You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > New prime minister
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

New prime minister


Page 7 of 37 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
nead1 Flag 28 Sep 22 7.11pm

Really - "is it as bad as the moaners are saying; no it is not"

That's certainly not my view. the Bank of England having to intervene to essentially prop up pension funds that are on the risk of default. £5bn a day for 13 days to try and stabilise things!

Not only was the whole "fiscal event" incredibly ill judged but on a philosophical level, why should we be borrowing to fund tax cuts for highly paid people? Equally, the whole package set the Govt on a collision course with the Bank of England - one trying to control inflation and the other stoking it up. No wonder there was no Office of Budget Responsibility analysis undertaken.

The Govt "strategy" if you can call it that, is, of course the dream of the Brexit idealogues; low tax, de-regulate and create the Singapore on Thames so many of them endlessly talk about. Small wonder that John Redwood was sent out to defend it!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Sep 22 7.38pm

Originally posted by nead1

Really - "is it as bad as the moaners are saying; no it is not"

That's certainly not my view. the Bank of England having to intervene to essentially prop up pension funds that are on the risk of default. £5bn a day for 13 days to try and stabilise things!

Not only was the whole "fiscal event" incredibly ill judged but on a philosophical level, why should we be borrowing to fund tax cuts for highly paid people? Equally, the whole package set the Govt on a collision course with the Bank of England - one trying to control inflation and the other stoking it up. No wonder there was no Office of Budget Responsibility analysis undertaken.

The Govt "strategy" if you can call it that, is, of course the dream of the Brexit idealogues; low tax, de-regulate and create the Singapore on Thames so many of them endlessly talk about. Small wonder that John Redwood was sent out to defend it!

I honestly thought this benefited all workers who pay tax and NI.
Is that not the case? If it’s the case then the fact the rich get more is just maths surely? I read somewhere that the high band tax take at 40% was more pro rata than at 45% since it’s inception. Again I could be mistaken.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Sep 22 11.22am

'Truss and Treasury secretary fail to reassure markets as bond yields rise, stock market tumbles and pound slides'.

What economic growth can actually result from handing the rich a tax-break, something so miniscule it cannot be measured.

This whole disaster is actually bad for growth, a long recession is now forecast all this pain for families and businesses was totally avoidable.

It is not as if the actually had a forecast or any figures to show us, because they were not in control from day one and haven't got a clue what they are doing.


 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Sep 22 12.39pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'Truss and Treasury secretary fail to reassure markets as bond yields rise, stock market tumbles and pound slides'.

What economic growth can actually result from handing the rich a tax-break, something so miniscule it cannot be measured.

This whole disaster is actually bad for growth, a long recession is now forecast all this pain for families and businesses was totally avoidable.

It is not as if the actually had a forecast or any figures to show us, because they were not in control from day one and haven't got a clue what they are doing.


What amuses me is how the opposition and other interested parties who stand to benefit from the current situation are making the problem worse by being negative and spreading doom and gloom.

Keir Starmer cares not one hoot for the common man. His only interest is political gain.

I have just lost 8k on an investment hub, wiping out half of a decade of gain. Even property value seems under threat now. Most people will suffer from the current economic climate to a greater or lesser extent, and maybe, just maybe, the Lefty media, the opposition and idiot Tory back benchers should have thought about the consequences of ousting Johnson and his cabinet during a period of upheaval.

Did it serve anyone or anything except their careers and their blinkered ideology?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Sep 22 1.09pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'Truss and Treasury secretary fail to reassure markets as bond yields rise, stock market tumbles and pound slides'.

What economic growth can actually result from handing the rich a tax-break, something so miniscule it cannot be measured.

This whole disaster is actually bad for growth, a long recession is now forecast all this pain for families and businesses was totally avoidable.

It is not as if the actually had a forecast or any figures to show us, because they were not in control from day one and haven't got a clue what they are doing.


Apart from energy prices, we are in the same boat than a lot of the world. this isnt just a UK problem.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Sep 22 1.51pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Apart from energy prices, we are in the same boat than a lot of the world. this isnt just a UK problem.

