You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Flag


Page 8 of 18 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Stirlingsays Flag 16 Jul 14 12.41pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Jul 2014 12.05am

It was not the only reason but is was the primary cause of the civil war and almost all other issues still had their roots in the southern states wanting to retain slavery. It wasn't the last straw at all, it was the primary cause.


I think it's fair to say that the causes of the war weren't just focused upon slavery but that.....it's true that slavery was the major cause.....But that the exclusion of other factors....Which is basically what most people do now...Doesn't do the reality justice.

Just before the civil war the nature of the Northern and Southern economies and social structure were significant factors in causing tension and division. The north was industrial and focused upon cities while the south due to the cotton wheel invention bet all its stock on slave plantations which provided a cotton economy.

There was a significant difference between the north and south's view of state and federal rights. This can still be seen today.

The belief in the south that Washington was anti south and pushed northern interests first ( again this attitude still lingers). Lincoln was seen as pro-northern interests and even though secession had started before his election once he was in place the die was cast.

To many the confederate flag flown in modern times stands for an 'American South' identity. Still I recognise that that racists and agitators and nutcases still like to use it....But that's also true of the St George. It doesn't mean we can't fly it.

What else do those who feel 'of the American South' have to fly?


Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Jul 2014 12.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jul 14 12.46pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 15 Jul 2014 7.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Jul 2014 6.34pm


They don't have the same history though do they. The Union and Cross of St George were not flags flown by the Confederate South and in defence of the right to own slaves.

They also weren't associated with the Jim Crow states, and the anti-desegregation movement by those states actual legislatures (Georgia State adopting the flag from the 1950s officially until 2000).

The ultimate difference is that a few idiot Nazis with british flags, vs US states and large scale racial movements.



It's a mistake to put down slavery as the only reason the South looked to secede from the union and the North and South came to blows.

Slavery was the last straw for the South but by far not the only one.

Definitely, and eventually it would have ended as industrialisation took over. However, the key point is that a flag is a symbol, and represents the presentation of a series of concepts associated with it society.

The Confederate Battle Flag cannot be separated from what it represents historically: its a flag that's associated with the Confederacy, slavery, the anti-desegregation movements and of course the KKK.

Its possible to reclaim symbols, such as the St Union flag from the NF etc but the Confederate Battle Flag has never really represented anything much beyond 'Southern US Politics' which has been stepped in racialism and racial prejudice since its inception.

Its only other association is with 'Rebellion', but again its the rebellion in which the South claimed independency from the North, and one of the key issues in the right of independency was retention of slave labour and racialism - That's why the Klan adopted it because it represented their beliefs.

Its a shame, because for Palace it could be a great symbolic flag, it being red and blue, with an association to the 'Rise of the South' / 'The South will Rise Again' only needing the word London added to give it a Selhurst poignancy.

All the talk about honouring the confederate dead seems a bit bizarre, as they represented a US that never was (and radically departed from the current US that the same people tend to talk about patriotically).

Its interesting that its reappearance in US culture was only really in the 1950s, when Georgia adopted the flag as its state flag whilst presenting a defence of segregation. I think a lot of people who claim the defence of honouring the dead great-great grandfather have essentially picking up on a discourse of 'defence of the indefensible' presented by certain factions in US Southern Politics that represent 'them good old days'. Kind of how politicians talk about 'supporting the troops' rather than discussing the war.

Certainly before the 1950s, hardly anyone down south was using the Confederate Battle Flag.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Jul 14 12.49pm

Quote MikeT at 15 Jul 2014 7.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Jul 2014 6.34pm

They don't have the same history though do they. The Union and Cross of St George were not flags flown by the Confederate South and in defence of the right to own slaves.

They also weren't associated with the Jim Crow states, and the anti-desegregation movement by those states actual legislatures (Georgia State adopting the flag from the 1950s officially until 2000).

The ultimate difference is that a few idiot Nazis with british flags, vs US states and large scale racial movements.


Jamie, it's clear that appealing to logic and reason is wasted in this thread. There are obviously a number of people who value their freedom of expression above the club's reputation, and are willing to let the chips fall where they may.

I suspect that most of this discussion is somewhat moot anyway. The club is already well aware of the negative feedback that arose from a brief TV closeup in the home game again Man City, and in discussion with the HF was able to prevent further escalation of the issue in subsequent games. Knowing this, I can't seem them allowing anybody to display the flag at Selhurst. They were certainly not shy about inhibiting Man U supporters freedom of expression to wear Cantona masks, since it would cause offence to a large number of Palace supporters.


Edited by MikeT (15 Jul 2014 7.52pm)

Great, and I think you are right

Now where did I put that old Tamil Tigers flag...

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jul 14 12.51pm

Although in fairness I've never really understood why people feel the need to fly flags all the time in the first place to show 'pride'. Whilst some of those I've met turn out to be decent people, most of them have tended to be fairly lowly educated stupid people, who use phrases 'I'm not a racist but...'.

Bloke over the road from my parents flies a Union Jack, as he calls it, I didn't have the heart to tell him that its only the Union Jack if flown from a Ship, or that its upside down.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Jul 14 1.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 12.46pm

Definitely, and eventually it would have ended as industrialisation took over. However, the key point is that a flag is a symbol, and represents the presentation of a series of concepts associated with it society.

The Confederate Battle Flag cannot be separated from what it represents historically: its a flag that's associated with the Confederacy, slavery, the anti-desegregation movements and of course the KKK.

Its possible to reclaim symbols, such as the St Union flag from the NF etc but the Confederate Battle Flag has never really represented anything much beyond 'Southern US Politics' which has been stepped in racialism and racial prejudice since its inception.

Its only other association is with 'Rebellion', but again its the rebellion in which the South claimed independency from the North, and one of the key issues in the right of independency was retention of slave labour and racialism - That's why the Klan adopted it because it represented their beliefs.

Its a shame, because for Palace it could be a great symbolic flag, it being red and blue, with an association to the 'Rise of the South' / 'The South will Rise Again' only needing the word London added to give it a Selhurst poignancy.

All the talk about honouring the confederate dead seems a bit bizarre, as they represented a US that never was (and radically departed from the current US that the same people tend to talk about patriotically).

Its interesting that its reappearance in US culture was only really in the 1950s, when Georgia adopted the flag as its state flag whilst presenting a defence of segregation. I think a lot of people who claim the defence of honouring the dead great-great grandfather have essentially picking up on a discourse of 'defence of the indefensible' presented by certain factions in US Southern Politics that represent 'them good old days'. Kind of how politicians talk about 'supporting the troops' rather than discussing the war.

Certainly before the 1950s, hardly anyone down south was using the Confederate Battle Flag.



I agree with a lot of that.

I don't feel you're being all that fair to people in the south who honour the past southern dead. Sure they were on the wrong side but a lot of them were bought up within a system that meant that being anything other than what they were was unrealistic.

Many in the south fought because they knew war was inevitable and they knew what was going to happen to their farms if they didn't repel the north.

The confederate flag has already been reclaimed by many in the modern sense as a symbol of the south.

I obviously don't support it being flown as a symbol of slavery or the KKK myself...And some people should recognise that many people don't object to the flag and want to fly it for other reasons.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Jul 2014 1.18pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Jul 14 1.04pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 12.51pm

Although in fairness I've never really understood why people feel the need to fly flags all the time in the first place to show 'pride'. Whilst some of those I've met turn out to be decent people, most of them have tended to be fairly lowly educated stupid people, who use phrases 'I'm not a racist but...'.

Bloke over the road from my parents flies a Union Jack, as he calls it, I didn't have the heart to tell him that its only the Union Jack if flown from a Ship, or that its upside down.


Much the same is said of football fans.

A flag is just a symbol Jamie. Are you saying you have no symbols to represent anything about you?


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

grump Flag Milford On Sea 16 Jul 14 7.17pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 12.51pm

Although in fairness I've never really understood why people feel the need to fly flags all the time in the first place to show 'pride'. Whilst some of those I've met turn out to be decent people, most of them have tended to be fairly lowly educated stupid people, who use phrases 'I'm not a racist but...'.

Bloke over the road from my parents flies a Union Jack, as he calls it, I didn't have the heart to tell him that its only the Union Jack if flown from a Ship, or that its upside down.

