This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Man Utd vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 23 11.20am |
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
We should remember that we have lost our engine room this season. No Jimmy Mac and no Gallagher. No wonder we're struggling . We are trying to compete with money bags clubs who can spend £300m in a transfer window? The financial fair play rules are being taken to the cleaners
In the recent Transfer Window, only Chelsea spent a similar amount. The next highest spenders were Southampton and Arsenal on amounts in the region of £60 Mill.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Feb 23 12.28pm |
|
|
Perhaps the players are still crying because nasty Mr Derry shouted hurty words at them. Diddums.
Red and Blue Army!
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Feb 23 12.29pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
In the recent Transfer Window, only Chelsea spent a similar amount. The next highest spenders were Southampton and Arsenal on amounts in the region of £60 Mill.
When was the last time we spent £60m or anywhere near it in a January window? It would have to have been before Hodgson. Indeed, apart from Summer 2021, when was the last time we spent that kind of sum in the Summer window.
At least half the teams in this last window spent more than we normally spend in our summer windows. We are struggling to compete financially.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Feb 23 12.33pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
When was the last time we spent £60m or anywhere near it in a January window? It would have to have been before Hodgson. Indeed, apart from Summer 2021, when was the last time we spent that kind of sum in the Summer window.
At least half the teams in this last window spent more than we normally spend in our summer windows. We are struggling to compete financially.
Utd put all their eggs in one basket and signed Butland.
Red and Blue Army!
|
waddy Highton,Melbourne 05 Feb 23 12.44pm |
|
|
Have a re look at the 2nd goal with the amount of space each player was given,no interjections- they played us with very very simple tippy tappy touch football about 8-9 passes.Watching & watching each ball getting passed around with
That was clinical ( what Pat talks about every post interview ) that we don’t have we just watch.
Keep saying it : we don’t have a on the pitch leader / mouth piece we don’t have a run at them keep pressure on them team - we do have sit back & wait attitude we don’t have a striker we don’t have a striker
So we see out the season in hope to draw our way out & Summer clean out on players who just cannot make the grade & too old
Forever Palace Proud
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Feb 23 12.44pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Utd put all their eggs in one basket and signed Butland.
and your point is? The reason they didn't spend in this last window is that they're up to their FFP limits. I suspect Man U have spent more in the last three years than we have in our entire PL history.
Edited by doombear (05 Feb 2023 12.45pm)
|
Dubai Eagle 05 Feb 23 1.07pm |
|
|
I saw an article not so long ago that was saying that any prospective bidder needed to be aware that UTD had some £300 million still to pay against recent player purchases -
I guess against a purchase price of however many billion the club sells for (if indeed it does sell) it doesn't sound so bad but in most peoples language its still a lot of money.
Originally posted by doombear
and your point is? The reason they didn't spend in this last window is that they're up to their FFP limits. I suspect Man U have spent more in the last three years than we have in our entire PL history.
Edited by doombear (05 Feb 2023 12.45pm)
|
Uphill Bedford 05 Feb 23 1.15pm |
|
Originally posted by waddy
Have a re look at the 2nd goal with the amount of space each player was given,no interjections- they played us with very very simple tippy tappy touch football about 8-9 passes.Watching & watching each ball getting passed around with
That was clinical ( what Pat talks about every post interview ) that we don’t have we just watch.
Keep saying it : we don’t have a on the pitch leader / mouth piece we don’t have a run at them keep pressure on them team - we do have sit back & wait attitude we don’t have a striker we don’t have a striker
So we see out the season in hope to draw our way out & Summer clean out on players who just cannot make the grade & too old
Is there a chance that one of our two new midfielders can fulfil this role ? Seem a bit young to me but this is what we need
|
Uphill Bedford 05 Feb 23 1.20pm |
|
|
And another thing ..
Does it not strike you that had the players so active in the Man Utd melee yesterday has shown the same 'fighting spirit' in some of our recent abysmal defeats (e.g. the Forest match) then we may have quite a few more points and not mow speculating on possible relegation ?
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Feb 23 2.38pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
and your point is? The reason they didn't spend in this last window is that they're up to their FFP limits. I suspect Man U have spent more in the last three years than we have in our entire PL history.
Edited by doombear (05 Feb 2023 12.45pm)
I know mate. Perhaps they're a bigger club.
Red and Blue Army!
|
silvertop Portishead 05 Feb 23 2.41pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
and your point is? The reason they didn't spend in this last window is that they're up to their FFP limits. I suspect Man U have spent more in the last three years than we have in our entire PL history.
Edited by doombear (05 Feb 2023 12.45pm)
Dear oh dear. I got the joke AS.
|
Glazier#1 05 Feb 23 2.55pm |
|
|
Or how about 'I agree' lol
|
grumpymort US/Thailand/UK 05 Feb 23 6.32pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
When was the last time we spent £60m or anywhere near it in a January window? It would have to have been before Hodgson. Indeed, apart from Summer 2021, when was the last time we spent that kind of sum in the Summer window.
