You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Just a bit of perspective.... Please?


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 30 Nov 20 11.21pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

So am I getting this right ? You're slaughtering the manager but advocating making pre-conceived substitutions as per a Sunday League or kids game with no allowance for injuries or what turn the game takes in the first half ? Ridiculous.

Playing less time isn't going to give the players speed or intensity either.

Careful. Posting common sense here often ends up with you being accused of abuse after you defend yourself against an avalanche of accusations of being out of touch.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 20 11.31pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

So am I getting this right ? You're slaughtering the manager but advocating making pre-conceived substitutions as per a Sunday League or kids game with no allowance for injuries or what turn the game takes in the first half ? Ridiculous.

Playing less time isn't going to give the players speed or intensity either.

Older players are not suddenly going to return to the flush of youth, and those lacking pace will not suddenly become greyhounds.
And Benteke won't suddenly become a regular goalscorer!

Our squad with 15 outfield players either 29 or in their 30s will be severely tested due to the congestion of games following on from a truncated pre-season.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 30 Nov 20 11.47pm

Originally posted by Willo

Older players are not suddenly going to return to the flush of youth, and those lacking pace will not suddenly become greyhounds.
And Benteke won't suddenly become a regular goalscorer!

Our squad with 15 outfield players either 29 or in their 30s will be severely tested due to the congestion of games following on from a truncated pre-season.

The Premier League's changed a lot in the last five years or so. There appears little room for players who are slow, even in the areas of the pitch where it traditionally hasn't mattered. Teams also can't afford too many sub 6ft players either.

I find the age of the squad completely unacceptable. You could see how many of the players were in decline last season and we were largely grinding out results through the odd moment of individual brilliance from Ayew and Guaita.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 12.01am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

The Premier League's changed a lot in the last five years or so. There appears little room for players who are slow, even in the areas of the pitch where it traditionally hasn't mattered. Teams also can't afford too many sub 6ft players either.

I find the age of the squad completely unacceptable. You could see how many of the players were in decline last season and we were largely grinding out results through the odd moment of individual brilliance from Ayew and Guaita.

My views on our 'Dad's Army' squad have been well documented. We cannot play vibrant, high-tempo football or press from the front with an ageing squad, short of pace,mobility and creativity.

The football has been turgid, we are a hard watch but quite a few of our players are not the players of yesteryear.The passage of time affects us all! Hodgson can only work with the players at his disposal and his sole objective is to secure PL survival.

Roy Hodgson as manager gets criticised but perhaps one needs to consider the 'Bigger picture'.

Edited by Willo (01 Dec 2020 12.06am)

 

redshift Flag Toronto 01 Dec 20 12.05am

Originally posted by Willo

We generally defend deep as we simply do not have the pace in defence.

I refer back to my previous comments apropos the age of the squad, with 15 players either 30 next year or in their 30s.
In general we don't possess the pace or mobility to play football on the front-foot 'Pressing' teams as others do, so Hodgson has to devise a system with all these contraints.

Most of our players are in the 'Twilight' of their careers and whilst outsiders might highlight certain 'Name' players, I suspect many of our supporters know they are not the players they were and have been on the wane for some time.This is the harsh reality of our situation.

I'm in agreement with you on this point. We just don't have what could be termed an even adequate defense (age & lack of speed impact) so we emphasize shape and everyone tracking back to cover. The hope is then that we can hit them on the counter but lately it seems we can never get enough bodies forward fast enough to do any damage if we do free up the ball, viz Bat's 3 offside goals called back. I'm not sure how to fix that.

Fortunately, there are some really dreadful teams at the bottom now so as long as they don't help themselves in the January window we should be ok.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 12.14am

Originally posted by redshift

I'm in agreement with you on this point. We just don't have what could be termed an even adequate defense (age & lack of speed impact) so we emphasize shape and everyone tracking back to cover. The hope is then that we can hit them on the counter but lately it seems we can never get enough bodies forward fast enough to do any damage if we do free up the ball, viz Bat's 3 offside goals called back. I'm not sure how to fix that.

Fortunately, there are some really dreadful teams at the bottom now so as long as they don't help themselves in the January window we should be ok.

Fulham gained a surprising 2-1 win at Leicester this evening and have now won 2 of their last 4 games.
Burnley of course beat us and this season at home only lost 1-0 to Southampton and Tottenham.
WBA gained their first win at the weekend beating Sheff Utd 1-0 and perhaps the confidence they will have gained from this will stand them in good stead against us!

Long way to go in this unusual season and I suspect a great deal of twists and turns.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Dec 20 8.45am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

So am I getting this right ? You're slaughtering the manager but advocating making pre-conceived substitutions as per a Sunday League or kids game with no allowance for injuries or what turn the game takes in the first half ? Ridiculous.

Playing less time isn't going to give the players speed or intensity either.

Why don’t you try getting your facts right. Where have I slaughtered the manager? I don’t agree with his approach as is my right and I believe his tactical set up and substitutions hinder our progress, again as s my right.

As for the rest, it was suggested by numerous posters that our players are too old to press the opposition and play on the front foot so I merely suggested a way of getting the most out of our older midfielders by getting them to maximise their effort early on and replacing them earlier in the game.

You refer to it as Sunday League or kids football. Well in rugby it’s referred to as impact substitutions for exactly the reason that players have run their balls off and need to be replaced.

You also simplified your point to suit your agenda. What I suggested doesn’t need to be inflexible and with the advent of 5 substitutions is exactly what most teams will be doing.

You are quick to ridicule and protect your precious Roy. Try thinking about the benefits of a different approach that maximises the ability of the limited squad we have.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Dec 20 9.21am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Why don’t you try getting your facts right. Where have I slaughtered the manager? I don’t agree with his approach as is my right and I believe his tactical set up and substitutions hinder our progress, again as s my right.

As for the rest, it was suggested by numerous posters that our players are too old to press the opposition and play on the front foot so I merely suggested a way of getting the most out of our older midfielders by getting them to maximise their effort early on and replacing them earlier in the game.

You refer to it as Sunday League or kids football. Well in rugby it’s referred to as impact substitutions for exactly the reason that players have run their balls off and need to be replaced.

You also simplified your point to suit your agenda. What I suggested doesn’t need to be inflexible and with the advent of 5 substitutions is exactly what most teams will be doing.

You are quick to ridicule and protect your precious Roy. Try thinking about the benefits of a different approach that maximises the ability of the limited squad we have.

And this the man that accuses others of "digging people out" when they post something he disagrees with.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Dec 20 9.35am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

And this the man that accuses others of "digging people out" when they post something he disagrees with.

I think his accusation of others was that they insult posters intelligence if have opposing views. Not sure he has gone anywhere near insulting , just disagreeing, which is what a discussion forum is about, is it not

Edited by Spiderman (01 Dec 2020 9.36am)

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Dec 20 9.53am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I think his accusation of others was that they insult posters intelligence if have opposing views. Not sure he has gone anywhere near insulting , just disagreeing, which is what a discussion forum is about, is it not

Edited by Spiderman (01 Dec 2020 9.36am)

Read this thread and then tell me he doesn't insult people.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

deleted 25 Flag 01 Dec 20 10.02am

Think we should avoid renewing contracts of players over 29 until season is complete.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Dec 20 10.22am

Originally posted by Willo

My views on our 'Dad's Army' squad have been well documented. We cannot play vibrant, high-tempo football or press from the front with an ageing squad, short of pace,mobility and creativity.

The football has been turgid, we are a hard watch but quite a few of our players are not the players of yesteryear.The passage of time affects us all! Hodgson can only work with the players at his disposal and his sole objective is to secure PL survival.

Roy Hodgson as manager gets criticised but perhaps one needs to consider the 'Bigger picture'.

Edited by Willo (01 Dec 2020 12.06am)

I agree with the general thrust of your comments Willo. The bigger picture suggests that the overhaul of the squad is tied into the Academy, which has come to fruition a couple of seasons too late, because we are treading a very fine line with our ageing squad this season. However it is what it is, and should we survive I for one expect to see a very different starting 11 next season. With contract renewals coming up, I think it is fair to say that some players who have been excellent servants for the club cannot compete at this fierce top level anymore. Dann, Ward, Kelly, Jimmy Mac, Townsend, Benteke, all need to be released and replaced.
Obvious Hodgson needs to go too, and a manager who is up to date with modern football and who is good at coaching youngsters needs to be brought in.
A big but necessary task. If Parish has some contingency plans in place it'll be a breeze...

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Dec 2020 10.30am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Dec 20 11.55am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Read this thread and then tell me he doesn't insult people.

What is your problem? You just seem to be unable to discuss the subject matter. The whole basis of your arguments revolve around the person making the comment rather than the matter in hand. There is a pattern to your posting that is mostly antagonistic.

If you cannot simply debate the subject there is no point in conversing with you.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Dec 20 12.03pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I agree with the general thrust of your comments Willo. The bigger picture suggests that the overhaul of the squad is tied into the Academy, which has come to fruition a couple of seasons too late, because we are treading a very fine line with our ageing squad this season. However it is what it is, and should we survive I for one expect to see a very different starting 11 next season. With contract renewals coming up, I think it is fair to say that some players who have been excellent servants for the club cannot compete at this fierce top level anymore. Dann, Ward, Kelly, Jimmy Mac, Townsend, Benteke, all need to be released and replaced.
Obvious Hodgson needs to go too, and a manager who is up to date with modern football and who is good at coaching youngsters needs to be brought in.
A big but necessary task. If Parish has some contingency plans in place it'll be a breeze...

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Dec 2020 10.30am)

We have some decent academy players who dont get on the bench let alone the pitch. If you are losing with your regulars what's the difference losing with a couple of kids. Might as well give it a go early season rather than at the end when your regulars are burnt out and you find out the kids arnt good enough just yet.

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Dec 20 12.30pm

We really need to be addressing the issue of players out of contact in the summer during the January window.
To leave it to the summer would not make sense and would run the risk of a number of players leaving for free in the summer.
For those we have no intention of keeping it surely would be prudent to try and sell them and release some value in January.
That assumes we have adequate cover in their positions.
There are rumours we are in talks with Benteke and Jairo, but I’ve heard nothing about PVA, Townsend, Sakho, Dann, Cahill, Meyer and Guiata.
Doesn’t mean talks aren’t happening, but that’s a lot of players who need their futures resolved.
All these players have a value though which could potentially be lost if it’s all left until the summer when they could potentially walk for free.
I think Riedewald has time remaining on his contract but believe the others finish in the summer.
Some would think for example it would be throwing good money after bad to offer Benteke yet another contract.
But he still has a value in the market which would be lost if his contract runs down.
Should we try and find a buyer in January then?
This approach needs to be considered for the others too, and sooner rather than later.
We’re only a few weeks from January.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 12.40pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

We really need to be addressing the issue of players out of contact in the summer during the January window.
To leave it to the summer would not make sense and would run the risk of a number of players leaving for free in the summer.
For those we have no intention of keeping it surely would be prudent to try and sell them and release some value in January.
That assumes we have adequate cover in their positions.
There are rumours we are in talks with Benteke and Jairo, but I’ve heard nothing about PVA, Townsend, Sakho, Dann, Cahill, Meyer and Guiata.
Doesn’t mean talks aren’t happening, but that’s a lot of players who need their futures resolved.
All these players have a value though which could potentially be lost if it’s all left until the summer when they could potentially walk for free.
I think Riedewald has time remaining on his contract but believe the others finish in the summer.
Some would think for example it would be throwing good money after bad to offer Benteke yet another contract.
But he still has a value in the market which would be lost if his contract runs down.

Should we try and find a buyer in January then?
This approach needs to be considered for the others too, and sooner rather than later.
We’re only a few weeks from January.

Offer a striker in his 30s, who has scored 6 PL goals in the previous 3 seasons an extended contract on £100K+ a week and we just might manage to get £50 in the transfer market.

My instincts would not allow me to gallivant down this path and I suspect supporters would be aghast should Benteke's contract be extended.

Edited by Willo (01 Dec 2020 12.43pm)

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Dec 20 12.45pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

What is your problem? You just seem to be unable to discuss the subject matter. The whole basis of your arguments revolve around the person making the comment rather than the matter in hand. There is a pattern to your posting that is mostly antagonistic.

If you cannot simply debate the subject there is no point in conversing with you.

Edited by PZ Eagle (02 Dec 2020 12.25am)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

PatrickA Flag London 01 Dec 20 1.10pm

My point related to a broader discussion about players out of contract rather than the narrower one about Benteke in isolation.
This needs to start being addressed now rather than in the summer.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Dec 20 1.16pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

My point related to a broader discussion about players out of contract rather than the narrower one about Benteke in isolation.
This needs to start being addressed now rather than in the summer.

It has been reported that talks have begun with the out of contract players.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Dec 20 1.23pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

My point related to a broader discussion about players out of contract rather than the narrower one about Benteke in isolation.
This needs to start being addressed now rather than in the summer.

To renew and revitalise the squad a good few would need to be moved on, for free if need be. There's not much transfer value to be had unless teams in the Championship want to stump up £1/2/3 million for the likes of Ward and Dann. The thought of the Palace gravy train extending contracts to players who are quite frankly finished at this level is baffling. The Premiership is a harsh place.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?