This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Discrimination on the grounds of any protected characteristic is illegal. Whether it's illegal or not 'protected characteristics' are BS.....this is law that didn't exist for most of this country's existence.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
That’s a lie so retract and apologise please. Will you cancel me if I don't then? I or Someone will find it eventually danh then I will allow you to apologise for calling me a liar!
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Will you cancel me if I don't then? I or Someone will find it eventually danh then I will allow you to apologise for calling me a liar! Find what I said, re-read it, realise what you said is completely different and retract and apologise please.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But that is different to positive discrimination, and that is going on right now. Some companies have internal memos promoting wokeness and encouraging the recruitment of minorities. This is fact.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
What did you say? These posts are found with a search.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Can't be arsed to find evidence but it's common knowledge that the public sector (i.e. police force / fire brigade) recruit based on race/gender/sexuality ahead of suitability for the role. I was with a mate on the weekend who told me it's his dream to be a fireman and has had his application rejected 8 years in a row. He is a white, heterosexual male, who is a lovely bloke and as fit as a fiddle... On his 7th attempt a mate of his applied with him who happens to be British/African and has a double barrelled surname, but uses his English surname. Both applications were rejected. The following year, they both applied, but this time his mate used his African surname. Guess what? - he's now a fireman. This was the final straw for my mate who has given up on his dream. He describes his African/British friend as being 'overweight and unfit, so can't fit through small gaps like I could'. This stuff happens and is real. Positive discrimination is racist, bad for society and in this example dangerous when you have the wrong person in a lifesaving job. You must recognise this is a problem? 99% of people couldn't give a toss what their beliefs/sexuality/race is as long they are the best candidate to do the job.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Can't be arsed to find evidence but it's common knowledge that the public sector (i.e. police force / fire brigade) recruit based on race/gender/sexuality ahead of suitability for the role. I was with a mate on the weekend who told me it's his dream to be a fireman and has had his application rejected 8 years in a row. He is a white, heterosexual male, who is a lovely bloke and as fit as a fiddle... On his 7th attempt a mate of his applied with him who happens to be British/African and has a double barrelled surname, but uses his English surname. Both applications were rejected. The following year, they both applied, but this time his mate used his African surname. Guess what? - he's now a fireman. This was the final straw for my mate who has given up on his dream. He describes his African/British friend as being 'overweight and unfit, so can't fit through small gaps like I could'. This stuff happens and is real. Positive discrimination is racist, bad for society and in this example dangerous when you have the wrong person in a lifesaving job. You must recognise this is a problem? 99% of people couldn't give a toss what their beliefs/sexuality/race is as long they are the best candidate to do the job. I would guess you will be told its not true and your mate is lying. Paraphrasing a certain posters response
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Find what I said, re-read it, realise what you said is completely different and retract and apologise please. I doubt it's going to impact your life one way or another. Maybe point me to the thread you supposedly didn't write it on and I will re read it and respond accordingly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Be serious.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I doubt it's going to impact your life one way or another. Maybe point me to the thread you supposedly didn't write it on and I will re read it and respond accordingly. This should of course come bundled with the awareness that if someone was on here saying that their black mate hadn't been promoted in 8 years and it was definitely due to his race, they'd have got laughed off here. Two sides of the same coin.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Will you cancel me if I don't then? I or Someone will find it eventually danh then I will allow you to apologise for calling me a liar! One of you should black up, and you should perpetually fire and hire each other in a piece of public performance art. I'll throw in a tenner!
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Anyway, so whens this report coming out?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Can't be arsed to find evidence but it's common knowledge that the public sector (i.e. police force / fire brigade) recruit based on race/gender/sexuality ahead of suitability for the role. I was with a mate on the weekend who told me it's his dream to be a fireman and has had his application rejected 8 years in a row. He is a white, heterosexual male, who is a lovely bloke and as fit as a fiddle... On his 7th attempt a mate of his applied with him who happens to be British/African and has a double barrelled surname, but uses his English surname. Both applications were rejected. The following year, they both applied, but this time his mate used his African surname. Guess what? - he's now a fireman. This was the final straw for my mate who has given up on his dream. He describes his African/British friend as being 'overweight and unfit, so can't fit through small gaps like I could'. This stuff happens and is real. Positive discrimination is racist, bad for society and in this example dangerous when you have the wrong person in a lifesaving job. You must recognise this is a problem? 99% of people couldn't give a toss what their beliefs/sexuality/race is as long they are the best candidate to do the job.
