You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs City Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs City Match Thread


Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
buzby1 Flag Devon 14 Apr 19 4.38pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I'm sick to death of the same old tactics. Wether we play man city or Huddersfield, same old same old. Keep everyone behind the ball and hope to catch them on the break...Oh but don't get the midfielders forward just in case we get caught on the break. You can not sit on the edge of your box against City and give their midfielders all thd tI'm in the world, you have to close them down otherwise eventually they'll break you down. Every team we play against we show far too much respect. FFS show some balls Roy

Agreed. Uninspiring and boring. Play like this next season and we’re down.

 

Bitter Flag Harpenden 14 Apr 19 4.39pm

Funny how BBC's Live Text noted that the last goal was offside, but the match report doesn't. More big club favouritism / lazy journalism?

Getting back to the point. Losing at home to Man City is no shame. Losing at home to Brighton, Watford, Southampton and Wolves on the other hand...

 

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Apr 19 4.41pm

I can accept the way we played today even though it was disappointing, but if we don't make a bit more effort to entertain in the rest of the remaining games then it will be a big shame. Midway through the season we were playing some good stuff and getting plaudits for it, but lately we have just been effective at getting results with very little entertainment value. Although I don't want us to go down, I really hope next season we just try and be a little bit more expansive. Ho hum.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Apr 19 4.41pm

I don't buy this "if we push forward they will tank us" talk. Frankly Hodgson sets up each game, whether against Huddersfield, Brighton, Man City or Chelsea, exactly the same - sit deep, deny the space in behind etc etc. Problem is that s*** is never going to work because the opposition know that Schlupp and PVA are an open door.

Hodgson has only plan A, irrespective of the quality of the opposition, there's nothing else in his locker.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (14 Apr 2019 4.45pm)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Apr 19 4.42pm

Originally posted by A89M

Who’s tactic have against City?

But in answer to your response, they did at the Etihad

Yep. We had 3 chances and scored 3 goals. They had loads of chances and scored 2. We played better going forward then than we did today. After the first 10 mins today it was clear our tactics weren't going to work. 1-0 down at half time we had to change things if we were to get something from the game. We didnt until we went 2-0 down. But hey if you're happy with the tactics today, good for you.

 

jem Flag Catford 14 Apr 19 4.45pm

As Jimmy Greaves once observed: "Football's a funny old game."

Well, losing 1-3 at home to Man City isn't exactly side-splitting, but in a game which elicited not even a yellow card, the most remarkable component of our performance for me today was Christian Benteke's start, and Roy Hodgson's persistence with him throughout.

Tell me, Roy: was that a bet? Was it a contractual obligation? Was it to contribute to the player's personal Premier League stats, with a view to making him a tad more saleable?

We're not quite in a parallel universe with this guy (Benteke, I mean) - it's just as if he's slightly out of phase with ours. A striker who, not only can't strike, but also now seems flatly resigned to refusing to do so. Why should we pay £120K a week, or whatever it is, for that?

Today's execrable display included a six-yard box heading opportunity, which he inevitably missed, but worse, a knock-down for a non out-and-out striker in that self-same part of the pitch. Surely that's what you're there for, fella.

And if your mojo has thoroughly deserted you, then you could at least haul your seemingly overpaid butt back up the pitch and help out defending, as per Messrs Zaha and Townsend, rather than standing there, statuesque, waiting for the perfect pass, which will never be delivered, because ironically, even if it were, you'd still somehow contrive not to connect with it.

I suppose that a somewhat fortuitous 39 points (17 goals scored in the last 15 mins, 10 pens from Luka) renders all of this somewhat academic; but it could all so very easily have been otherwise...

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 14 Apr 19 4.46pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I'm sick to death of the same old tactics. Wether we play man city or Huddersfield, same old same old. Keep everyone behind the ball and hope to catch them on the break...Oh but don't get the midfielders forward just in case we get caught on the break. You can not sit on the edge of your box against City and give their midfielders all thd tI'm in the world, you have to close them down otherwise eventually they'll break you down. Every team we play against we show far too much respect. FFS show some balls Roy

I get your sentiments. But correct me if I'm wrong but didn't all 3 of their goals come from when we had pushed higher up the pitch?

