You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Players' wages
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Players' wages


Page 7 of 12 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 13 Apr 20 4.00pm

Originally posted by EagleinSF

Actually think of the damage it'll do to the betting industry.

They’ll get even less sympathy than the players.

 

est1905 Flag 13 Apr 20 6.25pm

Originally posted by scuffy

And if you're seriously suggesting bankers show humility, you obviously weren't around, or didn't pay much attention to, the 2008 financial crisis where many people who deserved to end up in jail continued to pay themselves millions while taxpayers bailed them out and suffered the years of austerity that followed -- the results of which are a big factor behind the NHS being as depleted as it is today. But, yes, go ahead and blame young footballers...a much easier target while the establishment continue to make themselves richer!

You are a complete idiot that picks on a few isolated cases to attempt to make a point AND ignore the FACT that these professions work 60/70 hour weeks for many years to get where they are which requires discipline and yes dopey, it requires a certain amount of humility too.
Oh, and you are wrong on what a top lawyer earns. Very wrong. You only get 8 figure salaries in the legal game on the other side of the pond. Bankers? I only know one and he is not a close friend but a friend of a friend. Its the boardrooms of these top banks that created austerity Mr uneducated, not those actual bankers on the shop floor. Yes they make good money but again the vast vast majority don't earn a fraction of what todays average (in many cases VERY average) Prem players get.
I guess you are Andros Townsend in disguise? Trying to justify your greed again yes?
Next you'll be trotting out the line about how much Prem footballers contribute in tax. Is that before or after we take into account the tax avoidance schemes many of them use?

 

est1905 Flag 13 Apr 20 6.29pm

Originally posted by scuffy

Do you think it doesn't take footballers many years to reach the top in their profession? They just happen to be out on a field instead of in a classroom.

In a single word no, of course not.
Even a Spark takes 4 years in college to train to be an electrician. Most Prem footballers hit the first team in their late teens. How is that taking them years?
Oh please don't use a child academy player as a pathetic example. Until they are 15 they are not allowed to play/work in a serious mans environment. That so does not count.

 

scuffy Flag orpington 14 Apr 20 12.51pm

You are incredibly naive or just plain ignorant if you believe the 2008 financial crisis was purely the result of what happened in boardrooms. It was the result of collective, catastrophic failure and greed across the entire banking industry. Never before or since had a single industry inflicted so much damage upon the global economy.

As far as lawyers are concerned, the best paid are corporate lawyers who are paid fortunes to protect the financial interests of their clients, interests which often run contrary to those of the general public.

Football club academies are brutally competitive. For every one player that makes it to pro status, let alone premier league status, hundreds of wannabes fail. As I said before, I'm not seeking to justify all premier league wages. I just think some of the vitriol being pointed in their direction, ironically often from football fans, is unjustified.

Originally posted by est1905

You are a complete idiot that picks on a few isolated cases to attempt to make a point AND ignore the FACT that these professions work 60/70 hour weeks for many years to get where they are which requires discipline and yes dopey, it requires a certain amount of humility too.
Oh, and you are wrong on what a top lawyer earns. Very wrong. You only get 8 figure salaries in the legal game on the other side of the pond. Bankers? I only know one and he is not a close friend but a friend of a friend. Its the boardrooms of these top banks that created austerity Mr uneducated, not those actual bankers on the shop floor. Yes they make good money but again the vast vast majority don't earn a fraction of what todays average (in many cases VERY average) Prem players get.
I guess you are Andros Townsend in disguise? Trying to justify your greed again yes?
Next you'll be trotting out the line about how much Prem footballers contribute in tax. Is that before or after we take into account the tax avoidance schemes many of them use?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Apr 20 1.05pm

Originally posted by scuffy

You are incredibly naive or just plain ignorant if you believe the 2008 financial crisis was purely the result of what happened in boardrooms. It was the result of collective, catastrophic failure and greed across the entire banking industry. Never before or since had a single industry inflicted so much damage upon the global economy.

As far as lawyers are concerned, the best paid are corporate lawyers who are paid fortunes to protect the financial interests of their clients, interests which often run contrary to those of the general public.

Football club academies are brutally competitive. For every one player that makes it to pro status, let alone premier league status, hundreds of wannabes fail. As I said before, I'm not seeking to justify all premier league wages. I just think some of the vitriol being pointed in their direction, ironically often from football fans, is unjustified.

The lack of regulation was definitely a factor but who created these credit default swaps that were a compete con that they sold on and on and on? Who created 125% mortgages? Who rewarded recklessness?

If you watch ‘The Big Short’ for 2 hours you’ll see how it was nicely hidden, including by the ratings agencies, until some traders started to notice how vulnerable it was due to the client base of anyone who can write their own name being the key thing, and how it was inevitable it would collapse. It was just a matter of when.

It was not due to greed across the entire banking industry.

 


COYP

scuffy Flag orpington 14 Apr 20 1.24pm

There was a culture of greed across the entire industry.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The lack of regulation was definitely a factor but who created these credit default swaps that were a compete con that they sold on and on and on? Who created 125% mortgages? Who rewarded recklessness?

If you watch ‘The Big Short’ for 2 hours you’ll see how it was nicely hidden, including by the ratings agencies, until some traders started to notice how vulnerable it was due to the client base of anyone who can write their own name being the key thing, and how it was inevitable it would collapse. It was just a matter of when.

It was not due to greed across the entire banking industry.

 

scuffy Flag orpington 14 Apr 20 1.28pm

The UK taxpayer has been paying for that reckless greed through austerity measures for the past 12 years which is a big reason why the NHS is as depleted as it is.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The lack of regulation was definitely a factor but who created these credit default swaps that were a compete con that they sold on and on and on? Who created 125% mortgages? Who rewarded recklessness?

If you watch ‘The Big Short’ for 2 hours you’ll see how it was nicely hidden, including by the ratings agencies, until some traders started to notice how vulnerable it was due to the client base of anyone who can write their own name being the key thing, and how it was inevitable it would collapse. It was just a matter of when.

It was not due to greed across the entire banking industry.

 

scuffy Flag orpington 14 Apr 20 1.32pm

The Big Short references just one part of the crisis. It was a lot broader than that.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The lack of regulation was definitely a factor but who created these credit default swaps that were a compete con that they sold on and on and on? Who created 125% mortgages? Who rewarded recklessness?

If you watch ‘The Big Short’ for 2 hours you’ll see how it was nicely hidden, including by the ratings agencies, until some traders started to notice how vulnerable it was due to the client base of anyone who can write their own name being the key thing, and how it was inevitable it would collapse. It was just a matter of when.

It was not due to greed across the entire banking industry.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Apr 20 1.48pm

Originally posted by scuffy

There was a culture of greed across the entire industry.

True. Doesn’t mean they all caused the crisis.

Originally posted by scuffy

The UK taxpayer has been paying for that reckless greed through austerity measures for the past 12 years which is a big reason why the NHS is as depleted as it is.

True. Not our disagreement though.

Originally posted by scuffy

The Big Short references just one part of the crisis. It was a lot broader than that.

The crisis was caused by ridiculous and irresponsible lending causing an almighty credit bubble. What followed was because of that although I grant you that banks like Goldman’s and austerity measures placed on EU member countries were because of underlying issues too but they would never have been anywhere near in trouble if it wasn’t for the most unbelievable ‘get it while it’s on tap’ trend of lenders and those trading in credit default swaps.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Apr 2020 1.51pm)

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Apr 20 1.51pm

I don't think anyone can reasonably argue against the fact that Premier players get paid disproportionately too much and are living in a bubble. There was going to come a time, when it had to stop, nobody thought it would be a pandemic that did it. If you consider what they get paid in relation to the medical profession, who we will all rely on at some point, it just isn't sensical.
Clubs have been spending way beyond their means for years, now its all going to come tumbling down. An average player is earning £3m a year.

 

scuffy Flag orpington 14 Apr 20 1.56pm

All fair points. The original point I was making was in response to the suggestion that top bankers are more deserving of riches than top footballers -- i'm not sure that is necessarily true in all cases and I stand by that.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The crisis was caused by ridiculous and irresponsible lending causing an almighty credit bubble. What followed was because of that although I grant you that banks like Goldman’s and austerity measures placed on EU member countries were because of underlying issues too but they would never have been anywhere near in trouble if it wasn’t for the most unbelievable ‘get it while it’s on tap’ trend of lenders and those trading in credit default swaps.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Apr 2020 1.51pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 14 Apr 20 2.09pm

Originally posted by scuffy
You are incredibly naive or just plain ignorant if you believe the 2008 financial crisis was purely the result of what happened in boardrooms. It was the result of collective, catastrophic failure and greed across the entire banking industry. Never before or since had a single industry inflicted so much damage upon the global economy.

As far as lawyers are concerned, the best paid are corporate lawyers who are paid fortunes to protect the financial interests of their clients, interests which often run contrary to those of the general public.

Football club academies are brutally competitive. For every one player that makes it to pro status, let alone premier league status, hundreds of wannabes fail. As I said before, I'm not seeking to justify all premier league wages. I just think some of the vitriol being pointed in their direction, ironically often from football fans, is unjustified.

Fixing the Libor rate, short selling, sub-prime mortgages, tax evasion... banking was the wild west, but it was making all involved, including the people who make the rules lots of money.

Footballers, musicians, and actors can make rediculous abounts of money by being very good at what they do. Footballers are being made a scapegoat to some extent. Its distracting people from the amount the TV companies and owners are making.

Bankers and businessmen make lots of money by being smart and mainly screwing everyone out of every penny they can get.

Billionaire trader Daniel Levy took the first oportunity to get the tax payer to pay his low earning staff. When he got critised he diverted the attention onto the players.

Even the Spurs yearly wage bill of £80million doesnt seem much against his £1bn net worth. Even the players must be questioning why they should take a pay cut from someone with that much money?


 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Apr 20 2.24pm

Not a bad summary of the issues from the BBC

[Link]

Meanwhile in Scotland if anyone can follow what is going on up their good luck. The machinations and manoeuvrings between clubs and the SFA is something to be behold.

Confused? You will be (Soap).

Edited by Badger11 (14 Apr 2020 2.24pm)

 


One more point

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Apr 20 3.03pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Fixing the Libor rate, short selling, sub-prime mortgages, tax evasion... banking was the wild west, but it was making all involved, including the people who make the rules lots of money.

Footballers, musicians, and actors can make rediculous abounts of money by being very good at what they do. Footballers are being made a scapegoat to some extent. Its distracting people from the amount the TV companies and owners are making.

Bankers and businessmen make lots of money by being smart and mainly screwing everyone out of every penny they can get.

Billionaire trader Daniel Levy took the first oportunity to get the tax payer to pay his low earning staff. When he got critised he diverted the attention onto the players.

Even the Spurs yearly wage bill of £80million doesnt seem much against his £1bn net worth. Even the players must be questioning why they should take a pay cut from someone with that much money?


The difference in footballers is that:

1) People begrudge people with low intelligence, or ignorant people who lack class in their spending and behaviour to earn huge sums of money AND.....

2) Because it’s just become a going rate thing, or just squeeze essentially the paying punters and fans for every penny they can via their agents telling them they should and can. Only the best musicians and actors earn fortunes. Very few actually. A lot of footballers are making fortunes by not ‘being good at what they do’ but because others do or that’s the going rate for someone who may prove to be no use whatsoever.

Joe Lewis is the billionaire owner of spurs. Daniel Levy runs the operation. Spurs and Liverpool and whoever else have succumbed to pressure to cancel the furloughing of their non playing staff just as we’d like to see players accept they need to take a cut, not a bloody deferment, of their pay for the good of their club, fans and the game.

I have previously mentioned the beginning of Sky’s monopoly and hopefully in time no need to pay so much to watch football. But during these revenue rises from Tv contracts the players, via their agents, have continually managed to rinse nearly everything out of football.

I’m not sure I agree with footballers deciding that another person is richer than them so they shouldn’t accept a pay cut. If anything they should be more concerned with how the accounts of the club look, and if they knew anything about the effects of their wage demands they’d know the strain that football clubs are under because of the highest cost to the clubs. Themselves. I can’t believe I had to type that out tbh.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Apr 2020 3.22pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Apr 20 3.20pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Not a bad summary of the issues from the BBC

[Link]

Meanwhile in Scotland if anyone can follow what is going on up their good luck. The machinations and manoeuvrings between clubs and the SFA is something to be behold.

Confused? You will be (Soap).

Edited by Badger11 (14 Apr 2020 2.24pm)

‘ On 3 April, the Premier League agreed to advance £125m in payments to the EFL and National League, although only £2m of it will go to the 68 National League clubs.’

Of the 21 Championship clubs who competed in the EFL last season, the latest published accounts for five of them included parachute payments that came with relegation from the Premier League.

In 13 instances out of the remaining 16, the club's wage bills exceeded their income. In their accounts, Reading and Birmingham said there was "material uncertainty" over their ability to exist as a going concern. As is the case for the majority of Championship clubs, they are reliant on funding from their owners.

It has been reported that in order to protect themselves, if agreement can not be found between individual clubs and the Professional Footballers' Association over wage cuts and deferrals, a "nuclear option" of all 24 clubs going into administration was being considered.

But this notion has been rejected by alternative sources influential within Championship circles.

"It is hard enough getting all 24 clubs to agree the time of day, let alone the detail about how you could go about doing that," said one. "It just wouldn't happen."

Each club has a very different funding model.

Some - Stoke and Preston are two examples - have long-standing, wealthy owners, who have already vowed to honour their financial commitments. In contrast, Leeds and Birmingham have already reached deferral agreements with their first-team squads. Others are looking at other ways to reduce costs. West Bromwich Albion chief executive Mark Jenkins has taken a 100% pay cut.

Evidently, distrust exists. BBC Sport understands EFL chairman Rick Parry is in receipt of a letter from a club questioning how wage deferrals - existing and in the future - are going to be paid and whether, until salaries are honoured in full, clubs are going to be allowed to make new signings or agree new deals with players whose contracts expire on 30 June.

The argument is some have stretched themselves too far and should not be allowed to avoid the consequences.

When Covid-19 has been dealt with and life has returned to normal, it is anticipated the financial operations of EFL clubs will be looked at again.

Insiders have told BBC Sport the present "Profit and Sustainability" regulations are "not fit for purpose". The EFL already has a working group looking at the rule, which allows clubs not recently relegated from the Premier League to lose £39m over a three-year period. However, rather than look at the whole issue with scepticism, as has been thought likely, it is hoped the experience of the past month, and what lies ahead, will allow all parties to adopt a more mature position which, in theory, will provide the breathing space needed to reach more acceptable - and workable - regulations.

Indications are that Sky will not ask for the money they have paid for this season back. However, if the middle of June arrives with no indication when the 2020-21 campaign will begin, they are unlikely to hand over their first payment - and that would concern every club as it would chop off funding.

Indications are that Sky will not ask for the money they have paid for this season back. However, if the middle of June arrives with no indication when the 2020-21 campaign will begin, they are unlikely to hand over their first payment - and that would concern every club as it would chop off funding.

****************

That agreed administration by all clubs in the championship sounded like a good plan but unsurprisingly its fallen down.

First I’ve heard sky might not want their 19/20 Tv money instalment back.

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 Apr 20 4.43pm

[Link]

 

scuffy Flag orpington 14 Apr 20 6.07pm

Wow, mass generalization there...why do you even bother watching or supporting them if you think so little of them?

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The difference in footballers is that:

1) People begrudge people with low intelligence, or ignorant people who lack class in their spending and behaviour to earn huge sums of money AND.....

2) Because it’s just become a going rate thing, or just squeeze essentially the paying punters and fans for every penny they can via their agents telling them they should and can. Only the best musicians and actors earn fortunes. Very few actually. A lot of footballers are making fortunes by not ‘being good at what they do’ but because others do or that’s the going rate for someone who may prove to be no use whatsoever.

Joe Lewis is the billionaire owner of spurs. Daniel Levy runs the operation. Spurs and Liverpool and whoever else have succumbed to pressure to cancel the furloughing of their non playing staff just as we’d like to see players accept they need to take a cut, not a bloody deferment, of their pay for the good of their club, fans and the game.

I have previously mentioned the beginning of Sky’s monopoly and hopefully in time no need to pay so much to watch football. But during these revenue rises from Tv contracts the players, via their agents, have continually managed to rinse nearly everything out of football.

I’m not sure I agree with footballers deciding that another person is richer than them so they shouldn’t accept a pay cut. If anything they should be more concerned with how the accounts of the club look, and if they knew anything about the effects of their wage demands they’d know the strain that football clubs are under because of the highest cost to the clubs. Themselves. I can’t believe I had to type that out tbh.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Apr 2020 3.22pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Apr 20 6.21pm

Originally posted by scuffy

Wow, mass generalization there...why do you even bother watching or supporting them if you think so little of them?

I support my local club. I don’t idolise players. Most of them would be off in an instant if more money was on offer anyway. Some of the old guard and Tomkins are different. The rest are mostly far removed from us.

 


COYP

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 15 Apr 20 9.22am

Their refusal to moderate their wages show that the players have zero loyalty to their clubs nor, more importantly, to the supporters.

They all seem to feel "picked on" and are determined to hold their ground whatever. Be interesting to see if they are so resolute once clubs start going tits-up.

I'd propose a temporary maximum wage of £3,000 per week. Their inflated wages restored when normality returns.

Real hardship for the poor petals.

Who on here has earned £150,000 pa - not many I'll bet.

Edited by Eaglehamster (15 Apr 2020 9.23am)

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

jeeagles Flag 15 Apr 20 11.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The difference in footballers is that:

1) People begrudge people with low intelligence, or ignorant people who lack class in their spending and behaviour to earn huge sums of money AND.....

2) Because it’s just become a going rate thing, or just squeeze essentially the paying punters and fans for every penny they can via their agents telling them they should and can. Only the best musicians and actors earn fortunes. Very few actually. A lot of footballers are making fortunes by not ‘being good at what they do’ but because others do or that’s the going rate for someone who may prove to be no use whatsoever.

Joe Lewis is the billionaire owner of spurs. Daniel Levy runs the operation. Spurs and Liverpool and whoever else have succumbed to pressure to cancel the furloughing of their non playing staff just as we’d like to see players accept they need to take a cut, not a bloody deferment, of their pay for the good of their club, fans and the game.

I have previously mentioned the beginning of Sky’s monopoly and hopefully in time no need to pay so much to watch football. But during these revenue rises from Tv contracts the players, via their agents, have continually managed to rinse nearly everything out of football.

I’m not sure I agree with footballers deciding that another person is richer than them so they shouldn’t accept a pay cut. If anything they should be more concerned with how the accounts of the club look, and if they knew anything about the effects of their wage demands they’d know the strain that football clubs are under because of the highest cost to the clubs. Themselves. I can’t believe I had to type that out tbh.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Apr 2020 3.22pm)

I get where your coming from, and think players should either take a cut or donate a large sum to charity. Seeing the players car park recently made me realise how sickening the amount of money they have is and how detached they are from the fans.

It just depends on why the are taking a cut, if it was to keep the club alive then great, if the club owners go out and spend millions in the next transfer window the players taking a pay cut are likely to be pissed off.

I know a couple of firms I used to work for have cut staff wages by 15%. The firms arent struggling and set up to work remotely. They are probably saving money on office cost and it seems like profiteering. That sort of behaviour isnt being reported.

With premiership clubs having 25 man squads, that's 500 premiership players who are probably on £1m plus a year... add the championship, we are probably talking about 1000 footballes in the country earning massive amounts.

That's not really a huge number when you consider that there are 150 billionaires in the country with 1000 times more money.

Hence why I think this is a bit of a diversion tactic.

 

Page 7 of 12 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Players' wages