You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 11.38am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 79 of 122 < 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 6.06pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

I agree if this article is correct the club have done all they can to facilitate an agreement. They offered the original block and to keep talking as the new stand is built. It is completely unrealistic to expect them to force the move of existing season ticket holders.

Lets not rewrite events. The club did bvgger all apart from mishandle the whole issue.

 


COYP

est1905 Flag 12 Sep 18 6.11pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce


if you read the post clearly he doesnt sit in the holmesdale to give up his seat, young Nick stopped playing in 89,but a nice gesture

It was the first sentence that I was responding to not the second.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 6.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

As per the club statement :

"News of the proposal leaked out and we received a large number of written and verbal objections from supporters in the area that would have been affected. Many of those supporters writing to us pointed out that they had been in their seats since the stand opened and were strongly opposed to what they saw as them being forced out of their seats"

The club felt that it would have been not only disruptive but very unfair to forcibly move long-standing season-ticket holders out of their seats to accomodate the HF, besides this would have generated ill-feeling towards the fanatics.

There’s also been people in centre blocks warming to the idea on the BBS and either prepared to move because they know it’s going to happen at some point anyway or are waiting for an Approach from the club rather than scary rumours leaked over phone calls to the box office.

Do proper research and a consultation at the very least. They’ve done nothing of the sort.

 


COYP

Palace in the Blood Flag 12 Sep 18 6.45pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Lets not rewrite events. The club did bvgger all apart from mishandle the whole issue.

No I will leave that to you.

There is no proof if club mishandled situation. Look at the facts

It is clear that dialogue happened between sides

It is clear club said No can't move you to your requested seats as people don't want to move.

It is also clear that HF were offered original area and declined.


 

simonmdt Flag x 12 Sep 18 6.56pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

There’s also been people in centre blocks warming to the idea on the BBS and either prepared to move because they know it’s going to happen at some point anyway or are waiting for an Approach from the club rather than scary rumours leaked over phone calls to the box office.

Do proper research and a consultation at the very least. They’ve done nothing of the sort.


Your complete inability to rationally argue against any alternative view other that the HFs is both revealing and tedious. The longer this drivel goes on the more alienating your 'cause' becomes.

“We wanted to create something that’s bigger than 200 people,” a leading member of the Holmesdale Fanatics tells The Independent. “People were asking to join the section but they couldn’t"

The reality is they couldn't because they weren't wanted. The HF have become elitist and egotistical to point of parody. That is what stops them growing and this stance they (you) are taking now shows you care more about you than the club.

Edited by simonmdt (12 Sep 2018 6.58pm)

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 12 Sep 18 6.59pm

Very difficult to see how it will be fixed any time soon. The HF should take the seats back for now while they work on a solution, the club is clearly willing to talk at this point. They have bent over backwards and kept those seats open selling them on a match by match basis rather than off as season tickets. The HF are showing no willingness to help the club and are instead speaking to newspapers.

Perhaps the club can write to 150 fans in the middle of block E and offer them a half price season ticket for next season, if they accept the proposal to move.

If they tried this and it failed then the HF would have nothing to complain about. The club tried.

I don’t think it’s right to evict a single season ticket holder unless they agree to to move.

Either way it needs to be sorted soon, it’s just a shame the HF are happy to sabotage the atmosphere and impact the club they are meant to be fans of.

It’s difficult to see what other steps the club could have taken when the plans were leaked, and so far I have yet to see a shred of evidence to suggest that this proposed move was actually agreed by the club, it was just discussed.

The fact the club even were willing to have the discussion about it with a fans group is far more than most clubs will do.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (12 Sep 2018 7.01pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 7.03pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

No I will leave that to you.

There is no proof if club mishandled situation. Look at the facts

It is clear that dialogue happened between sides

It is clear club said No can't move you to your requested seats as people don't want to move.

It is also clear that HF were offered original area and declined.


No proof that the club mishandled the situation? What, like consulting or just communicating something with the fans, which you incidentally haven’t said they did and therefore mishandled the issue.

