You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread
November 16 2026 5.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The James McCarthy thread


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 16 Jan 20 9.01pm

Could turn out to be another Ayew or Jedi in that they need a season to adjust and get fit, but I'm not so sure, seems slow to react to situations then over-compensates by flying in, put in a woeful attempted through ball for Wilf to give the Arsenal full back the advantage the other day, he was a wunderkind but he looks an over-rated crock with a distinct lack of attacking flair to me - hope I'm wrong and he improves, but I've got definite doubts now based on what I've seen - hope he makes a fool of me but my expectations have become lower.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 16 Jan 20 10.24pm

Just what we need......another thread slagging off a player who is just making his way back after serious injury.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 16 Jan 20 10.56pm

it's not a matter of disloyalty or negativity, I've given him the benefit of the doubt, heard he tears it up in training but he's had a run of games and I'm not convinced - as I said I really hope he proves me wrong, you obviously think he should get more time before we write him off, fair enough, another point of view … can you not express that without getting on your high horse, just talk about the football ffs.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 16 Jan 20 11.40pm

It's not unfair to say whilst he is keen and generally tries to get involved, he seems to mostly give away fouls . His last game was his best by far.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Bangell Flag Oxford 16 Jan 20 11.49pm

I think he's been just fine.

Don't think we should have spent the money on him though.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jan 20 11.58pm

This thread is getting confusing. Jimmy should be reserved for McArthur and James should be McCarthy. We managed to get rid of Sako but at least they had totally different first names.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 17 Jan 20 5.32am

I tend to agree with the OP. Doesn’t have much about him. No stand out qualities and is rather non existent. I found it to be an uninspiring signing when we got him.

However, he is being used as a back up and is only really playing due to the injury crisis. He’s certainly behind Luka, Jimmy Mac, Schlupp, Kouyate and probably now Reidewald in the pecking order for a CM. He’s a solid enough squad player.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jan 20 7.22am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Could turn out to be another Ayew or Jedi in that they need a season to adjust and get fit, but I'm not so sure, seems slow to react to situations then over-compensates by flying in, put in a woeful attempted through ball for Wilf to give the Arsenal full back the advantage the other day, he was a wunderkind but he looks an over-rated crock with a distinct lack of attacking flair to me - hope I'm wrong and he improves, but I've got definite doubts now based on what I've seen - hope he makes a fool of me but my expectations have become lower.

Don't forget he has hardly played for about 2 years, he will need a lot more games to get back to being the excellent player that he was.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Jan 20 7.22am

All our midfielders should shoot more often. Scoring goals is what it’s all about. Maybe Roydoesnt like many but that’s what I’m paying for

 

taylors lovechild Flag 17 Jan 20 7.24am

I'm not sure I agree with the sentiment here. He seems a lot more feisty than I expected and I think if he stays in the team he'll prove some doubters wrong. One thing I will say though is I hope someone else is on free-kicks after some poor ones from him last time out. Riedewald looked much more accomplished in this regard.

 

EddieMac Flag 17 Jan 20 9.38am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I'm not sure I agree with the sentiment here. He seems a lot more feisty than I expected and I think if he stays in the team he'll prove some doubters wrong. One thing I will say though is I hope someone else is on free-kicks after some poor ones from him last time out. Riedewald looked much more accomplished in this regard.

I don’t agree myself with the negativity around McCarthy. I think he offers us something completely different than the rest of our midfielders and done ok in every game he has started. No worse than Luka has been this season and his tackling is a big plus. He is not afraid to get stuck in which is something we definitely needed.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 17 Jan 20 10.10am

Originally posted by Bangell

I think he's been just fine.

Don't think we should have spent the money on him though.

£3 mill? Providing Roy wanted him - doesn't seem outrageous?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Jan 20 10.27am

I said when we signed him that due to his lengthy lay-off we would not see the best of him until next season.

So far he has done nothing wrong so I am hoping I am right, time will tell. Ayew didn't pull up any tree trunks last season it can take time to settle.

Edited by Badger11 (17 Jan 2020 10.28am)

 


One more point

TheBigToePunt Flag 17 Jan 20 1.18pm

In 'Moneyball' terms McCarthy was a no-brainer of a signing. For next to nothing we got a proven premier-league standard player still at what could be his peak. The injuries of course make him a gamble, but at that price the risk was worth taking.

The other thing about him is that he comes into the category of a 'known-quantity'. He has not only played in this league, but lived and settled in this country, knows this football culture, never demonstrated an attitude problem before, and is in no way a 'left-field' signing. If he does well over the next few years we could put him alongside Tomkins, Kouyate, PVA, Dann etc. They have all done exactly what they said on the tin, didn't cost the earth, and didn't let us down at all.

For now, he'd be better off in a central 2 than in a 3 man midfield. When he plays left of centre he has to cover too much ground covering behind Zaha. He barely has the legs for that job, and plainly isn't suited to making forward runs in the way Kouyate can. If he just sat in alongside one other holding player as a double-pivot he could let the game come to him a bit more, and could be a bargain.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 17 Jan 20 1.34pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

In 'Moneyball' terms McCarthy was a no-brainer of a signing. For next to nothing we got a proven premier-league standard player still at what could be his peak. The injuries of course make him a gamble, but at that price the risk was worth taking.

The other thing about him is that he comes into the category of a 'known-quantity'. He has not only played in this league, but lived and settled in this country, knows this football culture, never demonstrated an attitude problem before, and is in no way a 'left-field' signing. If he does well over the next few years we could put him alongside Tomkins, Kouyate, PVA, Dann etc. They have all done exactly what they said on the tin, didn't cost the earth, and didn't let us down at all.

For now, he'd be better off in a central 2 than in a 3 man midfield. When he plays left of centre he has to cover too much ground covering behind Zaha. He barely has the legs for that job, and plainly isn't suited to making forward runs in the way Kouyate can. If he just sat in alongside one other holding player as a double-pivot he could let the game come to him a bit more, and could be a bargain.

Well said and I wholeheartedly agree.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 17 Jan 20 2.07pm

I met a few Everton fans about 5 years ago on holiday, they thought McCarthy was their best midfielder and the team didn’t function anywhere near as well, when he wasn’t playing.
Unfortunately his bad injury has set him back, through playing he will get his form back, I expect to see the best of him next season.

Edited by Painter (17 Jan 2020 2.08pm)

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 17 Jan 20 2.40pm

Originally posted by chris123

£3 mill? Providing Roy wanted him - doesn't seem outrageous?

Yeah but you're factoring in wages as well, and we're paying for a very average player who's trying to recover his career from a serious injury period - and is 29 years old. Not to mention central midfield is a position where we're well-stocked, and money is tight - all funds should have been reserved for areas of pressing need, i.e. full-backs, strikers, attacking midfielders.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 17 Jan 20 7.13pm

He's been poor - get our money back if poss.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 20 7.29pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Yeah but you're factoring in wages as well, and we're paying for a very average player who's trying to recover his career from a serious injury period - and is 29 years old. Not to mention central midfield is a position where we're well-stocked, and money is tight - all funds should have been reserved for areas of pressing need, i.e. full-backs, strikers, attacking midfielders.

We signed a player who is 30 this year and had only made 22 appearances in the previous 3 seasons.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 17 Jan 20 7.31pm

its all relative, innit.

we paid £3m for the guy, who had been injured for a few years and needed to get back to fitness, given evertons spending whilst he had been injured that seems a fair price.

i like him, he is a ball winning tenacious midfielder, who does have decent distribution and he works hard for the team.

he has fire in his belly and is up for the scrap, which lets make no bones about it, fits the club perfectly...which as a team mate you love to have that player lining up next to you.

we chastise watford for being a nasty team but you need that to survive in this league and he adds that.

would i start him above kouyate when everybody is fit? no, but im happy to have him & he cost is diddily squat.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The James McCarthy thread