It's a shame you have to ruin your articulate and reasoned argument with such distasteful comments. I think most people are aware that the British flag is in fact called the Union Flag. However it is still commonly known as the Union Jack whether flown from a ship or not, even by intelligent well educated people.

If you don't understand why people fly flags as a symbol of pride, let me ask you this. Do you have children? If so, do you not have any symbols of your pride in them? Photographs, sports medals, school certificates etc?

There are no restrictions on what people have pride in and if flying or displaying the "Union Jack" or the Confederate Southern Cross is a way of expressing pride in their homelands I'm not sure how that makes them lowly educated, stupid people.

 


Stay out the way of the Southern thing.

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 16 Jul 14 7.41pm

Quote goodersgold at 15 Jul 2014 8.00pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 15 Jul 2014 2.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 Jul 2014 10.36am

Quote bubble wrap at 15 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote nickgusset at 15 Jul 2014 10.22am

Quote bubble wrap at 15 Jul 2014 8.33am

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 9.36pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Jul 2014 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.


Don't get me wrong,I agree with you in the fact that it can be seen as offensive, so is. I was alluding to different posters having different opinions on the flag.

What about the flag with the skull and crossbones displayed at Selhurst, This could be deemed as promoting Pirates. You have more chance of bumping into a pirate than a slave these days. People are far to quick to worry themselves silly about other people being offended by something that in truth they probably don't give a rats arse about.


People who are concerned about how others feel = liberal. People who don't care what others think = right wing.

Has anyone actually complained about the flag, Anyone said they were deeply offended by the flag? No don't thinks so. Just trying to stick your beak in for the sake of it, Will get myself a huge BNP flag to give you something to really get your knickers in a twist about.


A few people on this thread have complained about the flag.
If you want to fly a BNP flag, fill yer boots. But they are SOOO yesterday-it's all about EDL and Britain First now innit.


The BNP fly the union flag. The EDL have claimed st George's cross as their own.

A case for both flags to be banned?


Like it or not a huge number of English/ british are more than proud of our flag and will never feel embarrassed to fly it .
Regardless of what group uses it or is offended by it.
I couldn't give 2 f-cks who is upset by it.
This is England after all

Spot on Gooders.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jul 14 7.50pm

Quote grump at 16 Jul 2014 7.17pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 12.51pm

Although in fairness I've never really understood why people feel the need to fly flags all the time in the first place to show 'pride'. Whilst some of those I've met turn out to be decent people, most of them have tended to be fairly lowly educated stupid people, who use phrases 'I'm not a racist but...'.

Bloke over the road from my parents flies a Union Jack, as he calls it, I didn't have the heart to tell him that its only the Union Jack if flown from a Ship, or that its upside down.

It's a shame you have to ruin your articulate and reasoned argument with such distasteful comments. I think most people are aware that the British flag is in fact called the Union Flag. However it is still commonly known as the Union Jack whether flown from a ship or not, even by intelligent well educated people.

If you don't understand why people fly flags as a symbol of pride, let me ask you this. Do you have children? If so, do you not have any symbols of your pride in them? Photographs, sports medals, school certificates etc?

There are no restrictions on what people have pride in and if flying or displaying the "Union Jack" or the Confederate Southern Cross is a way of expressing pride in their homelands I'm not sure how that makes them lowly educated, stupid people.

That's what I get for listening to ex-Navy

Nope, no kids. But I see where you're coming from, but surely that's taking pride in your children's achievements and personal success as a parent: ie something you have done yourself.

Generally lowly educated and stupid people in my experience, its not true of all of them. Their pride tends, in my experience, to be based in a rather false myopic view of a Britain that never was, and their own insecurities.

Just my general experience mind, not a statement of truth about everyone. There's a big difference in displaying a flag around internationals and football matches, to flying one indefinitely.

Personally, I think people should really be proud of things they've done and achieved, or influence, rather than generalised ideas about geography and history.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jul 14 7.54pm

Quote bubble wrap at 16 Jul 2014 7.41pm

Quote goodersgold at 15 Jul 2014 8.00pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 15 Jul 2014 2.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 Jul 2014 10.36am

Quote bubble wrap at 15 Jul 2014 10.34am

Quote nickgusset at 15 Jul 2014 10.22am

Quote bubble wrap at 15 Jul 2014 8.33am

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 9.36pm

Quote adrian b at 14 Jul 2014 7.04pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jul 2014 5.25pm

Gotta love the hol. Who would've thought we'd discuss flag semantics...


We're not discussing semantics here. It's a straight forward question of whether we , as Palace supporters, are happy to see a flag that most regard as a racist flag in the Park. No semantics about that.


Don't get me wrong,I agree with you in the fact that it can be seen as offensive, so is. I was alluding to different posters having different opinions on the flag.

What about the flag with the skull and crossbones displayed at Selhurst, This could be deemed as promoting Pirates. You have more chance of bumping into a pirate than a slave these days. People are far to quick to worry themselves silly about other people being offended by something that in truth they probably don't give a rats arse about.


People who are concerned about how others feel = liberal. People who don't care what others think = right wing.

Has anyone actually complained about the flag, Anyone said they were deeply offended by the flag? No don't thinks so. Just trying to stick your beak in for the sake of it, Will get myself a huge BNP flag to give you something to really get your knickers in a twist about.


A few people on this thread have complained about the flag.
If you want to fly a BNP flag, fill yer boots. But they are SOOO yesterday-it's all about EDL and Britain First now innit.


The BNP fly the union flag. The EDL have claimed st George's cross as their own.

A case for both flags to be banned?


Like it or not a huge number of English/ british are more than proud of our flag and will never feel embarrassed to fly it .
Regardless of what group uses it or is offended by it.
I couldn't give 2 f-cks who is upset by it.
This is England after all

Spot on Gooders.

People shouldn't be embarrassed to fly it, only maybe embarrassed as to why they fly it. Overall, Britain is a pretty decent country, and England a fine and decent land. There's plenty to be proud of, some things to maybe be ashamed of, but probably more of the former than the later.

Its the other stuff that slowly creeps into the reasoning that disturbs me.

But then that flag isn't as controversial as the Confederate Battle Flag.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jul 14 7.55pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Jul 2014 1.00pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 12.46pm

Definitely, and eventually it would have ended as industrialisation took over. However, the key point is that a flag is a symbol, and represents the presentation of a series of concepts associated with it society.

The Confederate Battle Flag cannot be separated from what it represents historically: its a flag that's associated with the Confederacy, slavery, the anti-desegregation movements and of course the KKK.

Its possible to reclaim symbols, such as the St Union flag from the NF etc but the Confederate Battle Flag has never really represented anything much beyond 'Southern US Politics' which has been stepped in racialism and racial prejudice since its inception.

Its only other association is with 'Rebellion', but again its the rebellion in which the South claimed independency from the North, and one of the key issues in the right of independency was retention of slave labour and racialism - That's why the Klan adopted it because it represented their beliefs.

Its a shame, because for Palace it could be a great symbolic flag, it being red and blue, with an association to the 'Rise of the South' / 'The South will Rise Again' only needing the word London added to give it a Selhurst poignancy.

All the talk about honouring the confederate dead seems a bit bizarre, as they represented a US that never was (and radically departed from the current US that the same people tend to talk about patriotically).

Its interesting that its reappearance in US culture was only really in the 1950s, when Georgia adopted the flag as its state flag whilst presenting a defence of segregation. I think a lot of people who claim the defence of honouring the dead great-great grandfather have essentially picking up on a discourse of 'defence of the indefensible' presented by certain factions in US Southern Politics that represent 'them good old days'. Kind of how politicians talk about 'supporting the troops' rather than discussing the war.

Certainly before the 1950s, hardly anyone down south was using the Confederate Battle Flag.



I agree with a lot of that.

I don't feel you're being all that fair to people in the south who honour the past southern dead. Sure they were on the wrong side but a lot of them were bought up within a system that meant that being anything other than what they were was unrealistic.

Many in the south fought because they knew war was inevitable and they knew what was going to happen to their farms if they didn't repel the north.

The confederate flag has already been reclaimed by many in the modern sense as a symbol of the south.

I obviously don't support it being flown as a symbol of slavery or the KKK myself...And some people should recognise that many people don't object to the flag and want to fly it for other reasons.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Jul 2014 1.18pm)

Nothing wrong with honouring your war dead etc, although its worth noting that this was done without flying confederate flags for about 70 years.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 16 Jul 14 9.08pm

As we should show respect for those die while fighting under a flag, are we to assume those who flew the Confederate Flag at Palace are showing this respect? Who are these Americans? Also can we fly a swaztica at Selhurst in respect for those who died for such a worthy cause?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jul 14 12.00am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 7.55pm


Nothing wrong with honouring your war dead etc, although its worth noting that this was done without flying confederate flags for about 70 years.



You don't know how popular the flag was outside of official circles Jamie. Besides whether it's done with the flag they fought under or not makes little difference if the flag's modern intent is meant to represents the South.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jul 14 12.03am

Quote adrian b at 16 Jul 2014 9.08pm

As we should show respect for those die while fighting under a flag, are we to assume those who flew the Confederate Flag at Palace are showing this respect? Who are these Americans? Also can we fly a swaztica at Selhurst in respect for those who died for such a worthy cause?


As has been said in the thread. The flag is of the South.....We are a South London team. That probably is the loose connection.

It makes sense in that context but really......The flag could be altered a bit to reflect that.

I can't think of a connection between us and the Nazis.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jul 2014 12.31am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Jul 14 12.04am

Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Jul 2014 12.00am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 7.55pm


Nothing wrong with honouring your war dead etc, although its worth noting that this was done without flying confederate flags for about 70 years.



You don't know how popular the flag was outside of official circles Jamie. Besides whether it's done with the flag they fought under or not makes little difference if the flag's modern intent is meant to represents the South.

True, but its popularity soared in the 1950s. You can only know what you know, prior to that resurgence, as far as I can tell its primary use was by the KKK and affiliated bodies.

Of course its history in terms of UK use is only really in relation to that. Arguably its much less of a controversial issue in the UK than the US.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jul 14 12.30am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jul 2014 7.50pm

Personally, I think people should really be proud of things they've done and achieved, or influence, rather than generalised ideas about geography and history.


If everyone thought like that how would a society be created? The cult of individualism is about as useless as a chocolate teapot for societies.

What would bring people together under a common banner to fight wars and pool resources?

Your reflections upon stupid people being more attracted to symbols of nationalism is a redundant argument. Statistically there are 'less' intelligent people than average or below average.

Really it isn't really about intelligence but about identity and individualism. The old line being that more 'intelligent' the person is, the more individualistic and vice versa the 'less intelligent' person prefers to self identify with a larger group.....A kind of safety in numbers.

It's all a kind of half truth nonsense of course and in reality flags are symbols and plenty of people of all intellects identify with them....It's an honest but slightly insulting impression.

As for people's impressions of national history.....Bah.

If people want to stand under a union flag and believe it stands for this or that other it is no less accurate than anything else that can be said.

Who gets to decide which history concerning the flag is valid or not?

Everything is built upon perception and any view can be analyzed and deconstructed. There is no single truth about any history.

It represents what they want it to represent.....That whole line of argument is a moot one.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 17 Jul 14 12.46am

More Waffles......That would be what my flag would say.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jul 2014 12.49am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 17 Jul 14 1.35am

I can't wait for the new season to start!

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 17 Jul 14 11.03am

Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Jul 2014 12.03am


I can't think of a connection between us and the Nazis.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jul 2014 12.31am)


Last nights result has put the mockers on any chances of an anschluss

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Jul 14 11.25am

Quote Stirlingsays at 17 Jul 2014 12.03am

Quote adrian b at 16 Jul 2014 9.08pm

As we should show respect for those die while fighting under a flag, are we to assume those who flew the Confederate Flag at Palace are showing this respect? Who are these Americans? Also can we fly a swaztica at Selhurst in respect for those who died for such a worthy cause?


As has been said in the thread. The flag is of the South.....We are a South London team. That probably is the loose connection.

It makes sense in that context but really......The flag could be altered a bit to reflect that.

I can't think of a connection between us and the Nazis.

Edited by Stirlingsays (17 Jul 2014 12.31am)

An excellent idea, a massive 'CPFC Eagle' in the centre with the legend 'South London Rises Again' would be f**king awesome (not only because it would so so Palace, it would rehabilitate one of the greatest flags in history from its murky past).

I cannot state clearly how much I love the Confederate Battle Flag.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 8 of 18 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag