You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your Most disliked Palace manager ever
November 16 2026 9.39am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Your Most disliked Palace manager ever


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 17 7.28am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

You're not the first to mention Paul Hart. I'm mystified because he came in under extraordinary circumstances, did what was asked of him and then went off on his way.

I don't recall there being a huge queue of potential managers all dying to take over the hot seat at the time either.

 

Vim Fuego Flag Haywards Heath 13 May 17 8.14am

Originally posted by Palace 1979

1- Mullery - A complete disaster
2 - Paul Hart - A desperate appointment
3 - Taylor - Loved the player hated the manager

In recent times would have to be Dowie for the way he tried to con us, closely followed by Bruce for similar reasons.

Why the hell wound anyone dislike Paul Hart, a manager who came in and did exactly what he was asked to do and then moved on?

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 May 17 8.26am

Most managers seem to have left on bad terms. The recent exceptions being Paul Hart (a stop-gap appointment) and Ian Holloway (who resigned on realising the job was too big for him)

Recent Managers who left a bad taste, include : George Burley, Neil Warnock, Dougie, Dowie...even Peter Taylor

Bruce did the dirty, but we all chase the wonga

Mullery was hated before he was even appointed, and it went downhill from there

But top of the pile is Venables. He nearly destroyed our club by lining his own pockets. "Thief, thief, thief"


Edited by Forest Hillbilly (13 May 2017 8.30am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

jeeagles Flag 13 May 17 8.49am

Some of the criticism seem pretty harsh. Going back in time over the managers mentioned.

Pardew - limited ability manager for the premiership. Took over when no one else would touch us. Saved us from religation, got us to two cup finals. In time we might forgive him.

Colin - no one else would go anywhere near us.

Ollie - as forest hillbilly said.

Dougie - being remembered for completely loosing his marbles once dispite being terrific for the club.

Burley - when he was appointed no one else would touch us.

Hart - stepped in when no one else would, saved us from religation.

Colin - worked against the back drop of insecurity and got us into the playoffs from no where.

Taylor - good player, terrible manager.

Dowie - religation spots to play off winners. Got us a few minutes away from staying up, then back into the playoffs.

Bruce - got us too the top of the league, then realised Jordan was a prick.


 

Carrick Flag In the Premierleague 13 May 17 8.51am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Most managers seem to have left on bad terms. The recent exceptions being Paul Hart (a stop-gap appointment) and Ian Holloway (who resigned on realising the job was too big for him)

Recent Managers who left a bad taste, include : George Burley, Neil Warnock, Dougie, Dowie...even Peter Taylor

Bruce did the dirty, but we all chase the wonga

Mullery was hated before he was even appointed, and it went downhill from there

But top of the pile is Venables. He nearly destroyed our club by lining his own pockets. "Thief, thief, thief"


Edited by Forest Hillbilly (13 May 2017 8.30am)

Not sure if warnock left on bad terms?

Taylor for me

 


Disclaimer The contains of the this message may not be the sober views of the originator. Often the orginator is overloaded with alcohol therefore waffle often gets posted to which the orginator has no responsibility.

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 17 8.58am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Some of the criticism seem pretty harsh. Going back in time over the managers mentioned.

Pardew - limited ability manager for the premiership. Took over when no one else would touch us. Saved us from religation, got us to two cup finals. In time we might forgive him.

That's not how I remember it as I seem to recall that quite a few potential managers were linked with the job at the time but Steve Parish was so desperate for someone with Palace connections that he allegedly paid £3m to Newcastle to release him from his existing contract

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 13 May 17 9.05am

This thread proves an interesting insight into the demographic on here.

I'm 45 but (just) don't remember the Mullery years - I remember with clarity Coppell onwards.

From what history I know (& having seen him countless times on Sky before they improved recruitment) I understand Mullery has to be the automatic pick from those older.

However - for me personally - it has to be Pulis, for a bloke to be that good (& he was) & show (whilst he was still our manager) absolutely no love or affinity for us as club I found disgusting at the time....& then he lied.

For the record, personally:

Burley's the worst I've seen (closely following by the dire triumvirate of Francis, Taylor & Holloway)

Freedman & Pardew are the biggest disappointments - could have been so much more here at Palace if greed & ego respectively hadn't intervened.

I would also like to vent my ire at the people on here who've mentioned:

Warnock - I hated the bloke before he came 1st time & felt sick when he was appointed BUT he proved that he could buy into the club culture & do very well in trying circumstances (if he'd had half the money Taylor / Francis wasted we'd have got promoted no probs - as it was we were a Ben Watson missed penno away from a play off final under Warnock).

You can't judge him on 2nd stint, he came in - a last minute "I've got no-one else to turn to" hail mary following the cnut Pulis. He left us in a league position no worse than Pardew did & wh he did go he accepted he was out of his depth.

Since the 1st stint he's always been really pro-Palace in the media, that goes a long way with me. (again - unlikel the cnut Pulis)

Hart - Throughly nice guy, came in under "circumstances Breda", kept us up, good day at Hillsboro'. Can be argued he helped DF's managerial development..... HTF can he be mentioned on this thread ?? Wrong!!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 17 9.12am

Originally posted by Dancer Cat


Freedman & Pardew are the biggest disappointments - could have been so much more here at Palace if greed & ego respectively hadn't intervened.

Freedman left for what he thought was a better job at a higher pay grade. Why is that "greed" when it's something that probably almost all of us have done at some stage in our lives.


 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 13 May 17 9.34am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Freedman left for what he thought was a better job at a higher pay grade. Why is that "greed" when it's something that probably almost all of us have done at some stage in our lives.


DF faced a choice - earn more money, or continue his development with a team which was top of the table, a team which held him close to it's heart & which had allowed him to endure a "Pardew-esqe" losing run only 16 games before (which like Pardew would have got him sacked elsewhere much much sooner).

He chose to earn money.

I'm not being judge or jury on his decision - but as a Plaace fan if I choose to label the choice of the former option emotionally as "greed"(as opposed to "sense"then I will. Just like I could emotionally class the second choice as "loyality" as opposed to "stupidity" - depends on the viewpoint.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 13 May 17 1.38pm

Originally posted by Dancer Cat
Warnock - I hated the bloke before he came 1st time & felt sick when he was appointed BUT he proved that he could buy into the club culture & do very well in trying circumstances (if he'd had half the money Taylor / Francis wasted we'd have got promoted no probs - as it was we were a Ben Watson missed penno away from a play off final under Warnock).

You can't judge him on 2nd stint, he came in - a last minute "I've got no-one else to turn to" hail mary following the cnut Pulis. He left us in a league position no worse than Pardew did & wh he did go he accepted he was out of his depth.

Since the 1st stint he's always been really pro-Palace in the media, that goes a long way with me. (again - unlikel the cnut Pulis)

This. I like Warnock. May come across as a bellend, but he's done nothing but be positive for Palace. First time round he did well and brought some of the youth through. Second time we all knew it was only an appointment that'd last weeks to couple months and he knew that and accepted it.

 


[Link]

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.25am

Originally posted by jimruss

1) Pardew - Obvious reasons really, we're still recovering from the damage he done and may still pay the price

2) Taylor - Turgid, boring football. Never been so bored watching Palace play

Hated for Taylor is harsh. Was s*** but you can't hate him.You

 

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.26am

Originally posted by Kermit8

The correct answer is, of course, Mullery for those of a certain age.

And Pardew haters make me laugh. You get your cues from what the Geordies said about him way back. Sheep the lot of you.

Rescued us from relegation, second highest top league finish in 110 years and an FA Cup final to boot. In two years.

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

 

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.30am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

I never warmed to Holloway, quickly realised that he was a pretty clueless manager. I thank him for getting us through the playoffs but our form under him was awful, every players form dropped away under him and was a terrible operator in the transfer market; the exception being signing Kevin Phillips. I was more sick of listening to him by the end than any other manager.

thank you. I've said this many times to a load of abuse. Some can really put the blinkers on when it comes to palace

 

The Dolphin Flag 14 May 17 8.32am

Originally posted by Dancer Cat

This thread proves an interesting insight into the demographic on here.

I'm 45 but (just) don't remember the Mullery years - I remember with clarity Coppell onwards.

From what history I know (& having seen him countless times on Sky before they improved recruitment) I understand Mullery has to be the automatic pick from those older.

However - for me personally - it has to be Pulis, for a bloke to be that good (& he was) & show (whilst he was still our manager) absolutely no love or affinity for us as club I found disgusting at the time....& then he lied.

For the record, personally:

Burley's the worst I've seen (closely following by the dire triumvirate of Francis, Taylor & Holloway)

Freedman & Pardew are the biggest disappointments - could have been so much more here at Palace if greed & ego respectively hadn't intervened.

I would also like to vent my ire at the people on here who've mentioned:

Warnock - I hated the bloke before he came 1st time & felt sick when he was appointed BUT he proved that he could buy into the club culture & do very well in trying circumstances (if he'd had half the money Taylor / Francis wasted we'd have got promoted no probs - as it was we were a Ben Watson missed penno away from a play off final under Warnock).

You can't judge him on 2nd stint, he came in - a last minute "I've got no-one else to turn to" hail mary following the cnut Pulis. He left us in a league position no worse than Pardew did & wh he did go he accepted he was out of his depth.

Since the 1st stint he's always been really pro-Palace in the media, that goes a long way with me. (again - unlikel the cnut Pulis)

Hart - Throughly nice guy, came in under "circumstances Breda", kept us up, good day at Hillsboro'. Can be argued he helped DF's managerial development..... HTF can he be mentioned on this thread ?? Wrong!!

Top post!

 

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.39am

Originally posted by Part Time James

Since I became a Palace fan as a kid, Bassett and Smith's stints are the ones most hazy in my memory I think. When I think of Dave Bassett my only image is of the Holmesdale work being completed (I think it was around the same time) and I think I spent more time gawping over at the Holmesdale from the AW than watching any actual football.

We were flying under bassett.

 

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.45am

Originally posted by kenbarr

Trevor Francis. He let Gregg Berhalter go on a free after the 2002 World Cup without any cover at CB simply because he hated Americans. I'm not saying Berhalter was the greatest CB Palace ever had, far from it, but he was a warm body when we had very few in the back.

Terry Venables. I'd hire him to be head coach but never let him anywhere near the club's bank account so never let him be manager. England was a perfect place for him.

I can't really blame Bruce for what he did as I was told things by the late Chief Steward Ron Greatorex about financial shenanigans Dominic Jordan did to him.

I am not a Pardew hater but he did lose his way and had to be let go.

You knew Ron? What lovely bloke. He was my nans cousin

 

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.48am

Originally posted by Palace 1979

1- Mullery - A complete disaster
2 - Paul Hart - A desperate appointment
3 - Taylor - Loved the player hated the manager

In recent times would have to be Dowie for the way he tried to con us, closely followed by Bruce for similar reasons.

Paul Hart????????

 

aashman12 Flag 14 May 17 8.53am

Originally posted by Dan1994

This. I like Warnock. May come across as a bellend, but he's done nothing but be positive for Palace. First time round he did well and brought some of the youth through. Second time we all knew it was only an appointment that'd last weeks to couple months and he knew that and accepted it.

And negotiated a fair bit of money off qpr for us when we needed it.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 14 May 17 10.27am

Originally posted by aashman12

You knew Ron? What lovely bloke. He was my nans cousin

He was my Asst Chief Steward under Ted Gammons while I was there. I worked for him at both Selhurst and Plough Lane in 1991-92 before I went back to the US. I spoke to him weekly until he passed. What a smashing bloke and dear friend.

Edited by kenbarr (14 Jun 2017 5.10pm)

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 14 May 17 10.53am

Coppell
Lombardo
Kember

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your Most disliked Palace manager ever