You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dortmund after Wilf
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dortmund after Wilf


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Aray Flag South London 23 Jan 19 9.31pm

Surprised there's not a thread on this already - apols if I have missed it.

So Dortmund have some cash burning a hole in their pocket. If he wants to go I wouldn't blame him going for Champions League football - and abroad so I'd be able to support him in his future efforts. This said, I'd rather him stay because without him we lack any game changers.

[Link]

 

ger20 Flag London 23 Jan 19 9.44pm

Lukaku and Morata were bought for around the £75 million mark. Dortmund are offering £44 million if thats not a joke I don’t know what is .

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 23 Jan 19 10.01pm

Originally posted by ger20

Lukaku and Morata were bought for around the £75 million mark. Dortmund are offering £44 million if thats not a joke I don’t know what is .

Looking at this without emotion, which is hard but I feel a dose of realism is required...

Although Morata is now officially set for the glue factory, he has a half decent goals per season return. Lukaku similarly, before he moved to United. Zaha has neither. Maybe top three in the highest dribbles chart, and that does not get you 75m.

I’d take anything above 50m. I think that’s a massive offer for a player with average to poor goal return and an average assist ratio, in comparison with some of the other players available at that price range

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 23 Jan 19 10.14pm

Sell, sick of all the arm flapping etc. Also, he's become too easy an excuse for the others to use to hide their own shortcomings "if Wilf doesn't play we don't win" etc. Also, I think he's ruined it for himself with his public 'attack' on the refs (he was right, but they're never going to give him anything now)

He's the best we've ever had, but as the song goes, he's just too good for us. Sell now, he can go on and have a stella career and we can invest the money.

If he's over the home sickness thing, Dortmund would be an excellent fit for him.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 23 Jan 19 10.14pm

Clubs often go down when they sell their best players.

I don't see Wilf being sold in this window.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 23 Jan 19 10.16pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

Clubs often go down when they sell their best players.

I don't see Wilf being sold in this window.

Neither do I - article suggests summer offer.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

YT Flag Oxford 23 Jan 19 10.17pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Sell, sick of all the arm flapping etc. Also, he's become too easy an excuse for the others to use to hide their own shortcomings "if Wilf doesn't play we don't win" etc. Also, I think he's ruined it for himself with his public 'attack' on the refs (he was right, but they're never going to give him anything now)

He's the best we've ever had, but as the song goes, he's just too good for us. Sell now, he can go on and have a stella career and we can invest the money.

If he's over the home sickness thing, Dortmund would be an excellent fit for him.

The trouble is, I expect we would waste the money.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 23 Jan 19 10.31pm

Originally posted by YT

The trouble is, I expect we would waste the money.

Fair point.

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 23 Jan 19 10.35pm

Originally posted by YT

The trouble is, I expect we would waste the money.

Totally agree, we'd probably spend most of it on another 3 goals a season target man

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Jan 19 10.42pm

Originally posted by YT

The trouble is, I expect we would waste the money.

Even more to the point, there are only about 6 players in the world who can do what he does on a pitch and £50m wouldn’t buy any of them, so at that price he would be a bargain. Put him in the current Man City side and he would tear teams apart.

 

Aray Flag South London 23 Jan 19 10.51pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Looking at this without emotion, which is hard but I feel a dose of realism is required...

Although Morata is now officially set for the glue factory, he has a half decent goals per season return. Lukaku similarly, before he moved to United. Zaha has neither. Maybe top three in the highest dribbles chart, and that does not get you 75m.

I’d take anything above 50m. I think that’s a massive offer for a player with average to poor goal return and an average assist ratio, in comparison with some of the other players available at that price range


But even if he doesn’t score enough he’s making most of our better chances. I don’t think we can replace him effectively or efficiently.

 

.TUX. Flag 23 Jan 19 10.57pm

Wherever Wilf goes it'll be with my blessing.

He's more than done his apprenticeship for a continually struggling side and has his prime years ahead of him.

I want to see him truly fulfill his potential.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 23 Jan 19 11.11pm

Same rumor that was pitched last year and it was complete rubbish like most regarding Wilf.

No one has even asked or anything regarding Wilf for a year.

50m wouldn't get him anyway Palace would be fools to let him go for 25m basically due to contract clause with United getting 50%.

If he goes it would be 70+ and Dortmund wouldn't be paying that out

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

RyWa Flag Beckenham 24 Jan 19 12.29am

If you believe the reports on sky sports,there's ongoing talks between wilfs people and Dortmund. This rumour seems to be a little more believable than the others.
Could see wilf pushing for a move this summer, he seems more on edge this season and let's face it, he's not been at his best.
Would miss him something rotten though.

 

JoeViper Flag bromley 24 Jan 19 12.41am

Originally posted by grumpymort

Same rumor that was pitched last year and it was complete rubbish like most regarding Wilf.

No one has even asked or anything regarding Wilf for a year.

50m wouldn't get him anyway Palace would be fools to let him go for 25m basically due to contract clause with United getting 50%.

If he goes it would be 70+ and Dortmund wouldn't be paying that out

Presumably it is 50% of anything above what we paid for him rather than a straight 50%.

 


One of the biggest mysteries in life is that loud stupid people normally don't have even the slightest inclination that they are stupid.

Bangell Flag Oxford 24 Jan 19 1.39am

I think his performances this season will have lowered his price - probably permanently. He's 26 now, and it's difficult to continue talking about potential at this stage. His shortcomings with the mental side of the game have become very apparent and have not improved - if a big club does come in for him, it won't be for the £60 million plus that we thought we might get.

No way do I think we should sell, by the way - I'd love to see us properly build a team that gets the best out of him here...

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 24 Jan 19 2.05am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Sell, sick of all the arm flapping etc. Also, he's become too easy an excuse for the others to use to hide their own shortcomings "if Wilf doesn't play we don't win" etc. Also, I think he's ruined it for himself with his public 'attack' on the refs (he was right, but they're never going to give him anything now)

He's the best we've ever had, but as the song goes, he's just too good for us. Sell now, he can go on and have a stella career and we can invest the money.

If he's over the home sickness thing, Dortmund would be an excellent fit for him.

I agree, recently i have become bored of him. He's exciting to watch, don't get me wrong - but i just feel he needs a change. I feel he didn't help himself with refs, i feel away fans use him as an easy scape goat - he reacts to all of these and we can see it.

I don't think he is the kind of player to realise this, take stock and just have a 'quiet' latter half of the season, in respects to just let the football doing the talking, no protests, no glares, no outbursts.

Like Beckham after 98' - it's not a direct comparison but i feel Zaha is in a tight spot.

Thing is, he is a good player to watch, but we need goals. If he was replaced by two players, one player that scores 13-15 a season for us, the other 15/16 assists, then in my eyes, business well done.

Also, the longer he stays here, we don't know if he will think 'damn i missed out'.

Going over to germany, he can fly out family, friends, every other week - he gets a day off, his money, he can be entertained.

I think for wilf, he needs to mature, one way or the other and a move would be great for him.

 


This was once a quality forum....

crvenaeagle Flag 24 Jan 19 5.21am

Originally posted by ger20

Lukaku and Morata were bought for around the £75 million mark. Dortmund are offering £44 million if thats not a joke I don’t know what is .

Yes but that's players coming into the Premier League, not leaving - the German newspapers have even been recently laughing at the absurd prices at which teams can sell their players to the English

 

ultra_combo Flag croydon 24 Jan 19 6.19am

Swap deal for sancho. Screw man u and their 50% clause lol

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 Jan 19 6.51am

Originally posted by Vaibow

I agree, recently i have become bored of him. He's exciting to watch, don't get me wrong - but i just feel he needs a change. I feel he didn't help himself with refs, i feel away fans use him as an easy scape goat - he reacts to all of these and we can see it.

I don't think he is the kind of player to realise this, take stock and just have a 'quiet' latter half of the season, in respects to just let the football doing the talking, no protests, no glares, no outbursts.

Like Beckham after 98' - it's not a direct comparison but i feel Zaha is in a tight spot.

Thing is, he is a good player to watch, but we need goals. If he was replaced by two players, one player that scores 13-15 a season for us, the other 15/16 assists, then in my eyes, business well done.

Also, the longer he stays here, we don't know if he will think 'damn i missed out'.

Going over to germany, he can fly out family, friends, every other week - he gets a day off, his money, he can be entertained.

I think for wilf, he needs to mature, one way or the other and a move would be great for him.

Top post, I feel he's definitely got to go by the summer.

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dortmund after Wilf