We scored the first goal City have conceded in 5 games. Think that highlights the monumental task we faced today. Can't say we played well but we were not completely out of it unlike many other teams city have faced this year.

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 14 Apr 19 4.49pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Some clown said get at them and if they run past us so what. Their third goal a prime example of what would have happened if we had done that all game. As for someone else saying our players weren't trying that's a disgrace because at this level players do try but sometimes you have to accept that he other team is just to good for us.

no need to be insulting Mr Tyler just because someone might know a bit more than you do about football and tactics.


Firstly, apology’s.

I’m a fan not a tactical genius otherwise I’d be in the game coaching or managing and not on a fan forum discussing. As has been written in the last few posts, we had nothing to lose. They did not take there foot off the gas so much as we decided to have a go. I’ve watched every minute of every game this year and I’m not calling for Roy’s head, far from it, but as a fan I, like many others, are bored silly of the way we play. It can be forgiven to grind out a result when relegation is in the balance but not when we can have a free hit.

We are not moving forwards and we will lose our best players if we keep playing like this. Would you want to play for a team like ours if you had Wilfs skills or AWB promise?

We need to push on now and using the remaining games would be a great time to try out some new tactics and set ups. It can’t be a coincidence that every striker who has played for us over the last few years has suffered. I feel sorry for Teckkers (although I don’t think he has helped himself either). Bats looked good when he started and within a couple of weeks looked like garbage. As I said it can’t be a coincidence.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 14 Apr 19 4.51pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Yep. We had 3 chances and scored 3 goals. They had loads of chances and scored 2. We played better going forward then than we did today. After the first 10 mins today it was clear our tactics weren't going to work. 1-0 down at half time we had to change things if we were to get something from the game. We didnt until we went 2-0 down. But hey if you're happy with the tactics today, good for you.

Not happy with the result but to expect anything from this fixture is unrealistic, show me a team this season with similar stature to us that has got anything else against city?

We also got a draw in the very same fixture last year which could have been a win had it not been for Luka’s penalty miss, this again was against a rampant city who were unbeaten at the time. But course, Roy don’t know what he’s doing..

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 14 Apr 19 4.54pm

Firstly, apology’s.

I’m a fan not a tactical genius otherwise I’d be in the game coaching or managing and not on a fan forum discussing. As has been written in the last few posts, we had nothing to lose. They did not take there foot off the gas so much as we decided to have a go. I’ve watched every minute of every game this year and I’m not calling for Roy’s head, far from it, but as a fan I, like many others, are bored silly of the way we play. It can be forgiven to grind out a result when relegation is in the balance but not when we can have a free hit.

We are not moving forwards and we will lose our best players if we keep playing like this. Would you want to play for a team like ours if you had Wilfs skills or AWB promise?

We need to push on now and using the remaining games would be a great time to try out some new tactics and set ups. It can’t be a coincidence that every striker who has played for us over the last few years has suffered. I feel sorry for Teckkers (although I don’t think he has helped himself either). Bats looked good when he started and within a couple of weeks looked like garbage. As I said it can’t be a coincidence.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 14 Apr 19 4.54pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

But at least it was f*****g exciting. If we'd havd payed like that all game, who knows what would havd happened....and by thd way, it was offside....


NOT as far as the officials it wasnt . . . & they are the ones who matter(wether we like it or not).


Next season with VAR, im not so sure. IMHO, i still think the 'big' clubs will still get the decisions.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 14 Apr 19 5.02pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

..very offside otherwise a good goal, very fortunate the officials for them today lots of niggly fouls to stop us breaking very clever stuff, VAR better sort it out next season!


Sorry to dissapoint you, BUT, VAR is not there for that. Its there for offsides, goals, cautions/dismissals, penalties & mistaken identities, oh & of the ball incidents.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

merganser Flag 14 Apr 19 5.04pm

I thought trekkers played well. Always a handful and helped defence out at corners.

Not much creativity in midfield, alas.

Our goal was a joyous moment. Well played the skipper.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 14 Apr 19 5.07pm

Benteke won some flick ons. Not much else. But if only we had a striker to play alongside him to feed off these second balls.

 

MR200% Flag 14 Apr 19 5.08pm

I can't keep watching this stuff at home, It's so depressing, When we attack we can score, but most home games we play 3 defensive midfielders and only go on the front foot in the last 20 minutes

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 14 Apr 19 5.13pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

beaten by a much better team.

no grumbles here, they controlled the game from the outset.

Correct, braunie. The whining on here is actually quite embarrassing.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 14 Apr 19 5.19pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Correct, braunie. The whining on here is actually quite embarrassing.

maybe a lot of people on here only started supporting when we got promoted...but genuinely, people should understand how good we currently have it as palace fans.

if they experienced the years struggling in the 2nd tier they wouldnt moan.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


taylors lovechild Flag 14 Apr 19 5.26pm

Originally posted by jem

As Jimmy Greaves once observed: "Football's a funny old game."

Well, losing 1-3 at home to Man City isn't exactly side-splitting, but in a game which elicited not even a yellow card, the most remarkable component of our performance for me today was Christian Benteke's start, and Roy Hodgson's persistence with him throughout.

Tell me, Roy: was that a bet? Was it a contractual obligation? Was it to contribute to the player's personal Premier League stats, with a view to making him a tad more saleable?

We're not quite in a parallel universe with this guy (Benteke, I mean) - it's just as if he's slightly out of phase with ours. A striker who, not only can't strike, but also now seems flatly resigned to refusing to do so. Why should we pay £120K a week, or whatever it is, for that?

Today's execrable display included a six-yard box heading opportunity, which he inevitably missed, but worse, a knock-down for a non out-and-out striker in that self-same part of the pitch. Surely that's what you're there for, fella.

And if your mojo has thoroughly deserted you, then you could at least haul your seemingly overpaid butt back up the pitch and help out defending, as per Messrs Zaha and Townsend, rather than standing there, statuesque, waiting for the perfect pass, which will never be delivered, because ironically, even if it were, you'd still somehow contrive not to connect with it.

I suppose that a somewhat fortuitous 39 points (17 goals scored in the last 15 mins, 10 pens from Luka) renders all of this somewhat academic; but it could all so very easily have been otherwise...

In my opinion Tekkers was one of our better performers. He won most balls in the air, held the ball up under pressure and cleared balls from defending corners and had a hand in our goal. He was our only outlet and the problem was not him but the lack of support he received. At one point he somehow held onto the ball despite pressure from 3 players but then had no one there offering themselves. He has rightly received criticism in the past, but it is unwarranted today.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 14 Apr 19 5.39pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

In my opinion Tekkers was one of our better performers. He won most balls in the air, held the ball up under pressure and cleared balls from defending corners and had a hand in our goal. He was our only outlet and the problem was not him but the lack of support he received. At one point he somehow held onto the ball despite pressure from 3 players but then had no one there offering themselves. He has rightly received criticism in the past, but it is unwarranted today.

Roy should have tried playing Batshsuayi alongside him upfront.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Apr 19 5.43pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Some clown said get at them and if they run past us so what. Their third goal a prime example of what would have happened if we had done that all game. As for someone else saying our players weren't trying that's a disgrace because at this level players do try but sometimes you have to accept that he other team is just to good for us.

no need to be insulting Mr Tyler just because someone might know a bit more than you do about football and tactics.

PZ Eagle you know absolutely nothing about football. You would have us losing safely 1-0 every week by the sounds of things. Are you related to Roy by any chance?


 

Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs City Match Thread