You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 17 Dec 19 9.10am

Cannot believe Roy won’t give him a try....
With our injuries mounting , Townsend out, we need to play a different style of football. Camarasa could be a revelation for us..just very strange
PS. Reidewald is no way good enough for the premier league ...seen enough of him now , he seems to be unable to move and run properly ..anything but athletic...

 

Beastie Flag 17 Dec 19 9.33am

Originally posted by Hutchyeagle

Cannot believe Roy won’t give him a try....
With our injuries mounting , Townsend out, we need to play a different style of football. Camarasa could be a revelation for us..just very strange
PS. Reidewald is no way good enough for the premier league ...seen enough of him now , he seems to be unable to move and run properly ..anything but athletic...

I thought the same but it seems he was playing with an injury.

Re:Camarasa, I can only assume there are reasons for his lack of game time that have not been made public. There has to be.

I just hope after Meyer’s great cameo, we see more of him.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 17 Dec 19 10.15am

There were question marks around whether he was faking an injury when Cardiff were struggling at one point last season, but whenever I saw him he stood out as their best player and seemed willing to get stuck in. I think his lack of game time here is really just down to Roy preferring a workmanlike midfield three - the same thing restricting Meyer's appearances - and a preference for Andros, Wilf and Schlupp in the wide positions. If Andros is out again on Saturday then I hope either Meyer or Camarassa get a chance to start.

I still hope he at least gets a chance to impress, as I can see him going to Norwich or somewhere in January and us asking 'What if?'

 

Painter Flag Croydon 17 Dec 19 10.40am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

There were question marks around whether he was faking an injury when Cardiff were struggling at one point last season, but whenever I saw him he stood out as their best player and seemed willing to get stuck in. I think his lack of game time here is really just down to Roy preferring a workmanlike midfield three - the same thing restricting Meyer's appearances - and a preference for Andros, Wilf and Schlupp in the wide positions. If Andros is out again on Saturday then I hope either Meyer or Camarassa get a chance to start.

I still hope he at least gets a chance to impress, as I can see him going to Norwich or somewhere in January and us asking 'What if?'

There are many post’s questioning Roy’s judgement, obviously Camarassa hasn’t impressed in training to force his way into the team. We play in a style that is workman like and functional, Camarassa maybe isn’t up for it.
People always think players not in the team are better than they really are, Reidewald being a good example.
Roy has us in 9th position with his methods, I can’t see him changing anytime soon.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 17 Dec 19 10.46am

Originally posted by Painter

There are many post’s questioning Roy’s judgement, obviously Camarassa hasn’t impressed in training to force his way into the team. We play in a style that is workman like and functional, Camarassa maybe isn’t up for it.
People always think players not in the team are better than they really are, Reidewald being a good example.
Roy has us in 9th position with his methods, I can’t see him changing anytime soon.

I'm not questioning Roy's tactics, rather stating what they are and why Camarassa doesn't seem to fit in. Camarassa is a bit different in that he proved himself PL standard at Cardiff last season getting their POTY; Riedewald on the other hand has had perhaps one, maybe two, good games in his Palace career. You may be right about VC struggling to impress in training, but it may also be a political thing with him seemingly not a player chosen by Roy. Who knows.

 

Hannes Flag Vienna 17 Dec 19 10.48am

Originally posted by Painter
Spot on!


There are many post’s questioning Roy’s judgement, obviously Camarassa hasn’t impressed in training to force his way into the team. We play in a style that is workman like and functional, Camarassa maybe isn’t up for it.
People always think players not in the team are better than they really are, Reidewald being a good example.
Roy has us in 9th position with his methods, I can’t see him changing anytime soon.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 17 Dec 19 11.14am

I wonder if there is something financial here, as in if he plays x number of mins, Palace have to pay something regarding the loan.

Roy wont play him unless he absolutely has to.

If possible, he will be going elsewhere in Jan.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 Dec 19 11.57am

Whatever reasons Roy has, it is a big shame Victor C. is not given any game time. As for Riedewald, think there is a good player in there - only not as a full back. He can pass the ball well to start with - unlike most of his team mates who yesterday mostly turned out color blind.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Dec 19 1.23pm

Originally posted by Painter


There are many post’s questioning Roy’s judgement, obviously Camarassa hasn’t impressed in training to force his way into the team.

Ian Botham never impressed in training either

 

Beastie Flag 17 Dec 19 1.38pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Ian Botham never impressed in training either

Yeah, just like Beefy, Camarasa should say, ‘that’s what I think of your selection policy. Piss off and leave me alone. I’m walking to John O’Groats for some spastics'.

Edited by Beastie (17 Dec 2019 1.38pm)

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 18 Dec 19 8.55am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

There were question marks around whether he was faking an injury when Cardiff were struggling at one point last season, but whenever I saw him he stood out as their best player and seemed willing to get stuck in. I think his lack of game time here is really just down to Roy preferring a workmanlike midfield three - the same thing restricting Meyer's appearances - and a preference for Andros, Wilf and Schlupp in the wide positions. If Andros is out again on Saturday then I hope either Meyer or Camarassa get a chance to start.

I still hope he at least gets a chance to impress, as I can see him going to Norwich or somewhere in January and us asking 'What if?'

I think Roy would rather play our 5th choice goal keeper in mid field rather than Meyer or Camarassa, defiantly rather than Camarassa

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Dec 19 9.48am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Whatever reasons Roy has, it is a big shame Victor C. is not given any game time. As for Riedewald, think there is a good player in there - only not as a full back. He can pass the ball well to start with - unlike most of his team mates who yesterday mostly turned out color blind.

He was bought by De Boer to play in a back three or as a defensive midfielder, not sure how many games he has played at left-back.I believe it was reported last year that Hodgson and Lewington are of the opinion that he doesn't react or get back quick enough for the PL.He is capable with the ball at his feet but I think a couple of years ago he was accused of switching off at times, but this charge could be labelled against a whole host of players.

In terms of Camarasa, it would appear that it is likely he will leave in January.Played really well for Cardiff last year but hasn't been given a chance at our club.I recall witnessing our players come on to the pitch after a home game this season, presumably for a "Warm down".Camarasa cut a solitary figure detached from a cluster of players.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 18 Dec 19 10.11am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Ian Botham never impressed in training either

I am sure scunthorpe were just pleased to have him.

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 18 Dec 19 10.21am

Painter Online Flag Croydon Today 10.11am
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Ian Botham never impressed in training either

I am sure scunthorpe were just pleased to have him.

If my memory serves me right, did Botham not turn down
a contract offer from us when he 15 or 16?

 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 18 Dec 19 1.08pm

Originally posted by Beastie

Yeah, just like Beefy, Camarasa should say, ‘that’s what I think of your selection policy. Piss off and leave me alone. I’m walking to John O’Groats for some spastics'.

Edited by Beastie (17 Dec 2019 1.38pm)

what a f***ing horrible word to describe the less fortunate people with special needs .

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 18 Dec 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle

what a f***ing horrible word to describe the less fortunate people with special needs .

Its a Ricky Gervais quote from The Office

[Link]

Edited by Jordan555x (18 Dec 2019 2.55pm)

 

aashman12 Flag 19 Dec 19 7.55am

Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle

what a f***ing horrible word to describe the less fortunate people with special needs .

It's a real word. Don't you remember the charity shops?

 

jeeagles Flag 19 Dec 19 8.24am

Originally posted by aashman12

It's a real word. Don't you remember the charity shops?

Could have been a Labour party fund raiser?

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 19 Dec 19 9.29am

There's clearly something more to the Camarasa situation than meets the eye. Whatever it is Roy will not play him as i'm sure they are negotiating his return to Betis behind the scenes. Such a shame I was very excited by his signing. Cant argue with Roys results this year but good god the lack creativity in our set up bugs me.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 19 Dec 19 9.44am

Well didn't Man Utd once pay £12 million for a very good player who never got a game in the PL for them?.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this