You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Last chance Saloon for Frank
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Last chance Saloon for Frank


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Dan89 Flag Se25 04 Sep 17 4.56pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

So is it a case of we want Woy?

Croydon roots, point to prove. Probably won't look for a massive survival bonus like a Rafa or dyche. Maybe he could get us survival this season and we could go for a dyche or Howe and look for stability that way.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Sep 17 7.06pm

Justin Edinburgh was sacked at Northampton after just 4 games.Found this bit from a local press report :


when the season began, and things started to unravel.

Prior to a ball being kicked, Edinburgh had insisted he wanted to play three at the back, with wing-backs providing the attacking width, and that is how the team lined up for the opener at Shrewsbury.

It didn’t work.

The Cobblers struggled to string two passes together, struggled to create chances, but they still should have claimed what would have been a hard-earned point at the New Meadow, only for the home side to snatch a last-gasp winner.

It was a depressing opening day, but it was just one game. Nothing to worry about.

A narrow League Cup defeat at a much-changed Queens Park Rangers saw an improved performance, but an expected 1-0 defeat, before Fleetwood came to town for the first league one match of the season at Sixfields.

Edinburgh again went with the wing-backs, and it was a better showing than the previous week at Shrewsbury, but the match still ended in a 1-0 defeat, with Town again struggling to create chances.

Sections of the support were now getting restless, they wanted the manager to abandon his three at the back preference, but he stuck by his insistence that it would work, and that the squad was the ‘right mould’ for the system.

Edinburgh, who at the back end of the previous season had played an equally unpopular diamond system, wasn’t for changing.

He went with three at the back again for the trip to Charlton, only to return with his tail between his legs as a certain Ricky Holmes showed the Cobblers fans just what they have lost as he inspired the south Londoners to a 4-1 win.

Social media was now awash with criticism of Edinburgh and his formation and tactics, and with the Peterborough derby on the horizon, the manager admitted he might be open to changing the system for the visit of the Posh.

But he also admitted he can be ‘stubborn’ as a manager - and he was stubborn as Grant McCann’s men came to town.

He again stuck with three at the back, and antagonised the fans even more by again pairing Marc Richards and Alex Revell in attack, a partnership that has consistently failed to fire.

He perhaps had an excuse at Charlton the week before as Long had injured himself in the warm-up at the Valley, but there was no excuse for the Posh encounter.

It meant the fans were far from onside before a ball had even been kicked, and once Peterborough went ahead, the fans turned, and quickly.

It was a horrible afternoon, similar to ones I have experienced in the final days of the likes of Gary Johnson and Aidy Boothroyd, and although I’m not sure there is ever a case for supporters calling for their own manager to be sacked while a match is being played, that is what happened.

They were voicing their displeasure at a woeful start to the campaign, with zero points and just two goals scored, and with Kelvin Thomas taking plenty of stick in the directors’ box, I would imagine Edinburgh’s fate was sealed , even though his misery was prolonged for four more days.

From the outside, a manager getting sacked just four games into the league campaign looks ridiculous, and it does seem unfair to not allow a manager the time to get a team functioning as a unit after so much change and recruitment.

And after the club have backed their man with so many new signings.

But anybody who has watched the Cobblers this season might feel a little differently about it.

As I said earlier, this was about more than results, it was about the vibe and the negative mood around Sixfields, something which has been prevalent since the back end of last season.


Sounds familiar !

Edited by Willo (04 Sep 2017 7.06pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 04 Sep 17 7.15pm

Yes, there's no point crying over spilt milk but you have to consider whether the manager can turn it round. The ambiance is a factor in that. If de Boer gets his jotters it won't be because he's lost three games - actually in one of them we were decent against high-class opposition - but because he has failed to gain the confidence of those that matter.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Flash Flag Lampeter 04 Sep 17 7.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

Justin Edinburgh was sacked at Northampton after just 4 games.Found this bit from a local press report :


when the season began, and things started to unravel.

Prior to a ball being kicked, Edinburgh had insisted he wanted to play three at the back, with wing-backs providing the attacking width, and that is how the team lined up for the opener at Shrewsbury.

It didn’t work.

The Cobblers struggled to string two passes together, struggled to create chances, but they still should have claimed what would have been a hard-earned point at the New Meadow, only for the home side to snatch a last-gasp winner.

It was a depressing opening day, but it was just one game. Nothing to worry about.

A narrow League Cup defeat at a much-changed Queens Park Rangers saw an improved performance, but an expected 1-0 defeat, before Fleetwood came to town for the first league one match of the season at Sixfields.

Edinburgh again went with the wing-backs, and it was a better showing than the previous week at Shrewsbury, but the match still ended in a 1-0 defeat, with Town again struggling to create chances.

Sections of the support were now getting restless, they wanted the manager to abandon his three at the back preference, but he stuck by his insistence that it would work, and that the squad was the ‘right mould’ for the system.

Edinburgh, who at the back end of the previous season had played an equally unpopular diamond system, wasn’t for changing.

He went with three at the back again for the trip to Charlton, only to return with his tail between his legs as a certain Ricky Holmes showed the Cobblers fans just what they have lost as he inspired the south Londoners to a 4-1 win.

Social media was now awash with criticism of Edinburgh and his formation and tactics, and with the Peterborough derby on the horizon, the manager admitted he might be open to changing the system for the visit of the Posh.

But he also admitted he can be ‘stubborn’ as a manager - and he was stubborn as Grant McCann’s men came to town.

He again stuck with three at the back, and antagonised the fans even more by again pairing Marc Richards and Alex Revell in attack, a partnership that has consistently failed to fire.

He perhaps had an excuse at Charlton the week before as Long had injured himself in the warm-up at the Valley, but there was no excuse for the Posh encounter.

It meant the fans were far from onside before a ball had even been kicked, and once Peterborough went ahead, the fans turned, and quickly.

It was a horrible afternoon, similar to ones I have experienced in the final days of the likes of Gary Johnson and Aidy Boothroyd, and although I’m not sure there is ever a case for supporters calling for their own manager to be sacked while a match is being played, that is what happened.

They were voicing their displeasure at a woeful start to the campaign, with zero points and just two goals scored, and with Kelvin Thomas taking plenty of stick in the directors’ box, I would imagine Edinburgh’s fate was sealed , even though his misery was prolonged for four more days.

From the outside, a manager getting sacked just four games into the league campaign looks ridiculous, and it does seem unfair to not allow a manager the time to get a team functioning as a unit after so much change and recruitment.

And after the club have backed their man with so many new signings.

But anybody who has watched the Cobblers this season might feel a little differently about it.

As I said earlier, this was about more than results, it was about the vibe and the negative mood around Sixfields, something which has been prevalent since the back end of last season.


Sounds familiar !

Edited by Willo (04 Sep 2017 7.06pm)

No quotation marks, Willo. Was that verbatim? Very good comparison.
The issue I'm worried about is the stubborness/arrogance issue. Like van Gaal.
Nobody knows what's been going on behind the scenes, But FdB offered evolution and hasn't delivered. FdB asked for a number of signings and SP hasn't delivered.
Can't see the relationship lasting.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 04 Sep 17 9.22pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We don't want FDB to fail, but when your booed off in your first 2 home games it doesn't look great. There's a lot of questions from the window. Was Sakho a FDB signing. Is FDB happy that we only have 2 gks, 1 fit striker and 7 centre backs. They should of given him the tools to succeed, they haven't too many players uncomfortable in this style. Maybe he believed the players he had at his disposal was better than he thought. Don't think he will get the time imo.

bit of a self fulfilling prophecy that statement mate??!!

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

pssguy Flag 04 Sep 17 9.31pm

Originally posted by Willo


Sounds familiar !

Edited by Willo (04 Sep 2017 7.06pm)

Not really. Northampton had scored twice

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 04 Sep 17 9.37pm

Originally posted by Dan89

95% sure that hodgson will get the job (if de Boer sacked) . Look at the criteria- parish will look for prem experience, someone out of work meaning no compo. Someone with a point to prove (after England mess, Roy wants 1 last job to lay England to bed). Also done well at similar sized clubs in Fulham and wba.

I frigging love Parish, but if he gives up on his own "evolution plan" after only a handful of games because he realises he chose the wrong man, or the wrong time, he should consider his position imo. People replying to my previous post, a year of dross under Pardew, constant poor home form etc-if Parish primarily cared about changing these results over adopting a new style he'd have hired a different type of manager. As it goes he didn't, so he needs to stick it out until frank has had a fair crack at it, it's called being accountable for your own actions. As Brauny said, the hate/negativity/reverie in failure is rather sad.

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

chateauferret Flag 04 Sep 17 9.44pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Not really. Northampton had scored twice

So have we. Well, McArthur has, at least.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Dan89 Flag Se25 04 Sep 17 10.08pm

Originally posted by rawpalace05

I frigging love Parish, but if he gives up on his own "evolution plan" after only a handful of games because he realises he chose the wrong man, or the wrong time, he should consider his position imo. People replying to my previous post, a year of dross under Pardew, constant poor home form etc-if Parish primarily cared about changing these results over adopting a new style he'd have hired a different type of manager. As it goes he didn't, so he needs to stick it out until frank has had a fair crack at it, it's called being accountable for your own actions. As Brauny said, the hate/negativity/reverie in failure is rather sad.

I don't think fans want him to fail but would a win against Burnley paper over the cracks. Rumours of 1 game to save job, parish dislikes him, undermined in transfer market. Certainly not looking good for FDB. I love us to play a new style, improve results especially at home but I personally don't think we have the players to play that way. That's why given the lack of funds, the FDB appointment looks a strange one.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

kev64 Flag Cambs 04 Sep 17 10.26pm

4/7 on to be the first prem manager sacked, thats a healthy return come 2:45 Saturday.

Dead man walking.

Edited by kev64 (04 Sep 2017 10.27pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Sep 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by pssguy


Not really. Northampton had scored twice

Making a comparison with "Three at the back" and it not working for Northampton.

Yes they scored twice but both game were 4-1 defeats !

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Sep 17 9.24am

Originally posted by Willo

Sounds familiar !


Worryingly so.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Sep 17 9.53am

Originally posted by kev64

4/7 on to be the first prem manager sacked, thats a healthy return come 2:45 Saturday.

Dead man walking.

Edited by kev64 (04 Sep 2017 10.27pm)

Why?
We aren't playing until 1.30pm Sunday.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 05 Sep 17 11.11am

[Link]


Ultimatum for under fire boss

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

YT Flag Oxford 05 Sep 17 11.16am

Originally posted by Dan89

[Link]


Ultimatum for under fire boss

It must be great being a journalist. Read a load of papers and then base your own article on them; "according to reports".

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 17 11.17am

Originally posted by Dan89

[Link]


Ultimatum for under fire boss

Even if it's win or out he could be excused for something like total dominance, hitting the woodwork 3 times, Burnley keeper getting MOTM and drawing. Or us winning and the cheating Snodgrass type diving and scoring a penalty.

The ultimatum might be just to aim for maximum and cut the experimental fvckling about with our future without wing backs or money to do it etc etc etc.

 


COYP

bodge Flag 05 Sep 17 11.41am

Why employ a manager to change and sack him after four games when he has not even been able to put out our best eleven Wilf Cabaye McArthur Tomkins RLC all missing games. Burnley away is not a game we should win Spurs and Chelsea could not beat them. Our problem is the same as its been for a long time we gift goals with bad defending and goal keeping. Swansea were poor we gave them two goals, Liverpool should have scored more but we end up gifting them the win.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 17 11.56am

Originally posted by bodge

Why employ a manager to change and sack him after four games when he has not even been able to put out our best eleven Wilf Cabaye McArthur Tomkins RLC all missing games. Burnley away is not a game we should win Spurs and Chelsea could not beat them. Our problem is the same as its been for a long time we gift goals with bad defending and goal keeping. Swansea were poor we gave them two goals, Liverpool should have scored more but we end up gifting them the win.

Sometimes with 3 men behind the ball, or Kelly in a situation where he is CB and LB. ideally he runs the ball away from defender without hardly touching it and back to keeper. But this Martin Kelly. If he had a lb it would've been passed to him.

The Huddersfield win was more to do with 3 at the back than you may want to admit. The other 2 not as much but they definitely contributed to it.

These players being unavailable is a valid point, but it's reminiscent of Pardew. Instead of making it easier for himself he makes it more difficult. Instead of seeing through the period he takes chances or plays players out of position or comfort of formation.

I do get what you're saying but to have Cabaye and Jimmy out v Huddersfield but play punch there, and Luka (after all pre season at CB where a lot of issues originate), with cheek at RF, Townsend on the bench after playing RWB all season and ward at RWB having hardly played there doesn't fill many with confidence.

However I don't want him out tonight and wait to see what he does.

 


COYP

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 05 Sep 17 12.50pm

Well if it is true that there is dressing room unrest and that De Boer job hinges on a win at Burnley then it is time to put £££ on a Palace defeat at Turf Moor. They obviously won't try and help the fella.

Edited by Kermit8 (05 Sep 2017 12.50pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 05 Sep 17 1.00pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Well if it is true that there is dressing room unrest and that De Boer job hinges on a win at Burnley then it is time to put £££ on a Palace defeat at Turf Moor. They obviously won't try and help the fella.

Edited by Kermit8 (05 Sep 2017 12.50pm)

If that was even remotely true then it would be fecking disgusting. Highly paid professionals not even trying, I'd sack the lot them and play the youngsters, at least they would be playing for their careers.

Hopefully professional pride will win out and, win or lose, we give Burnley a hard game.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Last chance Saloon for Frank