You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 8 of 71 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
coulsdoneagle Flag London 16 Oct 18 1.09pm

You have to wonder why the HF are not where they were this year?

Surely the reasonable thing to do would have been to keep things as they are until such a time as a solution is found.

We have the main stand redevelopment in the pipeline.

There is currently a research project in to implementing safe standing underway. Should finish in 2019 and I’d imagine trials to start in 2019/20 or 20/21.

Both of these points suggest that the move to Block E will be temporary anyway.

It’s shocking how poorly this has been handled by the club, but the fact is the HF has no need to move immediately, they could have absolutely had some patience for the good of the club and the fellow fans.

 

Skip Flag 16 Oct 18 1.26pm

I have been following this with interest and there are questions that I think the E Blockers need to be asking before agreeing to move.

As mentioned in a previous post, who in HF has the inside track directly to Steve Parish. How is it possible that a small group of fans can contact the club's chairman directly and get this kind of request agreed ?

What is stopping the 400 E Block season ticket holders from applying for their existing seats stating that they want to be part of the new singing section ?

Will the season tickets that are sold for the singing section be sold individually by the box office or do they release them to HF to administer. If it is the latter what is stopping them from selling to somebody who is currently serving a football banning order ?

This whole thing is a mess and it isn't going to get any better unless the club perform an unlikely U turn. Our stadium is simply not good or large enough for the club to be able to relocate 400 loyal supporters without compromising a number of things, including view, facilities and who they sit with. How can a family of 4 that currently sit in block E be asked to move but can not be guaranteed that they will be altogether. If they do get 4 seats together it is likely that they are seats that nobody else wants.

Judging the atmosphere without HF this season should only be done after a few games that we actually play well in, score a goal and maybe record a win. Of course it's been a bit low without a goal to lift everybody.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 16 Oct 18 1.52pm

Originally posted by Skip

I have been following this with interest and there are questions that I think the E Blockers need to be asking before agreeing to move.

As mentioned in a previous post, who in HF has the inside track directly to Steve Parish. How is it possible that a small group of fans can contact the club's chairman directly and get this kind of request agreed ?

What is stopping the 400 E Block season ticket holders from applying for their existing seats stating that they want to be part of the new singing section ?

Will the season tickets that are sold for the singing section be sold individually by the box office or do they release them to HF to administer. If it is the latter what is stopping them from selling to somebody who is currently serving a football banning order ?

This whole thing is a mess and it isn't going to get any better unless the club perform an unlikely U turn. Our stadium is simply not good or large enough for the club to be able to relocate 400 loyal supporters without compromising a number of things, including view, facilities and who they sit with. How can a family of 4 that currently sit in block E be asked to move but can not be guaranteed that they will be altogether. If they do get 4 seats together it is likely that they are seats that nobody else wants.

Judging the atmosphere without HF this season should only be done after a few games that we actually play well in, score a goal and maybe record a win. Of course it's been a bit low without a goal to lift everybody.

I think the point that everyone is missing here, is that SP owns the club not you or I He does. Therefore he can pretty much do what he wants. However there a number of points from your post I wish to address firstly the HF are not 400 strong, nearer a 100, so I have no idea where you get the 400 figure from.

Have you ever stopped to think that the flat as a witches tit atmosphere may be the reason the palyers aren't sparking ?

Lastly the simple fact is the atmosphere is better with the HF, are they better fans than those mealy mouthed whingebags in block E, yes I think so they certainly do more than just turn up and watch, do they not ?

lastly they are being asked to potentially move seats, not donate a kidney or get their kids pissed on Christmas morning.

Would I move to accommodate the HF ? Absolutely the much praised atmosphere at Selhurst that made us the pride of South London has gone and its now no different to the library at the emirates without them.

Harsh but true.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Oct 18 2.08pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

there a number of points from your post I wish to address

Have you ever stopped to think that the flat as a witches tit atmosphere may be the reason the palyers aren't sparking ?

the much praised atmosphere at Selhurst that made us the pride of South London has gone and its now no different to the library at the emirates without them.

Harsh but true.

Harsh but probably not true

You claim that it's possibly the lack of atmosphere at Selhurst that results in the players not sparkling and then you refer to the same lack of atmosphere at Arsenal's ground yet their players are sparkling and they are currently fourth in the table helped by their magnificent home record

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Oct 18 2.45pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I think the point that everyone is missing here, is that SP owns the club not you or I He does. Therefore he can pretty much do what he wants. However there a number of points from your post I wish to address firstly the HF are not 400 strong, nearer a 100, so I have no idea where you get the 400 figure from.

Have you ever stopped to think that the flat as a witches tit atmosphere may be the reason the palyers aren't sparking ?

Lastly the simple fact is the atmosphere is better with the HF, are they better fans than those mealy mouthed whingebags in block E, yes I think so they certainly do more than just turn up and watch, do they not ?

lastly they are being asked to potentially move seats, not donate a kidney or get their kids pissed on Christmas morning.

Would I move to accommodate the HF ? Absolutely the much praised atmosphere at Selhurst that made us the pride of South London has gone and its now no different to the library at the emirates without them.

Harsh but true.

Last season there were around 100. One of the reasons they want to move is to expand. As SP has not given the current occupants on block E thd option to stay and join the singing section, and in his own words he knows already who will be taking those seats, I'll be amazed if the HF wont be takng over those seats..

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Oct 18 3.21pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I think the point that everyone is missing here, is that SP owns the club not you or I He does. Therefore he can pretty much do what he wants. However there a number of points from your post I wish to address firstly the HF are not 400 strong, nearer a 100, so I have no idea where you get the 400 figure from.

Have you ever stopped to think that the flat as a witches tit atmosphere may be the reason the palyers aren't sparking ?

Lastly the simple fact is the atmosphere is better with the HF, are they better fans than those mealy mouthed whingebags in block E, yes I think so they certainly do more than just turn up and watch, do they not ?

lastly they are being asked to potentially move seats, not donate a kidney or get their kids pissed on Christmas morning.

Would I move to accommodate the HF ? Absolutely the much praised atmosphere at Selhurst that made us the pride of South London has gone and its now no different to the library at the emirates without them.

Harsh but true.

I believe this is the figure quoted by SP. It is the number of ST holders who have been told to mover undoubted knowledge of the HF maybe you can explain where 400 has come from and who are the people who have obviously been promised those seats.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 16 Oct 18 3.45pm

Originally posted by becky

That's why I said 'not only'- I'm well aware that we are the source of ridicule from several quarters already!


You said "not only will our club be a laughing stock", I'm saying not only is our club (already) a laughing stock; there is a difference between the future and present tense.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Oct 18 3.50pm

Blimey, even the 'Mods' are digging each other out now. Im backing 'becky' on this one.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 16 Oct 18 4.30pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2


Would I move to accommodate the HF ? Absolutely

I take it you will be just as happy to give up your seat then to allow one of the displaced supporters to have then, along with all the others that would happily give up there seats to accommodate the HF...in a roundabout way that is what you will be doing

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 16 Oct 18 4.42pm

Originally posted by Dannyh.V2

I think the point that everyone is missing here, is that SP owns the club not you or I He does. Therefore he can pretty much do what he wants. However there a number of points from your post I wish to address firstly the HF are not 400 strong, nearer a 100, so I have no idea where you get the 400 figure from.

Have you ever stopped to think that the flat as a witches tit atmosphere may be the reason the palyers aren't sparking ?

Lastly the simple fact is the atmosphere is better with the HF, are they better fans than those mealy mouthed whingebags in block E, yes I think so they certainly do more than just turn up and watch, do they not ?

lastly they are being asked to potentially move seats, not donate a kidney or get their kids pissed on Christmas morning.

Would I move to accommodate the HF ? Absolutely the much praised atmosphere at Selhurst that made us the pride of South London has gone and its now no different to the library at the emirates without them.

Harsh but true.


Could the 24 loyal supporters who sent in emails of support over the article in question kindly note ythat you are all mealy mouthed whingebags, according to the person above. kindly address your thoughts to him.

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 16 Oct 18 4.49pm

if we had terraces, if the lower Holmesdale were terraced, I reckon the singers in that stand would congregate exactly where Parish wants the singing section. so there is a natural order that places them there.

don't get me wrong, I have immense sympathy for the block E people, but all seater stadia have made English football matches among the most sterile in Europe. Possibly the most sterile. So too has the constant renewal of the same fans in the same seats, year after year.

to that end, this is a tiny effort to redress the balance. a truly tiny effort.

another way to think of it is...what would the lower Holmesdale do if it became terraced? would several thousand people complain about the displacement, or would a return to better days be widely celebrated. I think the latter.

yet the result of terracing that stand would be far more profound.

The HF make a dire atmosphere slightly better. perhaps in the right area, and backed by the club, they could make it half decent. That's a prize worth fighting for in my book.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

becky Flag over the moon 16 Oct 18 5.17pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


You said "not only will our club be a laughing stock", I'm saying not only is our club (already) a laughing stock; there is a difference between the future and present tense.

and I am saying that not only will (our club be as it is at present) BUT ALSO ( be something even worse in the future) - so I see no fault in my phrasing at all......

and remember, you can get carded for grammar bullying now that could be a first for Hol!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

bicycle repair man 16 Oct 18 5.39pm

The so called "singers/HF" chose to be in block B,and no one forced them to move.
But they with the disgraceful backing of Parish are forcing fellow Palace supporters from their chosen seats in order to accommodate them, as if they were some kind of superior supporter, it's outrageous.

 

Lumsdero Flag 16 Oct 18 5.47pm

Without taking sides, I will be pleased with the introduction of the singing section. I feel sorry for those being forced out of their seats but at the same time this is the only way for the HF to expand and really ramp up our atmosphere.
Those who have been in those seats since their introduction, who clearly renew year on year, have had the pleasure of occupying favourable seats without question. All good things come to an end.

 

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 16 Oct 18 6.32pm

Originally posted by Isley46

Possibly the most cynical post I’ve written but……

Maybe Steve Parish didn’t give in to blackmail but orchestrated the whole thing?

Parish is not a stupid person – inheriting The Adplates Group and turning it into one of the most successful Marketing Implementation agencies in the world before selling it on to Williams Lea.

He is surrounded by highly intelligent strategists, consultants and marketing experts. Crystal Palace is a brand and like it or not the HF have been moulded into a large part of that brand. Hence the media and TV coverage they receive (which for a group of 100 is exceptional). I often wondered how this group could afford some of the displays they put on without corporate help so maybe there were deep pockets operating in the background? Parish certainly has the expertise and resource at his fingertips to organise these media displays. Seems to have closed-door meeting with the HF leaders and I also wondered how they could have so many tickets for certain away games put aside in blocks for them to pick up at pre-arranged times.
(seen this happen at the club shop)

Football will surely move into the pay per view arena in the very near future with a global pay per view audience and American backers Crystal Palace need to raise their profile abroad. They need to look good on TV (not only on the pitch but on the terrace as well). To entice an audience in what will be a crowded market you need a USP and that could well be the HF centre stage in full view of the TV cameras with a backdrop of a new main stand, Palace need to be able to show the full entertainment package. Sitting in the corner just doesn’t cut it. They need to spread to cover the whole lower Holmesdale to have the full impact.

Moving loyal block E supporters from centre stage may just be an inconvenience in the implementation of a marketing strategy. There may be an outcry from other supporters but do people really care so much? It seems most think it is an injustice but want the HF cheerleaders back as they miss the noise and entertainment they bring– especially when it’s a dull game…(Think of the HF as the crystals but on the terrace – they are the entertainment during the game – hence why some of them don’t watch the game but have their backs to it conducting the ‘singers’ – if you were a real ‘fanatic’ could you bear to not watch the game?) Sounds like Parish has already sorted out who has first shout on these centre stage seats.

Whatever happens and however much this splits the support, Crystal Palace is a business and supporters are customers – just happens that there are more potential customers outside Selhurst Park than inside. Inconveniencing / sacrificing the 400 E Blockers to implement a corporate strategy will have been considered and agreed as low-risk by consultants, business advisers and legal departments.

I would expect the rejig of the Lower Holmesdale to coincide with a few good signings to improve the team – Palace go in a winning streak and all of this will be forgotten. (Part of me doesn't think it is coincidence that the HF pulling out coincides with poor performances to get the most impact - Palace have a recent history of poor home starts to the season so as an implementation strategy the timing is perfect.)

Successful team with a high profile fan base creating a me-too scenario for armchair audience becomes a marketing man’s dream – can sell that into any media.

As I mentioned at the start of this post maybe cynical – maybe not

I’d like to think that you are wrong and way off the mark, but...

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 16 Oct 18 7.22pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Last season there were around 100. One of the reasons they want to move is to expand. As SP has not given the current occupants on block E thd option to stay and join the singing section, and in his own words he knows already who will be taking those seats, I'll be amazed if the HF wont be takng over those seats..

One of the questions this raises and i have seen no answers given by club. The 300 new singers are they existing season ticket holders? If so where do they sit? I may be cynical but suspect they do not have seasons so this is a way of getting to jump the queue for season.

The club needs to answer a few very simple question.
1) Why did they consult the HF but not the rest of the Support?
2) The Club needs to provide proof of the demand for a singing section beyond heresay
3)The New singers where are they sat

On a personal level I have no objection to singing section (so I support the concept). However the club should have been far more open in its discussions and got a clear mandate from the supporters and had a much wider dialogue over solutions. I feel that SP should resign as a director of the limited companies that own the club as due diligence in these decisions has not been clearly taken. He should hand over day to day running of the club to directors appointed by the shareholders (of which he is one) who understand how a football club is run and the importance of longterm fans.

Edited by Palace in the Blood (16 Oct 2018 7.24pm)

 

Old Chap Flag Orpington 16 Oct 18 7.26pm

Saw in the Standard that Parrish is meeting fans from block E

[Link]

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Oct 18 3.28am

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

One of the questions this raises and i have seen no answers given by club. The 300 new singers are they existing season ticket holders? If so where do they sit? I may be cynical but suspect they do not have seasons so this is a way of getting to jump the queue for season.

The club needs to answer a few very simple question.
1) Why did they consult the HF but not the rest of the Support?
2) The Club needs to provide proof of the demand for a singing section beyond heresay
3)The New singers where are they sat

On a personal level I have no objection to singing section (so I support the concept). However the club should have been far more open in its discussions and got a clear mandate from the supporters and had a much wider dialogue over solutions. I feel that SP should resign as a director of the limited companies that own the club as due diligence in these decisions has not been clearly taken. He should hand over day to day running of the club to directors appointed by the shareholders (of which he is one) who understand how a football club is run and the importance of longterm fans.

Edited by Palace in the Blood (16 Oct 2018 7.24pm)


Read palace in frog land post above you and if you read it with an open mind you will realise how far off the mark you are. To suggest SP should resign shows your total lack of understanding of the corporate structure of CPFC. it is not owned by the fans nor are the seats. Premier league football is a very odd corporate product becoming odder and more unbalanced by the season. Eventually it will change, it has to, but for the time being it is here to stay and you need to understand it and move with it or you will remain in a miserable place where you and quite a few thousand fans clearly are.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Oct 18 3.37am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Read palace in frog land post above you and if you read it with an open mind you will realise how far off the mark you are. To suggest SP should resign shows your total lack of understanding of the corporate structure of CPFC. it is not owned by the fans nor are the seats. Premier league football is a very odd corporate product becoming odder and more unbalanced by the season. Eventually it will change, it has to, but for the time being it is here to stay and you need to understand it and move with it or you will remain in a miserable place where you and quite a few thousand fans clearly are.


It is the Isley46 post that palace in frog land comments on that I refer to. Isley46 clearly has his finger on the pulse of CPFC.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Oct 18 7.43am

Originally posted by Old Chap

Saw in the Standard that Parrish is meeting fans from block E

[Link]

That's for something different according to the Standard as it's about establishing a signing section - presumably for deaf fans

 

Page 8 of 71 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic