This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What I wrote had nothing to do with Brexit per se. It was merely the background event which could just as easily been something else. What makes no difference, for a while at least, is the 80 seat majority that Corbyn's stupidity handed to Johnson. With such a majority he can cope with quite a large rebellion and still do whatever he wants. I hear whispers that such a rebellion may well be brewing over the coming budget with a bunch of traditional Tories unhappy with the spend, spend spend largesse being thrown at the north by the Prince of Darkness (Dominic Cummings) who has taken control of the Treasury. Maybe the tories are taking a leaf out of Blair's book of office and buying a few votes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Maybe the tories are taking a leaf out of Blair's book of office and buying a few votes. Blair didn't "buy" any votes. He moved Labour to the centre ground which is where most people reside. The current Tories are playing to the Labour voters in the north who backed them over Brexit but in so doing they may well alienate their southern base. They aren't aiming at the centre at all. I have been doing a little research on Dominic Cummings in the past few days as it seems that he is actually the driving force behind many of the current government trends. He is going to worry traditional Tories as his politics seem a pretty mixed bag to me. Much of it seems rooted in socialistic thinking rather than capitalism. His reasons for wanting us out of the EU had almost no overlap with what the majority were thinking. He is riding high right now but I think the knives will be getting sharpened, both in Whitehall and Westminster. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (17 Feb 2020 2.28pm)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Harry Miller is next door neighbor and he is the most obnoxious, bigoted gobsh1te you could ever wish to meet. 54 year old men should refrain from climbing on their twitter soapbox Been following that case for a while now. Pleased he won because he has put a lot on the line for this. The most sinister part was this... He was told he had not committed a crime, but it would be recorded as a non-crime "hate incident". I believe the actual box that this was ticked against was called 'Crime-Non Crime.' And in the original call from the Police to him he was told to 'check his thinking'. A couple of interesting interviews about this out there but the implications were frightening including this 'non-crime' being disclosed in any future vetting checks for a variety of professions. Edited by nettletoneagle (17 Feb 2020 3.25pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Do you have a problem with the truth? Considering other viewpoints doesn't change the truth. It's not that I don't understand your viewpoint. It's just that it isn't true. The only reason I repeat it is because people like you continue to argue the point! MPs don't "serve" anybody. They "serve" the country's needs. Together they form our Parliament which is the sovereign power in the UK. We choose them so we can change them if they don't perform to our satisfaction so from that perspective alone they need to be mindful if their overriding priority is to keep a job. For those who put their duty above self interest (as those brave MPs did in the last Parliament) they will ignore any such pressure and concentrate on what they conclude is in the best interests of their constituents and the country as a whole. As I have repeatedly said our MPs are NOT delegates. They are our representatives and that fact completely changes what they must do and how they do it. The pity is that even some MPs don't actually understand this.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What is it with this guy, the thinking here is almost innocent. Instead of New Statemen articles why don't you actually read the man's own website. It's often said that the left don't really understand the right. The 'right' as just as fractional as the 'left'. He actually thinks we don't know what Cummings is and what kind of Tory, he and Johnson are. No one on here believes that Cummings or Johnson are their 'men'. I certainly don't....yet these straw man arguments are always being made. It's a fundamental misunderstanding of the positions that they think they are 'learning' about. Cummings and Johnson are just better than the alternatives on offer....it's as simple as that....It's the same Trump/Clinton dynamic. The real defining different isn't left and right, it's authoritarianism and libertarianism and the combinations that most people's beliefs center upon.....You pick your smelling salts and that's about it. Cummings is much more data driven than most and behind his anti EU motivations in an core belief in institutional adaptability much more than some heated nationalism that his opponents like to characterise. This core belief is a main realson why he rages against the EU. He knows that the centralisation of power within Brussels makes any delusions about change just that....a comfortable delusion.....Brussels is a political and economic oil tanker that's heading for rocks and can't change direction because there are 27 captains each pulling at the wheel....well about three main influences with 24 small nudges, but that's all it needs. I know that Cummings isn't the same as me....All that matters is that the path he wants to travel down is closer to mine than it is to those whose paths I deeply dislike.
