You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 13 Mar 18 8.07am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

you can't say Sorloth is head and shoulders above Benteke. that's daft.

As far as hitting the target in live play he is. Beat the Chelsea goalie twice on Saturday only being thwarted by the post and a w***er of a ref. He’s produced saves from headers in his other appearneces instead of putting them wide or over. We need a goal scoring hero at the moment and he’s showing much stronger signs of being that than Benteke is presently. Would you not agree with that?

Edited by Brentmiester_General (13 Mar 2018 8.17am)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

JtCpfc Flag 13 Mar 18 9.19am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

As far as hitting the target in live play he is. Beat the Chelsea goalie twice on Saturday only being thwarted by the post and a w***er of a ref. He’s produced saves from headers in his other appearneces instead of putting them wide or over. We need a goal scoring hero at the moment and he’s showing much stronger signs of being that than Benteke is presently. Would you not agree with that?

Edited by Brentmiester_General (13 Mar 2018 8.17am)

No I don't agree...

Yes the goal should have stood however the miss prior to this where he hit the post was inexcusable. He had the whole goal to aim at and he panicked and smashed it as hard as he could. No composure what so ever, the whole far post was open to aim for...

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 13 Mar 18 9.20am

Sorloth
Wickham
Benteke

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 13 Mar 18 9.41am

Originally posted by JtCpfc

No I don't agree...

Yes the goal should have stood however the miss prior to this where he hit the post was inexcusable. He had the whole goal to aim at and he panicked and smashed it as hard as he could. No composure what so ever, the whole far post was open to aim for...

From what I have seen of him live and in videos he does lack composure and finesse in his finishing. Hes a put your laces through it type.

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 13 Mar 18 9.53pm

Originally posted by merganser

Something that intrigues me is that Sorloth is completely expressionless. Most players give a clue to their emotions, eg when they miss a sitter. But our new man seems totally unengaged. Must be something to do with the Nordic temperament, but a bit of passion wouldn't come amiss. Assuming the happy day comes (the sooner the better), I wonder if/how he'll celebrate scoring a goal.

good post, I agree , its prob a scandanavian thing or perhaps hes a bit serious. Be good to see him score.

COYP

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 13 Mar 18 10.30pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

No I don't agree...

Yes the goal should have stood however the miss prior to this where he hit the post was inexcusable. He had the whole goal to aim at and he panicked and smashed it as hard as he could. No composure what so ever, the whole far post was open to aim for...

I’m having a go at this in memeory but for what I can remember his options were narrowed down to the near post. I’m happy to be corrected and would like to see it again to clarify.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 13 Mar 18 11.09pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

From what I have seen of him live and in videos he does lack composure and finesse in his finishing. Hes a put your laces through it type.

So is Connor Wickham. IMO We haven't done enough of this this season.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Mar 18 12.03am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Unfortunately at the moment neither player looks to have a goal in them and Palace will have to get goals to win the requisite matches to stay up.
It will help significantly to have Zaha available.
I’d probably go for Benteke at the moment as he has got a track record of goals in the premier league but he has been shocking this season.
His hold up play and effort looked poor in the first half but I don’t think playing him and Sørloth together helped as Chelsea were so dominant that they both had minimal involvement and this led to more pressure on the defence in the first half.
It looked like 11 v 9.


Were you not at the Chelsea game??
Sorloth netted once to be disallowed then hit the post.
Benteke was the fellah in the first half kept jumping up and down off the ball like a jack in the box.

 

bozsufc Flag SHEFFIELD 14 Mar 18 12.29am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Were you not at the Chelsea game??
Sorloth netted once to be disallowed then hit the post.
Benteke was the fellah in the first half kept jumping up and down off the ball like a jack in the box.

Benteke is finished drop him on the bench. Its got to be Wilf and Sorloth upfront for all of the remaining matches.
Benteke has done nothing form wise, and he will do nothing to contribute any goals to move us safely away from the religation zone.
The team are giving 100% in every match. and they creating chances for him to score but he's not done it from the start of the season till the very end. sell the man on so he can go and mug some other team off.All he does is hold his hand out and I feel sorry for the chairman having to fork out £120.000 a week for doing what exactly just 2 goals it stinks to high heaven.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Mar 18 6.55am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

As far as hitting the target in live play he is. Beat the Chelsea goalie twice on Saturday only being thwarted by the post and a w***er of a ref. He’s produced saves from headers in his other appearneces instead of putting them wide or over. We need a goal scoring hero at the moment and he’s showing much stronger signs of being that than Benteke is presently. Would you not agree with that?

Edited by Brentmiester_General (13 Mar 2018 8.17am)


fair points and those things gave me a lot of hope on Saturday.

however, it's just too early for me to say whether Sorloth will score regularly at this level or not. He hasn't in 4 full games (3 admittedly against top class opposition where we get relatively few chances), but he's shown signs he might be able to.

if he does then yeah he's The Man.

thing is that to me he looks a bit ponderous in his general play. he also seems slightly weak for his size. that might be a lack of familiarity with his team mates and coming in when he hadn't played for a while.

I find it a bit too early to judge. there's promise & hope there, but like most youngish players, some major rough edges.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Username Flag Horsham 14 Mar 18 7.58am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

As far as hitting the target in live play he is. Beat the Chelsea goalie twice on Saturday only being thwarted by the post and a w***er of a ref. He’s produced saves from headers in his other appearneces instead of putting them wide or over. We need a goal scoring hero at the moment and he’s showing much stronger signs of being that than Benteke is presently. Would you not agree with that?

Edited by Brentmiester_General (13 Mar 2018 8.17am)

Overlooking Benteke being denied by a world class save from De Gea? Or having efforts cleared off the line against Newcastle?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Uphill Flag Bedford 14 Mar 18 9.08am

Sorloth's first three games have been against better quality teams than us and so it is not fair to criticise him as his is a huge step up from the Danish League.

Playing him and Benteke as two centre forwards is never going to succeed and must be scrapped.

Sorloth deserves persevering with as he does try to lay the ball off whereas Benteke's only useful contribution has been in defence.

We are weak in midfield and so must rely on Zaha and Townsend to start providing the ammunition until RLC and Cabaye are back. Until they are fit I would give Lee a go as a skilful feed for the forwards. His disastrous game at Burnley was unfortunate but he should be given the chance to make amends.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 14 Mar 18 10.33am

Originally posted by Username

Overlooking Benteke being denied by a world class save from De Gea? Or having efforts cleared off the line against Newcastle?

Still not beating “the man”. Bit more power from him and perhaps he would have. Sørloth did twice on the weekend. Was a whisker away from having the ball in the back of the net twice.
And to whoever made the comment about him being a put his laces through the ball type player mode , at his size that isn’t a bad thing. It didn’t do Shearer any harm when it came to finding the net.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (14 Mar 2018 10.34am)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 14 Mar 18 5.55pm

what about the defender who back to cover the side, that cant be a open goal

Originally posted by JtCpfc

No I don't agree...

Yes the goal should have stood however the miss prior to this where he hit the post was inexcusable. He had the whole goal to aim at and he panicked and smashed it as hard as he could. No composure what so ever, the whole far post was open to aim for...

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 14 Mar 18 5.58pm

Yes!!!

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

I’m having a go at this in memeory but for what I can remember his options were narrowed down to the near post. I’m happy to be corrected and would like to see it again to clarify.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 14 Mar 18 5.59pm

YES!!

Originally posted by bozsufc

Benteke is finished drop him on the bench. Its got to be Wilf and Sorloth upfront for all of the remaining matches.
Benteke has done nothing form wise, and he will do nothing to contribute any goals to move us safely away from the religation zone.
The team are giving 100% in every match. and they creating chances for him to score but he's not done it from the start of the season till the very end. sell the man on so he can go and mug some other team off.All he does is hold his hand out and I feel sorry for the chairman having to fork out £120.000 a week for doing what exactly just 2 goals it stinks to high heaven.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 14 Mar 18 6.07pm

Lee is too lightweight, nice guy bit not at this level, he came on last two home games at late substitute (of why against Man Utd when we needed a defender!!) we lost both matches to late goals!!!

Originally posted by Uphill

Sorloth's first three games have been against better quality teams than us and so it is not fair to criticise him as his is a huge step up from the Danish League.

Playing him and Benteke as two centre forwards is never going to succeed and must be scrapped.

Sorloth deserves persevering with as he does try to lay the ball off whereas Benteke's only useful contribution has been in defence.

We are weak in midfield and so must rely on Zaha and Townsend to start providing the ammunition until RLC and Cabaye are back. Until they are fit I would give Lee a go as a skilful feed for the forwards. His disastrous game at Burnley was unfortunate but he should be given the chance to make amends.

 

The_Dumps Flag Croydon 14 Mar 18 10.44pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

Completely agree. I do not understand why people are raving about him. He was woeful at Chelsea. How he missed from 8 yards out where he hit the post i'll never know, not to mention the fact he took the ball of zaha for it.

Benteke all day long for me, hes had a hand in 7 of our 10 goals in 2018, 6 assists and a goal so clearly he is creating chances.

Sorloth looks slow and clueless, I hope for the good of the club that he comes good.

Idiot.

 

The_Dumps Flag Croydon 14 Mar 18 10.57pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

No I don't agree...

Yes the goal should have stood however the miss prior to this where he hit the post was inexcusable. He had the whole goal to aim at and he panicked and smashed it as hard as he could. No composure what so ever, the whole far post was open to aim for...

Hmm good point. If that single miss was inexcusable how many chances has Benteke missed this season, dozens... wide, over and/or straioght at the keeper. And he cost 3 x times as much. Sorloth scored a legitiimate goal and set up our second goal at Paalce, why isn't anyone on here acknowledging that? Unlike Benetke that let the ball run out of play the week before, he took the ball up the touchline, took on 1 or 2 Chelski players to square to Zaha, who squared to PVA.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 15 Mar 18 7.43am

Originally posted by The_Dumps

Hmm good point. If that single miss was inexcusable how many chances has Benteke missed this season, dozens... wide, over and/or straioght at the keeper. And he cost 3 x times as much. Sorloth scored a legitiimate goal and set up our second goal at Paalce, why isn't anyone on here acknowledging that? Unlike Benetke that let the ball run out of play the week before, he took the ball up the touchline, took on 1 or 2 Chelski players to square to Zaha, who squared to PVA.

I still see a lot in Benteke, but I am looking forward to seeing how Sørloth does against Huddersfield. I don’t think it is fair to judge him on his performances against Spurs, Chelsea and Manchester United.

How much someone cost is irrelevant to this discussion in my view.

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?