You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 3.59am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 75 of 91 < 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Feb 20 10.43am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I have refrained thus far from Commenting on this subject as like all of you I'm an ardent supporter and have 40 years of supporting Palace behind me.

However some of the (quite frankly) nonsense spouted on here in defence of the board, Manager, and Greedman is just red and blue tinted boillicks.

We have the worsts attacking stats in the division, that can only be the fault of one man.

We are still utterly inept in the transfer market, a six million buy out clause in Sorloth's contract being a case in point. Not to mention various failures in pretty much every window we've been in, resulting in panic buys on inflated wages Benheskey, and Sakho being another case in point. The board and Greedman at fault for the naivety in that mess.

Still no nearer a stadium development than we were 10 years ago despite numerous pretty models being slung about. Again this is purely down to the Board and old Pinocchio.

Our season on the pitch can be summarised by Hodgson's substitutions against Everton at the Weekend.

15 Mins to go, 2-1 down away from home, takes off a right back, puts a CM at RB, and brings another CM on, Leaving Andros Townsend (our only real attack minded player) on the bench. we immediately concede another. That is Roy's fault no matter how you cut it.

He could have taken Benteke off put Ayew up front and pushed Wilf and Andros out wide but no, a right back goes off and Kouyate comes on. The look on Wards face as he was going off spoke volumes.

Something is rotten at the core of our club at the moment, and unless something changes we are bang in trouble, and I honestly fear we will go down.

Anyone looking at the next run of games and thinks will we be OK is in dream land. Take Newcastle for example they have conceeded Nearly 1.5 goals a game this season, I bet we don't trouble the keeper in 90 mins.

Pathetic tactics from Roy will have us down.

Edited by Dannyh.V2 (11 Feb 2020 9.59am)

In a nutshell.
Interviewer: Well Roy, didn't go for you today. 2-1 down and needing a goal you bring on a defensive midfielder whilst you had Andros Townsend on the bench. Cn you explain your thinking at that point please?"
RH (starting to look angry): Well Everton are such a good side and have spent a lot this season and they have such good strikers I thought that it might be best to lose and keep the score down, and I'm pleased to say my plan worked because they only scored one more".

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Feb 20 11.03am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I have refrained thus far from Commenting on this subject as like all of you I'm an ardent supporter and have 40 years of supporting Palace behind me.

However some of the (quite frankly) nonsense spouted on here in defence of the board, Manager, and Greedman is just red and blue tinted boillicks.

We have the worsts attacking stats in the division, that can only be the fault of one man.

We are still utterly inept in the transfer market, a six million buy out clause in Sorloth's contract being a case in point. Not to mention various failures in pretty much every window we've been in, resulting in panic buys on inflated wages Benheskey, and Sakho being another case in point. The board and Greedman at fault for the naivety in that mess.

Still no nearer a stadium development than we were 10 years ago despite numerous pretty models being slung about. Again this is purely down to the Board and old Pinocchio.

Our season on the pitch can be summarised by Hodgson's substitutions against Everton at the Weekend.

15 Mins to go, 2-1 down away from home, takes off a right back, puts a CM at RB, and brings another CM on, Leaving Andros Townsend (our only real attack minded player) on the bench. we immediately concede another. That is Roy's fault no matter how you cut it.

He could have taken Benteke off put Ayew up front and pushed Wilf and Andros out wide but no, a right back goes off and Kouyate comes on. The look on Wards face as he was going off spoke volumes.

Something is rotten at the core of our club at the moment, and unless something changes we are bang in trouble, and I honestly fear we will go down.

Anyone looking at the next run of games and thinks will we be OK is in dream land. Take Newcastle for example they have conceeded Nearly 1.5 goals a game this season, I bet we don't trouble the keeper in 90 mins.

Pathetic tactics from Roy will have us down.

Edited by Dannyh.V2 (11 Feb 2020 9.59am)

Hodgson has been criticised for his substitutions but at the end of the day one has to rely on players doing their jobs once they cross that white line.

For the first goal, Bernard was left in acres of space to fire the ball home.We have conceded similar goals this season with defenders dropping back towards the six-yard box leaving attackers unmarked to score.
The second goal came from a long punt when we were attacking in their penalty area, and Richarlison was allowed to run through and slot in via his favoured right foot.
For the third goal, Calvert-Lewin was all on his own at the back post when the corner was flicked on.Poor goals to concede.

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Feb 20 11.16am

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I have refrained thus far from Commenting on this subject as like all of you I'm an ardent supporter and have 40 years of supporting Palace behind me.

However some of the (quite frankly) nonsense spouted on here in defence of the board, Manager, and Greedman is just red and blue tinted boillicks.

We have the worsts attacking stats in the division, that can only be the fault of one man.

We are still utterly inept in the transfer market, a six million buy out clause in Sorloth's contract being a case in point. Not to mention various failures in pretty much every window we've been in, resulting in panic buys on inflated wages Benheskey, and Sakho being another case in point. The board and Greedman at fault for the naivety in that mess.

Still no nearer a stadium development than we were 10 years ago despite numerous pretty models being slung about. Again this is purely down to the Board and old Pinocchio.

Our season on the pitch can be summarised by Hodgson's substitutions against Everton at the Weekend.

15 Mins to go, 2-1 down away from home, takes off a right back, puts a CM at RB, and brings another CM on, Leaving Andros Townsend (our only real attack minded player) on the bench. we immediately concede another. That is Roy's fault no matter how you cut it.

He could have taken Benteke off put Ayew up front and pushed Wilf and Andros out wide but no, a right back goes off and Kouyate comes on. The look on Wards face as he was going off spoke volumes.

Something is rotten at the core of our club at the moment, and unless something changes we are bang in trouble, and I honestly fear we will go down.

Anyone looking at the next run of games and thinks will we be OK is in dream land. Take Newcastle for example they have conceeded Nearly 1.5 goals a game this season, I bet we don't trouble the keeper in 90 mins.

Pathetic tactics from Roy will have us down.

Edited by Dannyh.V2 (11 Feb 2020 9.59am)


I also was left boggled by this change. The simple thing to do was take off a centre mid. Put Wilf and Andros on wings and put Ayew up top with Benteke. I have no idea what he was thinking especially the fact that Mccarthur was our only midfielder attacking and Kouyate is not an attacking player.

 

dazza Flag Wallington 11 Feb 20 1.08pm

Finally someone that talks sense could not agree more, people moan about the players saying we need strikers we have strikers we just dont play to them.

Roy is 100% to blame, If we had big Sam now I guarentee you Benteke would be scoring goals.

We all moaned about Sorloth now we all want him back.


Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I have refrained thus far from Commenting on this subject as like all of you I'm an ardent supporter and have 40 years of supporting Palace behind me.

However some of the (quite frankly) nonsense spouted on here in defence of the board, Manager, and Greedman is just red and blue tinted boillicks.

We have the worsts attacking stats in the division, that can only be the fault of one man.

We are still utterly inept in the transfer market, a six million buy out clause in Sorloth's contract being a case in point. Not to mention various failures in pretty much every window we've been in, resulting in panic buys on inflated wages Benheskey, and Sakho being another case in point. The board and Greedman at fault for the naivety in that mess.

Still no nearer a stadium development than we were 10 years ago despite numerous pretty models being slung about. Again this is purely down to the Board and old Pinocchio.

Our season on the pitch can be summarised by Hodgson's substitutions against Everton at the Weekend.

15 Mins to go, 2-1 down away from home, takes off a right back, puts a CM at RB, and brings another CM on, Leaving Andros Townsend (our only real attack minded player) on the bench. we immediately concede another. That is Roy's fault no matter how you cut it.

He could have taken Benteke off put Ayew up front and pushed Wilf and Andros out wide but no, a right back goes off and Kouyate comes on. The look on Wards face as he was going off spoke volumes.

Something is rotten at the core of our club at the moment, and unless something changes we are bang in trouble, and I honestly fear we will go down.

Anyone looking at the next run of games and thinks will we be OK is in dream land. Take Newcastle for example they have conceeded Nearly 1.5 goals a game this season, I bet we don't trouble the keeper in 90 mins.

Pathetic tactics from Roy will have us down.

Edited by Dannyh.V2 (11 Feb 2020 9.59am)

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 11 Feb 20 1.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hodgson has been criticised for his substitutions but at the end of the day one has to rely on players doing their jobs once they cross that white line.

For the first goal, Bernard was left in acres of space to fire the ball home.We have conceded similar goals this season with defenders dropping back towards the six-yard box leaving attackers unmarked to score.
The second goal came from a long punt when we were attacking in their penalty area, and Richarlison was allowed to run through and slot in via his favoured right foot.
For the third goal, Calvert-Lewin was all on his own at the back post when the corner was flicked on.Poor goals to concede.

You're missing the point All of their goals were defensive errors. However I'm talking about our ability to reply back.

BenHeskey headed straight at Pickford when it was easier to score. he also hit the Cross bar from about a foot away, the goal he did score was pure keeper error, then he sliced a fairly easy chance wide.

We go two one down. Instead of sharpening up the attack by bringing Townsend on for Benhesky pushing Ayew up to CF and wilf and Townsend getting crosses in, he utterly and ashamedly took Ward off, for Kouyate and put him in midfield and McArthur at right back.

I think OLD Roy needs to have his sanity checked as I haven't seen that type of nuts substitution since that piss head George Burley played Jobi McaNuff as left back !!

Enough is enough the simple fact is we do not attack teams enough to even think about winning.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 1.41pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You're missing the point All of their goals were defensive errors. However I'm talking about our ability to reply back.

BenHeskey headed straight at Pickford when it was easier to score. he also hit the Cross bar from about a foot away, the goal he did score was pure keeper error, then he sliced a fairly easy chance wide.

We go two one down. Instead of sharpening up the attack by bringing Townsend on for Benhesky pushing Ayew up to CF and wilf and Townsend getting crosses in, he utterly and ashamedly took Ward off, for Kouyate and put him in midfield and McArthur at right back.

I think OLD Roy needs to have his sanity checked as I haven't seen that type of nuts substitution since that piss head George Burley played Jobi McaNuff as left back !!

Enough is enough the simple fact is we do not attack teams enough to even think about winning.

Exactly. I said when we were higher up the table we’d had a lot of luck with var and the odd goal going in our favour but as usual BraunstonEagle and whoever else we’re having none of it. Well now we’re right in the sh1t because there is no luck happening. Just head scratching and the insanity of the repeated crap that doesn’t work and managers have the blueprint on how to defeat it. We might find the teams around us accept their draw.

 


COYP

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 11 Feb 20 1.58pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Exactly. I said when we were higher up the table we’d had a lot of luck with var and the odd goal going in our favour but as usual BraunstonEagle and whoever else we’re having none of it. Well now we’re right in the sh1t because there is no luck happening. Just head scratching and the insanity of the repeated crap that doesn’t work and managers have the blueprint on how to defeat it. We might find the teams around us accept their draw.

Insanity is doing the Same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Feb 20 2.46pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

You're missing the point All of their goals were defensive errors. However I'm talking about our ability to reply back.

BenHeskey headed straight at Pickford when it was easier to score. he also hit the Cross bar from about a foot away, the goal he did score was pure keeper error, then he sliced a fairly easy chance wide.

We go two one down. Instead of sharpening up the attack by bringing Townsend on for Benhesky pushing Ayew up to CF and wilf and Townsend getting crosses in, he utterly and ashamedly took Ward off, for Kouyate and put him in midfield and McArthur at right back.

I think OLD Roy needs to have his sanity checked as I haven't seen that type of nuts substitution since that piss head George Burley played Jobi McaNuff as left back !!

Enough is enough the simple fact is we do not attack teams enough to even think about winning.

Maybe his thinking was that Benteke had scored which might give him the confidence from netting.He also came close with the header that was kept out by Pickford and he also hit a post, so it was best he retained his position in the team.

The alternative was to pair Benteke with Ayew and introducing Townsend but not only would this have meant a change of shape it would have left Townsend, just back from injury, at the mercy of Digne who is good coming forward from left-back.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 4.28pm

It hasn’t gone unnoticed roy did wonders when copying without a striker, twice wasn’t it? But now won’t possibly use less than 3 defensive midfielders and given the chance to play an attacking player when points are at stake and needed he puts on a more defensive midfielder than attacking in kouyate.

Just hope that Townsend was being saved v Everton for some blasting performances, or at least scrape us by. He only had another 2 weeks break after all, but then, as already mentioned, why is he on the bench if he’s not going to feature, when a possible point or 3 is there if we get them on the ropes again before conceding at 1-1, only this time we’re one goal down and we put someone on the back foot with Ray Lewington shouting instructions to get on the front foot.

I am concerned, but apparently this wasn’t coming because we were so good earlier this season. We fvcking were not. The criticism didn’t happen or got shut down because the points were on the board, as is always the case with Roy.

 


COYP

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Feb 20 4.45pm

I'm still willing to support Roy until the end of the season, but one thing that did worry me was that when he came out before the game kicked off he looked lost as if he didn't know where he was.

In an ideal world I hope we string together some good results, take a couple of more scalps from the big guns and Roy retires on a high. He was clearly very proud to take the reigns here as a local lad and it would be sad to see his legacy end with people on his back. This season has been a hard watch but with no backing in the transfer market I still think it is unfair to judge Roy too harshly. If you look at how well we played when we had RLC and Bats on loan you can see with the right players we can play really good football under Hodgson, but with no backup for Townsend and Meyer failing to take his chances this season we have been very flat.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 4.56pm

Roy probably keeps us up, talks about retirement on the lap of appreciation, he gets a good reception and then Parish takes that as the green light to get him to pen another 2-3 years. You just know Parish would.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (11 Feb 2020 6.52pm)

 


COYP

scuffy Flag orpington 11 Feb 20 6.21pm

I noticed that too. He looked completely lost, like he didn't know what was happening. I still back Roy and I think everyone's focus right now needs to be on getting the points to guarantee safety. Once we get to that point, it will be the right time to think about the future.

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I'm still willing to support Roy until the end of the season, but one thing that did worry me was that when he came out before the game kicked off he looked lost as if he didn't know where he was.

In an ideal world I hope we string together some good results, take a couple of more scalps from the big guns and Roy retires on a high. He was clearly very proud to take the reigns here as a local lad and it would be sad to see his legacy end with people on his back. This season has been a hard watch but with no backing in the transfer market I still think it is unfair to judge Roy too harshly. If you look at how well we played when we had RLC and Bats on loan you can see with the right players we can play really good football under Hodgson, but with no backup for Townsend and Meyer failing to take his chances this season we have been very flat.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Feb 20 6.59pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I'm still willing to support Roy until the end of the season, but one thing that did worry me was that when he came out before the game kicked off he looked lost as if he didn't know where he was.

In an ideal world I hope we string together some good results, take a couple of more scalps from the big guns and Roy retires on a high. He was clearly very proud to take the reigns here as a local lad and it would be sad to see his legacy end with people on his back. This season has been a hard watch but with no backing in the transfer market I still think it is unfair to judge Roy too harshly. If you look at how well we played when we had RLC and Bats on loan you can see with the right players we can play really good football under Hodgson, but with no backup for Townsend and Meyer failing to take his chances this season we have been very flat.

Agree very much with this post.

We’re the worst to happen, I’d blame the lack of the investment well before Roy. I think he has done well by us all in all and I hope he eventually goes on good terms. Feel as though he deserves that but footballs a funnier game than ever now.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 7.18pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Agree very much with this post.

We’re the worst to happen, I’d blame the lack of the investment well before Roy. I think he has done well by us all in all and I hope he eventually goes on good terms. Feel as though he deserves that but footballs a funnier game than ever now.

Yes he needs to go in the summer, hopefully after we’ve scrambled safe.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Feb 20 7.20pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Agree very much with this post.

We’re the worst to happen, I’d blame the lack of the investment well before Roy. I think he has done well by us all in all and I hope he eventually goes on good terms. Feel as though he deserves that but footballs a funnier game than ever now.

Deserve has nothing to do with it.
If he takes us down then hes to blame forever.
Hes had players to change the system but has continued with his defensive shape and tactics.
The players must be bored s***less and it is showing from the stands.
If he tries attacking and we go down he can with all grace give the finger and say "told ya"
If we are to depart the PL I would prefer we go down fighting not whimping out trying to get ten
0-0 draws.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 20 7.34pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Eight years ago Parish was revered like a god on this forum. Three of us had reservations about him and were roundly derided at every given opportunity with one particular R Sole being banned several times for his tirade of personal insults.

I read many of the comments about our chairman nowadays with a wry smile

I think it was the Pardew summer window of going into the season with Papa Souare and Zeki Fryers the only left backs and only 6 other defenders to select from was when I came to the conclusion he shouldn’t be near football people on a regular basis. ALL the manager errors and fallouts were certainly eyebrow raising although in isolation you could see or understand how they happened or the decisions were made, but so many throughout his watch?

In summary, everything is emergency after emergency, some through hazards of the job, but too many to add to that from his choices, and choices he shouldn’t be making anyway.

 


COYP

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 11 Feb 20 8.01pm

Some of the criticism is fair particularly regarding subs but we conceded the critical second goal on Saturday when we were on the front foot trying to win the game. Even then we had a gilt edged chance to equalise.

My personal gripe is his persistence with Benteke but I think those complaining about him not using Meyer and Riedewald and blaming him for CB's goal record are clutching at any straw to reinforce their argument.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 11 Feb 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Some of the criticism is fair particularly regarding subs but we conceded the critical second goal on Saturday when we were on the front foot trying to win the game. Even then we had a gilt edged chance to equalise.

My personal gripe is his persistence with Benteke but I think those complaining about him not using Meyer and Riedewald and blaming him for CB's goal record are clutching at any straw to reinforce their argument.

Yes, we were running them all over the place and there were many images of Everton fans with their heads in their hands with much head shaking, I was then quite confident of at least a point, Hodgsons football just needs a Bernard and a Richarlison because clinical we are not ..at home against West Ham we did achieve it and it was a game everyone enjoyed purely because we simply scored two good opportunities, against Everton we had opportunities some were good some not so but to blame our manager for our players making the wrong decisions and hopelessly attempting to test England's best keeper is to be quite honest ridiculously ridiculous.
Not Hodgsons fault that Richarlison, Calvert-Lewin and Bernard all knew where to be and how to score.

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 11 Feb 20 10.56pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Roy probably keeps us up, talks about retirement on the lap of appreciation, he gets a good reception and then Parish takes that as the green light to get him to pen another 2-3 years. You just know Parish would.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (11 Feb 2020 6.52pm)

An augur of the highest quality!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 11 Feb 20 11.25pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Deserve has nothing to do with it.
If he takes us down then hes to blame forever.
Hes had players to change the system but has continued with his defensive shape and tactics.
The players must be bored s***less and it is showing from the stands.
If he tries attacking and we go down he can with all grace give the finger and say "told ya"
If we are to depart the PL I would prefer we go down fighting not whimping out trying to get ten
0-0 draws
.

We are in a position to get just that and if you believe for one moment that we are capable of playing like Liverpool then you really need to sit down and look into a mirror, our squad including all the subs are middle of the road and that's exactly where we are at the moment, we are as it stands not going down we are as it stands six flipping points above the drop zone, we have endured three defeats in a row one of which we lost because our silly keeper did a Sprake and the other two because four of the goals were as clinical as you can get, meaning to me that they had to do this in order to beat us.

You've seen and every other Palace fan has seen our squad trying to string three to four passes together on the pitch ..it doesn't take a rocket scientist to understand our managers response to how they should entertain us does it.

 

Page 75 of 91 < 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread