You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we in financial trouble
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we in financial trouble


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Only 10 a year!! Flag 04 Feb 19 12.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

I see the point you are making.

Rightly or wrongly I don't get the impression that Parish is a reluctant day-to-day controller who has an over-riding desire to relinquish his reponsibilities ! Quite the oppposite, with Parish delighted to be in the limelight and increasing his profile ! But of course I might be totally wrong.


I think the other three were reluctant but SP definitely sees it as being a chance for celebrity and enjoys being involved. It would take a very large shoehorn to remove him.

I think he is doing a good job and when we look back in ten years time we will view this period as 'the good old days' and wonder what anyone had to complain about.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 04 Feb 19 12.13pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

I am intrigued. That begs the question why would he give wolves and bournemouth, but not the other four, while at the same time excluding palace?

Makes no sense...

He mentioned it in passing on the day Bournemouth signed Solanki. He wasn't withholding info, just couldn't remember off the top of his head. It's not really of interest to him. His job gives him access to this type of info.

I specifically asked him about Palace and he said that we're not one of them.

 

est1905 Flag 04 Feb 19 5.38pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

A guy I know, who claims to have some inside info on the finances recently told me that there are currently six Premier League clubs who are on the brink of collapse if they are relegated in the next 5 seasons. Two are Wolves and Bournemouth, he didn’t give me the others. Palace are not one.

It could be BS, just passing on what I was told from a reliable source.

I cannot see how this know it all (sorry, guy you know) could possibly know that without having full insider knowledge of all of these 5 clubs. If he did I'd bet the remaining 15 Prem clubs would pay him handsomely for his knowledge on the opposition. When competing for a transfer target for example its quite handy knowing your rival is 'on the bring of collapse'!
Rubbish

 

est1905 Flag 04 Feb 19 5.39pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

I am intrigued. That begs the question why would he give wolves and bournemouth, but not the other four, while at the same time excluding palace?

Makes no sense...

Err no, you're gullible

 

est1905 Flag 04 Feb 19 5.42pm

Originally posted by Karlosfandango

How Bournemouth continue to spend as they do is beyond me. Even with TV money, with their gates it just can't be sustainable.

They are backed by a reclusive Russian billionaire who is worth more than Abramovic. Which is why the poster who claims they are 'on the brink of collapse' (correction-his mate told him they were, is talking rubbish.
Bournemouth are a small club so will never be able to attract the worlds best players. But...They have the finances to compete with anyone.

 

est1905 Flag 04 Feb 19 5.48pm

Originally posted by chris123

There's points deduction too now isn't there?

There is but the breach in FFP would have to be massive to justify such a punishment and should it be meted out I'd guess said club would fight it all the way (and be supported by all the other overspending clubs that will become twitchy they might be in line the the same punishment.
In short, it would be a very difficult penalty to enforce

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Feb 19 6.13pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

A guy I know, who claims to have some inside info on the finances recently told me that there are currently six Premier League clubs who are on the brink of collapse if they are relegated in the next 5 seasons. Two are Wolves and Bournemouth, he didn’t give me the others. Palace are not one.

It could be BS, just passing on what I was told from a reliable source.

We're permanently "on the brink of collapse" if the Brighton/Scouse accounting wizard is to be believed, and that's without the complication of relegation. And for his fans, he keeps questioning why he can't see £100m in cash, ringfenced in our accounts; now that is truly moronic

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 04 Feb 19 6.24pm

Originally posted by est1905

I cannot see how this know it all (sorry, guy you know) could possibly know that without having full insider knowledge of all of these 5 clubs. If he did I'd bet the remaining 15 Prem clubs would pay him handsomely for his knowledge on the opposition. When competing for a transfer target for example its quite handy knowing your rival is 'on the bring of collapse'!
Rubbish

As I said in my post, it could be BS but I’ve no reason to distrust the info. He’s an MD in a financial services company and works with Premier League clubs. It was something he mentioned in passing after hearing about the Solanki deal. It’s also probably info he shouldn’t be sharing, but did.

Anyway, I trust it to be accurate, which is that Palace are not in financial trouble whereas quite a few prem clubs are (if they go down).

Just something I heard and thought I’d share as there was a thread on it. Take or leave it. I’ve nothing else to add to the thread really.

