You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 6 of 71 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
fan Flag Caterham 14 Oct 18 3.32pm

Totally agree with last two posts Singing is about noise NOT view. So sing from any part of the ground why HF want Block E? easy better view. When partial standing at premier ground is introduced [as it will be at some stage] suppose the HF will want to move again.

 

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 14 Oct 18 5.55pm

Originally posted by Mapletree


They didn't realise I paid for my seat in 1995 for 25 years, so I don't think they can move me easily.

Edited by Mapletree (10 Oct 2018 3.46pm)

Maple,

Just going back to this point for a moment, it seems to me that there will be a breach of contract situation if they try to force you to give up this seat before the prepaid term ends.

I would be interested to know if the club have considered this, as my own (uninformed) view is that both parties entered into a legally binding arrangement for the full 25 year term.

Anyone with knowledge of contract law out there?

 

Spitfire Flag Biggin Hill 14 Oct 18 6.40pm

Originally posted by palace_in_frogland

Maple,

Just going back to this point for a moment, it seems to me that there will be a breach of contract situation if they try to force you to give up this seat before the prepaid term ends.

I would be interested to know if the club have considered this, as my own (uninformed) view is that both parties entered into a legally binding arrangement for the full 25 year term.

Anyone with knowledge of contract law out there?

The contract was probably with the Club / Business when owned by Noades or Goldberg.
That went bust then Jordan took over and then went bust.
My understanding is that each of the new businesses honoured long term season tickets but contractually were under no obligation to other than morally.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 14 Oct 18 7.12pm

Originally posted by palace_in_frogland

Maple,

Just going back to this point for a moment, it seems to me that there will be a breach of contract situation if they try to force you to give up this seat before the prepaid term ends.

I would be interested to know if the club have considered this, as my own (uninformed) view is that both parties entered into a legally binding arrangement for the full 25 year term.

Anyone with knowledge of contract law out there?

Who knows

I shall plough my own furrow on this and will let everyone know if I find out anything useful. I have one or two ideas on how to exercise leverage should I need to. But who knows if I do need to. The rules for the singing section and seat selection are unclear. What is clear is that this is the Club’s singing section not the HF. I shall therefore be spitting feathers if the HF gets preferential treatment to other singers.

 

EagleStew Flag Lewisham 14 Oct 18 7.15pm

So I'm not a season ticket holder in Block E, but I was for 10 years and my dad and his friends still are. I often use my dad's ticket when he doesn't go and so I still feel strongly against this so called 'Singing Section'.

For me the club have messed this up big time. Although what the HF have done may seem a little childish at first, I still think they are good for the club, and would have been in full support of them had they wanted to stay where they were in Block B.

The club have been bullied into making this singing section at the detriment to loyal ST holders in Block E. It doesn't matter if you've had a ST there for 2 years or 21 years, they are all loyal fans!

I propose an idea...

At the beginning of the Arsenal match, members of Block E that don't agree with how the club have managed this situation do not go straight to their seats at kick off. Instead they stay on the concourse (have a beer/hot dog or whatever) and then take to their seats 10 minutes or so into the game. This would be a silent but visible protest against the way the club are going about this 'so-called' managed-move!

It's just an idea.....

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Oct 18 7.55pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Who knows

I shall plough my own furrow on this and will let everyone know if I find out anything useful. I have one or two ideas on how to exercise leverage should I need to. But who knows if I do need to. The rules for the singing section and seat selection are unclear. What is clear is that this is the Club’s singing section not the HF. I shall therefore be spitting feathers if the HF gets preferential treatment to other singers.

I don't think so. Listen to SP interview with the FYP podcast. It's clearly going to be the HF taking those seats....

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 14 Oct 18 8.13pm

Originally posted by EagleStew

So I'm not a season ticket holder in Block E, but I was for 10 years and my dad and his friends still are. I often use my dad's ticket when he doesn't go and so I still feel strongly against this so called 'Singing Section'.

For me the club have messed this up big time. Although what the HF have done may seem a little childish at first, I still think they are good for the club, and would have been in full support of them had they wanted to stay where they were in Block B.

The club have been bullied into making this singing section at the detriment to loyal ST holders in Block E. It doesn't matter if you've had a ST there for 2 years or 21 years, they are all loyal fans!

I propose an idea...

At the beginning of the Arsenal match, members of Block E that don't agree with how the club have managed this situation do not go straight to their seats at kick off. Instead they stay on the concourse (have a beer/hot dog or whatever) and then take to their seats 10 minutes or so into the game. This would be a silent but visible protest against the way the club are going about this 'so-called' managed-move!

It's just an idea.....


Not a bad idea. Let's see if it's more than 100 HF who have got their own way. Then we'll see who Parish thinks are the better fans.

