You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back
November 16 2026 9.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Jul 17 5.24pm

Originally posted by si_1967

I agree with all this except for the one point - highlighted. I think you'll find most people (except Pardew) were arguing for a decent replacement last August rather than hindsight and we got ... Flamini, who never played!!

On the few occasions Flamini played with Cabaye we looked good in midfield. Problem was the Ledley and MacArthur aren't really very good defensive midfielders, they like to get forward too much (I like MacArthur, but he's more an all round midfielder).

And Cabaye doesn't have the power to be a defensive midfielder.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 9.40pm

With the budget only 30m. Is it time to sell Jimmy mac and dann to raise another 15m.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 03 Jul 17 9.57pm

Originally posted by Dan89

With the budget only 30m. Is it time to sell Jimmy mac and dann to raise another 15m.

It would cost far more to replace them than selling them would bring in. It depends whether the manager rates them, of course, and whether they fit into the way he wants to play, but you're not going to buy better premier league players for the money they would bring in, and untested players from abroad can be hit and miss; some work, but plenty of others don't (see West Ham's recent signings for example).

Continuity has it's merits, and change for change's sake doesn't make too much sense from a player morale point of view. I'd say keep both of them, at least until January and see what the new manager can bring to the team until then.

 


I used to be immortal

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Jul 17 10.06pm

MacArthur would be in my side ahead of Puncheon who's game really is in decline IMO.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Jul 17 10.22pm

Originally posted by Dan89

With the budget only 30m. Is it time to sell Jimmy mac and dann to raise another 15m.

Not IMO.
Both unlucky to lose there starting 11 positions.
See what Frank does.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 03 Jul 17 10.30pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

MacArthur would be in my side ahead of Puncheon who's game really is in decline IMO.

Totally agree ^^^^^

I used to love Punch's free kicks (better than Cabaye imo) and when he played out wider.

Now my heart just sinks when he had the ball.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 10.30pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Not IMO.
Both unlucky to lose there starting 11 positions.
See what Frank does.

Really. Mcarthur was dreadful the turn of the year

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 10.32pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

MacArthur would be in my side ahead of Puncheon who's game really is in decline IMO.

Puncheon isn't leaving anytime soon. Unless Cabaye leaves. We need to recoup some funds dann and mcarthur can do this.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 03 Jul 17 10.36pm

I would accept any bid of 7.5 mill onwards, one year left on contract, has been poor for a long time.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 03 Jul 17 10.37pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Exactly. I personally sell dann too. Get some younger blood in the line up.

You are actually mental. The kid in sweet shop behaviour just doesn't stop with you. Do you buy a new car every month by any chance? I say keep benteke and zaha coz they're alright, but sell everyone else replacing them with upgrades. Simple

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Jul 17 10.42pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Puncheon isn't leaving anytime soon. Unless Cabaye leaves. We need to recoup some funds dann and mcarthur can do this.

Upgrades on these two will not be as easy to find as you're suggesting.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 03 Jul 17 10.45pm

Originally posted by rawpalace05

You are actually mental. The kid in sweet shop behaviour just doesn't stop with you. Do you buy a new car every month by any chance? I say keep benteke and zaha coz they're alright, but sell everyone else replacing them with upgrades. Simple

What is your problem pal. If you don't like what written on here ignore. We haven't all got Scott dann posters on the wall like you. All I seen from your post is argumentative posts about people comment. This threads about opinions and suggestions. If that not for you, then maybe you should stop reading hol.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 03 Jul 17 10.54pm

Jimmy currently gives cover for Cayabe, punch and Milo he must be virtually the first name on the sub bench.

It's a brave man who sells such a versatile player.

Personally think you need to know the replacements will work out before letting him go. Other wise one or two injuries and we have BIG problems.

Do we need £8m that badly?

Don't think so.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 04 Jul 17 3.33am

didn't read pages of responses, so i don't know if anyone is arguing if he's a regular starter or a back up. he's just not a regular PL starter for a mid table side. you can like him as a player but the reality is he's not a player of that caliber. if YC is playing in front of mili, then he's a backup. i personally think YC should be in that role. he's better than jimmy.

if someone is paying 10M+ for a backup, it's worth considering. but he's a cup player at the PL level. not a starter. are we getting someone better to replace him? if someone better is found for equal fee, then do it. if not, keep...for now.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Jul 17 6.08am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Do we need £8m that badly?

Don't think so.

Where have these valuations come from if not thin air.

I read a couple of articles yesterday about different players. The first was a defender whom it was suggested we could get on the cheap as he is entering the last year of his contract and the second was for Jimmy Mac whose price seems to have gone up yet he is also entering the last year of his contract.

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 04 Jul 17 7.15am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Where have these valuations come from if not thin air.

I read a couple of articles yesterday about different players. The first was a defender whom it was suggested we could get on the cheap as he is entering the last year of his contract and the second was for Jimmy Mac whose price seems to have gone up yet he is also entering the last year of his contract.

We paid 8m for James mcarthur to Wigan and since then the inflated tv money has come into play. I highly doubt that we'd sell mcarthur for less than the 8m. If he doesn't sign a new deal, he walks away for nothing next summer.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 04 Jul 17 11.18am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Where have these valuations come from if not thin air.

I read a couple of articles yesterday about different players. The first was a defender whom it was suggested we could get on the cheap as he is entering the last year of his contract and the second was for Jimmy Mac whose price seems to have gone up yet he is also entering the last year of his contract.

No idea where the values have come from. I assume people are thinking anything less and we'd say no. But honestly I think it's (Jedi) risky buisness selling JM without a proven replacement

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 08 Jul 17 3.43pm

Now linked to Burnley, looks certain to of played last game, with all this interest , hopefully get the money back we paid.

[Link]

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 08 Jul 17 4.39pm

If it is true that Burnley want him they obviously rate him as a premier league player.

Really don't see the point.

We have form selling players (Jedi particularly) with no replacement.

 

You What Flag se25 08 Jul 17 5.56pm

Originally posted by rossboss29

I would accept any bid of 7.5 mill onwards, one year left on contract, has been poor for a long time.

Poor for along time! Really??? He has been probably our best form player in the time he has played for us.

Edited by You What (08 Jul 2017 5.58pm)

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back