This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well this thread is about the capture of Raqqa - Which wouldn't have been remotely possible without the several years of war that Iraqi and Rebel factions in Syria have been fighting, supported by US air support, training, equipment and special forces support. Trump hasn't actually achieved a victory in Syria, and taking credit for it is absurd. The fall of Raqqa required the defeats of IS in Iraq first, and then into Syria. Well, as has been stated. IS grew rapidly as a controlling force in Iraq due to the US troop withdrawn at a time of weak Iraqi unity. Poor policy by Obama...popular with the usual suspects but evidently poor policy all the same.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, as has been stated. IS grew rapidly as a controlling force in Iraq due to the US troop withdrawn at a time of weak Iraqi unity. Poor policy by Obama...popular with the usual suspects but evidently poor policy all the same. IS grew rapidly because the whole region was destabled by western intervention.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
IS grew rapidly because the whole region was destabled by western intervention. That's a different question. It's a question on Obama's decisions in Iraq. Not about Bush's decisions. IS did not grow rapidly until the US troops were gone....they took advantage of a lack of Iraqi unity.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, as has been stated. IS grew rapidly as a controlling force in Iraq due to the US troop withdrawn at a time of weak Iraqi unity. Poor policy by Obama...popular with the usual suspects but evidently poor policy all the same. IS was previously known, in the most part, as Al-Qaeda in Iraq, and had been active and a growing force in Iraq since the 2003 invasion, and whilst it probably benefited from the troop withdrawls, it was the Syrian based IS, which had built up allies within the Sunni insurgents in Northern Iraq, that actually launched an offensive from within Syria. Problem for the US was that continual deployment in northern Iraq wasn't really viable - It fed into the feeling of the insurgency, was economically taxing and undermined the authority of the Iraqi regime and military. Had the US remained at full presence in Iraq, I think you're right, you wouldn't have had the same kind of incursion that occurred in the same way - Their is some obfuscation in the idea that it was entirely an IS thing, but you also had an ongoing insurgency that erupted into a civil war, which ISIL (at the time) took advantage of. A calculated decision, probably the wrong one with hindsight, but the continued deployment of US troops in Iraq wasn't popular back in the US, with either democrats or republicans.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
That's a different question. It's a question on Obama's decisions in Iraq. Not about Bush's decisions. IS did not grow rapidly until the US troops were gone....they took advantage of a lack of Iraqi unity. They'd been operating in Iraq since 2003, and were very active through out the decade or so. Around 2006/7 they formed ISI (Islamic State of Iraq) which was active in the formation and growth of ISIS in 2012 (ish) during the civil war, with ISI switching their focus from Iraq to the Syrian civil war, and backing Jabhat al-Nusra which would in 2013 merge with ISI to form ISIL aka ISIS. People seem to forget that the initial ISIS was an offshoot formed by the ISI. They were never not active in Iraq.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Delayed, nothing else...accept making them wealthier. Delayed or postponed. To all accounts of the monitoring agency, Iran is in compliance with the treaty. Realistically, you can only ever delay or postpone countries developing the capability for nuclear weapons - based on their need. Increasing the military threat Iran is under, surely only accelerates that need (Despite the traditional sabre rattling, having nuclear capability generally paves the way to being immune to 'regime changes' The US can't start a war with Iran, without creating massive problems throughout Iraq (very close relationship with Iran).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Delayed or postponed. To all accounts of the monitoring agency, Iran is in compliance with the treaty. Realistically, you can only ever delay or postpone countries developing the capability for nuclear weapons - based on their need. Increasing the military threat Iran is under, surely only accelerates that need (Despite the traditional sabre rattling, having nuclear capability generally paves the way to being immune to 'regime changes' The US can't start a war with Iran, without creating massive problems throughout Iraq (very close relationship with Iran). I'm seeing no argument for the benefits of the Iranian deal here. It's short term wishful thinking. From what I can see criticisms of that deal are justified. Obama made the US look weak and scared. Putin knew it and just ignored him. Iran took his money and China and North Korea.....Well, so much for that pivot towards Asia. No one on the map of nations respects weakness.....The real world isn't Google. Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Oct 2017 1.58pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
They'd been operating in Iraq since 2003, and were very active through out the decade or so. Around 2006/7 they formed ISI (Islamic State of Iraq) which was active in the formation and growth of ISIS in 2012 (ish) during the civil war, with ISI switching their focus from Iraq to the Syrian civil war, and backing Jabhat al-Nusra which would in 2013 merge with ISI to form ISIL aka ISIS. People seem to forget that the initial ISIS was an offshoot formed by the ISI. They were never not active in Iraq. I didn't say they weren't active. I specifically stated they didn't grow rapidly until the departure of US troops. What cities did IS hold in Iraq before the US departure? The US withdrawed in 2011. The first city captured was in 2014.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't remember now.....But he misread the situation on the ground and pulled out despite expressed concerns. With hindsight it should have been done slowly and carefully....well, that's my layman's view anyway. Obama was a micro manager who was useless on foreign policy. The US troop withdrawal from Iraq was negotiated and signed and cast in stone during the Bush administration in 2008. Remember when he had a shoe thrown at him? That was the joint press conference with the Iraqi Prime Minister to announce the Status of Forces Agreement that set the timetable for the complete withdrawal of US combat forces from all cities by mid-2009 and from the whole country by the end of 2011. Yes, the exit happened during Obama's administration, but he was executing a withdrawal that was handed to him by his predecessor and which was being enforced by the Iraqi government. If you want to blame the rise of ISIS on the US' withdrawal from Iraq - not an illogical position to take at all - then make sure you're blaming the right people for the decision. Hint: Obama isn't one of them.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
OK, I'm trying to think of something Obama did well on the foreign stage... Agreeing with the UN's condemnation of Israel settlements in the West Bank? Though not sure the effect of that as he was departing office.
Internationally, he was part of the Iran nuclear deal (which Trump is trying to undo), the Paris Climate Accords (which Trump is trying to undo) and he relaxed US sanctions on Cuba (which Trump is trying to undo). Not a lot, to be fair, but he did revitalize the US' image around the world (which Trump is succeeding in undoing).
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
The US troop withdrawal from Iraq was negotiated and signed and cast in stone during the Bush administration in 2008. Remember when he had a shoe thrown at him? That was the joint press conference with the Iraqi Prime Minister to announce the Status of Forces Agreement that set the timetable for the complete withdrawal of US combat forces from all cities by mid-2009 and from the whole country by the end of 2011. Yes, the exit happened during Obama's administration, but he was executing a withdrawal that was handed to him by his predecessor and which was being enforced by the Iraqi government. If you want to blame the rise of ISIS on the US' withdrawal from Iraq - not an illogical position to take at all - then make sure you're blaming the right people for the decision. Hint: Obama isn't one of them. Obama is one of them. He was talking about pulling out of Iraq all the way through his election campaign. The lack of a response presence there enabled IS to get out of hand. Obama is directly responsible for enabling that chance. I do blame Bush for a lot of things that went wrong in Iraq actually.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Obama is one of them. He was talking about pulling out of Iraq all the way through his election campaign. The lack of a response presence there enabled IS to get out of hand. Obama is directly responsible for enabling that chance. I do blame Bush for a lot of things that went wrong in Iraq actually.
I know it's convenient for you to hang this around Obama's neck, but Bush took us into Iraq and Bush took us out - both decisions being disastrous for the region and the world. Edited by Ray in Houston (25 Oct 2017 2.50pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
I know it's convenient for you to hang this around Obama's neck, but Bush took us into Iraq and Bush took us out - both decisions being disastrous for the region and the world. Edited by Ray in Houston (25 Oct 2017 2.50pm) Sophistry. 'For the first time in nine years, there are no Americans fighting in Iraq'. 'I was able to keep my promise and end the war in Iraq'. And again, Bush has plenty to be blamed for. Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Oct 2017 2.56pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I didn't say they weren't active. I specifically stated they didn't grow rapidly until the departure of US troops. What cities did IS hold in Iraq before the US departure? The US withdrawed in 2011. The first city captured was in 2014.
So three years later, at the time the US had only been in Iraq for 11 years. I don't think their growth was really dependent on the withdraw of US troops per se. The swelling of IS was more about Jabhat al-Nusra in Syria merging with ISI to form ISIL /ISIS. However, I would agree that had the US military not been scaled back, the 2014 incursion may not have occurred, or if it had, the US military would likely have achieved far greater success than the Iraqi forces that effectively were routed - and they would likely have only 'lost the first city' (as US forces were largely confined to bases at that point). Long before ISIS could have pushed forwards from that first victory, the US would have deployed its forces. It was the wrong call, with hindsight, but with the Insurgents and ISI having switched their focus to Syria and Jabhat al-Nusra in Syria, I think the US effectively misread that as achieving a false level of security. But ISIS didn't really grow as a result of the US withdrawal, it was already a fairly substantial force in Syria and Northern Iraq.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Obama is one of them. He was talking about pulling out of Iraq all the way through his election campaign. The lack of a response presence there enabled IS to get out of hand. Obama is directly responsible for enabling that chance. I do blame Bush for a lot of things that went wrong in Iraq actually. I don't think anyone was really looking at ISI. Attacks by the group with the Syrian civil war had slackened, as they'd focused their attention across the Iraqi border with Southern Syria, the same was true of Sunni Nationalists not involved with ISI as well - In both cases Jabhat al-Nusra benefited and would merge with ISI to become ISIS. Obama definitely got it wrong, as did the US military - They'd seen the 'pacification of violence in Northern Iraq' as maybe being progress politically via the elections etc.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
So three years later, at the time the US had only been in Iraq for 11 years. I don't think their growth was really dependent on the withdraw of US troops per se. The swelling of IS was more about Jabhat al-Nusra in Syria merging with ISI to form ISIL /ISIS. However, I would agree that had the US military not been scaled back, the 2014 incursion may not have occurred, or if it had, the US military would likely have achieved far greater success than the Iraqi forces that effectively were routed - and they would likely have only 'lost the first city' (as US forces were largely confined to bases at that point). Long before ISIS could have pushed forwards from that first victory, the US would have deployed its forces. It was the wrong call, with hindsight, but with the Insurgents and ISI having switched their focus to Syria and Jabhat al-Nusra in Syria, I think the US effectively misread that as achieving a false level of security. But ISIS didn't really grow as a result of the US withdrawal, it was already a fairly substantial force in Syria and Northern Iraq. IS was always going to take advantage of the situation that was created in Syria. Watching the Vietham series is fascinating for seeing certain parallels.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm seeing no argument for the benefits of the Iranian deal here. It's short term wishful thinking. From what I can see criticisms of that deal are justified. Obama made the US look weak and scared. Putin knew it and just ignored him. Iran took his money and China and North Korea.....Well, so much for that pivot towards Asia. No one on the map of nations respects weakness.....The real world isn't Google. Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Oct 2017 1.58pm) Trump is already making the US look weak though, he did nothing over North Korea, whilst talking up a crisis, and he'll do nothing over Iran. He's basically humiliated himself in regards to Russia and completely flipped his stance on China (from his election campaign). The result of all that North Korea rhetoric, he just looked stupid. North Korea knows as long as it doesn't actually attack the South, US or Japan, the US can't do anything to them. Similarly, Iran. There isn't a military solution that doesn't completely f**k up the stability of the Middle East. There is no proxy he can use to fight and back - as the US wisely did against IS. All his done, is undermine the process that the rest of the world seems to think was making progress. If he takes on Iran, the US has to win, and quickly, and then occupy another hostile Middle East nation (another Iraq and Afghanistan). Otherwise, whatever actions the US takes, will result in Iran accelerating its nuclear program, and breaking off any chance of a negotiated settlement.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I don't think anyone was really looking at ISI. Attacks by the group with the Syrian civil war had slackened, as they'd focused their attention across the Iraqi border with Southern Syria, the same was true of Sunni Nationalists not involved with ISI as well - In both cases Jabhat al-Nusra benefited and would merge with ISI to become ISIS. Obama definitely got it wrong, as did the US military - They'd seen the 'pacification of violence in Northern Iraq' as maybe being progress politically via the elections etc. Parallels with Vietham.....I think by the time Obama came along the view of getting out was more important than what happened afterwards. Bush started it and Obama ended it. Iraq being seen as Vietham had as a war that wasn't worth the cost.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Sophistry. 'For the first time in nine years, there are no Americans fighting in Iraq'. 'I was able to keep my promise and end the war in Iraq'. And again, Bush has plenty to be blamed for.
So, yes, Obama campaigned on ending the war in Iraq and withdrawing troops - which was going to happen anyway - and also on ending the war in Afghanistan, which he did not do. It's impossible to know what Obama would have done without being handcuffed by the State of Forces Agreement but, considering he tried very hard to get out from under that agreement, it seems likely that getting out of Iraq was another campaign promise he was prepared to break. Yes, taking credit for it was ugly. As I have said, there was a lot about Obama's presidency that I didn't like. Doing this was dumb politics and set Clinton up to be branded as the "creator if ISIS" by Trump. Honesty on all things at all times is the best policy; and one rarely practiced by politicians.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Trump is already making the US look weak though, he did nothing over North Korea, whilst talking up a crisis, and he'll do nothing over Iran. He's basically humiliated himself in regards to Russia and completely flipped his stance on China (from his election campaign). Well, this is widening out to another point but ok. Trump has already made more progress against NK than Obama ever did. He has China signing up to restrict trade with them coating trade in the billions. There is no humiliation on Russia that I can see. His relationship with China is still emerging. Obviously considerations like NK are part of tactics. It's not accurate to state either way yet. Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The result of all that North Korea rhetoric, he just looked stupid. North Korea knows as long as it doesn't actually attack the South, US or Japan, the US can't do anything to them. I wouldn't be so sure that Trump isn't going to drop a small nuke on Pyongyang, simultaneously carrying out massive attacks on their military on the border. You are wrong to say that couldn't or wouldn't be done. It becomes a decision. It isn't one I'd make now but it's an option. I do actually see Trump as wanting a winnable war. Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Similarly, Iran. There isn't a military solution that doesn't completely f**k up the stability of the Middle East. There is no proxy he can use to fight and back - as the US wisely did against IS. All his done, is undermine the process that the rest of the world seems to think was making progress. If he takes on Iran, the US has to win, and quickly, and then occupy another hostile Middle East nation (another Iraq and Afghanistan). Otherwise, whatever actions the US takes, will result in Iran accelerating its nuclear program, and breaking off any chance of a negotiated settlement. I don't know who has been proposing invading Iran or anywhere actually. These are economic devices in relation to Iran. Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Oct 2017 3.39pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.