Quote oldcodger at 26 Sep 2015 11.02pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Sep 2015 10.22pm
Quote Kermit8 at 26 Sep 2015 6.32pm
I would be very interested in your opinion of the British soldiers and their superiors giving orders who apparently didn't stand and fight when conflict came their way in Dunkirk.
Yes I know they lived to fight another day but I am not talking about then but specifically what happened in Dunkirk. Nothing more.
And nothing more????.....Wow....That's almost impossible.
Firstly they were in an army fighting the German Army.....Unlike the vast majority of fit young Syria men I'm referring to who are running from ISIS and Assad. Right off the bat your comparison falls on its arse.
Secondly this army had been fighting the Germans.....Wow, Kermy who taught you history? Being a leftie you probably didn't bother listening in on British history lessons.....Despite the Scottish being a big part of the British Forces.
Thirdly, British and French lives were lost fighting and holding the line providing the time for the army to be cleared off the beach.
Lastly, they were ordered to undergo evacuation....Because they would have been surrounded or destroyed on the beaches...They were saved to fight later....It was a no brainer military decision, though it left the French right in it....Even so, these men are impeachable....These men were under orders as part of an Army that was later sent out on various missions during the war.
They didn't run away from a conflict. They fought for their country and many died.
Wow Kermy, just wow.
Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Sep 2015 10.25pm)
ISIS and Assad, they have an awful lot to run from then. You've avoided several of Jamies replies concerning why staying and fighting isn't this hero status fantasy outcome you've decided it is. As someone said, there is a difference between fighting for something and dying for nothing. What bliss it would be for these people to even be able to have a 'military decision' made on their behalf. This isn't a nation defending itself, it's factions that change with the wind, and influences, us included, that sway this way and that. The people on the ground are but leaves in the breeze no matter how much you get a thrill out of them staying for the sake of getting their head blown off and having an internet person hand them a virtual badge of honour.
The last I heard 'hated' Russia was being persuaded by the states to step up with a military presence. There are so many changes, one week you'd be a hero, one week a villain to whatever random person decided their opinion was some kind of vital component in what was happening. Not knowing who to join forces with in such a changable situation and not being equipped to do so even if you wanted you join the Kurdish forces for instance. You do realise that being 'fit' and 'young' doesn't make you superhuman?'
We've seen too many action movies in the west. "Oh it's good vs bad, don't you see? I'd do this, i'd do that". Yes of course you would. In the end, in this situation I don't blame people for doing what's best for them. You're not in their shoes. You're a million miles from any front line.
Edited by oldcodger (26 Sep 2015 11.06pm)
What you are saying about changing attitudes to Russia is speculation.....You can't really use it to make any point. One thing is certain to any sensible person is that things are in flux.....But Assad isn't going to get any Western support....I'm pretty sure of that.
As for answering Jamie, I have answered his points and agreed to an extent with some while making my own. If he had any particular questions he felt weren't answered from me I'm sure he'd ask.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)