This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Ref vs Liverpool
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Bullhorn76 Darlington 26 Mar 18 5.16pm |
|
|
Neil swarbrick from Preston is the ref for this saturdays game v Liverpool he was in charge for 0-5 defeat away to Man City ,1-1 draw away to West Ham Utd and the 2-3 home defeat to Manchester Utd
|
Eagle El Medway 26 Mar 18 7.32pm |
|
|
I just love Neil Swarbrick, what a great referee :I
Once a Glazier, now an Eagle, Palace Forever.
|
chateauferret 31 Mar 18 3.02pm |
|
|
Called the two penalty decisions correctly - ours he could hardly have got wrong - but failing to send Mane off completely ridiculous. Another outcome heavily influenced by an incompetent referee.
============ The Ferret ============
|
buzzby West Sussex 31 Mar 18 3.03pm |
|
|
Marne should have been sent off
rub a dub dub who's buying the next round in the Pub?
|
merganser 31 Mar 18 3.07pm |
|
|
Apart from that error, he had a very good match. Players, of course, make far more errors over the course of 90 minutes.
|
Bangell Oxford 31 Mar 18 3.07pm |
|
|
Ridiculous that referees never have to come out and explain themselves. How can you not give a yellow for a deliberate handball?
|
manwitheagletattoo Somewhere in England 31 Mar 18 3.48pm |
|
Originally posted by Bangell
Ridiculous that referees never have to come out and explain themselves. How can you not give a yellow for a deliberate handball?
Totally agree with this. Managers and Players have to do a after match interview so why not referees.
I personally I would like to see a league table for refs for each league and like with league tables the top and bottom two are either promoted or demoted.
South London & Proud Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it. Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give It’s never enough
|
SpyroCrystal 31 Mar 18 3.49pm |
|
|
We were Unlucky again but we move to the next game.
Big up the Palace!!!!
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 31 Mar 18 4.11pm |
|
|
I thought the ref had a good game, apart from the Mane incident. He most probably realised he made a mistake when Klopp immediately subbed Mane.
Saying that, the lino did help him at all. If Mane hadn’t handled the ball Cabeye was clean through ....
|
mcduh 31 Mar 18 4.20pm |
|
|
If Mane had been left on, would Swarbrick have given him a yellow and sent him off for blowing a snot rocket out of his nose? Just to make up for having blown the handball call?
If Mane had not needed to come off, would Lallana have remained on the bench and not done whatever damage he did to himself?
If you ever see Swarbrick at Tesco, will you break an egg on his head?
He generally got it right today, and Benteke .... what more is there to say.... but letting Mane stay on in that context at that point of the game... that's for me the biggest part of how we lost the point.
Infuriating.
|
the silurian The garden of England.(not really) 31 Mar 18 4.31pm |
|
|
Willo's very quiet today!
|
Bullhorn76 Darlington 31 Mar 18 4.34pm |
|
|
Probably because he can’t contradict anyone on here as we are all spot on the ref bottled it therefore Willo has nothing further to add
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 31 Mar 18 4.37pm |
|
|
It was a bizarre decision not to send Mane off for hand ball, personally I would have sent him off for the dive in the first half.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
The Dolphin 31 Mar 18 5.26pm |
|
|
Add to that - he had a word with Henderson which was presumably - "you had best take him off because the next thing he does wrong I will send him off"! Refs should not do that - it is not for them to advise a team - absolutely against the rules!
|
Spiderman Horsham 31 Mar 18 5.44pm |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Add to that - he had a word with Henderson which was presumably - "you had best take him off because the next thing he does wrong I will send him off"! Refs should not do that - it is not for them to advise a team - absolutely against the rules!
Henderson is claiming that the ref said to both captains "You both know why it is not a yellow!!" WTF does that mean? Even Klopp has said he expected a red (although he disagreed with the first yellow) People saying Mane was " clipped" for the first, right near me I didn't think so but the way he yelped and rolled around was disgraceful, even Salah just walked away. Don't worry Willo will explain why deliberate handball is not a Yellow card, Apparently Paddy Power tweeted that ref had in fact reached in his pocket for a card then obviously bottled it.
|
MrCParrot Taunton 31 Mar 18 5.51pm |
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Henderson is claiming that the ref said to both captains "You both know why it is not a yellow!!" WTF does that mean? Even Klopp has said he expected a red (although he disagreed with the first yellow) People saying Mane was " clipped" for the first, right near me I didn't think so but the way he yelped and rolled around was disgraceful, even Salah just walked away. Don't worry Willo will explain why deliberate handball is not a Yellow card, Apparently Paddy Power tweeted that ref had in fact reached in his pocket for a card then obviously bottled it.
Yeah I saw that tweet too. Is there a VAR for this sort of failure to impose the rules of the game?
Parrot
Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"
|
chateauferret 31 Mar 18 5.55pm |
|
|
Mane lost out in the tackle near the corner of his own box and fell on his arse. He thought he should be getting a free kick, which was not the case. So he palmed at the ball, then grabbed it, pre-empting the decision and preventing us from getting the ball back into the box. Handball, and also ungentlemanly conduct, oh and probably simulation as well. Three different kinds of yellow card in one.
============ The Ferret ============
|
chateauferret 31 Mar 18 5.57pm |
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Henderson is claiming that the ref said to both captains "You both know why it is not a yellow!!" WTF does that mean? Even Klopp has said he expected a red (although he disagreed with the first yellow) People saying Mane was " clipped" for the first, right near me I didn't think so but the way he yelped and rolled around was disgraceful, even Salah just walked away. Don't worry Willo will explain why deliberate handball is not a Yellow card, Apparently Paddy Power tweeted that ref had in fact reached in his pocket for a card then obviously bottled it.
That is to say, he would have given a yellow, but then realised who it was and that he would then have to send him off, so changed his mind.
Perhaps our resident refereeing expert can tell us why an offence which is a yellow card for a first offence suddenly becomes uncautionable if the player already has a yellow card.
============ The Ferret ============
|
Pigglelet Deepest Darkest Sussex 31 Mar 18 6.26pm |
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
That is to say, he would have given a yellow, but then realised who it was and that he would then have to send him off, so changed his mind.
Perhaps our resident refereeing expert can tell us why an offence which is a yellow card for a first offence suddenly becomes uncautionable if the player already has a yellow card.
Don't you know? It's when it happens to a member of a top six side playing against one of us lesser mortals.
Edited by Pigglelet (31 Mar 2018 6.26pm)
"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain.
|
grumpymort US/Thailand/UK 31 Mar 18 6.38pm |
|
|
First half he did very well (he did get mane going down in box wrong it was a penalty but i think delayed reaction is why he booked him instead)
Second half was different story he switched so many he got wrong liverpool players took out wilf few times which should of been yellows and he didn't even get free kick and well that hand ball was shocking.
but you could say palace was lucky here because we had maybe 3 players showing the card sign to the ref you cant do that so they could all of been booked.
the guy didn't want to break his record of not sending some one off
(VPN) - [Link] (Alt VPN) - [Link]
|