You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Churchill was a prick
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Churchill was a prick


Page 7 of 14 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 13 6.45pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.37pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 31 May 2013 6.10pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.


He called Hitler for the dangerous f*cker he was when it was very unfashionable to do so.

Fair point but he also admired Mussolini, probably as he was anti-communist, so 50% right wasn't too bad.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.37pm)


Firstly, where do you get Churchill admired Mussolini from?

Secondly to put that on an equal footing of the warnings over Hitler and the urging for action before he stuck is absurd.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 31 May 13 6.49pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 6.45pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.37pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 31 May 2013 6.10pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.


He called Hitler for the dangerous f*cker he was when it was very unfashionable to do so.

Fair point but he also admired Mussolini, probably as he was anti-communist, so 50% right wasn't too bad.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.37pm)


Firstly, where do you get Churchill admired Mussolini from?

Secondly to put that on an equal footing of the warnings over Hitler and the urging for action before he stuck is absurd.


I've never heard of him admiring 'The Bullfrog of the Pontine Marshes' as he once referred to him. Quite the opposite.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 31 May 13 6.50pm

Quote serial thriller at 22 May 2013 8.18pm

Had quite an intense with a mate of mine today about one of the great celebrated figures of this nation's political history.

I think I may have brought this up on here before but I've always held the view that Churchill is viewed as a great leader because he won. Had he lost, I believe a lot of questionable stuff the British did would have come out, but instead it's wiped under the carpet and we continue to moan about those nasty Germans with their concentration camps (an idea they knicked off us) and anti-Semitism (which was thriving in Britain in the 30s).

The clearest example of this for me is the Bengal Famine. Churchill, fearful that the Japs might invade northern India, decided rather than evacuate the natives, he would just stop sending them food and shelter (in the middle of a famine) leading to millions of deaths, some claim on a similar scale as the number of Jews killed in concentration camps. When asked about this, Churchill blamed them for 'breeding like rabbits'.

He also supported a Bill to sterilise the mentally disabled (I'm not making this up! [Link] a form of, err, eugenics.

So let's look at the evidence: a mass-murderer, who supported racial purification, but won a lot of people over because he was a good public speaker and adopted the role as figurehead of a nation.

Now who does that remind me of...

Anyone willing to defend him?

Edited by serial thriller (22 May 2013 8.18pm)


If Churchill had lost you probably would not be around today and if per chance you did survive you would be speaking german and running a concentration camp . Don't be a prick all your life and remember, lttle man all prick and big man big prick. Are you five feet two in your shoes?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 13 6.52pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.

Who is claiming that Churchill was a good general?

It's well established that Churchill wasn't good at the details of military strategy. His strength was in being a political leader and at being ultimately very good at picking or sacking generals.

No one praises Churchill for being a kind of modern Alexander.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

johnno42000 Flag 31 May 13 6.52pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 6.45pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.37pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 31 May 2013 6.10pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.


He called Hitler for the dangerous f*cker he was when it was very unfashionable to do so.

Fair point but he also admired Mussolini, probably as he was anti-communist, so 50% right wasn't too bad.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.37pm)


Firstly, where do you get Churchill admired Mussolini from?

Secondly to put that on an equal footing of the warnings over Hitler and the urging for action before he stuck is absurd.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 31 May 13 6.57pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.52pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 6.45pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.37pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 31 May 2013 6.10pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.


He called Hitler for the dangerous f*cker he was when it was very unfashionable to do so.

Fair point but he also admired Mussolini, probably as he was anti-communist, so 50% right wasn't too bad.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.37pm)


Firstly, where do you get Churchill admired Mussolini from?

Secondly to put that on an equal footing of the warnings over Hitler and the urging for action before he stuck is absurd.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]


Hardly authoritative. No respected historian has ever even suggested that Churchill might have admired Il Duce. There is, moreover, plenty in his own writings that show that he had little or no time for him.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

johnno42000 Flag 31 May 13 6.58pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 6.52pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.

Who is claiming that Churchill was a good general?

It's well established that Churchill wasn't good at the details of military strategy. His strength was in being a political leader and at being ultimately very good at picking or sacking generals.

No one praises Churchill for being a kind of modern Alexander.

He politically was involved in the military involvements I quoted. It seems very one sided to mention the one's he was involved in, that went very well, and not mention the others that went badly.


Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.59pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 13 7.13pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.52pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 6.45pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.37pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 31 May 2013 6.10pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.03pm

Quote kevpofcpfc at 31 May 2013 4.48pm

The persistence of Churchill in the battle for North Africa was pivotal, he alone persuaded the yanks that this was the place to deploy. The masterclass appointment of Mountbatten and the following kicking of the Africa Korps paved the way for the fall of Italy.


To balance things it should also be pointed out his involvement with failure's such as the Dardanelles campaign in the First World War, The Dieppe Raid and the Norway invasion.

I still think he was a very good Second World War leader but very far from perfect.


He called Hitler for the dangerous f*cker he was when it was very unfashionable to do so.

Fair point but he also admired Mussolini, probably as he was anti-communist, so 50% right wasn't too bad.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.37pm)


Firstly, where do you get Churchill admired Mussolini from?

Secondly to put that on an equal footing of the warnings over Hitler and the urging for action before he stuck is absurd.

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]


Hilarious.

To refer to a sentence Churchill said in 1927 to butter up a new leader to be indicative of Churchill's attitude towards Mussolini is ridiculous.

Mussolini in 1927 was a Fascist but at that time the word hadn't anything like as bad a reputation as it has today. Still, he was an unpleasant bully and criminal but not entirely different from most of Southern Europe at the time......Indeed there was no racial aspect to Mussolini's fascism until siding with Hitler.

It's as silly as saying the same of people on the left who liked Blair when he first emerged as an MP advocating CND policies.

Would it be sensible to say that they 'admired Blair' as a question mark against them?

Indeed the main thrust behind the WW2 books you are linking to seems to be also ridiculous.....This idea that making peace with Hitler would have been a good idea....So we give him Poland....Make peace, he takes France and ......Turns away from us and takes Russia....Who are fighting on their own...Just as Hitler wanted. Then what? He stops?

Those books are appeasement fantasies. God save us from their cosy and riskless revisionism.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2013 7.38pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 13 7.21pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.58pm

He politically was involved in the military involvements I quoted. It seems very one sided to mention the one's he was involved in, that went very well, and not mention the others that went badly.


Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.59pm)


My point is that here you are pushing against an open door.

No one with knowledge about Churchill, including Churchill published conclusions himself says that he always got it right.

Churchill had a very long political career.
How many commanders or leaders in history held commands for anything as long as he and had no defeats.

Caesar lived long but even he was defeated twice....And politically he was disastrous.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2013 7.23pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

johnno42000 Flag 31 May 13 7.28pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 7.21pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.58pm

He politically was involved in the military involvements I quoted. It seems very one sided to mention the one's he was involved in, that went very well, and not mention the others that went badly.


Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.59pm)


My point is that here you are pushing against an open door.

No one with knowledge about Churchill, including Churchill published conclusions himself says that he always got it right.

Churchill had a very long political career.
How many commanders or leaders in history held commands for anything as long as he and had no defeats.

Caesar lived long but even he was defeated twice....And politically he was disastrous.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2013 7.23pm)

My point is that people keep posting the good things about him and ignore the bad. It's almost if they had rose tinted specs.

I have never ignored his importance during the Second World War, and wouldn't dream of doing so, however, there are things he did badly, and certain people seem to conveniently ignore these and that, IMO, is wrong.

Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 7.33pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 13 7.35pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 7.28pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 7.21pm

Quote johnno42000 at 31 May 2013 6.58pm

He politically was involved in the military involvements I quoted. It seems very one sided to mention the one's he was involved in, that went very well, and not mention the others that went badly.


Edited by johnno42000 (31 May 2013 6.59pm)


My point is that here you are pushing against an open door.

No one with knowledge about Churchill, including Churchill published conclusions himself says that he always got it right.

Churchill had a very long political career.
How many commanders or leaders in history held commands for anything as long as he and had no defeats.

Caesar lived long but even he was defeated twice....And politically he was disastrous.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2013 7.23pm)

My point is that people keep posting the good things about him and ignore the bad. It's almost if they had rose tinted specs.

I have never ignored his importance during the Second World War, and wouldn't dream of doing so, however, there are things he did badly and certain people seem to conveniently ignore these and that, IMO, is wrong.


The balance is heavily weighted towards the positive.

Churchill is rightly regarded as the greatest Britain so naturally people will post supporting him.

I doubt many people are ignoring Churchill's mistakes but rather don't know about them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 31 May 13 11.15pm

Quote eaglesmad at 24 May 2013 12.00am

After recent events this is total disrespect to the armed forces and civilians that lost there lives during WW2, OP u are a absolute Prick for starting this thread, I find it offensive to say the least, I am a ex serviceman and lost friends fighting for this country it was our job we choose to do it to defend OUR country, and arseholes like you make me sick, you don't like it here f*** off your no better than a terrorist in my view, Churchill did what had to be done to stop a madman if he hadn't you would be speaking German and being told how to live your life and have no freedom of choice, I'm sure your grandparents or even parents are really proud of you. Arsehole

You were presumably defending free speech, though mate. So why the offence? You should be pleased you've defended it so well its still thriving. Thanks...though not sure I really felt under attack from Iraq or Afganistan. But Hey thanks again.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 May 13 11.38pm

Quote Bert the Head at 31 May 2013 11.15pm

You were presumably defending free speech, though mate. So why the offence? You should be pleased you've defended it so well its still thriving. Thanks...though not sure I really felt under attack from Iraq or Afganistan. But Hey thanks again.


9/11 resulted in 67 British dead.

The organization that conceived of and carried out the act was based inside Afganistan.

Until mid-morning I bet the British workers inside the World Trade centres didn't feel under attack either.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

moaner Flag Westerham 02 Jun 13 6.21pm

Quote serial thriller at 22 May 2013 8.18pm

Had quite an intense with a mate of mine today about one of the great celebrated figures of this nation's political history.

I think I may have brought this up on here before but I've always held the view that Churchill is viewed as a great leader because he won. Had he lost, I believe a lot of questionable stuff the British did would have come out, but instead it's wiped under the carpet and we continue to moan about those nasty Germans with their concentration camps (an idea they knicked off us) and anti-Semitism (which was thriving in Britain in the 30s).

The clearest example of this for me is the Bengal Famine. Churchill, fearful that the Japs might invade northern India, decided rather than evacuate the natives, he would just stop sending them food and shelter (in the middle of a famine) leading to millions of deaths, some claim on a similar scale as the number of Jews killed in concentration camps. When asked about this, Churchill blamed them for 'breeding like rabbits'.

He also supported a Bill to sterilise the mentally disabled (I'm not making this up! [Link] a form of, err, eugenics.

So let's look at the evidence: a mass-murderer, who supported racial purification, but won a lot of people over because he was a good public speaker and adopted the role as figurehead of a nation.

Now who does that remind me of...

Anyone willing to defend him?

Edited by serial thriller (22 May 2013 8.18pm)

Selective claptrap, you would be better getting a job at the BBC., they talk rubbish as well, only with a left wing agenda!

 


Everyone is entitled to my opinions

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Jun 13 7.02pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 11.38pm

Quote Bert the Head at 31 May 2013 11.15pm

You were presumably defending free speech, though mate. So why the offence? You should be pleased you've defended it so well its still thriving. Thanks...though not sure I really felt under attack from Iraq or Afganistan. But Hey thanks again.


9/11 resulted in 67 British dead.

The organization that conceived of and carried out the act was based inside Afganistan.

Until mid-morning I bet the British workers inside the World Trade centres didn't feel under attack either.

Partially true, Al-Qaeda had key members based there, but it hadn't really function in any way along real territorial lines. Even back in 2001, it definitely had people in Afghanistan, but its questionable how much influence or knowledge the regime had over them or of the attacks. Its likely that Al-Qaeda served more as a means of financing Jyhadist groups, rather than really directing them, and those active groups tended to move around a lot.

Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was only a member of Al-Qaeda from 1999 onwards, and had already an extensive history in terrorism and Jyhad, including having been involved in the 1993 WTC bombing (his nephew carried it out), Chechnya, Bali, Bosnia, pakistan and the Philippines.

Bin Laden certainly became very involved in the plot, but the role of Afghanistan in the scheme was fairly limited to a geographical convenience.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Jun 13 7.29pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2013 7.02pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 31 May 2013 11.38pm

Quote Bert the Head at 31 May 2013 11.15pm

You were presumably defending free speech, though mate. So why the offence? You should be pleased you've defended it so well its still thriving. Thanks...though not sure I really felt under attack from Iraq or Afganistan. But Hey thanks again.


9/11 resulted in 67 British dead.

The organization that conceived of and carried out the act was based inside Afganistan.

Until mid-morning I bet the British workers inside the World Trade centres didn't feel under attack either.

Partially true, Al-Qaeda had key members based there, but it hadn't really function in any way along real territorial lines. Even back in 2001, it definitely had people in Afghanistan, but its questionable how much influence or knowledge the regime had over them or of the attacks. Its likely that Al-Qaeda served more as a means of financing Jyhadist groups, rather than really directing them, and those active groups tended to move around a lot.

Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was only a member of Al-Qaeda from 1999 onwards, and had already an extensive history in terrorism and Jyhad, including having been involved in the 1993 WTC bombing (his nephew carried it out), Chechnya, Bali, Bosnia, pakistan and the Philippines.

Bin Laden certainly became very involved in the plot, but the role of Afghanistan in the scheme was fairly limited to a geographical convenience.



It's not partially true, it's totally true.

If you were going to attack Al-Qaeda after 9/11 you had to attack Bin Laden in Afghanistan. The Taliban were given the chance to give him up and refused it.

The war in Afghanistan suffered massively and detrimentally from mission creep.....There I would probably agree with you.

After going for the Al-Qaeda leadership and degrading the Taliban the West should have got out and then funded the Northern Alliance and resulting government instead.

They lost sight of the point in Afghanistan.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 02 Jun 13 9.43pm

Quote Pinky at 23 May 2013 7.54am

Also used armed troops to force miners back to work in the north-east during the General Strike. My grandad (miner, WW1 veteran) hated Churchill's guts. And a grateful nation kicked the nasty b****** out of office after they'd sorted out the mess and misery created by the crisis of capitalism in the 30s and 40s.


Whilst he was voted out in 1945, he got voted back in a few years later

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 29 Jan 15 2.19pm

Excellent programme about him on right now.

"Walden on Heroes".

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 29 Jan 15 2.32pm

Quote bright&wright at 23 May 2013 9.06am

Quote Icepick Tony at 23 May 2013 9.03am

Quote bright&wright at 23 May 2013 8.56am

Wembley. Block 140. Row 31. Seat 182. Come and tell me Churchill was a pr*ck to my face.

It's a shame he helped save people like you.

Wow.

Yeah that rolling eyes icon gets way over used on here. I'm merely offering to have a face-to-face to chat about it.

I'm sure he'll be defending the actions of Islamic terrorists next.


It's aways amusing to watch the childish rantings of a keyboard warrior.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

blackgirl3 Flag brighton 29 Jan 15 2.37pm

churcllill was a prick i bet this thread has gone down well , i really loved whinny er whinny the poo

 

Page 7 of 14 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Churchill was a prick