You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 65 of 91 < 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 >
indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 02 Feb 20 12.20pm

Originally posted by Painter

Riedeweld was the fans potm, due the fact they hadn't seen him for sometime and he covered LB well, but PVA is the better LB offers a lot more going forward.

PVA is not better going forward.
If you asked anyone in the ground what the most predictable pass is in the entire game before it's even begun, they will say PVA passing back to a CB or keeper. It's just boring and getting tiresome. We must waste 20 mins per game just giving it to him so he can pass it back again.
Reidewald has proven he can defend and attack efficiently.

Dropping him was just one of a handful of criminal decisions Hodgson made yesterday.

I think the time has come and we need fresh ideas. Hodgson's tactics and up-to-speed thinking is clearly non-existent.

 

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 02 Feb 20 12.24pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

please tell me why we had no one on the bench as a striker,

Cos our genius manager thought it would be a good idea to loan out our only striker who has done more in 3 games than Benteke has in 3 years.

Clueless.

We deserve everything we get which is nothing, because Hodgson's tactics are ancient, dull, uninspiring and I think the players have lost confidence in him. His subs are always way too late, he continues to play negative tactics at home. AT HOME. Time for a change.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 02 Feb 20 12.29pm

lets look at this whole academy player thing in isolation for a minute, we want to get a manager in who trusts academy players...

look at this article i found from november this year about academy player minutes in the PL this season...

[Link]

lets discard chelsea united arsenal & spurs from the conversation as their resources far outweigh ours, and are not
comparable.

norwich had the luxury of being able to blood those players in the championship.

the only teams on our level who i can see have played & trusted kids this year are

brighton - connolley
newcastle - obafemi

we are potentially starting to blood thru peirrick, and it would seem we are trying to now sign younger players, ferguson & bowen would have been a right step in that direction but they wernt to be.

a task this size wont happen overnight and i would suggest it will be the beginning of 21/22 season before we actually see this come to fruition, we cant just dispose of the current players as & when we like, it actually takes team to want to take them off our hands so we can replace them, like i assume we planned with PVA situation for example.


 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


black eagle. Flag south croydon. 02 Feb 20 12.34pm

Originally posted by indianapalace85

Cos our genius manager thought it would be a good idea to loan out our only striker who has done more in 3 games than Benteke has in 3 years.

Clueless.

We deserve everything we get which is nothing, because Hodgson's tactics are ancient, dull, uninspiring and I think the players have lost confidence in him. His subs are always way too late, he continues to play negative tactics at home. AT HOME. Time for a change.

I think the board have lost confidence with Roy also.

If it's as rumoured that Roy didn't want Carrasco and Bowen then it's no wonder he wasn't given money to spend.

He'll be off in the summer if not before.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Feb 20 12.43pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

I think the board have lost confidence with Roy also.

If it's as rumoured that Roy didn't want Carrasco and Bowen then it's no wonder he wasn't given money to spend.

He'll be off in the summer if not before.

I very much doubt that the Board have lost confidence in the manager. The way the club is being run by that Board, they are lucky to have him.

It's not true that he wasn't given money to spend, where do you get that from ??!!

If I was Hodgson then I would quit in the summer because there is every chance that without refinancing and team rebuilding the club are heading for an even tougher season next year.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Rainforest Flag London England 02 Feb 20 12.45pm

Originally posted by Sthlondonuk

How about a few long balls to Benteke plan B he wins most in the air and stop all the fiddling around in our own half.

We hardly had long longs in the opposition's danger area. Yesterday, did you notice we had a couple of free kicks the halfway line area ? Many a time we passed the ball sideways or backwards to play it up instead of long balls into SU's danger area.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 02 Feb 20 12.46pm

Originally posted by Rainforest

We hardly had long balls in the opposition's danger area. Yesterday, did you notice we had a couple of free kicks the halfway line area ? Many a time we passed the ball sideways or backwards to play it up instead of long balls into SU's danger area.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Feb 20 12.52pm

Originally posted by Sthlondonuk

How about a few long balls to Benteke plan B he wins most in the air and stop all the fiddling around in our own half.

He would need someone up alongside him on the same wavelength - dare I say like the old Wright / Bright combination
Not a bad idea to bypass the current midfield set-up as they do farq all attackwise anyway...
If we're going to play long ball we might as well go all the way and get Big Sam back

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 02 Feb 20 1.29pm

We had about as attacking a team out there in the second half yesterday, as ive seen all season. Yet we could hardly mount an attack.

Then he takes JM off for a defensive midfielder, that though we love, we know is not much good in offensive nature.

RH been good for us, there is no doubt, but comes a time where the players start saying WTF?, and i think thats shown this season.

We will lose Wilf for sure at end of season, maybe if we were playing more positive football, with chance of Europe, he might think about it. But no way now.

If he goes, other players will consider their future more seriously. Milo has been eyed up by bigger teams, as is Guaita and PVA.

Next season gonna be a total disaster unless we have big plans for change come end of season.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 02 Feb 20 1.35pm

buck stops with roy. the sum total performance of the team is way less than sum of the individual parts. Roy's tactics bare most of the blame. paying for draws in every game gets you killed when one in your team makes a mistake. this we are lucky to have roy thing is hogwash. credit he gets for saving us 2 seasons ago, but thats just it. BFS also did that. how about the sale of AWB,genius? NOT. Loan of CW, genius NOT. the not playing of riedewald till you have to, genius? Hardly. "he did not get any backing in the transfer window"..TRUE? HARDLY - like his liverpool stint where he almost ran them to the ground. now, has he done well elsewhere, well yes, but more through the luck of the draw, marginal wins, narrow losses and a heap of draws. our current palace team managed differently is capable of far better than we have managed. and dont get me wrong, RH is a good guy, means well but in this league you cant go into matches heaping praise to the teams you are playing especially if they are at or below your level

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Feb 20 1.48pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

buck stops with roy. the sum total performance of the team is way less than sum of the individual parts. Roy's tactics bare most of the blame. paying for draws in every game gets you killed when one in your team makes a mistake. this we are lucky to have roy thing is hogwash. credit he gets for saving us 2 seasons ago, but thats just it. BFS also did that. how about the sale of AWB,genius? NOT. Loan of CW, genius NOT. the not playing of riedewald till you have to, genius? Hardly. "he did not get any backing in the transfer window"..TRUE? HARDLY - like his liverpool stint where he almost ran them to the ground. now, has he done well elsewhere, well yes, but more through the luck of the draw, marginal wins, narrow losses and a heap of draws. our current palace team managed differently is capable of far better than we have managed. and dont get me wrong, RH is a good guy, means well but in this league you cant go into matches heaping praise to the teams you are playing especially if they are at or below your level

Clearly preparing excuses so he doesn't have to scrutinise his own tactical failure.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 02 Feb 20 1.57pm

Thank you

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

buck stops with roy. the sum total performance of the team is way less than sum of the individual parts. Roy's tactics bare most of the blame. paying for draws in every game gets you killed when one in your team makes a mistake. this we are lucky to have roy thing is hogwash. credit he gets for saving us 2 seasons ago, but thats just it. BFS also did that. how about the sale of AWB,genius? NOT. Loan of CW, genius NOT. the not playing of riedewald till you have to, genius? Hardly. "he did not get any backing in the transfer window"..TRUE? HARDLY - like his liverpool stint where he almost ran them to the ground. now, has he done well elsewhere, well yes, but more through the luck of the draw, marginal wins, narrow losses and a heap of draws. our current palace team managed differently is capable of far better than we have managed. and dont get me wrong, RH is a good guy, means well but in this league you cant go into matches heaping praise to the teams you are playing especially if they are at or below your level

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 02 Feb 20 2.11pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I very much doubt that the Board have lost confidence in the manager. The way the club is being run by that Board, they are lucky to have him.

It's not true that he wasn't given money to spend, where do you get that from ??!!

If I was Hodgson then I would quit in the summer because there is every chance that without refinancing and team rebuilding the club are heading for an even tougher season next year.

Hodgson has done an astounding job with very few resources and, seemingly, little backing, financially or otherwise, from the owners. I find it inconceivable that he's happy to simply muddle through on what limited squad there is available to him.

