You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 2.47pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 72 of 166 < 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 >
Painter Flag Croydon 15 Apr 18 5.17pm

Originally posted by The_Dumps

Below par at times this season? Is this a joke?

Giroud - £15mil
606 mins played
6 goals
101 mins per goal

Benteke - £30mil
2,173 mins played
1,087 mins per goal

Edited by The_Dumps (15 Apr 2018 5.09pm)

The price of the transfer is irrelevant to any argument about ability. Basically as a number of other elements come into play, how long left on their current contract, agents fee, signing fee and wages etc.
Also Giroud plays for a top 6 side as a sub coming on with 30 mins left.

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 15 Apr 18 5.38pm

Personally it’s been Benteke’s seeming lack of effort that has frustrated more than anything. Yesterday he was the “fresh legs” but did little chasing. He cannot be blamed for goal kicks being aimed out giving him no chance but when the ball was played around their back four I wanted him to press not stand there pointing. Any player can have a bad day but at least he can put in some hard yards.
Benteke just doesn’t look like a player at the moment. Maybe time to take him out of the firing line and give other options a go.

 

bozsufc Flag SHEFFIELD 15 Apr 18 5.56pm

Originally posted by Painter

The price of the transfer is irrelevant to any argument about ability. Basically as a number of other elements come into play, how long left on their current contract, agents fee, signing fee and wages etc.
Also Giroud plays for a top 6 side as a sub coming on with 30 mins left.

We can talk about all the stats as much as you like, but it all comes down to putting the ball in net.

I'm not one for all stats it's just about earning a chance to wear the Palace jersey and it looks like Benteke will end up with 2 goals and that's not worthy of one for me.

He may have kept ball out of our net, but he cost £30 million the club brought him in to score goals and that's not happened as it, the big man probably kept us up last season but with all good wishes he doesn't send us down this season.

The whole team have worked there rock's off to create chance's for him to score all season and he's not repaid them back and the club.
I think they've lost all faith in him to do the job.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 15 Apr 18 6.56pm


i would have put on sorloth, he's the future and he couldn't have done any worse than Benteke

 


This was once a quality forum....

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 16 Apr 18 2.50pm

Originally posted by Painter

The price of the transfer is irrelevant to any argument about ability. Basically as a number of other elements come into play, how long left on their current contract, agents fee, signing fee and wages etc.
Also Giroud plays for a top 6 side as a sub coming on with 30 mins left.

The nprice of the transfer and indeed salary does come into it when looking at investment. Taking all the things you have said comparing him and Giroud it is massively one sided.

 


Bring back Brolin

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 16 Apr 18 2.55pm

Originally posted by croydon proud


Yes, this all day long!

Croydon when are you ever going to wake up to what a complete waste of money your mate has been. On one hand I admire you sticking with him and I assume to show a united front but please promise me one thing, that after the last game against West Brom you come on here and give an honest seasons assessment of him because he is sure running out of games to let the hand brake off!

 


Bring back Brolin

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 16 Apr 18 3.08pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Croydon when are you ever going to wake up to what a complete waste of money your mate has been. On one hand I admire you sticking with him and I assume to show a united front but please promise me one thing, that after the last game against West Brom you come on here and give an honest seasons assessment of him because he is sure running out of games to let the hand brake off!

Thanks, you are right that i want a united front mate but do think he is getting more stick than others who might have a bad game simply because its the nature of his job to put the ball in the net, a bit like why a goalkeeper gets blamed when he lets a goal or two in, i think its easy to blame a striker and admit he hasnt had a great season like last, but also can see when he"s clearing a ball off the line, winning headers and taking two or three players out to free up someone else in the process ! We could pick any player you like for watford saturday, and analise him after, and im sure we could pick at least 5 things wrong with his game and apportion blame, and i doubt it would do his confidence any good for the next game, but we all got an opinion and pay our money, i just support whoever is in the shirt on the day !

 

Monty the Eagle Flag Lima 16 Apr 18 5.04pm

It has been clear a number of times this season that when we are in a points position in the second half the front players are the first line of defence and hold position rather than press the opposition CB's. Wilf and Townsend were doing it in the second half before Benteke came on. When we were playing Sorloth and Benteke they both held the same position. This must be to do with maintaining the shape of the team rather than lose shape by running around chasing a lost cause.

I think he is getting a lot of stick when actually he is doing what he has probably been told to do!

His finishing on the other hand has been pretty pony!

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 16 Apr 18 5.39pm

Originally posted by Monty the Eagle

It has been clear a number of times this season that when we are in a points position in the second half the front players are the first line of defence and hold position rather than press the opposition CB's. Wilf and Townsend were doing it in the second half before Benteke came on. When we were playing Sorloth and Benteke they both held the same position. This must be to do with maintaining the shape of the team rather than lose shape by running around chasing a lost cause.

I think he is getting a lot of stick when actually he is doing what he has probably been told to do!

His finishing on the other hand has been pretty pony!

yes I think that this was definitely the case on Saturday. He was brought on to allow Andros to drop into a more defensive role and eventually to play up top alone when Jairo came on. He was never going to get many chances in that situation and the only time we got a break-away near the end and he put Wilf in Wilf then chose to shoot rather than trying a cut-back to Tekkers in the box.

 

The Dolphin Flag 16 Apr 18 5.52pm

Anyone would have struggled with the job he was asked to do on Saturday so I don't blame him for his performance.
Generally though we don't want him and he doesn't want us.
I hope we bite the bullet in the Summer and part company!

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 Apr 18 6.11pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Anyone would have struggled with the job he was asked to do on Saturday so I don't blame him for his performance.
Generally though we don't want him and he doesn't want us.
I hope we bite the bullet in the Summer and part company!

No way Roy H. wish to see Benteke here next season. Cut the losses and get rid - the sooner the better (after season finished)!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Apr 18 7.01pm

Originally posted by Monty the Eagle

It has been clear a number of times this season that when we are in a points position in the second half the front players are the first line of defence and hold position rather than press the opposition CB's. Wilf and Townsend were doing it in the second half before Benteke came on. When we were playing Sorloth and Benteke they both held the same position. This must be to do with maintaining the shape of the team rather than lose shape by running around chasing a lost cause.

I think he is getting a lot of stick when actually he is doing what he has probably been told to do!

His finishing on the other hand has been pretty pony!

This. I agree he has been pants at putting ball in the net but "fans" were giving him abuse as soon as he came on Saturday WTF is that all about?

 

REILLY Flag Poole 16 Apr 18 7.20pm

Originally posted by Monty the Eagle

It has been clear a number of times this season that when we are in a points position in the second half the front players are the first line of defence and hold position rather than press the opposition CB's. Wilf and Townsend were doing it in the second half before Benteke came on. When we were playing Sorloth and Benteke they both held the same position. This must be to do with maintaining the shape of the team rather than lose shape by running around chasing a lost cause.

I think he is getting a lot of stick when actually he is doing what he has probably been told to do!

His finishing on the other hand has been pretty pony!

Its the manner he does it, he literally has zero dynamism so he might as well be chasing a lost cause.

Even if he is told to not close the players down he could at least make it tougher on the opposition centre backs, play smart, make them attempt a long ball on a weaker foot, put it out for a throw in by closing down an angle etc

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 16 Apr 18 7.20pm

I saw some footage the other day of when Benteke was at Aston Villa, he was such a different player a real handful with urgency. His failure at Liverpool seems to have affected him permanently. He has the occasional good game but he seems a shadow of the player he was at Villa. I wonder if part of it is psychological, as if he doubts whether he would ever cut it at a top club again and has settled for playing at a lesser club.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Apr 18 7.28pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

This. I agree he has been pants at putting ball in the net but "fans" were giving him abuse as soon as he came on Saturday WTF is that all about?

Actually the 'fans" were chanting his name as soon as he came on saturday.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Apr 18 7.44pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Actually the 'fans" were chanting his name as soon as he came on saturday.

Yes. A quite remarkable show of support. I don't believe any other fans in the Prem would have been anything like as positive

Edited by Mapletree (16 Apr 2018 7.45pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Apr 18 8.29pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Actually the 'fans" were chanting his name as soon as he came on saturday.

Not some of the ones near me. Perhaps I should move!!

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 16 Apr 18 8.53pm

Originally posted by Direwolf

yes I think that this was definitely the case on Saturday. He was brought on to allow Andros to drop into a more defensive role and eventually to play up top alone when Jairo came on. He was never going to get many chances in that situation and the only time we got a break-away near the end and he put Wilf in Wilf then chose to shoot rather than trying a cut-back to Tekkers in the box.

yes, that was right in front of me, put wilf in and didn"t get the return, wilf was on a hat trick but benteke was in a good position, anyway, i pay my money and am happy with tekkers, more to his game than scoring and hope he stays!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Apr 18 9.49pm

Originally posted by YT

Apology accepted. Good on you, mate.

Boz has also apologised to me in a PM, and I have apologised to him for the tone of my reaction.

Apologies all round, then, and all is well!

Did I miss something? Why did Boz get a yellow?

I have been called an idiot, a snowflake and a racist all in one go without the name caller getting a yellow. So this seems a bit of an overreaction for someone who has always been very polite.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 17 Apr 18 9.18am

Originally posted by chateauferret

That would be a valid comparison if those 90 minutes were the only 90 minutes Wilf had played. He'd had a couple of poorer games leading up to that, for example. It also ignores that Benteke does other things (or is supposed to) than head balls into the net. However, comapring Wilf's season with Benteke's is like comparing dung and chocolate cake and you don't need any statistics to demonstrate that.


You really are a proper wind up merchant mate, always here to act as a supercilious 'expert' on all things.

If my point that five players (one of them a £uc#in defender ffs) scoring more goals than Benteke isn't a reasonable argument in the "For or against Benteke" thread, I don't know what is.

Just READ other's opinions on these forums and try hard not to undermine them. They are opinions, that's all.

 


Spirit of 1974

Page 72 of 166 < 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread