This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
anyone know if he's gonna be fit for Saturday's game? wonder what alternative in the middle Roy would go for if he's out?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Aray
anyone know if he's gonna be fit for Saturday's game? wonder what alternative in the middle Roy would go for if he's out? Sadly it will be Schlupp instead of the correct person Riedewald, who is out in the cold despite being formerly a highly touted prospect of one of the world's elite academies Edited by Maine Eagle (22 Dec 2018 2.21pm)
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Sadly it will be Schlupp instead of the correct person Riedewald, who is out in the cold despite being formerly a highly touted prospect of one of the world's elite academies. Meyer was talked about in such terms but he came to us on a 'Free' and Riedewald cost less than £8 Mill which is 'Peanuts' in PL terms.If these players were that good they wouldn't have come to us and would have been acquired by clubs much higher up the Totem Pole.Furthermore a sum shy on £8 Mill for both does not suggest that they are as talented as has been suggested, besides I don't recall a great clamber for their services from other clubs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Meyer was talked about in such terms but he came to us on a 'Free' and Riedewald cost less than £8 Mill which is 'Peanuts' in PL terms.If these players were that good they wouldn't have come to us and would have been acquired by clubs much higher up the Totem Pole.Furthermore a sum shy on £8 Mill for both does not suggest that they are as talented as has been suggested, besides I don't recall a great clamber for their services from other clubs. In Riedewald's case he came because of De Boer. Max Meyer had no such personal attachment to the manager of our club. Apples to Oranges, Statto
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Manchestr City away is bad enough! Don't make it worse with Schlupp in the team...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Meyer was talked about in such terms but he came to us on a 'Free' and Riedewald cost less than £8 Mill which is 'Peanuts' in PL terms.If these players were that good they wouldn't have come to us and would have been acquired by clubs much higher up the Totem Pole.Furthermore a sum shy on £8 Mill for both does not suggest that they are as talented as has been suggested, besides I don't recall a great clamber for their services from other clubs. By that logic Richardson would never have gone to Watford, and Shaqiri would never have gone to Stoke. But, oh wait...
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
?????? What is that suppose to mean? Meyer came on a free so how is he included in the 8m? £8 Mill for both
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
?????? What is that suppose to mean? Meyer came on a free so how is he included in the 8m? £8 Mill for both I know, I thought that. Chuck Murray in as well who was free and Johnson who was chucked in as part of the Morrison deal and 8 mil for the 4 is great business.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
By that logic Richardson would never have gone to Watford, and Shaqiri would never have gone to Stoke. But, oh wait... I presume you mean Richarlison and not Richardson.Richarlison came from Brazilian club Fluminense and not many had even heard of him in this country.Shaqiri only played 15 games for Inter Milan,possibly quite a few of these from the bench, before his £12 Mill transfer to Stoke and there were question marks about his consistency and his defensive prowess.Both didn't arrive with big fanfares.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
In Riedewald's case he came because of De Boer. Max Meyer had no such personal attachment to the manager of our club. Apples to Oranges, Statto With the greatest of respect, I never made a comparison between the reasons the players signed for the club. In any event this line of debate veers away from the subject matter of this thread which of course is Kouyate whom Allardyce signed for W.Ham from Anderlect for £7 Mill and who on occasions filled-in at centre-half for the 'Hammers' when they had injuries.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I presume you mean Richarlison and not Richardson.Richarlison came from Brazilian club Fluminense and not many had even heard of him in this country.Shaqiri only played 15 games for Inter Milan,possibly quite a few of these from the bench, before his £12 Mill transfer to Stoke and there were question marks about his consistency and his defensive prowess.Both didn't arrive with big fanfares. Shaqiri was a 3-time title winner in Switzerland as well as a 2-times Bundesliga winner and Champions Leauge winner with Bayern before he even signed for Inter ...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With the greatest of respect, I never made a comparison between the reasons the players signed for the club. In any event this line of debate veers away from the subject matter of this thread which of course is Kouyate whom Allardyce signed for W.Ham from Anderlect for £7 Mill and who on occasions filled-in at centre-half for the 'Hammers' when they had injuries.
