This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't think anyone with even the slightest recall over history can think of the Russians as the 'good guys' as it were. I think the historical memory of the Soviets in Eastern Europe is wholly justified...not least in Ukraine itself. Invading Ukraine, regardless of perspective can't be seen as a reasonable response. God knows how many innocent people have perished already. I think we had a genuine gold plated opportunity there in the nineties and even early on with Putin up to 2004 but I think it was wasted for various reasons but I've gone on about that previously and I'm not eager for more navel gazing. What's important is how the west tackles the moves from here and our own government seems more up for a fist fight than anything else. The Americans also seem more interested in a 'let's bleed the Russians' in Ukraine strategy all the while the wider world outside of the west shrugs its shoulders and plays both. I think the Ukraine army should be proud of themselves but from what I'm hearing there is going to be a major battle in the Donbas and a lot of soldiers and of course civilians are going to die.....We know that the Russian speakers in those areas want to be Russian anyway so this all seems like a pointless bloodbath for territory that's going anyway. One part of me respects the right to fight and die fighting the invaders while the other part sees....what I think most of us realise what will be the basics of the peace treaty and it just looks like lives are being thrown away in the south east. I think four weeks ago Konstantin Kisin said a lot of things on the topic that are still relevant a month on. Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Apr 2022 1.44am) On what basis do you make this assertion? I think it is an assumption based on Putin's propaganda, but one that isn't actually backed up by facts. Yes, they held a referendum but, as with the similar one held in Crimea, it was not recognised as valid anywhere other than in Russia, asked a heavily loaded question and the people voted under duress. Independent polls taken at the same time indicated only around 18% of the people wanted the region to become Russian. The others wanted to remain part of Ukraine, some with a federated status, others fully integrated. I fear you are swallowing propaganda. Even though you are right to fear what could be coming down the line in the east, I don't believe it has anything to do with the people's wishes there. This is 100% Putin's own agenda.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
On what basis do you make this assertion? I think it is an assumption based on Putin's propaganda, but one that isn't actually backed up by facts. Yes, they held a referendum but, as with the similar one held in Crimea, it was not recognised as valid anywhere other than in Russia, asked a heavily loaded question and the people voted under duress. Independent polls taken at the same time indicated only around 18% of the people wanted the region to become Russian. The others wanted to remain part of Ukraine, some with a federated status, others fully integrated. I fear you are swallowing propaganda. Even though you are right to fear what could be coming down the line in the east, I don't believe it has anything to do with the people's wishes there. This is 100% Putin's own agenda. While I didn't agree with the coup that happened in Ukraine I also didn't agree with Russia walking into the Crimea and just annexing it either. However, I've looked for and didn't find your '18% of the people wanted the region to become Russian' poll so if you link me to that it would be interesting. What I did find was the following: Polling in 2008 by the Ukrainian Centre for Economic and Political Studies, found that 63.8% of Crimeans (76% of ethnic Russians, 55% of ethnic Ukrainians, and 14% of ethnic Crimean Tatars, respectively) would like Crimea to secede from Ukraine and join Russia. On March 12 – 14, 2014, Germany's largest pollster, the GfK Group, conducted a survey with 600 respondents and found that 70.6% of Crimeans intended to vote for joining Russia. Gallup conducted an immediate post-referendum survey of Ukraine and Crimea and published their results in April 2014. Gallup reported that, among the population of Crimea, 93.6% of ethnic Russians and 68.4% of ethnic Ukrainians believed the referendum result accurately represents the will of the Crimean people. Only 1.7% of ethnic Russians and 14.5% of ethnic Ukrainians living in Crimea thought that the referendum results didn't accurately reflect the views of the Crimean people.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
It was Hitler's favourite excuse for annexations too - they are German speaking and want to be part of Germany.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The groover
russia accounts for 12% of the worlds oil and 24% of gas. That makes up 45% of russia's trade income. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that if the west reduces its reliance on that then the russian economy is screwed. Other countries will be circling like vultures to take up the slack. We are also looking to start using Hydrogen in place of gas. This will accelerate that as well. This at a time when we are trying to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels over all as well. Its just going to push countries into doing that faster. It will also result in oil companies opening up wells that were previously uneconomical. Just as BP are doing in the north sea. If as seems may happen, russia defaults on its loans then the place will implode. Anyone that thinks russia will do well out of this war is living in cuckoo land. I honestly don't think you have been following what's happening. Russia's economy, like the west's is suffering, however it's being re-routed. They are already making deals around the world, with India for example, for their resources....Also, their importance in farming resources are significant. I'm hoping that there are easy ways around that. I think your view that green energy is going to take up the slack is about as realistic as Johnson's. The scale of what you are talking about is enormous. A cold war is a disaster both militarily and economically. The living standards of everyone...but especially the poor and vulnerable are those who suffer over bad long term decisions.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
It was Hitler's favourite excuse for annexations too - they are German speaking and want to be part of Germany. It's no different to what's happened around the world for thousands of years. England literally use to be split up into separate kingdoms. Besides no one is actually supporting what Putin did anyway.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
While I didn't agree with the coup that happened in Ukraine I also didn't agree with Russia walking into the Crimea and just annexing it either. However, I've looked for and didn't find your '18% of the people wanted the region to become Russian' poll so if you link me to that it would be interesting. What I did find was the following: Polling in 2008 by the Ukrainian Centre for Economic and Political Studies, found that 63.8% of Crimeans (76% of ethnic Russians, 55% of ethnic Ukrainians, and 14% of ethnic Crimean Tatars, respectively) would like Crimea to secede from Ukraine and join Russia. On March 12 – 14, 2014, Germany's largest pollster, the GfK Group, conducted a survey with 600 respondents and found that 70.6% of Crimeans intended to vote for joining Russia. Gallup conducted an immediate post-referendum survey of Ukraine and Crimea and published their results in April 2014. Gallup reported that, among the population of Crimea, 93.6% of ethnic Russians and 68.4% of ethnic Ukrainians believed the referendum result accurately represents the will of the Crimean people. Only 1.7% of ethnic Russians and 14.5% of ethnic Ukrainians living in Crimea thought that the referendum results didn't accurately reflect the views of the Crimean people. This is the Pew research poll:- Unsurprisingly, it's complicated and this gives some interesting background:-
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm no expert on these matters but from what I hear 83 percent of the world's energy relies upon oil and gas. From that I have no problem with green energy being expanded but I do have a problem with it being relied upon. Surely we need to be fracking.....We need to be building nuclear at affordable prices. Why are our energy needs even something that's an issue? This is a fundamental of civilisational competence. That was my instinct too, but I heard a German politician raise a point I hadn't thought of earlier today. Which is that the way the Russians attacked Chernobyl ought to give us pause for thought. A missile attack on a nuclear facility could be a disaster, so whether, and how, we can build safe reactors is a really big question. If we can build safe command bunkers, it ought to be possible, but current designs don't look adequate.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That was my instinct too, but I heard a German politician raise a point I hadn't thought of earlier today. Which is that the way the Russians attacked Chernobyl ought to give us pause for thought. A missile attack on a nuclear facility could be a disaster, so whether, and how, we can build safe reactors is a really big question. If we can build safe command bunkers, it ought to be possible, but current designs don't look adequate. That would be a red flag to push the button for sure.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This is the Pew research poll:- Unsurprisingly, it's complicated and this gives some interesting background:- I can instantly see that the top poll references Ukrainians as a whole and not Crimea. That wasn't what I was saying. Anyway like I said, I didn't agree with the coup but I also didn't agree with the annexation. Pretty much everything that's happened in the Ukraine has been from foreign meddling and pretty much for all its history as its a mixture of regional ethnic groups. There's a family party today that we are hosting so I'm off to cook muffins and pancakes but I'll have a peep back later.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That was my instinct too, but I heard a German politician raise a point I hadn't thought of earlier today. Which is that the way the Russians attacked Chernobyl ought to give us pause for thought. A missile attack on a nuclear facility could be a disaster, so whether, and how, we can build safe reactors is a really big question. If we can build safe command bunkers, it ought to be possible, but current designs don't look adequate. Saw you post just before I sign off. I agree, while I think its vital and that modern nuclear designs make accidents practically impossible I do agree that nuclear needs to be built underground for this reason. Every problem has a mitigation. A lot of the future involves underground, including travelling I think, something Musk is working on. Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Apr 2022 11.12am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I honestly don't think you have been following what's happening. Russia's economy, like the west's is suffering, however it's being re-routed. They are already making deals around the world, with India for example, for their resources....Also, their importance in farming resources are significant. I'm hoping that there are easy ways around that. I think your view that green energy is going to take up the slack is about as realistic as Johnson's. The scale of what you are talking about is enormous. A cold war is a disaster both militarily and economically. The living standards of everyone...but especially the poor and vulnerable are those who suffer over bad long term decisions. I follow what is happening very closely indeed. Just because I didn't mention something does not mean I don't know about it. It was a post not a thesis! I didn't say green energy would take up the slack. I said other countries. Saudi has already said they are increasing output. The US has released oil reserves. Probably after saudi said they would up output to replenish them. Don't get me wrong I don't like SA's attitude either. Countries that align themselves with russia could be making a rod for their own backs. The west could easily pull the plug on them as well. Look at china, russia's so called 'best friend' Remarkably silent. Why? Because they know that they do 2% of their business with russia and most of the rest with the west. That's a big risk putting all your eggs in that one basket. And india and the like would never take up as much oil and gas as the west do. Plus they will almost certainly have to sell it cheaper than the market price or why would india buy it! Europe takes 75% of russia's gas exports!!!! Or did.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The groover
I follow what is happening very closely indeed. Just because I didn't mention something does not mean I don't know about it. It was a post not a thesis! I didn't say green energy would take up the slack. I said other countries. Saudi has already said they are increasing output. The US has released oil reserves. Probably after saudi said they would up output to replenish them. Don't get me wrong I don't like SA's attitude either. Countries that align themselves with russia could be making a rod for their own backs. The west could easily pull the plug on them as well. Look at china, russia's so called 'best friend' Remarkably silent. Why? Because they know that they do 2% of their business with russia and most of the rest with the west. That's a big risk putting all your eggs in that one basket. And india and the like would never take up as much oil and gas as the west do. Plus they will almost certainly have to sell it cheaper than the market price or why would india buy it! Europe takes 75% of russia's gas exports!!!! Or did. Wouldn't bullying countries to our will be modern imperialism? Anyway Groover, I have to admit looking at the economic options for the west and Russia/China is just all a bit depressing. What I'd rather know is what has happened over at Comrades?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Wouldn't bullying countries to our will be modern imperialism? Anyway Groover, I have to admit looking at the economic options for the west and Russia/China is just all a bit depressing. What I'd rather know is what has happened over at Comrades? The site was attacked because of the site owner's constant pro Russia, anti Western stance. I have zero sympathy. The guy had it coming.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The site was attacked because of the site owner's constant pro Russia, anti Western stance. I have zero sympathy. The guy had it coming. Not really anti west but massively pro russia to the point where main stream news was not watched but pro russian news was. That's why I left. I couldn't square posting there and putting my name on the list for having a Ukrainian family stay with us. I've meet him a few times and had a beer. He is a lovely bloke and I would happily do so again. Just would have to agree to not discuss the war. Unless I had any of the Ukrainians with me of course! I left the BBS as well because its full of cry babies and people whose debate method is to call people racists/fascists etc. There is also a clique that pick on posters until they leave. They must be running out of targets by now! You could type a 200 word post and some b*llend would just reply Racist!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Wouldn't bullying countries to our will be modern imperialism? Anyway Groover, I have to admit looking at the economic options for the west and Russia/China is just all a bit depressing. What I'd rather know is what has happened over at Comrades?
Its the difference between right and wrong. putin is a loon and has to be reigned in. I have no issue with russia or its people. Just as we are now best of friends with Germany. There are so many issues in the world right now and turning a blind eye is just not working. Maybe this will be the catalyst for some good to come out of it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The groover
Its the difference between right and wrong. putin is a loon and has to be reigned in. I have no issue with russia or its people. Just as we are now best of friends with Germany. There are so many issues in the world right now and turning a blind eye is just not working. Maybe this will be the catalyst for some good to come out of it. Well we probably won't agree on much but it's good to see you here.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The site was attacked because of the site owner's constant pro Russia, anti Western stance. I have zero sympathy. The guy had it coming. I quite liked the site but I did get the impression that they wanted the more conservative voices off of there and what happened with you kind of confirmed that. I noticed it's back but moving the Politics link right down the list really miffed me off. Still, Comrades has/had good posters on it....Chris was excellent (is he still on there?) and I kind of got on with most. I think my attitude towards the Russia/Ukrainian war is closest to Hungray's Orban....I seem to be where Orban is on a lot of politics. I'm not pro Russian, anyone who has read my posts over the years knows that I'm pro English/British/pan European. Mostly I'm pro getting out of this war with the least death and the least damage to the west....and I'm not interested in hurting anyone. It's like a game of chess and my study of the board is that we have the black pieces and the position isn't as good as some think. But unlike chess where one side wins or draws here I think everybody loses and it's just about the extent. I guess that explains why I'm so annoyed about us being in that position in the first place but we move on. Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Apr 2022 11.20pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The site was attacked because of the site owner's constant pro Russia, anti Western stance. I have zero sympathy. The guy had it coming. I only ever had the odd nose around there, but I can't really say that I'm all that in favour of sites being attacked and closing their doors because of the owners opinion on an issue.. And if BBS is 'more appalling' should that close its doors too? Realistically we should be defending them to the hilt, regardless of their owners views or site moderation style. Where that doesn't happen it hardly puts HOL in a great position.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.