The rest of the world has not had a Truss mini-budget.

And there is no gain, only pain.

 

The Dolphin Flag 29 Sep 22 2.26pm

Anyone care to mention the £ is close to $1.1 - thought not.
Still low but rising for now!

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 29 Sep 22 7.17pm

How long have these clowns got before we can get rid of them? The Tories will probably struggle for decades if they don't turn their ship.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 29 Sep 22 7.53pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Apart from energy prices, we are in the same boat than a lot of the world. this isnt just a UK problem.

Everyone knows the run on the pound and the intervention of the BofE is a result of the mini budget other than the delusional.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Sep 22 7.59pm

'Claiming that cutting taxes on the richest individuals and largest companies will lead to a surge in economic growth betrays a wilful naivety'.

Labour building massive lead in the polls, one has 33 points lead.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 29 Sep 22 8.18pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

How long have these clowns got before we can get rid of them? The Tories will probably struggle for decades if they don't turn their ship.

If things get much worse, when you ring the ground to ask what time kick off is, they will say ‘What time can you make it for sir. ‘

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Sep 22 8.48pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'Claiming that cutting taxes on the richest individuals and largest companies will lead to a surge in economic growth betrays a wilful naivety'.

Labour building massive lead in the polls, one has 33 points lead.

Yup I hope they win. I don’t recall a time when they got into power and the bank account was empty which may be the case. Very interesting if it happens. How long will they blame the tories for when it fails so very badly. Cmon kier do the business and sort this country out. It’s simple as all you need to do is bring down the 40% tax bracket to 35k. I mean earning that much makes you seriously minted.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 29 Sep 22 9.51pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

If things get much worse, when you ring the ground to ask what time kick off is, they will say ‘What time can you make it for sir. ‘

Never Truss a Tory ... they're either incompetent or lie through their teeth. However, you can always be assured of their self-interest.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 29 Sep 22 10.39pm

This is as big a political crisis as I can remember, the consequences of which could easily see the break-up of the UK.

Now it's down to Parliament to sort out. I just hope they don't bottle it as they did prior to the 2019 GE when they had the chance to avoid Brexit, but failed to grasp the nettle. At least we don't have Corbyn to deal with now.

Parliament can reject the tax cuts and instruct the government to rethink. If they refuse then they have a vote of no confidence and the 1922 Committee rewrites the rules on how a new PM is chosen and the MPs themselves choose Truss's successor.

If that doesn't happen, we appear to be headed to a coalition at the next GE between Labour, the Liberals and the SNP, who will demand a binding referendum as the cost of their support.

Should that happen, in the current climate even I would vote for independence if I was a Scot.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Sep 22 10.46pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'Claiming that cutting taxes on the richest individuals and largest companies will lead to a surge in economic growth betrays a wilful naivety'.

Labour building massive lead in the polls, one has 33 points lead.


Dear oh Dear

Even if I was informed that my Tories were ahead by 33 points, I would hardly be whooping for joy as the General Election is 2 years away and the political landscape could change dramatically as events unfold.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Sep 22 5.38am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This is as big a political crisis as I can remember, the consequences of which could easily see the break-up of the UK.

Now it's down to Parliament to sort out. I just hope they don't bottle it as they did prior to the 2019 GE when they had the chance to avoid Brexit, but failed to grasp the nettle. At least we don't have Corbyn to deal with now.

Parliament can reject the tax cuts and instruct the government to rethink. If they refuse then they have a vote of no confidence and the 1922 Committee rewrites the rules on how a new PM is chosen and the MPs themselves choose Truss's successor.

If that doesn't happen, we appear to be headed to a coalition at the next GE between Labour, the Liberals and the SNP, who will demand a binding referendum as the cost of their support.

Should that happen, in the current climate even I would vote for independence if I was a Scot.

So, let me get this right; a 1% income tax cut for everyone who pays tax, a reversal of a 1.25% NI raise for everyone who pays NI and a 5% cut in income tax for the
top 1 or 2% of taxpayers is the biggest crisis you can remember!
The issue isn’t hmg or the tax cuts, it’s the left wing media keep going on about it and scaring the s*** out of everyone. Many many people are happy to receive the benefit of the cuts but then want to cane the ones giving it to them. How much less tax will specifically the high rate reduction cost then ? that’s open to anyone with the figure to answer.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 30 Sep 22 7.09am

Originally posted by cryrst

So, let me get this right; a 1% income tax cut for everyone who pays tax, a reversal of a 1.25% NI raise for everyone who pays NI and a 5% cut in income tax for the
top 1 or 2% of taxpayers is the biggest crisis you can remember!
The issue isn’t hmg or the tax cuts, it’s the left wing media keep going on about it and scaring the s*** out of everyone. Many many people are happy to receive the benefit of the cuts but then want to cane the ones giving it to them. How much less tax will specifically the high rate reduction cost then ? that’s open to anyone with the figure to answer.

Oh dear oh dear.
You're OCD over 'lefties' is leaving you so out of touch. If you really think that people's real fears about the cost of living, the housing cost crisis (sorry, was that a 'leftie; word? lol)and inequity is purely the result of The 'leftwing media' scaremongering, you really do need a check-up from the neck up, my paranoid friend.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Sep 22 7.59am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This is as big a political crisis as I can remember, the consequences of which could easily see the break-up of the UK.

Now it's down to Parliament to sort out. I just hope they don't bottle it as they did prior to the 2019 GE when they had the chance to avoid Brexit, but failed to grasp the nettle. At least we don't have Corbyn to deal with now.

Parliament can reject the tax cuts and instruct the government to rethink. If they refuse then they have a vote of no confidence and the 1922 Committee rewrites the rules on how a new PM is chosen and the MPs themselves choose Truss's successor.

If that doesn't happen, we appear to be headed to a coalition at the next GE between Labour, the Liberals and the SNP, who will demand a binding referendum as the cost of their support.

Should that happen, in the current climate even I would vote for independence if I was a Scot.

Didn’t Starmer say he would never go into coalition with the SNP? Apologies if this is incorrect.
A WE reply on politics that didn’t mention Trump! Party time. Although you did manage to get Brexit in

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 30 Sep 22 8.21am

Originally posted by Willo

Dear oh Dear

Even if I was informed that my Tories were ahead by 33 points, I would hardly be whooping for joy as the General Election is 2 years away and the political landscape could change dramatically as events unfold.

There you go again, bringing in common sense.

It's quite cringeworthy to see Labour banging on about the 40% tax rate.

As is pointed out ad nauseam, most of the tax cuts were supported by Labour.

No flesh on the bone as to how Labour will pay for the suggested policies at the conference.

Also these will need to be voted on at a pre GE get together when the GE date is known.

I would opine evert voter in the Red Wall knows that an adult female is a woman, why would they vote to bring in a PM who doesn't know that.

The more confident Labour feel the more silly their ideas will become

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 30 Sep 22 8.50am

Originally posted by cryrst

So, let me get this right; a 1% income tax cut for everyone who pays tax, a reversal of a 1.25% NI raise for everyone who pays NI and a 5% cut in income tax for the
top 1 or 2% of taxpayers is the biggest crisis you can remember!
The issue isn’t hmg or the tax cuts, it’s the left wing media keep going on about it and scaring the s*** out of everyone. Many many people are happy to receive the benefit of the cuts but then want to cane the ones giving it to them. How much less tax will specifically the high rate reduction cost then ? that’s open to anyone with the figure to answer.

I doubt the "left wing media", who-ever they are, are read by those who make the markets or internationally.

It's not whether you, or anyone else, will directly benefit from a tax cut, but what the whole package does to the economy. Paying £100 less in tax helps no-one if everything costs twice as much next year.

It's the lack of realism and detail about the funding that's at fault. It's the idea that trickle-down economics, which has been proven not to work in the best of times, will work in the worst. It's the analysis of the many experts that the package will increase problems, rather than solve them. It's the conclusion that the group of people behind this have no idea what they are actually doing.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 7 of 37 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > New prime minister