You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guessing the majority see that as good enough
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Guessing the majority see that as good enough


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Beanyboysmd Flag 12 Dec 16 3.52pm

Teams have worked out how to play us now, play positive and open and we panic and lose our shape. How many times have you heard commentators say about our opponents 'this is the best we have seen xxxx play in months'?
Thats because our nerves are shot. It was at the time because of Pardews gung ho approach. We then fixed that and have been looking a lot more competitive but there is still very little confidence in the squad.
Pardew still hasnt lost the dressing room and 4 points from the last 2 games will help that a lot. I think we will get points from 3 of the next 4 games because the team will know how focussed they need to be, nervous or not...

 

The Dolphin Flag 12 Dec 16 3.58pm

Refs will always make errors, players will always get injured - every team has to put up with it as well as good and bad luck.
We are not good enough right now despite the fact we are scoring a good few goals.
AP's new tactics - if that is what you call them - mean we don't defend from the front anymore and so our defence is in terrible trouble all of the time as it has no cover.
We have conceded 29 goals already this season which after 15 games equates to 74 conceded by the end of the season - that spells trouble.
Assuming that we don't get anything from the next two games (typical Palace - we will win both!) then we will be 15 points form 17 games - which equates to 34 points come the end of the season - that spells relegation.
I believe that we have the players with the right man in control but the current incumbent is not the right man whether we win or not tomorrow night.
We need to take a deep breath and get a new Manager in.

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 12 Dec 16 4.18pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Ref gets that call right, and its 10 men for sixty-seventy minutes, so we probably get the three points. But if you're scoring three goals in a game, you shouldn't be pointing at the referee decisions as the reason you lost.

Swansea, Liverpool, Burnley and Hull. Cluster f**k defending - the only saving grace in those games was that we scored a lot of goals - but if you can't win a game without outscoring the opposition - rather than preventing them scoring - then you're a busted flush. Because the goals always dry up.

Danny must not have watched the game.....

 


@sxp55555

Beanyboysmd Flag 12 Dec 16 4.30pm

All of our battling midfielders look really poor at the moment except jmac who has suddenly decided he prefers being an attacking midfielder!
Battling midfielders were the reason our defence were able to play with confidence last year but all of them are off form.

Face it, Cabaye looks terrible, McCarther suddenly wants to play alongside Benteke, Ledley looks so slow and makes so many mistakes that opposition actually like playing against him and Flamini is...well he looked ok for the 8 minutes we have played him!!!

In midfield we actually looked better a few years ago with a crazed Auzzie who cant pass and a South African battering ram who cant play football than we do with the dross in midfield right now. And on paper its a good midfield, thats whats so frustrating with them!!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 5.16pm

Originally posted by sxp55

Danny must not have watched the game.....

Watching highlights on tv and there was the Zaha dribble and shot vs their one on one before the penalty . We looked more positive early on but again the Pardew excusers are on excuse number 776. One game here and there fair enough. 11 months. Pffffft.

Is everyone ignoring ginger nearly converting the cross before we equalised in another under 12s style game?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (12 Dec 2016 5.16pm)

 


COYP

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 12 Dec 16 5.17pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

You're lying. To look good on a message board. And apparently I need to grow up.

Ok then big boy. Where was the lie? You cant grow up cos you are still a baby. Ever heard of respect for your elders and or people with more experience than you? Stop being abusive to people just because you think they are wrong.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 12 Dec 16 5.47pm

Originally posted by sxp55

Danny must not have watched the game.....

Ohhh didums your going to blame that draw on the ref not sending off a player ? FFS this is HULL we are talking about not b****** Real Madrid, HULL ! and we arguing over a s*** ref decision, it shouldn't have mattered.

And by the way, our record against ten men under AP is less than f***ing impressive.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 12 Dec 16 5.51pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Ohhh didums your going to blame that draw on the ref not sending off a player ? FFS this is HULL we are talking about not b****** Real Madrid, HULL ! and we arguing over a s*** ref decision, it shouldn't have mattered.

And by the way, our record against ten men under AP is less than f***ing impressive.

and we are Crystal Palace.....and here lies maybe the biggest problem. we are a small club in London punching above our weight.

 


@sxp55555

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 6.00pm

Originally posted by sxp55

and we are Crystal Palace.....and here lies maybe the biggest problem. we are a small club in London punching above our weight.

We're in our 4th season allowing bottom clubs and clubs in sh1t form to take the p1ss.

Do you not remember Parish saying we need to drop the mentally of losers. I can't believe so many are happy to let this bloke take is down because you don't want it to mean his last prem job seeing as nobody would take him on. Don't worry I'm sure Mr Super duper Al will survive on probably £3 mil on top of the millions already in the bank.

Ah feck it you can have half my season ticket seats. I'll still pay, just won't come to all of them after this surrender. Pathetic is what we're becoming. From manager to players to fans. Soft surrendering, spineless under belly.

 


COYP

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Dec 16 6.03pm

Judging from majority opinions here:

It seems like we have the following team right now:
Hennessey (mediocre --or crap)
Kelly (not prem level)
Fryers (not prem level)
Dann (good on his day, but inconsistent this season)
Delaney (solid but slow, and probably too old)
Ward (solid, or crap to some)
McArthur (good on his day, but inconsistent)
Cabaye (crap and over-rated) *
Ledley (solid but slow)
Zaha (a star) *
Puncheon (good on his day, but inconsistent)
Townsend (crap) *
Benteke (a star) *
Campbell (not prem level)
Flamini (who knows, but probably too old) *
Lee Chung-yong (not prem level) *
Mutch (not prem level) *
Sako (not prem level) *
Speroni(who knows, but probably too old)

Those with an asterisk may be Pards choices, though Sako and Lee were said to be Parish surprise signings at the time. (Injured Parish-Pards signing include Pape, Wickham, Remy and Mandanda) Interesting that except for Pape, Pards hasn't had any luck bringing in any of his defensive choices (unless you count Cabaye as a holding mid). But perhaps that makes sense with our goal scoring issues the past 2 seasons.

Is this the roster another manager would turn into a top-half team?


 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Dec 16 6.10pm

Originally posted by sxp55

and we are Crystal Palace.....and here lies maybe the biggest problem. we are a small club in London punching above our weight.

Sorry we used to punch above our weight, not any more.

 

Shortbutts Flag Birmingham 12 Dec 16 7.12pm

West Ham, Sunderland and Swansea all have more years in the Premier League than us, but are below us. So the 4th season statement is irrelevant. What makes us so special?

Palace are still a relatively poorly financed club (even with the new owners) with a limited stadium and a team (baring Benteke) that has not cost a fortune to pull together (especially after netting off sales) - so yes we punch above our size. Look at the big clubs that have languished in the Championship or below (e.g. Leeds, Sheffield Wed, Derby, etc).

I personally think Parish got ahead of himself and built up unrealistic expectations. That is not to say I am happy with losing - although over the years have got perhaps to used to it. Overall, I see the last few years have been some of the most optimistic since I started supporting the club. I don't think we'll go down and bar some awful defending on occasions I don't think we're playing that badly; but we'd survive if we did. Hull have been picking up in recent weeks - getting fair results at home (West Brom and Southampton) - so getting a draw is not the calamity or a surrender as you suggest. I would rather the high scores we are seeing than the Pulis approach - although a middle ground would relax my dodgy heart.

You can say I'm stuck in the past, have no ambition and accept losing, but I am saddened by the venomous rhetoric and apparent lack of realism. Maybe it is because of what Leicester achieved last year - but until yesterday they were below Palace.

I am not a huge fan of Pardew, but do not at the moment see a better option and he still seems to have the dressing room. Who is this super manager that we can attract? Why would they join a club apparently in crisis? Apart from being in London what do we offer to a big name manager who does not have major baggage?


Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We're in our 4th season allowing bottom clubs and clubs in sh1t form to take the p1ss.

Do you not remember Parish saying we need to drop the mentally of losers. I can't believe so many are happy to let this bloke take is down because you don't want it to mean his last prem job seeing as nobody would take him on. Don't worry I'm sure Mr Super duper Al will survive on probably £3 mil on top of the millions already in the bank.

Ah feck it you can have half my season ticket seats. I'll still pay, just won't come to all of them after this surrender. Pathetic is what we're becoming. From manager to players to fans. Soft surrendering, spineless under belly.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 12 Dec 16 7.32pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We're in our 4th season allowing bottom clubs and clubs in sh1t form to take the p1ss.

Do you not remember Parish saying we need to drop the mentally of losers. I can't believe so many are happy to let this bloke take is down because you don't want it to mean his last prem job seeing as nobody would take him on. Don't worry I'm sure Mr Super duper Al will survive on probably £3 mil on top of the millions already in the bank.

Ah feck it you can have half my season ticket seats. I'll still pay, just won't come to all of them after this surrender. Pathetic is what we're becoming. From manager to players to fans. Soft surrendering, spineless under belly.

Feckin hell. Dont know if you ever watched us for most of the eighties but you would have been suicidal. You do know that the 2010 in the CPFC bit indicates the rebirth of the club after nearly disappearing. 72 other league clubs would love to be where we are. Plus the 5 below us.

 

Den1923 Flag 12 Dec 16 7.42pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Judging from majority opinions here:

It seems like we have the following team right now:
Hennessey (mediocre --or crap)
Kelly (not prem level)
Fryers (not prem level)
Dann (good on his day, but inconsistent this season)
Delaney (solid but slow, and probably too old)
Ward (solid, or crap to some)
McArthur (good on his day, but inconsistent)
Cabaye (crap and over-rated) *
Ledley (solid but slow)
Zaha (a star) *
Puncheon (good on his day, but inconsistent)
Townsend (crap) *
Benteke (a star) *
Campbell (not prem level)
Flamini (who knows, but probably too old) *
Lee Chung-yong (not prem level) *
Mutch (not prem level) *
Sako (not prem level) *
Speroni(who knows, but probably too old)

Those with an asterisk may be Pards choices, though Sako and Lee were said to be Parish surprise signings at the time. (Injured Parish-Pards signing include Pape, Wickham, Remy and Mandanda) Interesting that except for Pape, Pards hasn't had any luck bringing in any of his defensive choices (unless you count Cabaye as a holding mid). But perhaps that makes sense with our goal scoring issues the past 2 seasons.

Is this the roster another manager would turn into a top-half team?


You have it about right, most of AP signings are players (or his mates) who could not get first team games at their previous clubs all they want is to pick up their inflated wages and they could not give a stuff about CP. AP will take us back to the championship with players who are past it or useless with a wage bill we cannot afford at that level and here we go again struggling for our survival
and existence. Those who want to keep AP in his job are misguided as his form is not supporting this!

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 12 Dec 16 7.47pm

Would people ever accept that a team like Hull can be a really tight nit group with a siege mentality at this stage of the season are fighting for their lives and with our confidence low can make these ( expected wins ) far from a certainty. We seem to have lost some of this togetherness perhaps being in the Prem for a couple of years does that but some of the sence of entitlement to beat teams and people's thoughts of where we should be now are not helping as the fear of what might happen seems to be transferring from the stands to the players.
There is absolutely no guarantee that changing the manager would help and I admire our chairman for giving our manager as much time as possible to get things right. Us as supporters should be helping as much as we could rather than hindering in my eyes. Perhaps if we are really scrapping for our lives at the end of the season we can get some of that siege mentality back and all pull together.

 

Mstrobez Flag 12 Dec 16 8.00pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Ok then big boy. Where was the lie? You cant grow up cos you are still a baby. Ever heard of respect for your elders and or people with more experience than you? Stop being abusive to people just because you think they are wrong.

You keep calling me a baby yet you publicly wanna have an argument to look special. It seems very strange to constantly comment on threads started by someone you decided you can't take seriously over a year ago. Seems like you care about my opinion a lot more than you make out.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Den1923 Flag 12 Dec 16 8.06pm

Originally posted by RH8Eagle

Would people ever accept that a team like Hull can be a really tight nit group with a siege mentality at this stage of the season are fighting for their lives and with our confidence low can make these ( expected wins ) far from a certainty. We seem to have lost some of this togetherness perhaps being in the Prem for a couple of years does that but some of the sence of entitlement to beat teams and people's thoughts of where we should be now are not helping as the fear of what might happen seems to be transferring from the stands to the players.
There is absolutely no guarantee that changing the manager would help and I admire our chairman for giving our manager as much time as possible to get things right. Us as supporters should be helping as much as we could rather than hindering in my eyes. Perhaps if we are really scrapping for our lives at the end of the season we can get some of that siege mentality back and all pull together.

This has nothing to do with Hull, this is all based on the form over the last 12 months which despite the biggest transfer spend in CP history has left us with a team that cannot beat teams around us, we leak goals like the Titanic leaked water, the manager has said his is not bothered about leaking goals, well that is just daft, he wants to be a top manager playing exciting football, one problem he has forgotten you have to stop teams scoring as well. TP like him or hate him knows how to keep mediocre teams is this league AP skill set would appear to be how to get them relegated!

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 12 Dec 16 8.08pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

You keep calling me a baby yet you publicly wanna have an argument to look special. It seems very strange to constantly comment on threads started by someone you decided you can't take seriously over a year ago. Seems like you care about my opinion a lot more than you make out.

Ah bless.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Dec 16 9.21pm

Originally posted by Den1923

You have it about right, most of AP signings are players (or his mates) who could not get first team games at their previous clubs all they want is to pick up their inflated wages and they could not give a stuff about CP. AP will take us back to the championship with players who are past it or useless with a wage bill we cannot afford at that level and here we go again struggling for our survival
and existence. Those who want to keep AP in his job are misguided as his form is not supporting this!

I can't recall any Palace manager that has managed to sign first choice players from other Prem clubs.

But, I recall the great transfer business that Holloway and Warnock did. Pulis did pretty well signing from lower leagues, but I don't think that's enough anymore.

I'm happy to get players like Zaha and Benteke who couldn't crack the starting line ups of top teams though. Cabaye hasn't been great, but his signing gave us legitimacy, and paved the way to convince other quality to sign.

Tomkins was a starter a WHU, probably the first time since promotion I can recall Palace signing a prem starter from a good team (at least they were last year).

Townsend has disappointed, but hard to blame Pards for that. The consensus here was that it was a great signing, and he was doing well at a lousy Newcastle side. Hopefully he can find his mojo.

The only Pards signing (not Parish-led) that I think was a clear miss was Mutch --and he was 23, so I see the chance he took. But he's young enough we may get most of it back from a lower level team anyway.


 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Dec 16 9.38pm

Originally posted by Den1923

This has nothing to do with Hull, this is all based on the form over the last 12 months which despite the biggest transfer spend in CP history has left us with a team that cannot beat teams around us, we leak goals like the Titanic leaked water, the manager has said his is not bothered about leaking goals, well that is just daft, he wants to be a top manager playing exciting football, one problem he has forgotten you have to stop teams scoring as well. TP like him or hate him knows how to keep mediocre teams is this league AP skill set would appear to be how to get them relegated!

The season isn't calendar based, so the last 12 months don't really matter now, the last 4 do. Last season we finished 15th. Not great, not the worst. This year's team has 4 different starters, it's a different team. Lots of injuries and no depth, but we're 15th. Not great, not the worst.

Biggest transfer spend? Nope. Our net spend was just £7.91m. Yes we bought some expensive players, but we sold some too. Overall, our net spend was 15th in the Prem. 14 teams spend more than us (most a lot more), so there does not seem to be a financial reason why we should be much higher up the table.

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guessing the majority see that as good enough