You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke to be sold
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke to be sold


Page 7 of 12 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
sprites Flag Auckland 11 Jan 17 8.42pm

The last two posts are nail head. Great posts.

 

mistergoldie Flag North Vancouver via Reigate 11 Jan 17 8.42pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Why would we want to sell the best striker we have had in years. I feel he gets a rough deal. Yes, the guy does not work as hard as he could, but he is isolated a lot of the time. He hasn't peaked and he has scored AS MANY GOALS AS SO FAR THAN OUR TOP GOALSCORER LAST SEASON.

Fans make you laugh! Everyone wants a proven premier league goal scorer, you buy one and then people moan because he doesn't run around alot.

Perhaps we should spend the proceeds on one of these sucesses;
Michy Batshuayi 33.15m
Memphis Depay 28.9m
Wilfried Bony 27.46m
Islam Slimani 25m
Simone Zaza 25m
Roberto Soldado 25m

Exactly

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 11 Jan 17 8.47pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

Why would we want to sell the best striker we have had in years. I feel he gets a rough deal. Yes, the guy does not work as hard as he could, but he is isolated a lot of the time. He hasn't peaked and he has scored AS MANY GOALS AS SO FAR THAN OUR TOP GOALSCORER LAST SEASON.

Fans make you laugh! Everyone wants a proven premier league goal scorer, you buy one and then people moan because he doesn't run around alot.

Perhaps we should spend the proceeds on one of these sucesses;
Michy Batshuayi 33.15m
Memphis Depay 28.9m
Wilfried Bony 27.46m
Islam Slimani 25m
Simone Zaza 25m
Roberto Soldado 25m

And that would have been more like 40m in today's market.

Your post is spot on. I'm not sure who the people wanting to sell CB think is waiting in the wings to come in and be our saviour when above average Championship strikers are going for 15m.

The only way I can see there being any truth in the rumour is if a) there's some truth to 40m+ potential offers from China, and b) CB has given some indication he'd be interested in going.

But 40m would buy us 3 average Prem players in places we need them: Centre back, left back and left wing; SP might stump up a bit more for an average Prem centre mid; and that leaves us relying on Campbell and a loanee prone to injury to get us enough goals to stay up.

Massive gamble in my opinion.

Edited by antipodeagle (11 Jan 2017 8.49pm)

Edited by antipodeagle (11 Jan 2017 8.49pm)

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 11 Jan 17 8.56pm

I hope this is not true and Benteke stays.

Benteke and Remy partnership has goals a plenty in it.

we may here more in fridays press conference on this.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 11 Jan 17 9.19pm

The people that are comparing Gayle with Defoe have zero idea about the game
lets put it this way
Gayle will not score a Quarter of the goals Defoe has in the Premier league

 

WJK1960 Flag 11 Jan 17 9.20pm

I agree with the last post. Benteke's ability with Remy's agility and speed should give us a real goal threat. And if we compare Benteke with Llorente in the Swansea match, Llorente was always doing knock downs to runners around him while Benteke was having to control and pass in isolation, and we just do not have runners who are close to him. I think he has been good for us without being great, but it's early days and apart from a brief period with Wickham he hasn't played up front with another striker. He has to stay.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 11 Jan 17 9.24pm

Originally posted by WJK1960

I agree with the last post. Benteke's ability with Remy's agility and speed should give us a real goal threat. And if we compare Benteke with Llorente in the Swansea match, Llorente was always doing knock downs to runners around him while Benteke was having to control and pass in isolation, and we just do not have runners who are close to him. I think he has been good for us without being great, but it's early days and apart from a brief period with Wickham he hasn't played up front with another striker. He has to stay.

Huh ?
We are never gonna play 2 up top all the time we are in the bottom 6

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 11 Jan 17 9.29pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Hmmm, not on here really no. Put it this way though,the person who told my friend, is a good friend of someone well placed within hierarchy of the club. I was told nothing more than there is some truth in the stories. The fact that Sky Sports are reporting it, would suggest that there is some truth in it. Whether it happens or not is another story.

Tell your friend of a friend,that for what it's worth, if this actually happens without some wonderful plan, I won't bother renewing my season ticket. I have no problem going down, but selling the family silver and running up the white flag with half a season to go, is frankly bollocks.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 11 Jan 17 10.09pm

Originally posted by Username

[Link]

Pressures the defender and continues on to the goalkeeper. Scores.

"Benteke is lazy" is just the new "Wilf has no end product"


Exactly. 8 goals in 18 league games is a poor return. No wonder Dann's p*ssed off. Not top goal scorer.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 11 Jan 17 10.11pm

If we sell Benteke for what we paid or less, we might aswell pack up and settle for the Championship next season. He's the best goalscorer I ever remember us having, and he's got a 1 in 2 record for us. If we sell him, how much can we realistically strengthen for £30m in today's market that is tried and tested in this league? Absolutely ridiculous some of you are.

 


[Link]

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 11 Jan 17 10.14pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Hmmm, not on here really no. Put it this way though,the person who told my friend, is a good friend of someone well placed within hierarchy of the club. I was told nothing more than there is some truth in the stories. The fact that Sky Sports are reporting it, would suggest that there is some truth in it. Whether it happens or not is another story.

It took you a full stop to spill the beans & practically name your source. Not the best person to tell secrets to.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 11 Jan 17 10.56pm

can one of you "sell Benteke" crowd just tell me exactly who will be our main striker for the rest of the season? Remy? in his physical state? - Oh sorry I forgot about Fraser ...sorry

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 11 Jan 17 10.57pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Hmmm, not on here really no. Put it this way though,the person who told my friend, is a good friend of someone well placed within hierarchy of the club. I was told nothing more than there is some truth in the stories. The fact that Sky Sports are reporting it, would suggest that there is some truth in it. Whether it happens or not is another story.

Half the stories on SSN appear after they've been published elsewhere on t'internet - I sometimes think they simply follow NewsNow & t***ter.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

bodge Flag 11 Jan 17 10.57pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Huh ?
We are never gonna play 2 up top all the time we are in the bottom 6

So you think we will not start with Remy and Benteke. If both are fit they will start v West Ham.

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 11 Jan 17 10.58pm

Selling Benteke is a dumb move. So he's had a bad few games? The WHOLE team has! We've waited SOOOOO LOOOONG to finally get a decent PL striker! All he needs is service and the goals will flow. And as for people saying he's lazy - I say BS! Maybe he got a bit disillusioned because he was being asked too much of late, but my recollection of him is running balls down all day - such as the first Southampton goal. He's been "PARDEWED" a bit that's all. For goodness sake - KEEP HIM!

 


[Link]

NI_palace_fan Flag Newtownards 11 Jan 17 11.12pm

West brom to bid 30m and berahino for benteke. I'd bite their hand off.

 

cpfc84 Flag 11 Jan 17 11.25pm

west brom value berahino at 14mill so would only be getting 16mill in cash from benteke

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 Jan 17 11.32pm

Originally posted by cpfc84

west brom value berahino at 14mill so would only be getting 16mill in cash from benteke

[Link]

I think we would get more than £14m. Berahino is out of form and not match fit, whilst Benteke has already got 8 goals in a struggling team. My guess is more like £20m plus Berahino

 

NI_palace_fan Flag Newtownards 11 Jan 17 11.37pm

West brom value berahino at 5m now according to talk sport and papers. So cash value of 25m possibly would still bite their hand off.

 

cpfc84 Flag 11 Jan 17 11.38pm

ye id agree with that them asking 14 is far to high like you said hes out of contract soon

 

Page 7 of 12 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke to be sold