You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Utd Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Utd Match Thread


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 27 Feb 19 10.06pm

A pity but worth remembering that their so called reserve side still featured 8 or 9 players who would walk into our first team.

I think we really missed AWB and Sakho in defence and never really got going until Max came on. Is he going to get a run in the side before the end of the season? I'm not holding my breath.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Skinnii Flag Sheffield 27 Feb 19 10.06pm

Tactical mistake from the start. The midfield was too lightweight. Should have played Kouayte to combat Pogba. Then brought on Schlupp and Meyer as their midfield tired.

 


"The object of war is not to die for your country but to make some other b*stard die for theirs" - General Patton

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 27 Feb 19 10.07pm

Originally posted by Harry Beever

Not wanting to Schlupp bash too much as he’s done some good things this game but he was found wanting for all 3 goals in my opinion and a little bench time in order.

I don't like bashing players either and he has been massively improved recently but he was rubbish tonight. He did very little right and put the team under too much pressure because he didn't commit to challenges and get stuck in.

Personally I think this is to be expected, this isn't his normal position. Although he's played left back he was always too lightweight there and in central midfield you HAVE to put your body on the line. I don't think he's used to that type of play and was fairly headless running around. It was also an obvious mismatch for him to be marking Lukaku, 3 times I counted him completely lose him from corners and they punished us.

Utd had a passenger in midfield today in Fred but they managed to make up for this by having willing runners, I think we were just second best for too much of that game in the centre of the park. We can't afford for someone to do that in our team. So I was confused why Schlupp wasn't taken off, each time we had a sub today I would have preferred Schlupp to have been the one replaced.

Oh well, not a good match, not a great result but we have a huge month coming up and we have some positivity about us currently, even the come back today was good to watch. Loved seeing Meyer, he really changed our forward movement.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 27 Feb 19 10.11pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Thought subs were bizarre today.

SChlupp having a nightmare so takes Mccarthur off. Then when we're fully in control and dominating disrupts our rhythm and brings on Benteke for Batshuyai. And to cap it all off takes off a left back for a centre mid and they immediately score from the vacant left back position. So strange

Roy must take some flak for this. Dreadful mismatch between him and Lukaku and then asking to fill a new role at the death after a bizarre sub.

Edited by Booted Eagle (27 Feb 2019 10.13pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Tyrelli Flag London 27 Feb 19 10.23pm

I was there today ... 2 soft goals, great atmosphere, our goal well taken .. Meyer needs to start !!!!!! When he came on he was istramental in our pressure .. I’m not angry today .. just disappointed

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Feb 19 10.35pm

Bit unfortunate to lose by two goals, their third was obviously a huge defensive cock up a shame because we had them running all over the place until it, satisfying though to scare them for fifteen mins.
Great man goal by Ward.

 

Bekken Flag 27 Feb 19 10.36pm


Just back from the game. Great atmosphere again, well done to all who contributed.

Meyer simply has to start. He gets the ball, turns and looks to attack the space. I don’t think I’ve ever seen him pass sideways, it’s all forward thinking and we need that to feed the runs of Townsend, Zaha and Batshuayi.

Hodgson - I have no idea what goes through his mind. 2-1 down at home, takes off Batshuayi for an ineffective Benteke then takes off PVA for Kouyate, puts Schlupp to left back for 30 seconds and we concede from that side. The way PVA ran off, I cannot imagine he had any injury concerns so that substitution baffled me.

Good performance overall. Great effort just think Hodgson needs a wake up call. The persistance with Schlupp over Meyer is becoming boring

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Feb 19 10.40pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Thought subs were bizarre today.

SChlupp having a nightmare so takes Mccarthur off. Then when we're fully in control and dominating disrupts our rhythm and brings on Benteke for Batshuyai. And to cap it all off takes off a left back for a centre mid and they immediately score from the vacant left back position. So strange

The only sub that failed was Van Aanholt's the others were good, maybe Zaha was at fault for leaving Young free.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 27 Feb 19 10.44pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

The only sub that failed was Van Aanholt's the others were good, maybe Zaha was at fault for leaving Young free.

You aren't allowed to criticise Zaha on here, everything has to be schlupps fault. Even though he did make our only goal..

 

leejaneagles Flag 27 Feb 19 10.46pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

The only sub that failed was Van Aanholt's the others were good, maybe Zaha was at fault for leaving Young free.

I think our star attacker who literally every good attack seems to go through has the right to stay forward when chasing a goal at home. It's for Schlupp to defend the left side of our own penalty box if he's been moved to left back. The blame can fall on the 2 Centre Backs or Luka if Pogba scores through the middle but Young can't be standing there on that side with a finger up his bum waiting for a tap in.

Meyer just baffles me. I have never got a players name on the back of my shirt but this guy makes me think he could easily be my favourite player and I'd wear his kit like a 5 year old...if he ever played more than 10 minutes.

Honestly I hate to say it but Meyer is so good if it comes to him or Hodgson next season I'd rather Roy walk. I'd rather he just see sense and keep them both but there's something there obviously behind the scenes.

 

jeeagles Flag 27 Feb 19 10.46pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

The only sub that failed was Van Aanholt's the others were good, maybe Zaha was at fault for leaving Young free.

We were on the ascendancy before Benteke came on.

Mayer was a great sub because he should have started.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Feb 19 10.49pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Left early for the second time.
Last time was the 3-0 defeat to Huddersfield.

Wards goal was the first in open play I’ve seen this season by a palace player.

I missed Burnley, Leicester, and Fulham so haven’t seen us win at home yet.

We’ve been awful this season. Not through lack of ability. Or lack or effort. But through complete tactical stupidity.

Schlupp had one of his better games today. But should have been all over Pogba for the entire game, but wasn’t. He’s not got the concentration. Switches to left back. United score straight away. What was the point?

Pundits are continually raving about Mayer. He can’t get a start. He comes on, we score after 5 minutes. What does he have to do to get a start?

Not picking Scott Dann. They have Pogba and Lukaku. Schlupp is left to mark Lukaku at corners. The second goal comes from a corner. We never look like a threat from corners. Why's he on the bench?

At 2-1 down he takes of our striker with 1 goal from 1 start for Benteke (3 goals since August 2017). How’s he suddenly expected to turn the fortunes around in 10 minutes against Manchester United.

Hodgson is a throwback from the Field Marshall Hague school of tactics. If it doesnt work. Try they same thing over and over again.

How long until we can get rid of him. He’s only in the job due to sentiment.

Edited by jeeagles (27 Feb 2019 10.08pm)

You cannot be serious, we were threatening a second goal for fifteen mins and had moan.u all over the place and you criticise Hodgson for one player on the pitch making one mistake to allow Young a free hit!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Feb 19 10.57pm

Originally posted by Painter

You aren't allowed to criticise Zaha on here, everything has to be schlupps fault. Even though he did make our only goal..

I thought Schlupp was our best player tonight. I do agree Meyer is a different type of player who finds space and drives forward. I wish he could shoot

 

cardiff eagle Flag 27 Feb 19 11.01pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I thought Schlupp was our best player tonight. I do agree Meyer is a different type of player who finds space and drives forward. I wish he could shoot

Arguably at fault for every goal!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Feb 19 11.05pm

A tad harsh I think. Yes went missing for the third goal but to be fair on him it was a bizarre substitution

 

Rainforest Flag London England 27 Feb 19 11.06pm

We lost to an average ManU side due to poor tactics and poor subs. We relied too much on crosses from the wide players and most of the time the ball got hit too far over the oppo danger area.

 

jeeagles Flag 27 Feb 19 11.10pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You cannot be serious, we were threatening a second goal for fifteen mins and had moan.u all over the place and you criticise Hodgson for one player on the pitch making one mistake to allow Young a free hit!

I've criticised him for at least 4 mistakes. But there are several every week. There's two mistakes highlighted in your post.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Feb 19 11.34pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

We were on the ascendancy before Benteke came on.

Mayer was a great sub because he should have started.

We sadly forgot Young was on the pitch but up until that moment after our goal we were on top and moan.u were looking worried, Meyer needs to play at least 45 mins yes ..and removing Van Aanholt is never a good idea unless injured he and Schlupp are very instrumental with us attacking with pace.
Benteke needs time on the pitch because he belongs to us and will be with us next season,

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Feb 19 12.07am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I thought Schlupp was our best player tonight. I do agree Meyer is a different type of player who finds space and drives forward. I wish he could shoot

Yes and he was involved in all the goals tonight lol and really should have done much better with one of the best chances with that header from Townsend's lovely cross, I like him because he gets himself stuck in and has a lovely pacy pass when he gets it right.
We cannot be too critical tonight on our players, we very nearly deserved a draw.

Young said that he gave us our goal ..someone needs to explain to him that every single goal scored is because of a mistake.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 Feb 19 12.27am

This was truly bizarre tonight, we played shocking until they scored twice, brought on Meyer who made us look like a different team, played likeBarcelona for 15 minutes and then Roy in his infinite wisdom decides to take off PVA and move Schlupp to left back. Was it 30 seconds later they scored down that side whilst Schlupp was still adjusting to his new role thereby killing the game? As good as Meyer’s substitution was, Kouyate for PVA was a poor decision. He should have moved Meyer to left midfield and taken Schlupp off if he wanted to bring Kouyate on.

We showed for 15 minutes tonight that Utd were there to be beaten but we just seem to lack faith when we play them. Never mind, there is always next year!

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Utd Match Thread