This is coming, it’s just a matter of when, but if it’s left too long there’ll be no atmosphere and no added attraction to supporting Palace over 4 or 5 home wins a season. At least everyone can look over and know acquaintances are kept together for some small talk once a fortnight. If everyone’s lucky we’ll be able to overhear the conversations we’ve kept for the loss of atmosphere for good. I may as well find a quiet area of the ground myself. I sat in the empty Arfur until Lloyd’s day and felt the start of something and some passion rumbling in the belly of Palace.

 


COYP

Charlie Croker Flag Hampshire 12 Sep 18 7.08pm

Originally posted by simonmdt

Your complete inability to rationally argue against any alternative view other that the HFs is both revealing and tedious. The longer this drivel goes on the more alienating your 'cause' becomes.

“We wanted to create something that’s bigger than 200 people,” a leading member of the Holmesdale Fanatics tells The Independent. “People were asking to join the section but they couldn’t"

The reality is they couldn't because they weren't wanted. The HF have become elitist and egotistical to point of parody. That is what stops them growing and this stance they (you) are taking now shows you care more about you than the club.

Edited by simonmdt (12 Sep 2018 6.58pm)

And therein lies what I see as part of the issue. Is it 100 or 200?

Regardless, the same would happen in E block as B block - the 100 or 200 HF would have seats (and not use them), they would stand - forcing all other block E ticket holders to stand - and additional fans (who aren't part of the HF) would radiate towards that block, affecting the other seat holders by crowding into other rows.

There isn't a magic solution, the club appear to have tried to accommodate the block E request, but rightly season ticket holders have exercised their right to say 'no', and then seemingly, rather than the HF saying, 'okay, let's try and work on a solution with the club' have decided to either move or stay away.

If they were a user on here, they'd be rightly labelled as having 'left in a flounce'.

 


“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Sep 18 7.16pm

Originally posted by Charlie Croker

And therein lies what I see as part of the issue. Is it 100 or 200?

Regardless, the same would happen in E block as B block - the 100 or 200 HF would have seats (and not use them), they would stand - forcing all other block E ticket holders to stand - and additional fans (who aren't part of the HF) would radiate towards that block, affecting the other seat holders by crowding into other rows.

There isn't a magic solution, the club appear to have tried to accommodate the block E request, but rightly season ticket holders have exercised their right to say 'no', and then seemingly, rather than the HF saying, 'okay, let's try and work on a solution with the club' have decided to either move or stay away.

If they were a user on here, they'd be rightly labelled as having 'left in a flounce'.

And where you go we flounce, we flounce, we flounce.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 7.37pm

Originally posted by simonmdt


Your complete inability to rationally argue against any alternative view other that the HFs is both revealing and tedious. The longer this drivel goes on the more alienating your 'cause' becomes.

“We wanted to create something that’s bigger than 200 people,” a leading member of the Holmesdale Fanatics tells The Independent. “People were asking to join the section but they couldn’t"

The reality is they couldn't because they weren't wanted. The HF have become elitist and egotistical to point of parody. That is what stops them growing and this stance they (you) are taking now shows you care more about you than the club.

Edited by simonmdt (12 Sep 2018 6.58pm)

Yawn, waffle, bollox. Read the BBS. The fan opinion spreads further than this page.

 


COYP

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 12 Sep 18 7.44pm

There IS a significant conflation in what the HF are saying...they say loads wanted to join AND they couldn't keep the atmosphere going from where they were.

Well, why couldn't the club have facilitated joiners and singers being close to where the HF were, if there were all these applicants? Why did their numeric expansion HAVE to come alomg with the best seats in the Holmesdale, when that path was clearly going to upset many.

To be clear, I do back what the HF wants to achieve. It'll be dire if they fail.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 7.53pm

Coulsdoneagle, they’re protesting inaction. That’s what I’ve been saying and what most of both sides on the BBS apart from about 3 t1ts think should happen. Some action, even if it’s just consultation and a result of absolutely not possible. But the club have done nothing.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (12 Sep 2018 8.02pm)

 


COYP

Palace in the Blood Flag 12 Sep 18 8.12pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
No proof that the club mishandled the situation? What, like consulting or just communicating something with the fans, which you incidentally haven’t said they did and therefore mishandled the issue.

There are many ways of consultation some formal some informal. The Club have said there was a negative reaction from existing season tickets phoning box office. Such a reaction if large enough negates the need for formal consultation.

The world is not black and white - Not for the HF or against the HF.

You by your responses clearly want the HF demands met irrespective of any potential costs to the club we all support.

Clearly others have totally the opposite view of the HF.

The vast majority of people including those on this forum would like to see a solution in the interest of the club as a whole. The HF in block B worked and was accepted by most if not all. Moving them to the Centre has a lot of problems

Existing season ticket holders against
HF will want to still stand?
Others will stand so that they can see and many will complain to club

The result of that will Club will be told to stop the standing and if they fail authority could close area.

That is why going back to Block B as a Status Quo position makes sense for all. Dialogue can continue on how to expand the "singing" section. The fact is it will not happen overnight. It may have to wait for new development or a safe standing trial

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 12 Sep 18 8.42pm

I think at this point the HF have made their point and should come back to Block B and start the conversation for the 19/20 season.

HF are a fantastic asset for us and CPFC need to do all they can, but it's not going to happen midway through a season now.

- on a side note, whichever poster put Zaha and the HF in the same sentence needs a bit of a reality check.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

.TUX. Flag 12 Sep 18 8.44pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Very difficult to see how it will be fixed any time soon. The HF should take the seats back for now while they work on a solution, the club is clearly willing to talk at this point. They have bent over backwards and kept those seats open selling them on a match by match basis rather than off as season tickets. The HF are showing no willingness to help the club and are instead speaking to newspapers.

Perhaps the club can write to 150 fans in the middle of block E and offer them a half price season ticket for next season, if they accept the proposal to move.

If they tried this and it failed then the HF would have nothing to complain about. The club tried.

I don’t think it’s right to evict a single season ticket holder unless they agree to to move.

Either way it needs to be sorted soon, it’s just a shame the HF are happy to sabotage the atmosphere and impact the club they are meant to be fans of.

It’s difficult to see what other steps the club could have taken when the plans were leaked, and so far I have yet to see a shred of evidence to suggest that this proposed move was actually agreed by the club, it was just discussed.

The fact the club even were willing to have the discussion about it with a fans group is far more than most clubs will do.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (12 Sep 2018 7.01pm)

........that they, to be honest for a moment, created? Hardly ''sabotage''.
As much as the haters here are glad to see the back of them, they've not stepped up to the plate despite wallowing in the plaudits for many years now? Hmmm.....
There's no doubt that we as a club have suffered a loss, and a nationally recognised loss at that.


 


Buy Litecoin.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 8.45pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

There are many ways of consultation some formal some informal. The Club have said there was a negative reaction from existing season tickets phoning box office. Such a reaction if large enough negates the need for formal consultation.

The world is not black and white - Not for the HF or against the HF.

You by your responses clearly want the HF demands met irrespective of any potential costs to the club we all support.

Clearly others have totally the opposite view of the HF.

The vast majority of people including those on this forum would like to see a solution in the interest of the club as a whole. The HF in block B worked and was accepted by most if not all. Moving them to the Centre has a lot of problems

Existing season ticket holders against
HF will want to still stand?
Others will stand so that they can see and many will complain to club

The result of that will Club will be told to stop the standing and if they fail authority could close area.

That is why going back to Block B as a Status Quo position makes sense for all. Dialogue can continue on how to expand the "singing" section. The fact is it will not happen overnight. It may have to wait for new development or a safe standing trial

You’re clearly wrong. I can just imagine the kind of response you get in real life trying to speak for or twist other people’s words.

‘Irrespective of any costs to the club that we all support.’ Cringe. There’s standing everywhere. You watch the whole of the new spurs end stand, even if the seats aren’t fully made into those for standing yet.

Again, I’m talking about dialogue with more than ‘irate from Cheam or Sutton’ tweeting to Parish or writing to the club, but yet again, you fail to see that for about the 199th time.

 


COYP

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Sep 18 9.22pm

Originally posted by chris123

And where you go we flounce, we flounce, we flounce.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Palace in the Blood Flag 12 Sep 18 11.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You’re clearly wrong. I can just imagine the kind of response you get in real life trying to speak for or twist other people’s words.

‘Irrespective of any costs to the club that we all support.’ Cringe. There’s standing everywhere. You watch the whole of the new spurs end stand, even if the seats aren’t fully made into those for standing yet.

Again, I’m talking about dialogue with more than ‘irate from Cheam or Sutton’ tweeting to Parish or writing to the club, but yet again, you fail to see that for about the 199th time.


I can't be wrong as all you do is repeat the HF demands. So why would I twist your words you are clearly only interested in their view not the rest of the people who also pay their money and choose to support Palace in a different way.

If safe standing is rejected by Parliament and presently I would say its 50:50 then the licensing authorities will look to rigorously enforce. Do you want it to be Palace stands that are closed?

Also there is the question of liability for mass standing in seated areas if there was an incident and people were hurt or even killed. Pre the current Law such incidents were common now they are rare. SP and the other directors are not fools and I am sure they will have taken legal advice. The law relating to corporate manslaughter has changed dramatically since Hillsborough and prosecution of senior individuals is much easier.

I support safe standing and I think that the political view and their advisors is moving in that direction, however any serious incident that takes place would reverse that movement. CPFC if I remember correctly are one of the clubs who support the change in law

Your final paragraph you show how biased you are in your views "Again, I’m talking about dialogue with more than ‘irate from Cheam or Sutton’ tweeting to Parish or writing to the club, but yet again, you fail to see that for about the 199th time". You only want the HF view heard - 100 season ticket holders. Irate of Cheam or Sutton has as much right to be heard. Other season ticket holders in area have a right to be heard too. It would be interested how and who you wanted Club to consult? In my mind if after the original contact with HF the club had decided that it should have been taken forward then some sort of formal contact with those affected would have taken place. Reading between the lines I think it had failed before that point ie there was clear indication that many people objected. There is also the question of cost of consultation who should pay? I assume it would be a written letter to all season ticket holders in Holmesdale with a pre paid reply. Possibly sent to an independant organisation so there is no question of bias.

Your final point for 199th time. Unlike you I have not commented 199 times.

You have your own views and I respect your right to have them. You need to respect that other people think you are very wrong and that you are unwilling to debate solutions which fall short of HF demands

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 18 11.58pm

You fool I want everyone to be asked and heard, that’s the point. That’s the HF point too. They’re protesting ‘inaction.’

I have my opinion on what I want, but that should be, or needs to be, after everyone is consulted and/or there are alternative seating arrangements. Nobody knows for sure if there is or isn’t solutions to this because there’s been zero effort. On my description of irate from wherever, it doesn’t mean I don’t think it’s fair they’re consulted.

The liability reason is just an excuse to kick it into the long grass. Lots of big areas stand. Old spurs, and all behind the goal and along the pitch, the Kop, Arsenal, probably new Spurs and thousands there, Chelsea, etc etc etc.

Questioning who should pay for consultations when Palace is now a multi multi million pound business making a profit every year is quite amusing, especially when you then factor in the cost of pre-paid envelopes.

If you venture onto the BBS you’ll see how many there are who think it should at least be explored with consultations, and there are some who don’t want it but agree on consultations and then some in central blocks who would move.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (13 Sep 2018 12.00am)

 


COYP

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 Sep 18 3.48am

Originally posted by Woolsy

Interesting article in the Independent

[Link]

I thought the HF were maintaining a dignified silence, whilst talks could progress between them and the club.

But no. they have links to the media, so go gobbing -off, and not for the first time.
Regardless of content, the fact they've gone to the meeja is just very poor form indeed.


 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Page 79 of 122 < 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread