You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread


Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Sep 18 9.00pm

Originally posted by Username

Would say that's a pretty big overreaction. Ayew looked neat and tidy for 60 minutes and I thought some of his link up play with Wilf and PVA was nice.

Townsend looked much better today and at least offered a threat, should have had an assist with that Sakho chance.

Kouyate gives us a presence we simply didn't have against Southampton, Watford and Liverpool, but he did fade after half time. Travels with the ball better than the rest of our midfield, although he did get caught in possession as well.

Jimmy and Luka were better today, although Luka's set pieces were dreadful.

We're not cutting teams open, but we still controlled the game and we did get in behind a couple of times. We created chances but didn't take them. We had Newcastle penned back, but our delivery from dead ball situations is so bad that we kept letting Newcastle off the hook.


This pretty much sums up my thoughts


Edited by Bexley Eagle (22 Sep 2018 9.01pm)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Sep 18 9.00pm

As for strikers neither Ayew or Sørloth have had a sniff of a goal. Ayew at least as plenty of energy. When he does get a chance hopefully he will show he can stick it away

Edited by Bexley Eagle (22 Sep 2018 9.01pm)

Edited by Bexley Eagle (22 Sep 2018 9.03pm)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 22 Sep 18 9.04pm

Originally posted by Username


Watching Søloth run 40 yards to overlap Townsend on the outside instead of getting in the box was painful.

Yes, I’d forgotten about that one!

Was sat in the Main Stand in Block B so right near where that happened. He just ended up getting in Townsends way and you could see the look on Andros’ face was just like, what on earth are you doing?!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Sep 18 9.32pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

As for strikers neither Ayew or Sørloth have had a sniff of a goal. Ayew at least as plenty of energy. When he does get a chance hopefully he will show he can stick it away

Edited by Bexley Eagle (22 Sep 2018 9.01pm)

Edited by Bexley Eagle (22 Sep 2018 9.03pm)

Positional play poor never in the box to create a chance.
Could possibly benefit from playing in a front 2 with Benteke. Lone striker role isn't for him.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Sep 18 9.45pm

Originally posted by Painter

Positional play poor never in the box to create a chance.
Could possibly benefit from playing in a front 2 with Benteke. Lone striker role isn't for him.

He's still very rusty so I'm hoping his attacking sharpness will improve. It's a relief to see a striker actually closing down, putting some effort in and contributing defensively, but I must say I was confused to see him defending a throw-in level with our six-yard box in the second half when we'd prefer him up with Zaha ready to pounce on the break.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Sep 18 10.03pm

Originally posted by Bangell

He's still very rusty so I'm hoping his attacking sharpness will improve. It's a relief to see a striker actually closing down, putting some effort in and contributing defensively, but I must say I was confused to see him defending a throw-in level with our six-yard box in the second half when we'd prefer him up with Zaha ready to pounce on the break.

Exactly my point, no strikers instinct.

 

the.universal 22 Sep 18 10.10pm

Originally posted by Bangell

He's still very rusty so I'm hoping his attacking sharpness will improve. It's a relief to see a striker actually closing down, putting some effort in and contributing defensively, but I must say I was confused to see him defending a throw-in level with our six-yard box in the second half when we'd prefer him up with Zaha ready to pounce on the break.

At that point Ayew was playing left midfield. We rotated Andros, Wilf and Ayew between the wings and the front 2 positions during the second half.

 


Vive le Roy!

samprior Flag Hamburg 22 Sep 18 10.37pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

6 games, 4 goals. 3 from Zaha, 1 from Schlupp. And only one of those games was against a top team.

Basically, when Zaha doesn't have the ball, we have no chance to score.

Ayew has done nothing so far. Invisible today.
Townsend has lost a step, and speed was his only skill. He passes like he's blindfolded.
Kouyate has done nothing. No idea what he brings.
JMac and Luka have done nothing. I'm ready to bench one of them.

Offensively, we're hopeless. Nice that we have 7 points, but it's excruciating to watch.

We'll improve as the season goes on like last year. Meyer seems like he's getting up to speed which should make us a bit more fluid. Plus fingers crossed RLC makes a return in January. He took a lot of pressure off of wilf at the back end of last year.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 22 Sep 18 11.30pm

Sorry but we need a decent striker more than Loftus-Cheek. Obv I’ll take him but if it’s between him and some top Spanish striker we could possibly get that we can somehow afford, then that should be our guy

Send benteke to Siberia

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 23 Sep 18 6.46am

Originally posted by matthau

Sorry but we need a decent striker more than Loftus-Cheek. Obv I’ll take him but if it’s between him and some top Spanish striker we could possibly get that we can somehow afford, then that should be our guy

Send benteke to Siberia

Palace buying strikers just never works out! Seems to only be successes when cheap/free/exchange. I currently can't think of many strikers that would be a good fit and affordable/availablr over RLC joining who we know at least will definitely boost our attacking play.

 

The Dolphin Flag 23 Sep 18 7.27am

I know that we can't score goals but we looked different gravy when Meyer came on yesterday.
He gave us what had been lacking throughout the game up to that point where central midfield was a wilderness.
Luka is lost without Cabaye and I hope that Meyer is the answer.
We will see but if he starts then the future is a little brighter.
We also need to do our best to get RLC again in January.
We should have won yesterday, didn't, on to Bournemouth!

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Sep 18 7.52am

I’m concerned about the lack of goals in the team.There were plenty of chances created against Newcastle but no finisher.
For all his bad form and terrible record over the last year Benteke still looks the best option which is a worry.
Townsend never looks like scoring and there is too much reliance on Zaha.
It’s a shame Sako didn’t rejoin because he does offer something different, can go past people and score goals.
If we go back to the loan market in January I hope it’s more inspiring than the recent list - Sanogo,Bamford,Adebayor,Doyle,Remy,Ameobi

 

YT Flag Oxford 23 Sep 18 8.00am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m concerned about the lack of goals in the team.There were plenty of chances created against Newcastle but no finisher.
For all his bad form and terrible record over the last year Benteke still looks the best option which is a worry.
Townsend never looks like scoring and there is too much reliance on Zaha.
It’s a shame Sako didn’t rejoin because he does offer something different, can go past people and score goals.
If we go back to the loan market in January I hope it’s more inspiring than the recent list - Sanogo,Bamford,Adebayor,Doyle,Remy,Ameobi

Not to mention Sørloth in the ‘cash’ market.

Edited by YT (23 Sep 2018 8.02am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 23 Sep 18 8.02am

Originally posted by samprior

Palace buying strikers just never works out! Seems to only be successes when cheap/free/exchange. I currently can't think of many strikers that would be a good fit and affordable/availablr over RLC joining who we know at least will definitely boost our attacking play.

We had a brilliant one in Murray. Pardew ruined that.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 23 Sep 18 8.28am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I know that we can't score goals but we looked different gravy when Meyer came on yesterday.
He gave us what had been lacking throughout the game up to that point where central midfield was a wilderness.
Luka is lost without Cabaye and I hope that Meyer is the answer.
We will see but if he starts then the future is a little brighter.
We also need to do our best to get RLC again in January.
We should have won yesterday, didn't, on to Bournemouth!

Agree. When he came on he was for me the best Palace player on the pitch.I really think he should start next game.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Sportyteacher Flag London 23 Sep 18 8.31am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m concerned about the lack of goals in the team.There were plenty of chances created against Newcastle but no finisher.
For all his bad form and terrible record over the last year Benteke still looks the best option which is a worry.
Townsend never looks like scoring and there is too much reliance on Zaha.
It’s a shame Sako didn’t rejoin because he does offer something different, can go past people and score goals.
If we go back to the loan market in January I hope it’s more inspiring than the recent list - Sanogo,Bamford,Adebayor,Doyle,Remy,Ameobi

Spot on analysis.We did not get the much needed striker in the summer transfer window and it is already proving to very telling in points attained.Tougher opposition awaits as well.

 

Aray Flag South London 23 Sep 18 8.36am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I know that we can't score goals but we looked different gravy when Meyer came on yesterday.
He gave us what had been lacking throughout the game up to that point where central midfield was a wilderness.
Luka is lost without Cabaye and I hope that Meyer is the answer.
We will see but if he starts then the future is a little brighter.
We also need to do our best to get RLC again in January.
We should have won yesterday, didn't, on to Bournemouth!

At least Roy made the substitution relatively early. God it’s so painful watching us play without a playmaker. Hardly surprising we are struggling for any fluency. Weirdly a draw is probably what we needed for Roy (in whom we trust...) to start Meyer.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 23 Sep 18 8.57am

Originally posted by Aray

At least Roy made the substitution relatively early. God it’s so painful watching us play without a playmaker. Hardly surprising we are struggling for any fluency. Weirdly a draw is probably what we needed for Roy (in whom we trust...) to start Meyer.

Yes to this as well.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Sep 18 10.02am

I've been a big critic of benteke, but we are worse off without him. We have no focal point in attack. Players were looking to put the ball into thd box and there's no one there, so we end up trying to play quick one twos to get thd ball into thd box, which doesn't work. Sad state of affairs really.

 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 23 Sep 18 10.03am

Just watched the highlights on motd and that Sakho miss is going to sting for a while , I even found myself (even though I watched the game live yesterday ) screaming at Sakho to leave it for Zaha to tap it in at the back post

 

Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread