This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
Funny game today. Despite being poor in the first half it looked from the away end like we still had the chances to go in level at half time. Also both Eze and Zaha scored great goals despite not being particularly effective. The last few games and today in particular have IMO exposed why Olise was a bargain (8£mil ?) and not three times what we paid. His right foot isn't just weak it's non-existent and might stop his progress. Class from James McArthur turning his first half performance into the best player on the pitch in the second half. Yh it’s not like Olise only had an 8 mil release clause. Also not like he got a class assist from a cross with his right foot against Burnley. Might stop his progress… crazy
|
|
|
Originally posted by Luarddd
Yh it’s not like Olise only had an 8 mil release clause. Also not like he got a class assist from a cross with his right foot against Burnley. Might stop his progress… crazy Not crazy at all. First rule of defending is to show the player onto his weaker foot. As I said a still a bargain.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Living In Hope
I only get to a few games each season, but I've seen the last two (Leeds and Southampton). Our centre-back combination is top class - I think we'll have a real problem with our style of play if either of them has a lengthy absence. Clyne has had 2 cracking games and is surely 1st choice right back, even though Wardy played well v Leeds (not so today though). Eze has been struggling, no idea how some have him as MOTM today, but let's hope today's goal helps restore his confidence and we start to see once again the excellent player he is. I can't understand the criticism of Wilf from some - still our best player, it's just that we are no longer totally reliant on him. I am also sick and tired of prats like Philips saying he dives. You can criticise Gallagher and Ayew for going down too easily, not Wilf, who is constantly fouled. Mateta, bless him and his huge effort, but not a PL quality player in my view. I know I'll wind up people in saying it, but the difference when Tekkers came on v Leeds was huge. His technical ability was so far above Mateta. Appreciate Mateta gets points for movement and effort, but I can't see him as our future. Anyway, fantastic day to see Palace win late, and PV takes huge credit for Palace trying to win away rather than not lose. 100%. Mateta at his absolute best is marginally better than Tekkers and Eduoard at their worst. He’s not the answer. New striker top priority.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
The mind boggles doesnt it , VAR was brought in to catch these things that the blind ref and the lines and the 4th offical miss but it seems to make it more controversial and all depends on the badge on the shirt cough (Liverpool ) , we must have done something to upset the powers that be , we just dont seem to get a fair game anymore . VAR can review without a stoppage of play, right? Based on what I saw, the defender did reach in and step on Gallagher's "toe" but it was hard to tell if he caught much of the boot or really just a sliver where the upper meets the sole plate. In my view, there wasn't enough to overturn the no-call. It doesn't help Gallagher that he goes down a little too quickly. If I were in his boots, I'd be a bit more judicious about going to ground – it's a boy who cried wolf thing, similar to that of the old Wilf. Going down easily/animatedly ends up hurting them when they actually get fouled.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Living In Hope
I only get to a few games each season, but I've seen the last two (Leeds and Southampton). Our centre-back combination is top class - I think we'll have a real problem with our style of play if either of them has a lengthy absence. Clyne has had 2 cracking games and is surely 1st choice right back, even though Wardy played well v Leeds (not so today though). Eze has been struggling, no idea how some have him as MOTM today, but let's hope today's goal helps restore his confidence and we start to see once again the excellent player he is. I can't understand the criticism of Wilf from some - still our best player, it's just that we are no longer totally reliant on him. I am also sick and tired of prats like Philips saying he dives. You can criticise Gallagher and Ayew for going down too easily, not Wilf, who is constantly fouled. Mateta, bless him and his huge effort, but not a PL quality player in my view. I know I'll wind up people in saying it, but the difference when Tekkers came on v Leeds was huge. His technical ability was so far above Mateta. Appreciate Mateta gets points for movement and effort, but I can't see him as our future. Anyway, fantastic day to see Palace win late, and PV takes huge credit for Palace trying to win away rather than not lose.
gloryhunter (eagle in exile) |
|
|
Originally posted by gloryhunter
It was no lost cause but a well judged pass from Ayew. And Mateta started the move FYI
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
Not crazy at all. First rule of defending is to show the player onto his weaker foot. As I said a still a bargain. Doesn’t seem to have stopped Mahrez being a very good player
|
|
|
Originally posted by CT Charlie
VAR can review without a stoppage of play, right? Based on what I saw, the defender did reach in and step on Gallagher's "toe" but it was hard to tell if he caught much of the boot or really just a sliver where the upper meets the sole plate. In my view, there wasn't enough to overturn the no-call. It doesn't help Gallagher that he goes down a little too quickly. If I were in his boots, I'd be a bit more judicious about going to ground – it's a boy who cried wolf thing, similar to that of the old Wilf. Going down easily/animatedly ends up hurting them when they actually get fouled. 100% Salah would have got that, he goes to ground very easily. As CT said it depends on what badge you have on your shirt, always has always will
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
100% Salah would have got that, he goes to ground very easily. As CT said it depends on what badge you have on your shirt, always has always will Yup. Even the pundits buy into it. If Salah, Mane etc etc get a soft penalty, it's: "there was definitely contact; he had every right to go down" When the likes of us are denied a spot-kick, it's: "there was barely any contact; he goes down far too easily"
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Yup. Even the pundits buy into it. If Salah, Mane etc etc get a soft penalty, it's: "there was definitely contact; he had every right to go down" When the likes of us are denied a spot-kick, it's: "there was barely any contact; he goes down far too easily" Liverpool would have been six goals up by then mind
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Yup. Even the pundits buy into it. If Salah, Mane etc etc get a soft penalty, it's: "there was definitely contact; he had every right to go down" When the likes of us are denied a spot-kick, it's: "there was barely any contact; he goes down far too easily" Absolutely right. The pundit yesterday dismissed it without giving it much thought other than the “he goes down too easily” and “not all contact is a penalty” . It was a foul, not a bad one, but a foul none the less, his foot got in front of Gallagher’s foot, missed the ball and there was contact. Salah would definitely have got that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by gloryhunter
1. on MOTD Jenas gave a good explanation of how the injury impacted Eze as he had the same one himself. After recovery the muscles around the ankle still lack that explosive power to get past a player over 5 yards. This explains why fans moan that Eze ambles around and doesn't take people on. The good news is that it looks like he is getting his fitness back so as other have said if he has a good end to the season and a good pre season hopefully he will be back to full fitness. 2. Clyne seems to be getting better and better starting to look like his old self. I am not sure we need AWB if he keeps performing.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
1. on MOTD Jenas gave a good explanation of how the injury impacted Eze as he had the same one himself. After recovery the muscles around the ankle still lack that explosive power to get past a player over 5 yards. This explains why fans moan that Eze ambles around and doesn't take people on. The good news is that it looks like he is getting his fitness back so as other have said if he has a good end to the season and a good pre season hopefully he will be back to full fitness. 2. Clyne seems to be getting better and better starting to look like his old self. I am not sure we need AWB if he keeps performing. . When Nat was here previously i thought he was the best RB we've ever had, even better than Doris.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
1. on MOTD Jenas gave a good explanation of how the injury impacted Eze as he had the same one himself. After recovery the muscles around the ankle still lack that explosive power to get past a player over 5 yards. This explains why fans moan that Eze ambles around and doesn't take people on. The good news is that it looks like he is getting his fitness back so as other have said if he has a good end to the season and a good pre season hopefully he will be back to full fitness. 2. Clyne seems to be getting better and better starting to look like his old self. I am not sure we need AWB if he keeps performing. Very much agree with both points. Will also add for Eze that speed was never his ‘thing’. He seems to do better with his deception and movement in leaving players chasing shadows as opposed to just breezing past them, saw a bit of that yesterday so hopefully he won’t be too effected. With regards to Clyne, I said something similar after Leeds. He looked low on confidence for me at the beginning of the season but now looks to be regaining that including the confidence in his own ability. Let’s hope he’s on an upwards trajectory and my personal right-back anxiety may start to diminish. Still buzzing after yesterday! COYP!!!!!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
. When Nat was here previously i thought he was the best RB we've ever had, even better than Doris. Yep, me too.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Can anyone explain why the foul on Gallagher didn’t appear to be looked at by VAR? It was looked at, commentator mentions it on the MOTD review. What is even more boggling is, why didn't VAR give it? It's a clear pen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
100%. Mateta at his absolute best is marginally better than Tekkers and Eduoard at their worst. He’s not the answer. New striker top priority. I was in boxpark arfter the semi final and Andy Johnson was on stage saying we need a 20 gaal a season striker. Teend to agree with him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
. When Nat was here previously i thought he was the best RB we've ever had, even better than Doris. Paddy Mulligan wasnt bad
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.