The name point is interesting, since if taken at face value the implication is that they were looking to fill a quota. An counterpoint is that there have been numerous studies and experiments where CVs/Resumes sent out with the exact same qualifications but some featuring 'western sounding' and some 'foreign sounding' names and the latter received far fewer replies. That feeds into the previous point about why these situations come to exist to begin with. Many would have been silent on these past injustices, viewing them as 'human nature', cultural kinship, or dismissing and demeaning anyone succeeding against the odds as being 'token' anyway. When the shoe is on the other foot though suddenly it's viewed in a different light. The scales of justice are rarely perfectly balanced, but hopefully in time common sense can hold sway rather than quotas or bias in either direction, because I for one would rather appreciate people on their merits than in terms of groups. Beyond that, if someone has been rejected for 8 years in a row it's clearly worth looking beyond solely pinning that on minorities. I know plenty of non white mates who have been rejected for promotion after promotion for years on end. One or two of them put that down to race, but if I'd said that on here, there would have been a peppering of dismissive replies and 'race card' comments. Black or whites, sometimes in life things don't go your way. Whether that's due to ability, being unlucky or unjust outcomes, the best you can do is dust yourself off and find a way to success and prove people wrong. Edited by BlueJay (11 Nov 2021 1.04pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Can't be arsed to find evidence but it's common knowledge that the public sector (i.e. police force / fire brigade) recruit based on race/gender/sexuality ahead of suitability for the role. I was with a mate on the weekend who told me it's his dream to be a fireman and has had his application rejected 8 years in a row. He is a white, heterosexual male, who is a lovely bloke and as fit as a fiddle... On his 7th attempt a mate of his applied with him who happens to be British/African and has a double barrelled surname, but uses his English surname. Both applications were rejected. The following year, they both applied, but this time his mate used his African surname. Guess what? - he's now a fireman. This was the final straw for my mate who has given up on his dream. He describes his African/British friend as being 'overweight and unfit, so can't fit through small gaps like I could'. This stuff happens and is real. Positive discrimination is racist, bad for society and in this example dangerous when you have the wrong person in a lifesaving job. You must recognise this is a problem? 99% of people couldn't give a toss what their beliefs/sexuality/race is as long they are the best candidate to do the job. My Stepson wants to be a Fireman but a mate of mine who has been in there a while now and who is quite senior said that as a 22 year old white male - ex Army by the way - he is in a pool of 25% of those that will be chosen to get the available roles - the other 75% of places will go to female, bame etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
My Stepson wants to be a Fireman but a mate of mine who has been in there a while now and who is quite senior said that as a 22 year old white male - ex Army by the way - he is in a pool of 25% of those that will be chosen to get the available roles - the other 75% of places will go to female, bame etc. Wash your mouth out. Danh wants evidence not just people who it is happening to!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But that is different to positive discrimination, and that is going on right now. Some companies have internal memos promoting wokeness and encouraging the recruitment of minorities. This is fact. Discrimination based upon a protected characteristic is illegal. How many times shall I repeat that? Read the Equality Act 2010. This is fact. Don’t conflate positive action with ‘positive discrimination’.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Discrimination based upon a protected characteristic is illegal. How many times shall I repeat that? Read the Equality Act 2010. This is fact. Don’t conflate positive action with ‘positive discrimination’. Doesn't positive action toward one group discriminate against the others?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Discrimination based upon a protected characteristic is illegal. How many times shall I repeat that? Read the Equality Act 2010. This is fact. Don’t conflate positive action with ‘positive discrimination’.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Doesn't positive action toward one group discriminate against the others? No.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.