You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread


Page 6 of 12 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
sprites Flag Auckland 30 Aug 22 10.33pm

Originally posted by adelaar

I cannot understand how Luka gets on the pitch. When he came on with 10 left I knew that was it. He's too slow, can't tackle, can't pass or cross.
Absolutely need to upgrade him, Jairo also seems out of the picture and this evening showed how thin we are outside of the first 11. We wont improve on last seasons position with this current squad.

Edited by adelaar (30 Aug 2022 10.27pm)

Yaaaawn. I know it's popular to hate on Luka. But he's not why we lost tonight. We changed too defensively instead of giving them more to think about from an attacking sense. This one's on PV.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 30 Aug 22 10.35pm

[quote=bright&wright;3743064]

Luka Milivojavic is officially the worst player I've ever seen at Palace.

And I've seen Itzik Zohar.

If you're dumb enough to play him for a minute you deserve the sack.

You're a clown.

 

pssguy Flag 30 Aug 22 10.36pm

Giving up three leads after just five games - costing us seven points - just isn't acceptable. Period

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 30 Aug 22 10.36pm

Originally posted by NE14T

Spot on Palace Chick.

Veira needs to ask himself would Brentford or teams like Fulham have made such negative changes when they were winning with 10 mins left. Errrr. No.
You can not incentivise opposition more than doing what Veira did tonight and we were lucky not to lose. I like Veira but it was poor game management tonight.

Edited by NE14T (30 Aug 2022 10.33pm)

I think we’re all feeling the same tonight, we definitely slipped into Roy mode instead of trying to finish them off. It must give the opposition a lift to see a team go five at the back and bring a defensive midfielder on. Brentford knew they didn’t have to worry too much about the other end, they could afford to go for it

Edited by monkey (30 Aug 2022 10.38pm)

 

Andy0629 Flag Warlingham 30 Aug 22 10.41pm

Did the same against Arsenal away last season went from a winning position and invitees them to attack…. Should have stayed with the same formation, at 1-0 it was up to Brentford to commit players forward which would have giving us more time to break on them with pace. If we must go with 3 at the back don’t go 5-4-1 at least go 3-5-2 so we can have a chance of retaining the ball up front.
On another note we desperately need a striker …..

 

pssguy Flag 30 Aug 22 10.47pm

Hard to believe this is the same guy who less than a year ago took Kouyate off when we were 1-0 up at City after 86 minutes and replaced him with Olise - who set up Gallagher for the clinching goal.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 30 Aug 22 10.48pm

I can never understand the way some managers use subs. If you are in the ascendecy as we were and the players show no sign of flagging then why change it? All it does is cause unneccesary problems. If a team is behind or a player is looking knackered then of course make changes. Fully understand Franks changes as he needed a goal but they would have been wide open for us to get a 2nd goal and seal the win. Sorry PV you've been great but were a complete plonker tonight

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 30 Aug 22 10.52pm

Luka hasn't been good enough for about 3 seasons. I
Nothing is changing, points dropped at home again & again against the weaker sides due to a lack of boldness. We have creative players like Eze & Olise, who along with Schlupp were not playing poorly tonight, why replace them with Ayew, Luka and Clyne ??

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 30 Aug 22 11.01pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

Easy to say PV made a bad decision with the benefit of hindsight. Guehi was ball watching at the goal unfortunately. We should have been out of sight but don’t have a striker who knows how to find space.

Disagree. It was obvious at the time. We were playing well and Brentford were posing zero threat. There wasn't a need to make big structural changes

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 30 Aug 22 11.11pm

When it’s only 1 nil, there is always a chance the opposition will get back into it. The game was stretched and we looked very comfortable until all the changes.

Brentford are no mugs and we invited the pressure on ourselves, again.

I want us to see these games out when we are in control, tonight was ridiculous!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 30 Aug 22 11.13pm

Wilf 'doing his nut'.

Don't blame him, the goalscorer was completely unmarked despite PVs dubious defensive changes.

Fatigue also understandably a factor.

Duocore is a really good addition.

The PL is tougher each year, you really cannot afford a slip.

Frustration rules.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 30 Aug 22 11.16pm

Absolutely correct PV's unnecessary substitutions cost us two points this evening, our attacking threat with Olise, Eze and also Schluppy disappeared and we handed over our advantage to Brentford.In the end we were fortunate to hang on for a point.

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 30 Aug 22 11.19pm

Originally posted by sprites

Yaaaawn. I know it's popular to hate on Luka. But he's not why we lost tonight. We changed too defensively instead of giving them more to think about from an attacking sense. This one's on PV.


Yes this is on PV, but if he can bring on better quality (even Hughes rather than Luka), we shore up the middle of the park.
Luka was brilliant for us when he came but every footballer has a sell by date. Unfortunately Luka has passed his one with us. You may think 'yawn' but if you think Luka is still Premier league quality please let us all know!

