

Gimmick like PRP, if people remember. Funny that the TUC are finessing an ex-Tory idea to include voting rights.


I expect not as most on here nowadays seem to be ex-public sector on gold plated (ill health) pensions.

The TUC have just come out with the brilliant idea that workers should only do a 4 days week. Have they seen the state of the high street? Companies are dropping like flies and before long many TUC members will be enjoying 7 days a week off.

I am all in favour of flexible working hours but they expect to work less for the same pay. Well I want a date with Kylie and that aint going to happen either.

 


One more point

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 10 Sep 18 3.43pm

Originally posted by Badger11

The TUC have just come out with the brilliant idea that workers should only do a 4 days week. Have they seen the state of the high street? Companies are dropping like flies and before long many TUC members will be enjoying 7 days a week off.

I am all in favour of flexible working hours but they expect to work less for the same pay. Well I want a date with Kylie and that aint going to happen either.

did you mean to post this on the flexible working hours thread or the dividends?

Edited by pefwin (10 Sep 2018 3.43pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Sep 18 3.51pm

Originally posted by pefwin

did you mean to post this on the flexible working hours thread or the dividends?

Edited by pefwin (10 Sep 2018 3.43pm)

Hi I posted here as there wasn't a working hours thread at the time. Feel free to move or delete it as I have since added my comments to that thread.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Sep 18 9.14am

Labour has announced that companies should be forced to hand over 10% of their shares to the workers.

I am in favour of workers owning shares and most responsible companies have a scheme, but I don't like compulsion.

The cynic in me has spotted a more sinister purpose in what appears to be a benevolent policy.

In their plans Labour say that whilst the workers will receive the dividends the share will be held in a central pool. I would call that a voting block.

Question: Who controls the voting rights for that block? The unions perhaps?

Edited by Badger11 (24 Sep 2018 9.14am)

 


One more point

chris123 Flag hove actually 24 Sep 18 11.18am

Originally posted by Badger11

Labour has announced that companies should be forced to hand over 10% of their shares to the workers.

I am in favour of workers owning shares and most responsible companies have a scheme, but I don't like compulsion.

The cynic in me has spotted a more sinister purpose in what appears to be a benevolent policy.

In their plans Labour say that whilst the workers will receive the dividends the share will be held in a central pool. I would call that a voting block.

Question: Who controls the voting rights for that block? The unions perhaps?

Edited by Badger11 (24 Sep 2018 9.14am)

I did some contract work for a firm that had recently floated having been privately owned for years. Staff were awarded shares partly based on years of service, and the IPO was at £2.15 - in 2012 the shares traded at over £17.00. Needless to say there were some who made some serious money.

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 24 Sep 18 12.43pm

I think instead of shares wages should be linked from the top earners to the bottom.
If the chief executive gets a rise all workers get the same %

If the top bosses get a bonus the other employees get the same % of earnings.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 24 Sep 18 12.46pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

I think instead of shares wages should be linked from the top earners to the bottom.
If the chief executive gets a rise all workers get the same %

If the top bosses get a bonus the other employees get the same % of earnings.

Can"t argue with that !

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour’s workers dividends plan