You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy
November 4 2026 12.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Good bye Roy


Page 7 of 36 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Croydon-Trucker Flag 22 Jan 24 7.18pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Is there anyone left on here supporting Roy to stay on?
I haven't seen a supporter for a while now.

Not looking good is it .

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Jan 24 9.50pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Is there anyone left on here supporting Roy to stay on?
I haven't seen a supporter for a while now.

Well, I’ve been saying Roy out since the second season of his first stint, so maybe I should change tack now just to be different.

Seriously though I’ve never liked his tactics since the debacle with England and the flaws of his system have finally become all to visible even to those who couldn’t see clearly because he was a Croydon boy. Nobody wanted him to fail, but it’s difficult to argue against a change now.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 22 Jan 24 10.07pm

Roy was gonna get the sack this morning but SPs phone couldn't get a signal apparently

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 Jan 24 11.07pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Is there anyone left on here supporting Roy to stay on?
I haven't seen a supporter for a while now.

i have always been a stalwart defender of Roy. Remembering PV, Alan Pardew, that useless dutch bloke, the treachery of so many proven managers like Sam Allardyce & Tony Pulis.....and all the other disappointments.

today ? i fear for a freefall upon losing Roy. And i also believe the problems we have, on the pitch, are the fault of the money men and the backroom bosses. Not necessarily Roy.

Hypothetical question : imagine the best managers in the World....Carlo Ancelloti, Jurgan Klopp, Zidane, Pep Guardiola.....how would any of them handle the current mess at Selhurst ? i reckon they would struggle and maybe throw the towel in.

And if we sack Roy and get a greenhorn, a question-mark manager then we will defo get relegated. Probably playing fun and exciting football while we do so.

officially i will abstain from any voting on the future of Roy. I like him. i also like Palace. If we lose to Sheffield, i will change my vote.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 22 Jan 24 11.54pm

Roy has 2 big games coming up. Lose at home to Sheffield United and I reckon he’s gone. Draw and the jury is out until the Brighton game. Win and he’s safe to the end of the season. He has been unlucky with injuries and unfortunately Olise isn’t Wilf. How many times did Wilf go off with an injury but somehow be fit for the next big game. Sadly Olise and Eze don’t have his powers of recovery.

Roy hasn’t been helped by recruitment. Parish and Freedman clearly knew Roy wouldn’t play a kid from South America so I can only assume he was bought for the future and with Roy’s blessing on the assumption he had enough in the squad to finish mid table at least. That said spending money on a keeper we don’t need is bizarre.

The only chink of light at the end of the tunnel (unless Olise is fit this week) is that Ayew will be on the plane home soon after Ghana’s early exit. Hopefully he will play against Sheffield United.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 23 Jan 24 12.26am

Honestly, relegation doesn't bother me... the board taking their money and running does... Parish needs to go...we should not be in this position and he's the captain at the helm.

 


This was once a quality forum....

dreamwaverider Flag London 23 Jan 24 1.43am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

I was saying ages ago before Viera that Dyche was a good choice, still that ship has long gone now!

The only thing that goes against Dyche is he fiddles with his nose during the game, has anyone else noticed him. Give it a rest man!

All that snow up there.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 23 Jan 24 2.23am

When we get a situation when Roy makes public statements about bringing Kalvin Philips on board:

"'I would like to think that if Kalvin Phillips is available and a possibility for the club - once again, there will be financial restrictions, who knows whether the club feels they will be able to afford that"

and then we see this in the press:

"West Ham are close to agreeing a loan deal with Manchester City for Kalvin Phillips, 28, but Juventus could still make a late move for the England midfielder" we can only assume he is either a) delusional or b)completely delusional and totally off script.

If I were Parish, I would be apoplectic about my manager saying things like this in front of the media.

 

EagleAlan78 Flag Southampton 23 Jan 24 2.27am

Originally posted by Palacesince64

Roy has 2 big games coming up. Lose at home to Sheffield United and I reckon he’s gone. Draw and the jury is out until the Brighton game. Win and he’s safe to the end of the season. He has been unlucky with injuries and unfortunately Olise isn’t Wilf. How many times did Wilf go off with an injury but somehow be fit for the next big game. Sadly Olise and Eze don’t have his powers of recovery.

Roy hasn’t been helped by recruitment. Parish and Freedman clearly knew Roy wouldn’t play a kid from South America so I can only assume he was bought for the future and with Roy’s blessing on the assumption he had enough in the squad to finish mid table at least. That said spending money on a keeper we don’t need is bizarre.

The only chink of light at the end of the tunnel (unless Olise is fit this week) is that Ayew will be on the plane home soon after Ghana’s early exit. Hopefully he will play against Sheffield United.

This is the problem beating sheff United shouldn’t mean anything. There terrible. Even if they do have a bit more about them at the moment. If he makes it to the Sheff United which I think he will unfortunately because we are a shambles and pathetic we should have to get 6 points from next 3 games for us even to consider keeping him till end of the season. The fact that he hasn’t gone regardless is an absolute disgrace.

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Jan 24 7.59am

I said it once and I will say it twice. Roy will not be sacked.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 23 Jan 24 8.11am

Originally posted by radicalsteve

When we get a situation when Roy makes public statements about bringing Kalvin Philips on board:

"'I would like to think that if Kalvin Phillips is available and a possibility for the club - once again, there will be financial restrictions, who knows whether the club feels they will be able to afford that"

and then we see this in the press:

"West Ham are close to agreeing a loan deal with Manchester City for Kalvin Phillips, 28, but Juventus could still make a late move for the England midfielder" we can only assume he is either a) delusional or b)completely delusional and totally off script.

If I were Parish, I would be apoplectic about my manager saying things like this in front of the media.

Bang on. That is unacceptable. It's like I already said, the club is disjointed. Parish needs to get on top of things.

Edited by dreamwaverider (23 Jan 2024 8.12am)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Jan 24 8.18am

Originally posted by radicalsteve

When we get a situation when Roy makes public statements about bringing Kalvin Philips on board:

"'I would like to think that if Kalvin Phillips is available and a possibility for the club - once again, there will be financial restrictions, who knows whether the club feels they will be able to afford that"

and then we see this in the press:

"West Ham are close to agreeing a loan deal with Manchester City for Kalvin Phillips, 28, but Juventus could still make a late move for the England midfielder" we can only assume he is either a) delusional or b)completely delusional and totally off script.

If I were Parish, I would be apoplectic about my manager saying things like this in front of the media.

Or does it reflect that fact that Roy is being fed the same false hope the fans are?

It's a bit like me telling my wife I hope to become a millionaire underwear model by the end of this year then just sitting around in my pants moaning about Palace.

There's little point talking of such aspirations when there's no action to deliver upon them.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Jan 24 8.38am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Roy was gonna get the sack this morning but SPs phone couldn't get a signal apparently

Carrier pigeon?

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 23 Jan 24 8.49am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I said it once and I will say it twice. Roy will not be sacked.

I believe he has to go and a fresh new team come in. Whether he is sacked or leaves ‘by mutual consent’ I don’t see him being with us much longer. (I was hoping he would’ve been dispensed with after the Arsenal game).

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Jan 24 8.50am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Or does it reflect that fact that Roy is being fed the same false hope the fans are?

It's a bit like me telling my wife I hope to become a millionaire underwear model by the end of this year then just sitting around in my pants moaning about Palace.

There's little point talking of such aspirations when there's no action to deliver upon them.

Your use of analogy to describe a certain situation have hit new heights of the surreal, excellent ha ha ha!

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 23 Jan 24 10.07am

Originally posted by palace chick

I also agree that it is an excellent post. However, I Just can’t see anyone being able to make our present 11 / squad any better than Hodgson? If we can’t bring any additional players in only Hodgson in my opinion is able to keep us up. But staying up is not a definite even if Hodgson stays? Ayew and Olise coming back soon will hopefully be the reason we stay up? Then, a new manager/team will have a bloody hard job ahead as we will go down next season without major incoming quality players and a change in playing style?

Too true, coupled with the likelihood that Leicester and Soton will automatically be promoted and be far stronger than the teams promoted this season, then next season is looking even tougher. Roy might of only of got the extension of this season as the preferred candidates were not available. Now if the management do have somebody available now then this is the time to make this choice. If not then he will remain in charge until the end of the season. As the days pass it is highly likely this is the scenario. Also what happens on the pitch next week might force their hand. Only time will tell.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

EddieMac Flag 23 Jan 24 10.56am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I believe he has to go and a fresh new team come in. Whether he is sacked or leaves ‘by mutual consent’ I don’t see him being with us much longer. (I was hoping he would’ve been dispensed with after the Arsenal game).

I agree it is time for him to move on but when you think of it logically it won’t happen till the end of season for many reasons. The big one being there are 3 worse teams than us in this division and Parish and Co. wont believe there is a major risk of getting relegated (neither do I)

We are so weak in so many areas of the pitch that it is almost laughable and it would be a bigger risk to get rid of Roy now and expect a new manager to mould that team before the end of the season.

This is an unbelievably depressing season especially that it started with so much hope.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Jan 24 10.58am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Your use of analogy to describe a certain situation have hit new heights of the surreal, excellent ha ha ha!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Jan 24 11.16am

I've copied and pasted this from the BBC. A summary I very much align with:

Alex Pewter, FYP podcast

Whether we claim to be objective or not, we are all guilty of our sporting biases.

They can cloud our judgement or at least extend our tolerances. In the case of Crystal Palace, many of us are, at best, struggling to stomach this particular season.

A pair of FA Cup fixtures that amounted to an abject waste of time from a Palace perspective only added further fan anger or apathy directed at this football club - with the drubbing delivered by Arsenal on Saturday and a fan protest the accompanying cherries on top.

That brings further questions about Roy Hodgson's position at the club. Many hold respect and fondness for him yet find their patience thin and tested.

Would we accept such negativity and surrounding toxicity if it was a different manager in his place?

The chairman and club carry their fair share of the blame, as we have touched on across previous weeks, adding a layer of confusion to the debate. However, a leopard never changes its spots, so they knew the coach they re-hired and the squad they were equipping him with.

The end of last season acted as a small redemption arc for Hodgson. However, the past months, regardless of caveats and context, have dredged up memories of dire pandemic football with a football club seemingly on its knees.

The fans may have returned to the stands but will now voice the frustration absent from those once-empty stadia.

Like an unwanted Hollywood franchise sequel, this season has done more harm than good for Hodgson's legacy at the club rather than repeat the success.

For those who hold lingering hope for a satisfying final chapter with a historically important coach who can leave on his terms, the path to that outcome is quickly narrowing.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jan 24 5.58pm

I have a vision of Mr Hodgson at the Sheff Utd game stroking his chin deep in thought !

 

Page 7 of 36 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy