You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FA Cup next round
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

FA Cup next round


Page 6 of 10 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Elpis Flag In a pub 18 Feb 19 10.05pm

Originally posted by Jefroc

I think it is time we gave Watford another drubbing!

I used to love Watford. I remember a 5-1 drubbing wasn’t it? With AJ etc. Mind you I would settle for a one goal victory this time if pushed!

Yes I had us to win 4-1 and was the only Palace fan in the ground hoping AJ would miss the pen that made it 5

Anyway decent enough draw ,would have taken that at the start of January as a 1/4 final match . COYP

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 18 Feb 19 10.10pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Hopefully not Zaha's legs lol

Well we won't get away with anything dangerous this time.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 18 Feb 19 10.15pm

Nope VAR will mess up this dirty game plans of yours


Originally posted by Superhorns3

Well we won't get away with anything dangerous this time.

 

Jefroc Flag Crete 18 Feb 19 10.15pm

Earlier I said “I used to love Watford”! I meant of course:

“I used to love going to Watford”!

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 18 Feb 19 10.33pm

Terrific draw for us. Wouldn’t have been confident if we had been drawn at home as we’re so much better away.

 

jjsperling Flag 18 Feb 19 10.53pm

The FA cup has always confused me. Provided that we beat Watford, will there be a draw for the the semi-final fixtures? Or does it become "World Cup style" from the quarters going forward?

 

B.L.C. Bob Flag London 18 Feb 19 11.28pm

Originally posted by jjsperling

The FA cup has always confused me. Provided that we beat Watford, will there be a draw for the the semi-final fixtures? Or does it become "World Cup style" from the quarters going forward?



Yes, JJ. Rule 8a of the Competition specifies draws taking place at each round right up to and including the Semi-finals.

Edited by B.L.C. Bob (18 Feb 2019 11.29pm)

Edited by B.L.C. Bob (18 Feb 2019 11.30pm)

 


Claret and blue with a touch of gout too

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 19 Feb 19 7.46am

Originally posted by Willo

To me and of course the club, survival in the PL is all important, accordingly I don't give a jot about the FA Cup.

Perhaps if we were safe I might have a frisson of excitement about the cup but we are in a relegation battle and it is imperative we don't slip through that dreaded relegation trapdoor.

If we manage to reach relative safety and find ourselves in the semi-final I might start to dream about a trip to Wembley but at present I am concerned about our standing in the table and don't give two hoots about the cup.

Yep, thats exactly how i feel willo, two hoots sums it up perfectly.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 19 Feb 19 7.56am

Originally posted by .TUX.

Being 270 minutes away from possibly winning OUR FIRST EVER MAJOR TROPHY is a distraction?!!!!!!!!

This mentally absolutely baffles me tbh.


What baffles me is that you can't see that that the FA cup at any time is a distraction for Palace survival, that at the moment hangs on a thread.
I know a lot of fans put the cup above all else, but i would think the majority would consider survival more important. IMHO

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 19 Feb 19 8.06am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER
What baffles me is that you can't see that that the FA cup at any time is a distraction for Palace survival, that at the moment hangs on a thread.
I know a lot of fans put the cup above all else, but i would think the majority would consider survival more important. IMHO

I vote for the FA Cup.
What's the point of finishing 17th every year if you don't ever have some fun?
Beating Man City occasionally is a little fun but nowt compared to the magic of Punch scoring that goal in the FA Cup Final. I want more of that please

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 19 Feb 19 9.08am

Originally posted by MrCParrot

I vote for the FA Cup.
What's the point of finishing 17th every year if you don't ever have some fun?
Beating Man City occasionally is a little fun but nowt compared to the magic of Punch scoring that goal in the FA Cup Final. I want more of that please

Parrot

I do agree. The flip side is Portsmouth and Wigan.

 

Johng Flag 19 Feb 19 9.21am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Yep, thats exactly how i feel willo, two hoots sums it up perfectly.

Then presumably, both you and 'Willo' will, if you can be arsed, be watchimg the final, should we reach it, from the comfort of your armchairs.

 

Johng Flag 19 Feb 19 9.25am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

What baffles me is that you can't see that that the FA cup at any time is a distraction for Palace survival, that at the moment hangs on a thread.
I know a lot of fans put the cup above all else, but i would think the majority would consider survival more important. IMHO

Utter cobblers. We're in this game to win stuff. Hope you have a lovely time gardening or washing the car when the rest of us are at Wembley.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 Feb 19 9.38am

Always so many posts on other threads re: Cup or PL? Genuinely starting to annoy me now.

We stumbled to the cup final with a team that was suffering from an infamous Pardew run in the league.

The FA cup and League are not mutually exclusive, we would only have to win two more games to be in the final and whoever imagines that people would forget about our PL fight for survival on a daily basis should we progress in the cup are talking nonsense.

Desperate need for us to survive the in the Prem but cup success is a different entity and that would be magnificent. Can't be bored of a cup we have never even won!

There are 12 games left, a couple more will not hurt and we should be able to compete on both fronts without any hassle.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 19 Feb 19 9.43am

Can't believe some of the nervous nellies on here. We have another 4 league games before the QF where we should be picking up a few points and there's an international break after so no reason we shouldn't put out our strongest team possible.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Feb 19 9.51am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

What baffles me is that you can't see that that the FA cup at any time is a distraction for Palace survival, that at the moment hangs on a thread.
I know a lot of fans put the cup above all else, but i would think the majority would consider survival more important. IMHO

I'm with TUX on this.

Ex players doing radio and TV punditry are not the most erudite of chaps and you can see or hear they are just winging it with space fill platitudes and awful humour. However, one thing they seem to unite on is the Cup. The same question is asked: did you see the Cup as a distraction. Answer: definitely not. Getting knocked out stuffs confidence and loses momentum. OK, but you are fresher with more energy missing a weekend? Answer: we're athletes. We're fully conditioned to last the term, cup games and all. The games add absolutely nothing to fatigue levels. If anything, we're sharper.

Shearer constantly proves he has nothing of any merit to say. However, as a player I trust his opinion on what he thought as a player. Newcastle players, he says, would be happy with a comfy mid table finish and a good Cup run.

OK what else are pundits going to say co-hosting a Cup game? However, the proof seems to be in the pudding. Teams suffer from a Thursday night in Moldova in the Noddy Euro. But there seems no advantage from missing the Cup.

Lose an important player through injury and you might get a different answer. Or maybe you could have lost said important player while training over the same weekend?

You then have to look at commerce. You have to win it to get the big returns. However, the gain is in international recognition; increased sales of merchanside worldwide; a reducing reliance on TV revenue; correspondingly reducing impact of FFP...

And then there's the poor old fans. Battling every season for mid-table survival until we inevtitably do a Stoke. You'll look back in 10 years while we try year after year for the miracle to get us back up and think - what was it all for? Those wembley days, that's what.


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Feb 19 10.01am

The truth is the decision is made within the club before or after the league game before the next cup game and is when I take my view.

Lose 4 in a row or gain 1 point and priorities on the league are very very clear.

Hopefully we’ll be doing okay at the very least and then brush Watford aside like the dirty on pitch vermin pests they are now.

 


COYP

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Feb 19 10.20am

Originally posted by silvertop

I'm with TUX on this.

Ex players doing radio and TV punditry are not the most erudite of chaps and you can see or hear they are just winging it with space fill platitudes and awful humour. However, one thing they seem to unite on is the Cup. The same question is asked: did you see the Cup as a distraction. Answer: definitely not. Getting knocked out stuffs confidence and loses momentum. OK, but you are fresher with more energy missing a weekend? Answer: we're athletes. We're fully conditioned to last the term, cup games and all. The games add absolutely nothing to fatigue levels. If anything, we're sharper.

Shearer constantly proves he has nothing of any merit to say. However, as a player I trust his opinion on what he thought as a player. Newcastle players, he says, would be happy with a comfy mid table finish and a good Cup run.

OK what else are pundits going to say co-hosting a Cup game? However, the proof seems to be in the pudding. Teams suffer from a Thursday night in Moldova in the Noddy Euro. But there seems no advantage from missing the Cup.

Lose an important player through injury and you might get a different answer. Or maybe you could have lost said important player while training over the same weekend?

You then have to look at commerce. You have to win it to get the big returns. However, the gain is in international recognition; increased sales of merchanside worldwide; a reducing reliance on TV revenue; correspondingly reducing impact of FFP...

And then there's the poor old fans. Battling every season for mid-table survival until we inevtitably do a Stoke. You'll look back in 10 years while we try year after year for the miracle to get us back up and think - what was it all for? Those wembley days, that's what.


The Most convincing argument for the FA Cup I have read here!

The only this it does not address is the 'distraction' Element. Having 'One eye on the cup' is not a good way to garner points from a League game in this division. Like it or not, the best Way to progress as a club is to bring in the money that the Premier League offers. To win the FA Cup at the expense of the Premier League survival is short-termism and where it will benefit the Fans and give them 'those Wembley days', it'll do more damage to the club in the long run if that means relegation to the ultra competive and far Less lucrative Championship.

I am all for the FA Cup, It can do wonders for moral and gives the 2nd string a chance to impress - which can only be good for cometition. But would take PL survival first any day of the week.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Feb 19 10.35am

The two are not mutually exclusive, and there's is no reason why we cannot compete in both. PL survival is absolutely crucial, but hey, we are 90 minutes away from a semi final place - enjoy!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 19 10.49am

I have been in conversation with a chap who is very knowledgable about football, regarding teams who have got to an FA Cup final and then been relegated in the same season.

Wigan are the only team to have actually won the FA Cup and been relegated that season.That was back in 2013 and they have never returned to the PL.Portsmouth got to the final in 2010, were relegated and have has spells in League One and League Two.They have not returned to the top flight.Brighton got to the FA Cup final in 1983 and it too them over 30 years to get to the PL !

All these supporters had their day out in the sun for the final but one can only speculate as to whether this was any compensation for the heartbreak of relegation.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2019 10.51am)

 

Page 6 of 10 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FA Cup next round