At least half the teams in this last window spent more than we normally spend in our summer windows. We are struggling to compete financially.
For people to see what you are getting at our spend (loan fees and compensation fees not included)
22/23 - €46.60m [Winter €12.00m] PV 21/22 - €85.62m [Winter €12.18m] PV 20/21 - €22.40m [Winter €3.50m] 19/20 - €7.60m [Winter €0m] 18/19 - €11.85m [Winter €1.15m] 17/18 - €48.95m [Winter €11.75m] FDB/Roy 16/17 - €101.20m [Winter €41.70m] Pardew/Sam 15/16 - €28.80m [Winter €0m] Pardew 14/15 - €31.22m [Winter €15.48m] Warnock/Pardew 13/14 - €33.00m [Winter €11.18m] Holloway/Pullis 12/13 - €1.73m (Championship) [Winter €0m]
Edited by grumpymort (05 Feb 2023 6.34pm)
(VPN) - [Link] (Alt VPN) - [Link]
|
Den1923 06 Feb 23 12.30pm |
|
Originally posted by Hannes
Exactly! We played ManU and not Westminster Choir Boys. They are better in every department, let’s be fair. Don‘t think that not getting a result at OT makes us a relegation candidate or a Tier 3 side.
I agree, it is only getting 5 points from a possible 27 over the last nine games that makes us red hot relegation favourites at this time!
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Feb 23 12.41pm |
|
Originally posted by Den1923
I agree, it is only getting 5 points from a possible 27 over the last nine games that makes us red hot relegation favourites at this time!
Mr Pedant here - I think it's 5 out of the last 24 and 8 out of the last 27.
|
PJEagle London 06 Feb 23 12.55pm |
|
Originally posted by doombear
Mr Pedant here - I think it's 5 out of the last 24 and 8 out of the last 27.
Whatever it is it's not very many !
|
palace99 New Mills 06 Feb 23 4.45pm |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
For about the tenth time this season in his post match comments Vieira has said 'we need to be more clinical.' When will the penny drop? The current squad do not appear capable of clinical decision making in the final third. This is a realistic rather than a harsh or negative assessment. Unless the two new signings or McArthur's return make a dramatic difference I can't see how our decision making will improve. Wilf will continue to run into blind alleys, Ayew will continue to play with his head down, Olise will contine to either under/over hit crosses and Eze will continue to get caught in possession. Pass and move is the way forward as can be seen from Man Utd's second goal today.
I have to agree. IMHO i think PV is trying not to be too critical of the players in public but it's now getting tiresome.
Palace bingo every week (in no particular order)
1. pass out from a goal kick and it either goes nowhere, we lose possession or we end up kicking it long. If we want to pass out we need the midfield to be involved. If they are not good enough, well try something different 2. Start slowly so the opposition have lots of the ball and gain in confidence 3. Play it around too slowly so the opposition get numbers back 4. Look clueless at throws in. Eventually just lob it up the line as per an U12 teams 5. Get a freekick on the half way line, pass it short and eventually go back to the goalie 6. Have no real tactic for getting the centre forward involved. Does he play a target man or run the channels? More often than not he does neither
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Feb 23 4.54pm |
|
Originally posted by palace99
I have to agree. IMHO i think PV is trying not to be too critical of the players in public but it's now getting tiresome.
Palace bingo every week (in no particular order)
1. pass out from a goal kick and it either goes nowhere, we lose possession or we end up kicking it long. If we want to pass out we need the midfield to be involved. If they are not good enough, well try something different 2. Start slowly so the opposition have lots of the ball and gain in confidence 3. Play it around too slowly so the opposition get numbers back 4. Look clueless at throws in. Eventually just lob it up the line as per an U12 teams 5. Get a freekick on the half way line, pass it short and eventually go back to the goalie 6. Have no real tactic for getting the centre forward involved. Does he play a target man or run the channels? More often than not he does neither
The free kicks one annoys me - it's not that hard to get players in the box and launch it in. I find it hilarious how poor our strikers are in the air considering their heights. Get the centre backs into the box - although not actually the tallest rather paradoxically.
Red and Blue Army!
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Feb 23 5.01pm |
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
The free kicks one annoys me - it's not that hard to get players in the box and launch it in. I find it hilarious how poor our strikers are in the air considering their heights. Get the centre backs into the box - although not actually the tallest rather paradoxically.
Mateta is 6ft 4in in height.His former coach at a French club mentioned that he is better with his feet than his head. Of the 7 PL goals he has scored 2 have been with his head.
Eduoard has scored 9 PL goals but only 1 with his head.
Edited by Willo (06 Feb 2023 5.05pm)
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Feb 23 5.05pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
Mateta is 6ft 4in in height.His former coach at a French club mentioned that he is better with his feet than his head.
Maybe he can give Guehi a piggyback on set pieces.
Red and Blue Army!
|