 

mileend Flag East London 04 Feb 19 6.43pm

there is no danger of admin or FFP judging by the last set of accounts - profit made - little debt - £15m cash in the bank - previous director loans of £6m repaid - though directors made a further capital injection of £21m that is not huge for the Premier League

these accounts now lag well behind as the £21m represent Sam's window spending on Milo, Schlupp and van Aanholt

the very high wages to turnover reported (78%) are a big problem that is presumably going to be even worse in the next set of accounts due out next month as they will have Sakho's wages added amongst others (not Wilf's latest deal though - you'll need to wait until 2020 to see the impact of those on the figures)

spending so little in the last three windows shows that FFP issues are highly unlikely as the owners are not continually investing new capital (unlike the crazy stuff happening at Bournemouth). Admin is not on the cards because there is such little debt and cash flow is good. Assuming no relegation of course - though with parachute payments and some very saleable players that wouldn't be immediately life threatening.

All the super secret Delaware stuff represents the deal made between Parish and the Americans. That doesn't directly affect the financial results but of course those contracts represent who has the power over the finances (and new stadium) and how the financial decisions are made.

Since speculation is fun I think Parish didn't quite get the deal he expected and he is not running the club exactly how he wants - perhaps because the Americans want to sell or have loans repaid first or perhaps they are just prudent. Why not when you get such a low return on a risky and expensive player like Sorloth? Maybe Blitzer / Harris don't trust the current managements scouting and deal making ability any more than many on here.

We should stay up and if so the last three transfer windows should have stabilised the club finances and put us in a good position. Still have to find a way to sign the right players on the right wages though.

 

mileend Flag East London 04 Feb 19 6.51pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

As I said in my post, it could be BS but I’ve no reason to distrust the info. He’s an MD in a financial services company and works with Premier League clubs. It was something he mentioned in passing after hearing about the Solanki deal. It’s also probably info he shouldn’t be sharing, but did.

Anyway, I trust it to be accurate, which is that Palace are not in financial trouble whereas quite a few prem clubs are (if they go down).

Just something I heard and thought I’d share as there was a thread on it. Take or leave it. I’ve nothing else to add to the thread really.

Tottenham could be one of 5 clubs that would implode financially if they got relegated since they are heading towards a billion pounds spent on a new stadium and the funding of that is going to hurt them a lot

obviously they are not going to get relegated but they really need Champions League football to keep their cash flow healthy

no surprise they are spending zero pounds right now on transfers - it tells it's own story just as our low expenditure tells ours - but they are completely different stories

 

mileend Flag East London 04 Feb 19 7.22pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

We're permanently "on the brink of collapse" if the Brighton/Scouse accounting wizard is to be believed, and that's without the complication of relegation. And for his fans, he keeps questioning why he can't see £100m in cash, ringfenced in our accounts; now that is truly moronic

too true - the £100m is important in the long term to build the stand, raise the capacity and increase our yearly revenues but it is not immediately relevant to Palace as a going concern. I don't doubt there are some stresses between the owners and the next set of financial results may give the 'wizard' a bit more fuel for his argument but the measures have already been taken to rectify the issues - ie spending very little and moving on the non essential squad players.

Brighton will soon be facing the same issues that we have had. Namely if you are not a very big club who gets promoted and you stay up it is easy to make profits for a couple of years. But as the players who got you there need to be upgraded and replaced the transfer fees and wage costs needed to attract sufficient quality escalate dramatically until very soon 80% of your turnover is going to the players leaving you little money for everything else let alone new transfers as even the deepest pockets run dry eventually (see Bolton as a prime example)

We have scraped through so far - Brighton are not immune from facing similar financial challenges in the next few years

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 04 Feb 19 8.33pm

Originally posted by mileend

there is no danger of admin or FFP judging by the last set of accounts - profit made - little debt - £15m cash in the bank - previous director loans of £6m repaid - though directors made a further capital injection of £21m that is not huge for the Premier League

these accounts now lag well behind as the £21m represent Sam's window spending on Milo, Schlupp and van Aanholt

the very high wages to turnover reported (78%) are a big problem that is presumably going to be even worse in the next set of accounts due out next month as they will have Sakho's wages added amongst others (not Wilf's latest deal though - you'll need to wait until 2020 to see the impact of those on the figures)

spending so little in the last three windows shows that FFP issues are highly unlikely as the owners are not continually investing new capital (unlike the crazy stuff happening at Bournemouth). Admin is not on the cards because there is such little debt and cash flow is good. Assuming no relegation of course - though with parachute payments and some very saleable players that wouldn't be immediately life threatening.

All the super secret Delaware stuff represents the deal made between Parish and the Americans. That doesn't directly affect the financial results but of course those contracts represent who has the power over the finances (and new stadium) and how the financial decisions are made.

Since speculation is fun I think Parish didn't quite get the deal he expected and he is not running the club exactly how he wants - perhaps because the Americans want to sell or have loans repaid first or perhaps they are just prudent. Why not when you get such a low return on a risky and expensive player like Sorloth? Maybe Blitzer / Harris don't trust the current managements scouting and deal making ability any more than many on here.

We should stay up and if so the last three transfer windows should have stabilised the club finances and put us in a good position. Still have to find a way to sign the right players on the right wages though.


Thanks Mileend, I've been looking at the accounts and trying to work them out. So in 2016/17 we made a pre tax profit of £12m. I'm assuming it does include all the transfer spend or £104m, does it exclude the £32m that appears in section 15 creditors amount falling with in one year.

Attachment: accounts.pdf (953.07Kb)

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

mileend Flag East London 04 Feb 19 9.24pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge


Thanks Mileend, I've been looking at the accounts and trying to work them out. So in 2016/17 we made a pre tax profit of £12m. I'm assuming it does include all the transfer spend or £104m, does it exclude the £32m that appears in section 15 creditors amount falling with in one year.

the creditors are a balance sheet item rather than profit and loss so if they are still on the balance sheet as a creditor then they haven't be paid out yet

the transfers are not generally paid out in one go - they are paid in instalments so over the last few years it's likely Liverpool have been our biggest creditor.

Roy made a special mention that we were spending less because we had big payments to make on previous transfers (Benteke and Sakho) which illustrates this

from this small piece of information you can gather that the club is being sensible with the finances and lowering the risk of future financial problems and FFP - however they have to juggle that with staying in the PL

Since the Sakho transfer fee will only come into this years accounts we might not see any improvement in this creditors figure until next year accounts (for 2019)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Feb 19 9.52am

I wasn’t concerned with our finances. We would’ve known if we were in serious trouble. They’re lining up to tell us we are.

We’re lucky we have Roy who’s accepting the limitations he’s working under. The repetition, lack of changes during the match and trying to push for the result that day are very frustrating to watch but he fits perfectly with the financial strategy right now. I wouldn’t want this football forever although I bet Parish would. The previous successful escape artist managers would never accept it, especially for 2 seasons (and maybe another). We just have to accept some of the things that frustrate us on match day for now because they’re better than relegation and not challenging for however many seasons.

We now have to be more successful at finding players at the right price and wages. We’ve shown signs of that since the Rakip, Jach and Sørloth window debacle but I’m still not confident. Since then they haven’t been core players and it’s debatable if they’re actually suitable for the manager. Maybe because the budget is so limited we have to, or we find better if we buy what’s available rather than what we bid for. This is where the jury is still out for me. The running of football matters and joined up thinking, not whether we know how to manage the finances.

This might be an obvious or sensible or strange thing to point out depending on your view but it might be why we’re still here in the Prem. Parish didn’t fold when Pulis or Allardyce probably wanted more funds but left at a time they weren’t going to be provided. The issue was rather that we were going through catastrophe, escape job, catastrophe, escape job, and then when we did, Parish makes some left field leap into a football strategy we can’t deliver. Well not instantly and hovering where we do, that’s dangerous. (We’ve been passing the ball around under Hodgson anyway, as we could with a few managers). Hopefully when we come out of this we’ll correct these kind of repeated mistakes. We hope.

 


COYP

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 19 1.03pm

Originally posted by chris123

There's points deduction too now isn't there?

All sorts. Points deduction, transfer embargo, disqualification from competitions - they can even take away a championship or trophy if they want to.

After the last fine Bournemouth paid I seem to recall there being a quote that "Fines don't seem to work so other options will be considered for future breaches".

The current FFP cycle ends this year so I presume that not only have we cleared the decks but are waiting to see what new limits/parameters are imposed. There was talk of tightening in certain areas to try & stop the Citeh/PSG situations worsening re "income" albeit this shouldn't impact on us.

Edited by Nobbybm (05 Feb 2019 1.11pm)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Feb 19 3.52pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

All sorts. Points deduction, transfer embargo, disqualification from competitions - they can even take away a championship or trophy if they want to.

After the last fine Bournemouth paid I seem to recall there being a quote that "Fines don't seem to work so other options will be considered for future breaches".

The current FFP cycle ends this year so I presume that not only have we cleared the decks but are waiting to see what new limits/parameters are imposed. There was talk of tightening in certain areas to try & stop the Citeh/PSG situations worsening re "income" albeit this shouldn't impact on us.

Edited by Nobbybm (05 Feb 2019 1.11pm)

Don’t 3 year FFP cycles begin and end every year for every club?

 


COYP

chateauferret Flag 05 Feb 19 4.10pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

I am intrigued. That begs the question why would he give wolves and bournemouth, but not the other four, while at the same time excluding palace?

Makes no sense...

Fulham must be in the s*** given that they spent about £100m and are still s***e.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 05 Feb 19 4.10pm

Originally posted by mileend

the creditors are a balance sheet item rather than profit and loss so if they are still on the balance sheet as a creditor then they haven't be paid out yet

the transfers are not generally paid out in one go - they are paid in instalments so over the last few years it's likely Liverpool have been our biggest creditor.

Roy made a special mention that we were spending less because we had big payments to make on previous transfers (Benteke and Sakho) which illustrates this

from this small piece of information you can gather that the club is being sensible with the finances and lowering the risk of future financial problems and FFP - however they have to juggle that with staying in the PL

Since the Sakho transfer fee will only come into this years accounts we might not see any improvement in this creditors figure until next year accounts (for 2019)

Decent post. I'd not really factored in instalment payments, which as you've pointed out create a financial hangover especially when you've shelled out 60m on two players relatively recently. Explains why the new main stand is so badly needed to increase revenue and leave us with a little more liquidity.

Also explains neatly why we aren't 'progressing' in the minds of some unrealistic supporters. If you want to be challenging for top 5, from the start point we had (dilapidated stadium, rented training ground, poor finances) then I think realistically you're looking at a 10-15 year timeframe.

Don't forget that we are also going to be ploughing money into expanding and upgrading the training facilities as well as building a new main stand, all while constantly upgrading and maintaining the current infrastructure the club owns, paying players wages and, if there's some left shelling out a few million on new players and their ever increasing weekly pay packets. Not to mention FFP. So when someone says we're treading water, it might look like that to you but I think the reality is somewhat different.

I think the key here is to do our best at building the club sustainably and slowly, investing in all areas, rather than going all in to the transfer market every year. This appears to be the approach that has been taken.

Southampton are a great example of this – and despite all of it, are currently going through a low period. It happens to every team, the key is making sure you are on a strong enough footing in all areas to give yourself the best chance of weathering whatever gets thrown at you.

QPR are the bad example. Which would you rather be?

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Feb 19 4.50pm

Originally posted by mileend

the creditors are a balance sheet item rather than profit and loss so if they are still on the balance sheet as a creditor then they haven't be paid out yet

the transfers are not generally paid out in one go - they are paid in instalments so over the last few years it's likely Liverpool have been our biggest creditor.

Roy made a special mention that we were spending less because we had big payments to make on previous transfers (Benteke and Sakho) which illustrates this

from this small piece of information you can gather that the club is being sensible with the finances and lowering the risk of future financial problems and FFP - however they have to juggle that with staying in the PL

Since the Sakho transfer fee will only come into this years accounts we might not see any improvement in this creditors figure until next year accounts (for 2019)

The transfer fees may well have been paid in full by factoring agents. If so, it would be those agents who are the creditor and not Liverpool.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Feb 19 4.51pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Decent post. I'd not really factored in instalment payments, which as you've pointed out create a financial hangover especially when you've shelled out 60m on two players relatively recently. Explains why the new main stand is so badly needed to increase revenue and leave us with a little more liquidity.

Also explains neatly why we aren't 'progressing' in the minds of some unrealistic supporters. If you want to be challenging for top 5, from the start point we had (dilapidated stadium, rented training ground, poor finances) then I think realistically you're looking at a 10-15 year timeframe.

Don't forget that we are also going to be ploughing money into expanding and upgrading the training facilities as well as building a new main stand, all while constantly upgrading and maintaining the current infrastructure the club owns, paying players wages and, if there's some left shelling out a few million on new players and their ever increasing weekly pay packets. Not to mention FFP. So when someone says we're treading water, it might look like that to you but I think the reality is somewhat different.

I think the key here is to do our best at building the club sustainably and slowly, investing in all areas, rather than going all in to the transfer market every year. This appears to be the approach that has been taken.

Southampton are a great example of this – and despite all of it, are currently going through a low period. It happens to every team, the key is making sure you are on a strong enough footing in all areas to give yourself the best chance of weathering whatever gets thrown at you.

QPR are the bad example. Which would you rather be?

Agreed. They are the model we should be aspiring to.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we in financial trouble