Well done on another accurate post.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Blair didn't "buy" any votes. He moved Labour to the centre ground which is where most people reside. The current Tories are playing to the Labour voters in the north who backed them over Brexit but in so doing they may well alienate their southern base. They aren't aiming at the centre at all. I have been doing a little research on Dominic Cummings in the past few days as it seems that he is actually the driving force behind many of the current government trends. He is going to worry traditional Tories as his politics seem a pretty mixed bag to me. Much of it seems rooted in socialistic thinking rather than capitalism. His reasons for wanting us out of the EU had almost no overlap with what the majority were thinking. He is riding high right now but I think the knives will be getting sharpened, both in Whitehall and Westminster. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (17 Feb 2020 2.28pm) The northern labour voters are not that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Well done on another accurate post. I tip my hat sir.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Well done on another accurate post. But it isn't accurate. There are several mistakes in the first couple of lines and the rest is opinion. I don't read the New Statesman and nor have I referenced anything they have written on Cummings. I have though looked at his own website and his blog. I haven't expressed any opinion about him. My remarks were all about how I think the Tory establishment are likely to react. Only today a new controversy has surfaced regarding one of his appointees, Andrew Sabisky. It seems he has said some things in the past which are causing a bit of a furore. Not just from the opposition parties either but also from within the Tories. Reading the reports of what he is reported to have said made me smile because they seem oddly familiar. I wonder if he is one of the most regular posters here?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
How they perform their constituency duties is a completely separate issue. I have asked for my MP's help several times in dealing with government departments and always been given it. What I am talking about are their duties in Parliament.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
How they perform their constituency duties is a completely separate issue. I have asked for my MP's help several times in dealing with government departments and always been given it. What I am talking about are their duties in Parliament. Isn’t it possible that these Parliamentary duties have changed since Burke outlined his views on representatives v delegates? It was 250 years ago and at that time only about 10% of men could vote, and of course no women.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Isn’t it possible that these Parliamentary duties have changed since Burke outlined his views on representatives v delegates? It was 250 years ago and at that time only about 10% of men could vote, and of course no women. No. The basic tenets of their role remain unchanged by time. Parliamentary procedures and conventions evolve to suit the conditions of the day but the duty of every MP to represent their constituents, and use their best endeavours to decide what is in their best interests remain unaltered. That is the way our Parliament works and it's that which defines an MP's duty. It cannot change unless we change our Parliamentary system.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
No. The basic tenets of their role remain unchanged by time. Parliamentary procedures and conventions evolve to suit the conditions of the day but the duty of every MP to represent their constituents, and use their best endeavours to decide what is in their best interests remain unaltered. That is the way our Parliament works and it's that which defines an MP's duty. It cannot change unless we change our Parliamentary system. That’s one interpretation. Another is that an electorate comprising 10% have different expectations to the current situation and MPs should accept the change.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
That’s one interpretation. Another is that an electorate comprising 10% have different expectations to the current situation and MPs should accept the change. I am really sorry but I don't understand your point. What do 10% of the electorate have to do with this? No section of the electorate can simply decide to change the whole system. It would require a major national debate and then for Parliament to enact the change. I see no reason for that to happen and even less chance of it happening. The only major change I can see arriving at some time in the foreseeable future is PR. It may start with a partially elected second chamber with perhaps half the seats there being filled on a county basis by PR. The other half by the most recently ennobled life peers, with strict controls over their appointment being put in place.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am really sorry but I don't understand your point. What do 10% of the electorate have to do with this? No section of the electorate can simply decide to change the whole system. It would require a major national debate and then for Parliament to enact the change. I see no reason for that to happen and even less chance of it happening. The only major change I can see arriving at some time in the foreseeable future is PR. It may start with a partially elected second chamber with perhaps half the seats there being filled on a county basis by PR. The other half by the most recently ennobled life peers, with strict controls over their appointment being put in place. Just that when Burke raised this point the percentage eligible to vote was very small so the elected MPs also had to consider the disenfranchised majority. The electorate is now much larger, consequently the expectation has increased.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Isn’t it possible that these Parliamentary duties have changed since Burke outlined his views on representatives v delegates? It was 250 years ago and at that time only about 10% of men could vote, and of course no women. At the time we had a fledgling party system so MPs who were notoriously corrupt (so no change there then)changed alliances more easily. What Burke said makes sense if you have no party system that is the big difference with today's MPs. Back then people (sorry I mean the elite) voted for the local landowner because he was the important individual in that location and whatever he said goes so the tiny percentage of voters had no real choice in candidates. Burke always had an idealised view of parliament that never matched the reality. Quite simply MPs gathered around the politician they thought controlled the purse strings and could dish out the pork. Those out of favour complained bitterly about corruption and Government incompetence simply because they weren't getting their share. To sum up then MPs were voted by a tiny percentage of the population those votes were often bought so they arrived in Parliament on a tide of corruption and made decisions based on whether or not they were getting a bung. So "Yeah go Burke"... Edited by Badger11 (18 Feb 2020 7.46am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
At the time we had a fledgling party system so MPs who were notoriously corrupt (so no change there then)changed alliances more easily. What Burke said makes sense if you have no party system that is the big difference with today's MPs. Back then people (sorry I mean the elite) voted for the local landowner because he was the important individual in that location and whatever he said goes so the tiny percentage of voters had no real choice in candidates. Burke always had an idealised view of parliament that never matched the reality. Quite simply MPs gathered around the politician they thought controlled the purse strings and could dish out the pork. Those out of favour complained bitterly about corruption and Government incompetence simply because they weren't getting their share. To sum up then MPs were voted by a tiny percentage of the population those votes were often bought so they arrived in Parliament on a tide of corruption and made decisions based on whether or not they were getting a bung. So "Yeah go Burke"... Edited by Badger11 (18 Feb 2020 7.46am) Thanks, Badger. A much fuller explanation than I was giving!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Just that when Burke raised this point the percentage eligible to vote was very small so the elected MPs also had to consider the disenfranchised majority. The electorate is now much larger, consequently the expectation has increased. All true but the fact that the electorate is now much larger with a consequential increased expectation only means that the MPs have an even greater duty to be independent than before. None of that changes the principal of representation. If we decide we want to send delegates to Parliament then we need to determine that via our current system. Our Parliament would need to take such a decision and set it in place. It must not happen by default. If it becomes such an overriding priority for a majority of the people then they need to send MPs to Parliament who agree with them.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.