You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester United vs. Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 4.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manchester United vs. Crystal Palace match thread


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Dec 21 5.44pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Ayew should only come off the bench late in a match when we are winning. He's a defensive sub, that's it. Or, you can start him in matches where you have no intention of ever scoring a goal.

Schlupp should only come off the bench late in a match when we are losing, and we have no other possible options on the bench. He usually makes one run per appearance, then you never see him again.

Benteke should only start when you've given up trying to pass the ball, and you just want to hoof the ball up to him and hope for a lucky bounce to Wilf.

The past 2 weeks, PV has bemoaned our lack of finishing, then he starts Ayew, Schlupp, and Benteke. Benteke does nothing, Ayew misses a sitter, and Schlupp passively watches Fred boot in the winning goal right past him.

Yes, JMac and Andersen are good players, but we shouldn't look this sh-t. Our bench today was stronger than our starting lineup. It's safe to say that PV has started to lose the plot. Today looked exactly like Royball. Negative lineup, negative football.

So what would you have written if Ayew's attempt hadn't just missed but gone in I wonder, it would've altered what happened after and we may have actually won the game, We lost to Villa by one goal a little undeservedly and then did the same away to Leeds, some games are tough and some fans need to get a grip.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Dec 21 5.47pm

[quote=Den1923;3680536]

Let us not forget that CG could not save WBA or Fulham from the drop and I expect that will also apply to us!

hardly surprising. He’s never played for Fulham!!

 

1969eagle Flag manchester 05 Dec 21 5.49pm

We really miss Anderson. Makes playing out from the back very difficult. McArthur is also a big miss. Ayew is essential when we are defending against much better sides like United. The big test will be when we have players away for Africa nations cup soon (zaha, schlupp, ayew? Kouyate). But good news is that will be an opp for olise Eze and others to start &#129395;

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Dec 21 5.52pm

Plan B is urgently required. Don’t ask me what that is. I know we are missing Jimmy and Anderson badly but we have Eze Olise Edouard to name others all ready.
We need something different.

 

The Dolphin Flag 05 Dec 21 5.59pm

If Burnley win their game in hand then we are 3 points above the drop zone albeit with a better goal difference.
I am worried because we have repeated the same mistakes and played the same misshapen way for 270 mins now.
Concerned!

Edited by The Dolphin (05 Dec 2021 6.00pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Dec 21 6.04pm

But Ayew didn't score, as he hasn't supposedly in around the last 30 odd games.
To apply this logic you might as well say Ayew cost us 2 points v Brighton as we would have beaten them if Ayew had taken his chance. It's futile to refer to what might have been.
Furthermore, we were not unlucky v Villa and deserved to lose against an average side on the day.
It's perfectly legitimate to question our recent performances rather than look for weak excuses and be told to 'get a grip.'
It is after all a game of opinions and being a supporter doesn't mean not being able to question recent performances or Ayew's goalscoring record.

Originally posted by Tickled pink

So what would you have written if Ayew's attempt hadn't just missed but gone in I wonder, it would've altered what happened after and we may have actually won the game, We lost to Villa by one goal a little undeservedly and then did the same away to Leeds, some games are tough and some fans need to get a grip.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 05 Dec 21 6.58pm

I think Ayew may have been offside even if he had scored.

 

Hannes Flag Vienna 05 Dec 21 7.00pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I think Ayew may have been offside even if he had scored.

This was also my first impression.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 05 Dec 21 7.18pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

I think Ayew may have been offside even if he had scored.

No he wasn't. 2 others were who, if they had got a touch on it would meant it would of been disallowed but Ayew was fine.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Dec 21 7.22pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

We miss them but it's more than that. We have been worked out, as we always would be. We are being pressed before we can press. Gallagher has been recognised as our main creative player and the link we always look for and he is being given no time and crowded out. This is now a real challenge for our management team. We weren't just second best today, we were third or fourth best. The ref and the crowd played better and we were lucky to get 0 goals the lack of belief we showed.

As much as it pains me to say it, I agree with you, although we should be fitting Eze into the team who will put a foot on it and lift his head, something Kouyate struggles with.

 

ATL Eagle Flag Atlanta 05 Dec 21 7.24pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

We miss them but it's more than that. We have been worked out, as we always would be. We are being pressed before we can press. Gallagher has been recognised as our main creative player and the link we always look for and he is being given no time and crowded out. This is now a real challenge for our management team. We weren't just second best today, we were third or fourth best. The ref and the crowd played better and we were lucky to get 0 goals the lack of belief we showed.

Basically agree with this analysis.
And the lack of Andersen as the one player in the back line who wants to push up and can pass with pinpoint accuracy.
And Jimmy Mac being an attack dog in midfield.

Wilf and Benteke are history. They need to be dropped, because they are not playing for the team. They are playing for themselves. Ayew is partially guilty of this too.
Olise needs to start but maybe someone should tell him his dead balls should clear the first defender.

 

ATL Eagle Flag Atlanta 05 Dec 21 7.25pm

Kouyaté. I love him, and he loves Palace. But he is playing Royball. Can PV teach him to turn with the ball and look to play it forwards? If not, he has to go too.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Dec 21 7.26pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

But Ayew didn't score, as he hasn't supposedly in around the last 30 odd games.
To apply this logic you might as well say Ayew cost us 2 points v Brighton as we would have beaten them if Ayew had taken his chance. It's futile to refer to what might have been.
Furthermore, we were not unlucky v Villa and deserved to lose against an average side on the day.
It's perfectly legitimate to question our recent performances rather than look for weak excuses and be told to 'get a grip.'
It is after all a game of opinions and being a supporter doesn't mean not being able to question recent performances or Ayew's goalscoring record.

A certain manager had come in against us with Villa as the same today and it creates a lift as you know and I wouldn't ever class Villa as average.
Our position in the table is one I didn't expect, I really thought we'd be struggling this season to keep out of the bottom three and have been pleasantly surprised with the players we now have and the football which is being implemented, to say the things many fans have been saying is quite freighting when considering everything that's happened so far, yes our last three defeats looks bad but they could've quite easily have been three draws so I'm not too bothered especially when also considering we could've easily prevented two of those losses with a little more competence and concentration which can also be fixed in our new training facilities ..another thing I wasn't expecting.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Dec 21 7.32pm

Originally posted by ATL Eagle

Kouyaté. I love him, and he loves Palace. But he is playing Royball. Can PV teach him to turn with the ball and look to play it forwards? If not, he has to go too.

He shouldn't be played in the middle, he should be played at the back.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 05 Dec 21 7.35pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He shouldn't be played in the middle, he should be played at the back.

Really? When our new philosophy is about playing out from the back? God no...

Kouyate should be used to harass and tackle against the good teams. Every other game he should be on the bench. I like him and his energy...but he's not great at football.

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Dec 21 8.06pm

The important thing is that Vieira recognised the failings against both Villa and today and did not seek to make excuses about facing new manager bounce.
From the press conference today he said,
- we weren’t brave enough on the ball
- we didn’t play between the lines to give them problems
- there were too many long balls
- our forwards didn’t hold the ball up well enough.
He thought we did quite well defensively but not offensively.
This gives the impression that the team didn’t play as instructed and I’ve no doubt changes will be made if this pattern continues.
And this is at should be - no favourites.
We have the squad now to make changes.
He also said he had planned to give Hughes some time today, but when we went a goal behind he put on more attacking players instead.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Dec 21 9.18pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio


that was probably the weakest ManUre we have faced in many years.

its a pity Ayew missed, but i have run out of patience with both him and Benteke.

I thought Wilf was worse.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Dec 21 9.18pm

Originally posted by sprites

Really? When our new philosophy is about playing out from the back? God no...

Kouyate should be used to harass and tackle against the good teams. Every other game he should be on the bench. I like him and his energy...but he's not great at football.

There is no set up where any player is useful if his passing is below the standard required, he had a bad day at the office highlighted by the standards of the opposition ..which also highlights the reason why he plays for us.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Dec 21 9.48pm

Originally posted by chris123

I thought Wilf was worse.

Benteke and Ayew are easy targets sadly.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Dec 21 9.59pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

The important thing is that Vieira recognised the failings against both Villa and today and did not seek to make excuses about facing new manager bounce.
From the press conference today he said,
- we weren’t brave enough on the ball
- we didn’t play between the lines to give them problems
- there were too many long balls
- our forwards didn’t hold the ball up well enough.
He thought we did quite well defensively but not offensively.
This gives the impression that the team didn’t play as instructed and I’ve no doubt changes will be made if this pattern continues.
And this is at should be - no favourites.
We have the squad now to make changes.
He also said he had planned to give Hughes some time today, but when we went a goal behind he put on more attacking players instead.

It gives me the impression that the opposition prevented us from playing as instructed.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester United vs. Crystal Palace match thread