You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 61 of 80 < 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Aug 14 9.53pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 8.38pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 8.29pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 7.56pm

Ok, let me explain, in simple terms...

You made an entirely unsubstantiated allegation that everyone who opposes the building of the wall is condoning the killing of Israelis.

After being pushed, you have now provided some very basic statistics which show that the killings have reduced since the wall was built.

I doubt anyone would deny that building the wall has reduced killings, at least in the short term, but to state that people who are opposed to building the wall are condoning the killings is utter nonsense.

Has it occurred to you that building the wall may be a very short-sighted solution which, whilst reducing casualties in the short term, may actually provoke and prolong the conflict and ultimately increase the number of casualties?

Of course no one knows the answer to that question, but your initial statement was simplistic, arrogant and insulting to everyone who disagreed with you (along with many other comments on this thread an elsewhere).

As I have said to you before, I think you should stop pontificating for a while and actually read up a bit on things first so that you could make a more informed and valuable contribution to the debate, if that is what you wish to do.

If you do not have the patience to actually sit and learn, then a less arrogant tone to your posts would, I am sure, be appreciated by the majority on here.

As it is, you come over simply as the pub boor who thinks that, if they say things loudly and confidently enough, then people will believe you.


Edited by SloveniaDave (03 Aug 2014 7.57pm)


More condescension: if nothing else your posts to me provide an insight into how you see yourself and obviously me.

At least near the beginning of your post you (at last) provide some content before you lapsed back into your usual.

Dealing with the content I could see how I might have refined that statement,.but essentially it holds to be mostly true in its consequences.

I can see arguments again the wall in terms of route and disruption to Palestinian life. Those who argue that the wall is unjust in those aspects have a point and Israel have a duty of care that they have or haven't taken on.

However, if the upshoot of that is that they support the wall coming down.....Well, you can be mealy mouthed all you like but I view that as de facto ignoring or supporting the obvious increase in Israel deaths that would result.

Maybe some people are ok with ignoring the practical consequences of there being no more west bank wall rather than openly condoning increased Israeli death.......There is that enough of a refinement to the statement for you?

In the future.....As part of a final peace agreement...Where Hamas and other groups are no longer willing to send militants using that method......Well, who knows maybe that wall would come down.

Again, utterly stupid bilge. The wall has to go one day, same as the Berlin Wall, or there will never be peace. The only question is the terms on which it is removed.

No one condones deaths on either side - when will you get that into your thick head?

I do. I condone the killing of militants by the IDF, and of Palestinian actions against the IDF and the settlements, both of which are legal under UN Law. I accept that the IDF has a right to retaliate against attacks on Israel, and that the Palestinian's have a right to resist occupation.

What I don't accept is the killing of innocent civilians who are just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Targets of convenience. Its a war, and both sides can present valid legitimate grounds for some of their actions.

Any group or state, when it acts militarily has an obligation of duty to target the valid infrastructure, support network and military capacity of their enemy.

The problem is that neither side actually cares about who they kill, maim or cripple now. They've become engaged in a conflict in which each atrocity is justified by the last one.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 03 Aug 14 10.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Aug 2014 9.53pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 8.38pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 8.29pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 7.56pm

Ok, let me explain, in simple terms...

You made an entirely unsubstantiated allegation that everyone who opposes the building of the wall is condoning the killing of Israelis.

After being pushed, you have now provided some very basic statistics which show that the killings have reduced since the wall was built.

I doubt anyone would deny that building the wall has reduced killings, at least in the short term, but to state that people who are opposed to building the wall are condoning the killings is utter nonsense.

Has it occurred to you that building the wall may be a very short-sighted solution which, whilst reducing casualties in the short term, may actually provoke and prolong the conflict and ultimately increase the number of casualties?

Of course no one knows the answer to that question, but your initial statement was simplistic, arrogant and insulting to everyone who disagreed with you (along with many other comments on this thread an elsewhere).

As I have said to you before, I think you should stop pontificating for a while and actually read up a bit on things first so that you could make a more informed and valuable contribution to the debate, if that is what you wish to do.

If you do not have the patience to actually sit and learn, then a less arrogant tone to your posts would, I am sure, be appreciated by the majority on here.

As it is, you come over simply as the pub boor who thinks that, if they say things loudly and confidently enough, then people will believe you.


Edited by SloveniaDave (03 Aug 2014 7.57pm)


More condescension: if nothing else your posts to me provide an insight into how you see yourself and obviously me.

At least near the beginning of your post you (at last) provide some content before you lapsed back into your usual.

Dealing with the content I could see how I might have refined that statement,.but essentially it holds to be mostly true in its consequences.

I can see arguments again the wall in terms of route and disruption to Palestinian life. Those who argue that the wall is unjust in those aspects have a point and Israel have a duty of care that they have or haven't taken on.

However, if the upshoot of that is that they support the wall coming down.....Well, you can be mealy mouthed all you like but I view that as de facto ignoring or supporting the obvious increase in Israel deaths that would result.

Maybe some people are ok with ignoring the practical consequences of there being no more west bank wall rather than openly condoning increased Israeli death.......There is that enough of a refinement to the statement for you?

In the future.....As part of a final peace agreement...Where Hamas and other groups are no longer willing to send militants using that method......Well, who knows maybe that wall would come down.

Again, utterly stupid bilge. The wall has to go one day, same as the Berlin Wall, or there will never be peace. The only question is the terms on which it is removed.

No one condones deaths on either side - when will you get that into your thick head?

I do. I condone the killing of militants by the IDF, and of Palestinian actions against the IDF and the settlements, both of which are legal under UN Law. I accept that the IDF has a right to retaliate against attacks on Israel, and that the Palestinian's have a right to resist occupation.

What I don't accept is the killing of innocent civilians who are just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Targets of convenience. Its a war, and both sides can present valid legitimate grounds for some of their actions.

Any group or state, when it acts militarily has an obligation of duty to target the valid infrastructure, support network and military capacity of their enemy.

The problem is that neither side actually cares about who they kill, maim or cripple now. They've become engaged in a conflict in which each atrocity is justified by the last one.



Agreed - my use of the word 'condone' was loose. In terms of 'refrain from punishing', if something is legal under UN and international law, then I would accept it. The fine line is whether condoning something gives it tacit approval though.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Aug 14 10.23pm

That's what I don't get about Islamist Terrorists, the indiscriminate carnage against people who might otherwise be sympathetic to your cause. I get the idea of targeting government, institutions of government, politicians even the military and organisations implicit in 'oppression', what I don't get is how just killing a train full of people actually works towards anything except an escalation.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 10.29pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Aug 2014 9.53pm

I do. I condone the killing of militants by the IDF, and of Palestinian actions against the IDF and the settlements, both of which are legal under UN Law. I accept that the IDF has a right to retaliate against attacks on Israel, and that the Palestinian's have a right to resist occupation.

What I don't accept is the killing of innocent civilians who are just in the wrong place at the wrong time. Targets of convenience. Its a war, and both sides can present valid legitimate grounds for some of their actions.

Any group or state, when it acts militarily has an obligation of duty to target the valid infrastructure, support network and military capacity of their enemy.

The problem is that neither side actually cares about who they kill, maim or cripple now. They've become engaged in a conflict in which each atrocity is justified by the last one.



I think it's hard to sum it up more powerfully than that.

If a Palestinian kills an IDF soldier while protecting their home.....Well, I don't think any of us can say that we would willingly have our home destroyed with no response.....It still is a kind of disaster because that Israeli conscript probably didn't want to be there either.....War destroys innocents in many different ways.

However, joining Hamas under the banner of the destruction of Israel and all Jews makes that individual a legitimate target for the IDF.

It's a tricky and somewhat trite line to state....But essentially that's how terrible yet ridiculous the situation is.

The IDF shouldn't be there...There were other options....Untold innocent bodies lie below rubble and that's unforgivable.

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Aug 2014 10.32pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 03 Aug 14 10.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Aug 2014 10.23pm

That's what I don't get about Islamist Terrorists, the indiscriminate carnage against people who might otherwise be sympathetic to your cause. I get the idea of targeting government, institutions of government, politicians even the military and organisations implicit in 'oppression', what I don't get is how just killing a train full of people actually works towards anything except an escalation.


But isn't that the basis of all terrorism, Islamic or otherwise? We could talk about the IRA, ETA, the ANC the Black September movement and many others. Terrorism is not conventional war. History suggests that it doesn't have a direct effect, but it does have an indirect impact in terms of bringing people to the negotiating table.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 03 Aug 14 10.34pm

The Irish parliament had an interesting debate. Here's one of the milder speakers! [Link]

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Aug 14 10.42pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Aug 2014 10.23pm

That's what I don't get about Islamist Terrorists, the indiscriminate carnage against people who might otherwise be sympathetic to your cause. I get the idea of targeting government, institutions of government, politicians even the military and organisations implicit in 'oppression', what I don't get is how just killing a train full of people actually works towards anything except an escalation.

It does seem counter to common sense....But I believe there is a twisted narrative to it.

If you undermine the faith in the state protecting you by successfully killing indiscriminately you reduce support for that regime and trust in anything other than your 'group'.

You are more likely to decentralize control from the government.

In the Islamic world it is easy to see how this would fall down easily defined religious groups and quickly lead to a march towards civil war.

The breakdown in structures that results makes it more possible for extremism to become more acceptable and hence see a rise in support for the terrorist group.

They grow stronger and stronger and so on.

I don't think it's the most sensible method either.....But I suppose these aren't the most stable people.

Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Aug 2014 10.47pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 03 Aug 14 10.44pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Aug 2014 10.23pm

That's what I don't get about Islamist Terrorists, the indiscriminate carnage against people who might otherwise be sympathetic to your cause. I get the idea of targeting government, institutions of government, politicians even the military and organisations implicit in 'oppression', what I don't get is how just killing a train full of people actually works towards anything except an escalation.


When the aim from one side is manipulative war then actions and atrocities that escalate the chances of that happening will occur.

You want to start something? Go slap someone who will fight back but before you do make sure you know first you will be able to outbox them tactically. Al Qaeda 9/11 and the subsequent US and other military deaths and rise in Islamic extremism and Israel's long standing state terror in Gaza both fine examples of what an atrocity or two can bring. A level of desired control over others.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 03 Aug 14 10.44pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 10.34pm

The Irish parliament had an interesting debate. Here's one of the milder speakers! [Link]


The parallels with Ireland are by no means perfect but they do provide some hope and possible ways forward. In the mid/late 1970s, I think there were very few in the UK who believed there was a 'solution' to the Irish problem which they could envisage in their lifetime.

History suggests that, with goodwill and sensible people at the negotiating table, then many things are possible.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 03 Aug 14 11.50pm

Thought it was worth sharing this letter from the parents of a British boy shot by an Israeli sniper. If they can't get justice what hope have the Palestinian families that have had their loved ones picked off by Israeli marksmen?

IDF should be held to account in Gaza

[Link]

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Red-Blue-Yellow Flag Surrey 04 Aug 14 1.58am

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 11.50pm

Thought it was worth sharing this letter from the parents of a British boy shot by an Israeli sniper. If they can't get justice what hope have the Palestinian families that have had their loved ones picked off by Israeli marksmen?

IDF should be held to account in Gaza

[Link]


Can't complain that Israel is treating the Palestinians unfairly now, can we?

 


I also enjoy posting on: Love Everton Forum, the Acceptable Face of Scouse Football.
[Link]
twitter.com/LuvEvertonForum
Come and give it a look, new members would be lovely.
Come and JOIN.
Or they'll nick your telly.

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 04 Aug 14 6.27am

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 04 Aug 2014 1.58am

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 11.50pm

Thought it was worth sharing this letter from the parents of a British boy shot by an Israeli sniper. If they can't get justice what hope have the Palestinian families that have had their loved ones picked off by Israeli marksmen?

IDF should be held to account in Gaza

[Link]


Can't complain that Israel is treating the Palestinians unfairly now, can we?


Indeed! It treats all others equally... [Link]

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 04 Aug 14 8.52am

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 8.37pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Aug 2014 8.06pm

Quote Palacetinian at 03 Aug 2014 7.50pm

Really Stirling? It's you that trots out Israeli propaganda all the time despite all the evidence that others here have posted in reply.

If you really believe the wall is solely responsible for a 90% reduction in suicide bombing then you are mistaken.

Did Israeli apartheid wall really stop suicide bombings?

[Link]

Are you calling actual statistics that can be checked, Israeli propaganda?

This done from a website called, 'electronicintifada.net'.....Does that statement qualify as self parody?

Are statistics Israeli propaganda now?

Some Wiki links on deaths from suicide bombers which show the massive declines from 2002 onwards. In the references for the two you have two non Israeli sources.

[Link]

It is very clear.

452 in 2002 when the barrier was built to 9 in 2010....Hardly any now.

It is certainly true that militants could increase this number but the quickly found out that attacking via this method was far less effective. In terms of reducing Israeli civilian the barrier has been a huge success.....though I recognise the problems associated with it.

In terms of arguing against this....perhaps it is you who are listening to propaganda.

You are using a simple statistic (452 in 2002 when the barrier was built to 9 in 2010....Hardly any now) and drawing a simple conclusion.

If you actually read the article which was written by Ben White (not an Israeli or a Palestinian. In fact you can also google what Roger Waters from Pink Floyd thinks about the wall, which is actually illegal in terms of international law.

Unlike you, I suspect, I have actually seen the wall at first hand and know the impact it has had on people's lives so your last comment is also invalid - I don't need to be "listening to propaganda".

Over 12 hours and nobody has made a Pink Floyd/Wall gag?

Standards are slipping.

Well he should know a thing or two about walls.


Edited by EagleEyedAlbert (04 Aug 2014 8.53am)

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

legaleagle Flag 04 Aug 14 9.12am

It seems to me not credible to argue that a substantial purpose of the Israeli government in building the wall was not to inappropriately try and unilaterally mark out an advantageous divide for a future two state solution by putting "facts on the ground", as much as to try and reduce deaths, however much the latter might have been a part of the reason.

[Link]

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Aug 14 11.55am

[Link]

Interview with Hamas leader.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Aug 14 12.19pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 03 Aug 2014 10.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Aug 2014 10.23pm

That's what I don't get about Islamist Terrorists, the indiscriminate carnage against people who might otherwise be sympathetic to your cause. I get the idea of targeting government, institutions of government, politicians even the military and organisations implicit in 'oppression', what I don't get is how just killing a train full of people actually works towards anything except an escalation.

But isn't that the basis of all terrorism, Islamic or otherwise? We could talk about the IRA, ETA, the ANC the Black September movement and many others. Terrorism is not conventional war. History suggests that it doesn't have a direct effect, but it does have an indirect impact in terms of bringing people to the negotiating table.

For the most part the IRA weren't that indiscriminate - the majority of targets were military, government and infrastructure. Similarly ETA, both were part of a greater political struggle. Civilians were targets but the campaigns weren't entirely about just killing people in the UK. Similarly like Hijackings people were killed, but the purpose behind those attacks wasn't to kill as many people as possible, it fitted into a greater whole.

I kind of understand the idea of people going off to fight Jyhad to 'liberate' muslim nations, such as Syria etc, but not really how blowing up a bus in London fits with any kind of strategy or goal.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 04 Aug 14 12.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2014 11.55am

[Link]

Interview with Hamas leader.


If he's as good at dodging the IDF as he is at dodging questions, he's in no danger whatsoever.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Aug 14 12.59pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 04 Aug 2014 12.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2014 11.55am

[Link]

Interview with Hamas leader.


If he's as good at dodging the IDF as he is at dodging questions, he's in no danger whatsoever.


Is there a price on his head or is his safety guaranteed by not wanting to make martyrs or for having someone to negotiate with?

 


Red and Blue Army!

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 04 Aug 14 1.20pm

Quote ASCPFC at 04 Aug 2014 12.59pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 04 Aug 2014 12.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2014 11.55am

[Link]

Interview with Hamas leader.


If he's as good at dodging the IDF as he is at dodging questions, he's in no danger whatsoever.


Is there a price on his head or is his safety guaranteed by not wanting to make martyrs or for having someone to negotiate with?

errrrr... yes maybe?

Pass.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 04 Aug 14 2.27pm

Quote EagleEyedAlbert at 04 Aug 2014 12.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2014 11.55am

[Link]

Interview with Hamas leader.


If he's as good at dodging the IDF as he is at dodging questions, he's in no danger whatsoever.


 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 61 of 80 < 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine