This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
How do we do that? And isn't it a two-way street? We do it by doing what we do best. We show patience, tolerance and understanding. We don't give up when rebuffed or faced with intolerance ourselves. We demonstrate that British values are worth having. Of course it's a two way street but first you need to show people where the street is and that they are welcome to use it. How many erstwhile immigrants, or the children of immigrants, do you know that are now proud to be British? It doesn't happen overnight though and I am old enough to have seen this whole scenario several times before. Prophecies of impending disaster and a melt down of our culture are not new.
Why do you associate people wanting to improve social cohesion and eradicate certain barbaric principles as 'extreme' (or far right I assume) all of the time? Who are the 'extreme' posters on this thread and what have they said? I want also to improve social cohesion and eradicate barbaric principles there is no dispute there! Most decent Muslims would as well. The issue is not the destination. It's the route to be taken to get there. I won't name names because although they ought to be obvious I am not in the habit of directly accusing anyone. The only one who gets a pointed finger is "Robinson" himself, who is openly, and unapologetically, an extremist. I despise extreme politics, whether they be of the left or the right.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I want also to improve social cohesion and eradicate barbaric principles there is no dispute there! Most decent Muslims would as well. The issue is not the destination. It's the route to be taken to get there. I won't name names because although they ought to be obvious I am not in the habit of directly accusing anyone. The only one who gets a pointed finger is "Robinson" himself, who is openly, and unapologetically, an extremist. I despise extreme politics, whether they be of the left or the right. More evidence that Wisbech is deluded......You can't force integration on people and demographics increase year on year....With birth rates and new people coming in all the time....complete delusion. His idea that Muslims will....large scale integrate over time is divorced from reality. The very nature of their religion is based upon not losing their values...it's in their book. Figures from 2016. 23% of Muslims want sharia. 39% agreed that 'wives should always obey their husbands', compared to 5 percent nationally. Nearly a third (31%) thought it was acceptable for a British Muslim man to have more than one wife, compared with 8% of the wider population. Only 18 percent believe homosexuality should be legal in Britain. Wisbech tells us he's lived in Islamic countries.....Well, he seems to have a very basic idea about how willing people are to give up the values their religions teach...which is a large part of their identity....Which is a problem when the basic tenets of that religion do not easily relate to liberal western values. Oh and most Muslims want Islamic schooling.......just to say the obvious to Wisbech who seems to think they will be having beer and chips on the sofa in a couple of generations. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2018 4.58pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
More evidence that Wisbech is deluded......You can't force integration on people and demographics increase year on year....With birth rates and new people coming in all the time....complete delusion. His idea that Muslims will....large scale integrate over time is divorced from reality. The very nature of their religion is based upon not losing their values...it's in their book. Figures from 2016. 23% of Muslims want sharia. 39% agreed that 'wives should always obey their husbands', compared to 5 percent nationally. Nearly a third (31%) thought it was acceptable for a British Muslim man to have more than one wife, compared with 8% of the wider population. Only 18 percent believe homosexuality should be legal in Britain. Wisbech tells us he's lived in Islamic countries.....Well, he seems to have a very basic idea about how willing people are to give up the values their religions teach...which is a large part of their identity....Which is a problem when the basic tenets of that religion do not easily relate to liberal western values. Oh and most Muslims want Islamic schooling.......just to say the obvious to Wisbech who seems to think they will be having beer and chips on the sofa in a couple of generations. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2018 4.58pm) In these threads you admit that you are a member of UKIP. You defend "Robinson" and cheerlead for Trump. Then you call ME deluded. I will let others decide about that. I would take long odds that if we asked the general public, although not the contributors here, it wouldn't be me who they thought deluded! I don't question the 2016 survey results. The point is that they are from 2016. Not from 2026 or 2066. If the attitudes reported in 2016 continued then we would have a problem. We will though surely see a difference in 10 and 50 years from now, when positive policies and time have worked. Unless you are a creationist, or evolution denier, like so many other Trump supporters are, there is a lesson from evolution that is instructive. Which is that everything adapts to a changed environment. The same is true both of religions, and of local cultures. British culture has modified itself many times in my lifetime as changes occurred. My mother never ate a Chicken Tikka Marsala but I bet you have. It will adapt again. So will Islam in the UK. Islam adapts. It's different in Turkey, Malaysia and Indonesia so why not the UK? It just needs encouragement and support mixed with an unswerving commitment to seeing that the law is applied to all, fairly and equally. Alongside the removal of any religious teaching in schools and the instruction in British values I agree with the government's idea to introduce a stricter requirement for those wishing to become citizens that necessitates a commitment to adhere to a set of British values, as well as an understanding of life in the UK. Break the commitment and you lose your citizenship. I also have no problem with requiring citizens not to cover their face in public. Most second generation Muslims, especially the women, will welcome more emancipation and freedom. In short I am not at all gloomy about the future, because of Islam. Because of the stupidity of Brexit and the damage the idiot in the WH is doing to the world I am very concerned, but hopeful that the former can be reversed and that the latter will soon be in jail.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
In these threads you admit that you are a member of UKIP. You defend "Robinson" and cheerlead for Trump. Then you call ME deluded. I will let others decide about that. I would take long odds that if we asked the general public, although not the contributors here, it wouldn't be me who they thought deluded! 47 per cent of Britons want to stop immigration from Muslim majority countries. Only 23 percent disagreed. So once again, you are deluded.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Again, these attitudes amongst this group are seen across the Islamic world. They do not change significantly over time. Also again, you ignore the fact that foreign Muslims are always coming into the country. These attitudes are from their religion, but suggesting that they will change you are essentially saying that Muslims will become agnostic. Some will, most won't. Look at the populations of Muslims around the world who are in minorities. Point to me the ones that have majority secular and liberal attitudes. You are in dreamland. They will defend their religion because it is their identity. The kind of dreamland scenario you are waffling about could only happen if we only had reformist mosques allowed here and that Muslims were not allowed to live in highly Islamic areas where they can be a 'country within a country'. That's totally impractical and it's not going to happen. There is no will for any of this to happen. Your views on integration come out of hope rather than any realistic notion of reality. The generations of the future will know who to blame. Unfortunately they will be long dead. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2018 9.11pm) Firstly the fact that the majority want to see immigration from Muslim countries limited, or even banned, has no bearing at all on the issue. The majority want to bring back hanging, but we don't do it. We operate in a representative democracy in which we pay people to study the issues and take decisions on our behalf. This is why we should never hold a referendum on any issue. Popularism as a means to govern is a disaster, as Trump is proving. We cannot allow ourselves to be governed by base instincts. Our only role is to choose who represents us. That's the way we do things and to think otherwise is to be truly deluded. That the current levels of pakistani and Bangladeshi inflow, and the way they are arriving, needs to be changed is without doubt. I think you need to wait a while to see the impact of the much tougher family route immigration requirements that have quietly been introduced in recent years before making too many judgements. It must be having a direct impact on numbers and forcing the communities to marry locally, rather than by arrangement back in their "home" countries. The checks now being made, alongside the financial requirements are long and stringent. It will be interesting to see the more recent figures because if, as I anticipate, they have dropped significantly this will be a big step towards modifying the outcome. I also anticipate that the young people involved, especially the girls, will welcome the change. Once the growth is contained, as it will be because it must be, then the work on ensuring that every citizen adheres to British values can proceed. There is much to do. Dispersing ethnic communities more widely takes time. Ensuring English is the first language requires much effort. It has though been done before, and can again. I just don't buy the idea that Islam is so different that those of that faith are beyond our reach. People are people and once they have the information available they have the brains to process it. There are plenty of examples already.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Can someone tell me the ages of the muslim fanatics who have killed and maimed in the last ten years. That we have seen a growth in home produced radicalised fanatics is clearly true. The numbers though are small and are, hopefully, a temporary phenomenon. I condemn all religion based extremism whatever it's source. Just as the IRA and "Loyalists" both claimed to be Christians they, and the radicalised fanatics, are really just terrorists. The changes will be quiet and unseen, just working their way through as the exposure to British culture makes it's impact. It often won't even be realised by those involved and will take years to be visible.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| Park Road |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Firstly the fact that the majority want to see immigration from Muslim countries limited, or even banned, has no bearing at all on the issue. The majority want to bring back hanging, but we don't do it. We operate in a representative democracy in which we pay people to study the issues and take decisions on our behalf. This is why we should never hold a referendum on any issue. Popularism as a means to govern is a disaster, as Trump is proving. We cannot allow ourselves to be governed by base instincts. Our only role is to choose who represents us. That's the way we do things and to think otherwise is to be truly deluded. That the current levels of pakistani and Bangladeshi inflow, and the way they are arriving, needs to be changed is without doubt. I think you need to wait a while to see the impact of the much tougher family route immigration requirements that have quietly been introduced in recent years before making too many judgements. It must be having a direct impact on numbers and forcing the communities to marry locally, rather than by arrangement back in their "home" countries. The checks now being made, alongside the financial requirements are long and stringent. It will be interesting to see the more recent figures because if, as I anticipate, they have dropped significantly this will be a big step towards modifying the outcome. I also anticipate that the young people involved, especially the girls, will welcome the change. Once the growth is contained, as it will be because it must be, then the work on ensuring that every citizen adheres to British values can proceed. There is much to do. Dispersing ethnic communities more widely takes time. Ensuring English is the first language requires much effort. It has though been done before, and can again. I just don't buy the idea that Islam is so different that those of that faith are beyond our reach. People are people and once they have the information available they have the brains to process it. There are plenty of examples already. And that is where the naivety lies.
|
|
| Park Road |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That we have seen a growth in home produced radicalised fanatics is clearly true. The numbers though are small and are, hopefully, a temporary phenomenon. I condemn all religion based extremism whatever it's source. Just as the IRA and "Loyalists" both claimed to be Christians they, and the radicalised fanatics, are really just terrorists. The changes will be quiet and unseen, just working their way through as the exposure to British culture makes it's impact. It often won't even be realised by those involved and will take years to be visible. Let's see how are great British culture gets past this.
You write with conviction mate, but you seem a bit wet behind the ears.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
OK, let me know what you think of the report when you've read it fully. I am about 1/3rd my way through but already have the gist of the report, it's conclusions and recommendations. It's a well researched and comprehensive piece of work which is thought provoking. I am sure that it's conclusions will be taken seriously by policy makers. Some things stand out to me. Right wingers, like "Robinson" can draw little comfort from it for it's whole approach seems driven by the need to avoid the impact of the extremists, either within the Muslim community, or from the far right. The report goes out of it's way to specifically make this clear. Indeed it suggests that Muslim and right wing extremists have more in common with each other, than with the rest of us. The thing though that most surprised me was the level of marriages that are between British Muslims of pakistani and Bangladeshi origin, and spouses from their "home" countries. I was aware that it happened, but not that the level appears to be so high. These have to be arranged in some way and absolutely need to stop, especially as they are often between cousins. What is not generally known is that the family route to settlement has become much, much tougher and expensive in recent years. I have personal experience of this, having been twice married to a foreign national, firstly in 2002 and again in 2016. The difference between the two processes is extreme. In 2002 it was a breeze. In 2016 it was torture. It now costs a lot of money and you need to show a reasonable income, and separate accommodation before you even start. Make even a simple mistake and your application is refused and your fees lost. They refuse whenever there is the slightest doubt that the relationship is genuine, has existed for a long time and is sustainable. Then there is the NHS surcharge to pay. This must be having an impact. It took me a month to prepare all the documents and I am pretty skilled with these kind of things. It will be interesting to know what the current situation is, but I suspect it is much changed. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (08 Aug 2018 11.55am) Edited by Guntrisoft (09 Aug 2018 11.32am)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That we have seen a growth in home produced radicalised fanatics is clearly true. The numbers though are small and are, hopefully, a temporary phenomenon. I condemn all religion based extremism whatever it's source. Just as the IRA and "Loyalists" both claimed to be Christians they, and the radicalised fanatics, are really just terrorists. The changes will be quiet and unseen, just working their way through as the exposure to British culture makes it's impact. It often won't even be realised by those involved and will take years to be visible. The numbers may be small but the impact is massive.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
The numbers may be small but the impact is massive. I think there are one or two Christians still around. Mohammed seems to tick quite a few boxes in Revelation's descriptions of the false prophet.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
I think there are one or two Christians still around. Mohammed seems to tick quite a few boxes in Revelation's descriptions of the false prophet. Not Christianity only.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
I think there are one or two Christians still around. Mohammed seems to tick quite a few boxes in Revelation's descriptions of the false prophet. Is that false prophet like payday
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Not Christianity only. Which ones? Genuinely interested to know. I know that early Christianity stamped out opposition pretty ruthlessly, although that was largely dissent within its own (fairly loose) ranks. islam has only waged war in any meaningful sense against Christianity since its inception, although they do seem to have an ongoing “thing” about the Jews.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Park Road
Let's see how are great British culture gets past this.
You write with conviction mate, but you seem a bit wet behind the ears. It will because it has to and always has done in the past. Most posting here seem to assume that things will simply progress on the same track and that there won't be any interventions. I disagree because there already have been. Not widely publicised nor appreciated but done quietly to avoid confrontation and controversy.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
The numbers may be small but the impact is massive. From where do you get your 15% to 20%? I think that is wildly overstated and doesn't match my own experiences at all. It might be true in parts of Iraq or Afghanistan but cannot be so in Indonesia, Turkey or Malaysia. I have no time at all for religion based intolerance and want to see it eradicated every bit as anyone else does. The question is not if that needs to be done, but how. You cannot just wipe away a religion, so the only way has to be to make other things become more important. That can be done with economic progress and a place in the modern world. It works already in some Muslim countries and can, in time, in all of them. It will for us, once we stop herding them into ghettos and treating them like outcasts. I realise that for many that is currently their own choice but we need to break that circle.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.