Well you did when you opined on why they hadn't signed for other clubs. That is the same thing essentially.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Well you did when you opined on why they hadn't signed for other clubs. That is the same thing essentially. I think we will respectfully have to agree to disagree on this matter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tez
Shaqiri was a 3-time title winner in Switzerland as well as a 2-times Bundesliga winner and Champions Leauge winner with Bayern before he even signed for Inter ... I don't believe being a title winner in Switzerland is right up towards the top of the 'Totem Pole'.In terms of Bayern Munich I really don't know how much a part he played in their successes but one has to question if he played a major role why they sold him on to Inter Milan.Didn't appear to have made a major impact at Inter Milan and was bought by Stoke. He arrived at Stoke as a talented player but one not noted for his consistency or defensive duties hence he never arrived with any great fanfare, besides he did join Stoke who had finished in 9th place in the PL in the previous 2 seasons so were somewhat established and not a club that had been flirting with relegation season on season. Ive asserted enough on Shaqiri and appreciate that the thread concerns Kouyate so perhaps the debate should really return to the subject matter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I don't believe being a title winner in Switzerland is right up towards the top of the 'Totem Pole'.In terms of Bayern Munich I really don't know how much a part he played in their successes but one has to question if he played a major role why they sold him on to Inter Milan.Didn't appear to have made a major impact at Inter Milan and was bought by Stoke. He arrived at Stoke as a talented player but one not noted for his consistency or defensive duties hence he never arrived with any great fanfare, besides he did join Stoke who had finished in 9th place in the PL in the previous 2 seasons so were somewhat established and not a club that had been flirting with relegation season on season. Ive asserted enough on Shaqiri and appreciate that the thread concerns Kouyate so perhaps the debate should really return to the subject matter. Squirm all you want, but it was you who introduced Meyer to the thread and put forward the idea that the value of the fee was directly indicative of a player's quality. Here is what you said: "Meyer was talked about in such terms but he came to us on a 'Free' and Riedewald cost less than £8 Mill which is 'Peanuts' in PL terms.If these players were that good they wouldn't have come to us and would have been acquired by clubs much higher up the Totem Pole.Furthermore a sum shy on £8 Mill for both does not suggest that they are as talented as has been suggested, besides I don't recall a great clamber for their services from other clubs." I pointed out good players (albeit one name had a typo) who went to other clubs of similar stature to us, and did so for low fees. Hence you are, again, talking bulls***.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
You could even add our own Wilf to the mix. Who wanted him when he had that poor loan spell at Cardiff? How much did he cost us from United? Sure it couldn't be much more than the Reidewald fee. Originally posted by NickinOX
Squirm all you want, but it was you who introduced Meyer to the thread and put forward the idea that the value of the fee was directly indicative of a player's quality. Here is what you said: "Meyer was talked about in such terms but he came to us on a 'Free' and Riedewald cost less than £8 Mill which is 'Peanuts' in PL terms.If these players were that good they wouldn't have come to us and would have been acquired by clubs much higher up the Totem Pole.Furthermore a sum shy on £8 Mill for both does not suggest that they are as talented as has been suggested, besides I don't recall a great clamber for their services from other clubs." I pointed out good players (albeit one name had a typo) who went to other clubs of similar stature to us, and did so for low fees. Hence you are, again, talking bulls***.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
Squirm all you want, but it was you who introduced Meyer to the thread and put forward the idea that the value of the fee was directly indicative of a player's quality. Here is what you said: "Meyer was talked about in such terms but he came to us on a 'Free' and Riedewald cost less than £8 Mill which is 'Peanuts' in PL terms.If these players were that good they wouldn't have come to us and would have been acquired by clubs much higher up the Totem Pole.Furthermore a sum shy on £8 Mill for both does not suggest that they are as talented as has been suggested, besides I don't recall a great clamber for their services from other clubs." I pointed out good players (albeit one name had a typo) who went to other clubs of similar stature to us, and did so for low fees. Hence you are, again, talking bulls***. I am hardly squirming - I have carried out a robust defence of my comments and stand 'Four square' behind them.I don't consider them a blizzard of obfuscation. My comments were in response to the narrative that Meyer was one of the top prospects in German football and the next generation of top players from that country and that Riedewald was another hot prospect from one of the top academies in football.Richarlison was hardly heard of in this country so never came with any fanfare and whilst Shaqiri was much better known,played for Bayern Munich and was considered a talent he had issues with his consistency and defensive prowess.Besides, Shaqiri joined Stoke who had finished 9th in the PL in the previous two seasons and had at that time established themselves in the top-flight and hadn't been flirting with relegation season-on-season. I really cannot be more clear about my line of debate on this issue so let's get back to the subject matter - any further comments I make on this thread will relate to Kouyate.We will have to agree to disagree. Edited by Willo (21 Dec 2018 5.13pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
The thought of Schlupp in midfield against Man Citys midfield is just ridiculous.. I know some on here defend him but I still standby the opinion that he really is a truly awful player... But Roy seems to like him. Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (21 Dec 2018 1.16am) I think I trust Roy’s opinion over yours,no offence.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.