 

ageingleftback Flag 30 Aug 22 11.30pm

There needs to be an inquest between Vieira and his coaching staff as to why they thought a defensive back three formation was suitable for seeing out Brentford at home.
As soon as he made the decision, I looked at my teenage son and we both said this is the wrong call.
If laymen like us can see the problem, why can’t professional coaches like Vieira and his staff see it?
I still have lots of respect for how Vieira changed our playing style for the better, but he just doesn’t seem to learn how to see a tight game out.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 30 Aug 22 11.31pm

Just back from the match and I agree PV made a bad call on the substitutions. From being on top in the second half we suddenly looked a mess, lost our shape and couldn't keep possession any more.

And of course now having the option of 5 substitutes increases the risk of making wholesale changes that can upset the whole balance of the team.

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 30 Aug 22 11.32pm

We need a new song “ stop sitting back yawn yawn yawn “ to sweet Caroline
Or “ Throwing it all away”

So jacks the crowd off when Palace defend when they should attack.
We’d rather lose a game if we kept trying to win

 


Forever Palace Proud

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 30 Aug 22 11.41pm

Originally posted by Palacesince64

Easy to say PV made a bad decision with the benefit of hindsight. Guehi was ball watching at the goal unfortunately. We should have been out of sight but don’t have a striker who knows how to find space.


It was clear to see if you had watched the game live [clearly by your comments you did not] we was all over them and he did the changes after they did and it changed the whole game.

Wrong about the goal you can see he get drawn because of Tony who does try to go for the ball and the stupid VAR tried to claim he was not active ridiculous he has drawn a player towards him and even moved hoping to gt the ball.

Correct on one point we should have scored more but you could say the same for them.

Nothing to do with striker ED many times got into good positions and Wilf messed up pass (you cant expect the guy to keep closing people down and defend then do all the work up front and we saw Mateta gets gassed quickly hes better coming of bench)

It's the style which is the issue and realistically unless you are sticking in a top player which Palace can't afford or attract the style up top needs to change.

This whole one guy up front doesn't work well.

Last thing the manager needs to stop blaming tiredness if these players are struggling they need better fitness and why is he playing the same players all the time this is what a squad is for.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 31 Aug 22 12.09am

Originally posted by grumpymort

I watched it live and like most people I also thought we should’ve kept Olise and Eze on and subbed Schlupp who was poor tonight. My point was that PV had a call to make and it didn’t work out but if he hadn’t made those changes and Brentford had scored he’d have been slaughtered here for doing nothing. He went 5 at the back against Liverpool and we got a point. He tried it again here and it didn’t come off. Doesn’t make him a genius at Liverpool and a clown here.


It was clear to see if you had watched the game live [clearly by your comments you did not] we was all over them and he did the changes after they did and it changed the whole game.

Wrong about the goal you can see he get drawn because of Tony who does try to go for the ball and the stupid VAR tried to claim he was not active ridiculous he has drawn a player towards him and even moved hoping to gt the ball.

Correct on one point we should have scored more but you could say the same for them.

Nothing to do with striker ED many times got into good positions and Wilf messed up pass (you cant expect the guy to keep closing people down and defend then do all the work up front and we saw Mateta gets gassed quickly hes better coming of bench)

It's the style which is the issue and realistically unless you are sticking in a top player which Palace can't afford or attract the style up top needs to change.

This whole one guy up front doesn't work well.

Last thing the manager needs to stop blaming tiredness if these players are struggling they need better fitness and why is he playing the same players all the time this is what a squad is for.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Aug 22 12.18am

Only just back!

Probably been mentioned already but some points from me:

Weren’t at our best tonight, not awful but looked sluggish and ambivalent
Wilf’s goal superb
Olise looks about 95% there so that’s great
Doucoure quickly becoming my favourite player
Ward looks better now than he did before he started declining (for me)
I still think clyne looks superb. Don’t need AWB with any desperation
Schlupp looked knackered after about 30 mins (may just be me)
Mateta didn’t do much but didn’t have much of anything to work with
Eze looked ‘off the boil’
Pat’s subs were once again somewhat bemusing as was the decision to switch formations at that point, we went from looking in control and under little threat to looking disorganised and inviting them to give it a go, then we conceded. We then could have easily lost the match at several points as we looked all over the gaf.
I think a lot of gratitude is sorely missing for Luka and there’s too much vitriol for me personally but he is, as all players will be, done at this level.


1-1 probably a fair result but the manner bitterly disappointing. We weren’t a million miles off being able to ride that one out or even get another. Pat needs to learn from mistakes but overall I’m not too despondent.

As always, COYP!!! Onwards and upwards hopefully.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 31 Aug 22 12.18am

theory : we lose our winning position when Luka comes on for the last twenty minutes.

anybody bothered to crunch the data ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 6 of 12 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Brentford - Match Thread