This is a club in a very dangerous limbo. There are stories going around that the Americans want out (waiting to trouser the Zaha money in the summer, perhaps), which would maybe explain the lack of investment in the squad and why the stadium development has ground to a halt. While this uncertainty persists, the squad gets older, highly paid underperformers continue to drain resources and fresher, younger blood isn't coming on board. As long as all this is going on, form and morale will drop and relegation becomes more and more likely.

In this kind of atmosphere, it wouldn't surprise me in the least if Hodgson walked at the end of the season. People will be frantically looking around for someone to blame but, believe it, Hodgson isn't one of them.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Bud Flag 02 Feb 20 2.22pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Roy and strikers' by bexleydave

Maybe someone with better knowledge than me has the answer, has Roy ever had an high scoring striker in any of he’s teams? Before him we scored goals I know he is ultra defensive but so have other managers we’ve had.

 

Sthlondonuk Flag STH NORWOOD 02 Feb 20 2.32pm

Not suggesting we play long ball all the time but have it as an option. Teams know exactly how we play and can prepare. I would add maybe using substitutes earlier in the game if it isn’t working and get them on quickly. When Van Aanholt limped off recently the management didn’t even seem to notice and it took ages to get a sub on which is amateurish. One final moan is it just luck that Sheff Utd have one injured player coming back soon and we have had up to nine or ten perhaps our training / preparation is wrong?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Feb 20 2.38pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Roy and strikers' by bexleydave

He had Harry Kane, who was banging them in for fun with Spurs, put on corner duty for England. I think that answers your question.

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Feb 20 3.01pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

buck stops with roy. the sum total performance of the team is way less than sum of the individual parts. Roy's tactics bare most of the blame. paying for draws in every game gets you killed when one in your team makes a mistake. this we are lucky to have roy thing is hogwash. credit he gets for saving us 2 seasons ago, but thats just it. BFS also did that. how about the sale of AWB,genius? NOT. Loan of CW, genius NOT. the not playing of riedewald till you have to, genius? Hardly. "he did not get any backing in the transfer window"..TRUE? HARDLY - like his liverpool stint where he almost ran them to the ground. now, has he done well elsewhere, well yes, but more through the luck of the draw, marginal wins, narrow losses and a heap of draws. our current palace team managed differently is capable of far better than we have managed. and dont get me wrong, RH is a good guy, means well but in this league you cant go into matches heaping praise to the teams you are playing especially if they are at or below your level


Good post.

We are the lowest scorers in the PL. We have conceded first in 15 of our 25 league games. We have not scored a goal in open play in the first half of any of our 15 home league and cup matches - that's over 11 hours of football without a goal. Roy has one tactic and that is to sit back, not pressure teams and hope we get lucky on the break. He is too slow making subs - at least 15 mins after they scored before he did anything yesterday - and when he does make a chnage he never changes the formation. Why not leave CB on and put Ayew with him and take off one of our defensive central midfielders? Why play 3 of them in every game anyway? Why on earth have we shipped out Whickham on loan when he scored against Norwich and forced the OG at Man City, yet we keep Benteke who hasn't scored in 10 months? Yesterday we fielded our oldest ever PL side with an average age of over 30.

It's got to the stage where I don't even look forward to going to games anymore. Hodgson is 'anti-football' and is slowly killing this club. I appreciate he asked for 2 new full-backs and didn't get them - Parish has a lot to answer for in always trying to get players in on the cheap. Also we tried for Bowen and were outbid - but would he have wanted to come to a club where attacking midfielders are ignored or played out of position? The club is an omnishambles.

 

Sthlondonuk Flag STH NORWOOD 02 Feb 20 3.25pm

Cpj

Sadly have to agree and why I’m seriously considering whether to renew my season tickets

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 02 Feb 20 3.34pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Which one of them told you this?

They don't trust his judgement in the transfer window.
He has history of bad buys. They're quite rightly holding onto their money till he's gone. This is of course my opinion only and I accept I could be totally wrong. We'll wait and see.

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Feb 20 4.33pm

Other stats - fewest shots; fewest shots on target.

 

Page 65 of 91 < 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread