You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a keeper
November 16 2026 9.55am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need a keeper


Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 25 Jan 17 12.26pm

How about Joe Hart? Apparently available, and worked under Sam Allardyce when he was manager of the England squad.

 

bicycle repair man 25 Jan 17 12.42pm

I think our defensive woes began when Jules got injured and Super Al stubbornly refused to reinstate him when he was fit,when it was plain to see neither McCarthy or Hennessey were as good as him.
But now he has been out of first team action for so long he probably isn't as capable as he once was,and it would be unfair to expect he would be.
I am not a huge advocate of Hennessey but I believe we have no choice at the moment other than to keep him between the sticks.Maybe our new goalkeeping coach can give him some tips.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 25 Jan 17 1.36pm

WH does make some damn good saves. There were 2/3 last Saturday against Everton.

The main criticism of him is his decision making and positioning. Is this something a decent goalkeeping coach could eradicate from his game? If so I think, although I seem to be very much in the minority on this one, that he may still have something to offer. Or, are his bad habits too ingrained in him now?

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 25 Jan 17 1.51pm

This is silly.

We have far more urgent needs than a keeper.
The three we have are experienced and capable.

Once the defence situation is sorted there is a desperate requirement for a creative midfielder, confident on the ball, an accurate ground passer who doesn't treat the ball like a hot potato.

We have midfielders but not one confident in holding the ball like a Fabrigas. Cabaye was bought to fulfil this function but for all his effort has not done it.

 

mattteo Flag 25 Jan 17 2.01pm

What do you guys have against Mandanda?

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 25 Jan 17 2.21pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

julian speroni.

proven
palace
pride
passion

still younger than some keepers playing in the Champions league

Oh so very very true.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jan 17 4.22pm

Originally posted by mattteo

What do you guys have against Mandanda?

He doesn't appear to be any good, he came with a lot of hype. He seems to struggle with the Premiership intensity.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Jan 17 4.29pm

Keeper is the least of our problems

As others have said get the defence right and we will be almost there.

As for Mandanda I am not sure how anyone can make a judgement whether good or bad. De Gea took a full season to get up to speed albeit he was 19. Give the guy a chance at least.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Salford eagle Flag 25 Jan 17 4.46pm

The fact that we have been questioning Henneseys place in the starting line up for the last couple of years suggests that the keeper position is a problem.

Fair enough he made a couple of saves against Everton, all were at a relatively comfortable height. I was more worried about the four balls he palmed out. If Everton had any sense about them they would have followed up on all shots.

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

cpj Flag Kent 25 Jan 17 5.00pm

WH was in an Italian paper's European team of the week for his performance on Saturday. We have more important positions to fill than goalkeeper (I still maintain that if Speroni wasn't here for everyone to keep comparing with WH or SM then there wouldn't be so many threads on here about this).

 

Mo Sizlak Flag 25 Jan 17 5.04pm

Originally posted by Salford eagle

The fact that we have been questioning Henneseys place in the starting line up for the last couple of years suggests that the keeper position is a problem.

Fair enough he made a couple of saves against Everton, all were at a relatively comfortable height. I was more worried about the four balls he palmed out. If Everton had any sense about them they would have followed up on all shots.

It mainly suggests to me that many fans can't let go where Speroni is concerned.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

srh Flag london 25 Jan 17 5.20pm

Originally posted by Painter

He doesn't appear to be any good, he came with a lot of hype. He seems to struggle with the Premiership intensity.

This post sums up lots of opinions on this site. What a ridiculous comment. What evidence do you base this view on?

 

srh Flag london 25 Jan 17 5.23pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I think our defensive woes began when Jules got injured and Super Al stubbornly refused to reinstate him when he was fit,when it was plain to see neither McCarthy or Hennessey were as good as him.
But now he has been out of first team action for so long he probably isn't as capable as he once was,and it would be unfair to expect he would be.
I am not a huge advocate of Hennessey but I believe we have no choice at the moment other than to keep him between the sticks.Maybe our new goalkeeping coach can give him some tips.

I think people forgot about the endless mistakes speroni made last season, for example spilling shots in front of sttackers on a few occasions (Southampton comes to mind immediately) and his terrible distribution st times out the team under needless pressure. Hennessy however is not the answer to this problem.

 

Salford eagle Flag 25 Jan 17 5.24pm

Originally posted by Mo Sizlak

It mainly suggests to me that many fans can't let go where Speroni is concerned.

I can only speak for myself, Speroni aside I just want a competent keeper who can pull off the odd match winning display.

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

Salford eagle Flag 25 Jan 17 5.26pm

Originally posted by srh

This post sums up lots of opinions on this site. What a ridiculous comment. What evidence do you base this view on?

True I can't remember there being much hype about him

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jan 17 7.55pm

Originally posted by Salford eagle

True I can't remember there being much hype about him

He was referred to as the best keeper playing in the French league and Frances number 2 keeper, I would consider that hype. All I can assume is the standard in France is poor.

 

srh Flag london 25 Jan 17 8.03pm

Originally posted by Painter

He was referred to as the best keeper playing in the French league and Frances number 2 keeper, I would consider that hype. All I can assume is the standard in France is poor.

Or you could assume that it's a bit short sighted to form an opinion of a player after a handful of games? Tbf he made some superb saves and his distribution was outstanding. Hes probably too good for the players around him because his game is quick tempo and he distributes the ball to players feet or for them to run on to. Our style is more hoof to Benteke's head and moan that he can't fend off 2 defenders and keep the ball.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jan 17 8.14pm

Originally posted by srh

Or you could assume that it's a bit short sighted to form an opinion of a player after a handful of games? Tbf he made some superb saves and his distribution was outstanding. Hes probably too good for the players around him because his game is quick tempo and he distributes the ball to players feet or for them to run on to. Our style is more hoof to Benteke's head and moan that he can't fend off 2 defenders and keep the ball.

I would prefer him to save shots going in his net and catch the ball from corners and crosses.

 

srh Flag london 25 Jan 17 8.40pm

Originally posted by Painter

I would prefer him to save shots going in his net and catch the ball from corners and crosses.

Which he does too. I can only recall a mistake against Sunderland (but he did make a one on one save in that game too)

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 25 Jan 17 8.48pm

Originally posted by Painter

He was referred to as the best keeper playing in the French league and Frances number 2 keeper, I would consider that hype. All I can assume is the standard in France is poor.

Yeah must be that the standard is poor. Not like the French league produces many top attacking players for him to have to deal with after all, is it.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (26 Jan 2017 8.46am)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a keeper