 

becky Flag over the moon 14 Oct 18 8.37pm

Originally posted by EagleStew

So I'm not a season ticket holder in Block E, but I was for 10 years and my dad and his friends still are. I often use my dad's ticket when he doesn't go and so I still feel strongly against this so called 'Singing Section'.

For me the club have messed this up big time. Although what the HF have done may seem a little childish at first, I still think they are good for the club, and would have been in full support of them had they wanted to stay where they were in Block B.

The club have been bullied into making this singing section at the detriment to loyal ST holders in Block E. It doesn't matter if you've had a ST there for 2 years or 21 years, they are all loyal fans!

I propose an idea...

At the beginning of the Arsenal match, members of Block E that don't agree with how the club have managed this situation do not go straight to their seats at kick off. Instead they stay on the concourse (have a beer/hot dog or whatever) and then take to their seats 10 minutes or so into the game. This would be a silent but visible protest against the way the club are going about this 'so-called' managed-move!

It's just an idea.....

Or.......

get everyone going with a rousing chorus of that good, old, protestors favourite "We shall not be moved"


At least with a vocal protest it will come over on the TV transmission, and maybe a banner or two to go with it - just to prove that the HF aren't the only ones who can do displays....

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 14 Oct 18 8.50pm

Originally posted by rach_cpfc

Well I already sit in block E row 23 AND I have a music degree so does that mean my seat is guaranteed now....??

Seriously though, what the club is "offering" us is exchange for being turfed out of our seats after years with no guarantee of where or when we might able to renew for next year would be laughable if it wasn't just totally ridiculous instead...

Had my letter - called box office & asked if they could guarantee 4 seats together - NO !!!!!! Whilst we get “priority” we may have to sit in different rows

And I know people near me who have been in the same seats since the stand was built

 

eagles2011 Flag 14 Oct 18 9.21pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

So Inclusive singing area, actually means,..Exclusive

Singing will be banned in all other areas, offenders will be ejected from the stadium and banned for life (not sure what will happen to sway fans who dare to sing)

This will mean that HF and Parrish can say it’s omly HF who sing, and they are the only real supporters

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 14 Oct 18 9.57pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I don't think so. Listen to SP interview with the FYP podcast. It's clearly going to be the HF taking those seats....

In that case I was lied to by the Box Office. Who’d a thought it.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 14 Oct 18 10.16pm

Originally posted by becky

Or.......

get everyone going with a rousing chorus of that good, old, protestors favourite "We shall not be moved"


At least with a vocal protest it will come over on the TV transmission, and maybe a banner or two to go with it - just to prove that the HF aren't the only ones who can do displays....


Perhaps someone could hang a picture from the Holmesdale Upper balcony, just over block E, of Parish's backside doing a dump on the people below.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Oct 18 10.59pm

Why not put all the seats in the LH up for grabs at the beginning of next season. Block off a thousand in the middle explicitly for singers. Then do the same each season. In the picture above no one ws ever guaranteed a place on the terraces. Match by match

 

veterancpsup Flag Pimlico 15 Oct 18 12.15am

Have I missed the auditions?[

 

PalacePhotoMan Flag Wallington 15 Oct 18 2.18am

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

Had my letter - called box office & asked if they could guarantee 4 seats together - NO !!!!!! Whilst we get “priority” we may have to sit in different rows

And I know people near me who have been in the same seats since the stand was built

You're not guaranteed ONE seat, let alone 4. And get priority over who? The rest of the 400 displaced E Block, all vying for the same seats? This will be a bunfight, and it's a shocking way to treat any loyal supporter, let alone 400 of them. Or us, I should say.

In Parish's own press release just 6 weeks ago, he said nearly 100% renew in the Lower Holmesdale, and about 92% elsewhere in the ground. By my calculation, that's about 800 seats dotted around all 4 sides of the ground, becoming free for the 400 to apply for on 22nd April (which is Easter Monday btw, when presumably the Box Office will be closed). Most of those will be at the back of the Arthur and are free because nobody wants to sit there regularly. So it's expected that E Block fans will meekly accept "sacrificing" (his word) their best seat in the house for the chance of a seat that nobody else wants?

This is his statement dated 2nd Sept 2018

[Link]

Would Parish have become a millionaire if he'd treated his loyal customers this way? I doubt it.

It's shameful and he knows it.

 


Zaha, Williams, Murray, Ambrose, Scannell.

A 5-man forward line who scored 3 goals in 10 minutes on 27th September 2011 at .......................

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 15 Oct 18 7.44am

Originally posted by PalacePhotoMan

You're not guaranteed ONE seat, let alone 4. And get priority over who? The rest of the 400 displaced E Block, all vying for the same seats? This will be a bunfight, and it's a shocking way to treat any loyal supporter, let alone 400 of them. Or us, I should say.

In Parish's own press release just 6 weeks ago, he said nearly 100% renew in the Lower Holmesdale, and about 92% elsewhere in the ground. By my calculation, that's about 800 seats dotted around all 4 sides of the ground, becoming free for the 400 to apply for on 22nd April (which is Easter Monday btw, when presumably the Box Office will be closed). Most of those will be at the back of the Arthur and are free because nobody wants to sit there regularly. So it's expected that E Block fans will meekly accept "sacrificing" (his word) their best seat in the house for the chance of a seat that nobody else wants?

This is his statement dated 2nd Sept 2018

[Link]

Would Parish have become a millionaire if he'd treated his loyal customers this way? I doubt it.

It's shameful and he knows it.



"We explained to the Fanatics that we felt it would be hugely unfair and disruptive - as well as potentially cause a great deal of ill feeling towards their group - if we pressed ahead. Instead, we promised that we would revisit this once the Main Stand was rebuilt"

"...unless 100 supporters at the centre of block E would like to give up their seats voluntarily on the basis that the club will do its very best to find them alternatives, there is no real prospect of facilitating their wish of a move to the centre of Block E at this time"

"We remain open to any ideas and sensible solutions that do not disadvantage our other valued supporters"

So what changed in two months Parish? Possibilities are that the Main Stand isn't going to be rebuilt anytime soon (he's already started making noises on that score) or he's scared of the HF, plain and simple; frightened for his own safety.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 15 Oct 18 8.32am

Can't believe what is happening to the club I've supported since 1961/62 season.

I've seen some really bad times over those years but we, as fans, stuck together.

I actually thought we as a club were on the up,5/6 years of Premier League,apparently in the black,new stand in the pipeline,Dyson dryers in toilets ..now that is posh

A group of Palace fans,who already had their own area and were great with what they added to the atmosphere,decided they wanted to move, have now got a singing section ( how pathetic ) at the expense of other Palace fans.

Fan against fan is now a new low for us.

 

BuckinghamshireEagle Flag 15 Oct 18 8.33am

What a shame that this could not have been sorted out through discussion between the club, the HF and other fans in the LH. But since it was not, the club should have stuck to their original position.
Without doubt the u-turn is due to the Main Stand redevelopment and possibility of a standing section receding into the distance.
It is more than shameful. The original statement was correct. Forcing 100 loyal fans to move would have been unfair. Now it is extended to 400. I’m sure this is only to perpetuate the lie that it is being done to create a larger “singing section” rather than to advantage one group of supporters over another. When only 100 or so of these seats have been taken up will the others be offered back to their original holders, even if they have accepted a worse seat elsewhere in the interim?
It’s a mess, is likely to get very ugly and has the potential to cause long term damage to the relationship between the club and its loyal fans, whether they sit in Block E or not.

 

.TUX. Flag 15 Oct 18 8.46am

Originally posted by bexleydave



"We explained to the Fanatics that we felt it would be hugely unfair and disruptive - as well as potentially cause a great deal of ill feeling towards their group - if we pressed ahead. Instead, we promised that we would revisit this once the Main Stand was rebuilt"

"...unless 100 supporters at the centre of block E would like to give up their seats voluntarily on the basis that the club will do its very best to find them alternatives, there is no real prospect of facilitating their wish of a move to the centre of Block E at this time"

"We remain open to any ideas and sensible solutions that do not disadvantage our other valued supporters"

So what changed in two months Parish? Possibilities are that the Main Stand isn't going to be rebuilt anytime soon (he's already started making noises on that score) or he's scared of the HF, plain and simple; frightened for his own safety.

Care to expand on this little gem?

 


Buy Litecoin.

eritheagle Flag Erith 15 Oct 18 9.02am

Originally posted by bexleydave



"We explained to the Fanatics that we felt it would be hugely unfair and disruptive - as well as potentially cause a great deal of ill feeling towards their group - if we pressed ahead. Instead, we promised that we would revisit this once the Main Stand was rebuilt"

"...unless 100 supporters at the centre of block E would like to give up their seats voluntarily on the basis that the club will do its very best to find them alternatives, there is no real prospect of facilitating their wish of a move to the centre of Block E at this time"

"We remain open to any ideas and sensible solutions that do not disadvantage our other valued supporters"

So what changed in two months Parish? Possibilities are that the Main Stand isn't going to be rebuilt anytime soon (he's already started making noises on that score) or he's scared of the HF, plain and simple; frightened for his own safety.

Or the hf are threatening to release the naked pictures they have of him!

 

Page 6 of 71 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic