You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Just a bit of perspective.... Please?


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
PatrickA Flag London 01 Dec 20 1.24pm

So do we seek to sell them in January if they are surplus to requirements or if they won’t re-sign where we wish to retain them?
Celtic supposedly want Mcarthy and there is apparently interest in PVA for example.
It’s foolhardy to leave these decisions until summer.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 1.32pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

It has been reported that talks have begun with the out of contract players.

This is what I have been informed.
I anticipate that the hinges on the door marked 'Exit' will come in for some use!


 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Dec 20 1.34pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

We really need to be addressing the issue of players out of contact in the summer during the January window.
To leave it to the summer would not make sense and would run the risk of a number of players leaving for free in the summer.
For those we have no intention of keeping it surely would be prudent to try and sell them and release some value in January.
That assumes we have adequate cover in their positions.
There are rumours we are in talks with Benteke and Jairo, but I’ve heard nothing about PVA, Townsend, Sakho, Dann, Cahill, Meyer and Guiata.
Doesn’t mean talks aren’t happening, but that’s a lot of players who need their futures resolved.
All these players have a value though which could potentially be lost if it’s all left until the summer when they could potentially walk for free.
I think Riedewald has time remaining on his contract but believe the others finish in the summer.
Some would think for example it would be throwing good money after bad to offer Benteke yet another contract.
But he still has a value in the market which would be lost if his contract runs down.
Should we try and find a buyer in January then?
This approach needs to be considered for the others too, and sooner rather than later.
We’re only a few weeks from January.


I don’t think you are going to realise much of a transfer fee for any 30+ year old with a few months of their contract left.
If they have any value, they will see their contract run down, hoping to get a signing on fee with a new club.
The problem the club has, is which players to let go. Changing the team by more than 4 players doesn’t appear popular with coaches.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Dec 20 1.35pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

So do we seek to sell them in January if they are surplus to requirements or if they won’t re-sign where we wish to retain them?
Celtic supposedly want Mcarthy and there is apparently interest in PVA for example.
It’s foolhardy to leave these decisions until summer.

The question is obviously whether we have adequate replacements to step in to sustain our Premiership status.

 

GujiMadDog Flag England 01 Dec 20 2.12pm

We have started to refresh the squad with youth, albeit two years too late. Moreover its probably going to take another couple of years before we see a signifacnt drop in squad age.

The question is will we still be in the premiership while this happens. While fearing each upcomming season, the past suggests there are ususally 2, if not 3, teams that are evidently worse than us. Touch wood this will hold true going forward. And yes, like most of the premiership, i'm looking downwards not upwards... survival takes priority.

We brought in one of own, who put his faith in experienced players and tired n tested tactics to stablise a sinking ship. We have done this.

This short term measure is now evolving into a long term view. Although its too early to say whether he can take us forward with a younger squad, I am doubtful.

Sorloth left a broken man. Shorn of confidence, after being overlooked for a misfiring Benteke, he was given piecemeal oppotunities to deliver.

Alex Meyer showed creative glimpses of what he could do but didnt fit into The Hodgson Way. Now seemingly frozen out, again after being shorn of confidence, of team crying out for creativity in Wilf's absence.

Instead, we are offering another year's extension to Benteke. At least we know what we get for £100k a week here.

I hope Im proved wrong and Hodgson enables a succesful transition but like I said, I am doubtful


Edited by GujiMadDog (01 Dec 2020 2.12pm)

Edited by GujiMadDog (01 Dec 2020 2.21pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 01 Dec 20 2.59pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

We really need to be addressing the issue of players out of contact in the summer during the January window.
To leave it to the summer would not make sense and would run the risk of a number of players leaving for free in the summer.
For those we have no intention of keeping it surely would be prudent to try and sell them and release some value in January.
That assumes we have adequate cover in their positions.
There are rumours we are in talks with Benteke and Jairo, but I’ve heard nothing about PVA, Townsend, Sakho, Dann, Cahill, Meyer and Guiata.
Doesn’t mean talks aren’t happening, but that’s a lot of players who need their futures resolved.
All these players have a value though which could potentially be lost if it’s all left until the summer when they could potentially walk for free.
I think Riedewald has time remaining on his contract but believe the others finish in the summer.
Some would think for example it would be throwing good money after bad to offer Benteke yet another contract.
But he still has a value in the market which would be lost if his contract runs down.
Should we try and find a buyer in January then?
This approach needs to be considered for the others too, and sooner rather than later.
We’re only a few weeks from January.

Those players cost roughly £100m to assemble and will cost £150m to replace.

Benteke's contract renewal isn't too bad considering an unproven replacement will be £20m on the same wage. Although I can see us signing Bats too.

We need to keep Benteke, Reidewald, Townsend and Guiata to avoid a hole in the first team.

Given Dann and Cahill's age I'd opt for keeping Sakho.

Would like to keep Meyer, but doubt he wants to stay, and we have a lot of poor midfielders.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Dec 20 3.05pm

Originally posted by GujiMadDog

We have started to refresh the squad with youth, albeit two years too late. Moreover its probably going to take another couple of years before we see a signifacnt drop in squad age.

The question is will we still be in the premiership while this happens. While fearing each upcomming season, the past suggests there are ususally 2, if not 3, teams that are evidently worse than us. Touch wood this will hold true going forward. And yes, like most of the premiership, i'm looking downwards not upwards... survival takes priority.

We brought in one of own, who put his faith in experienced players and tired n tested tactics to stablise a sinking ship. We have done this.

This short term measure is now evolving into a long term view. Although its too early to say whether he can take us forward with a younger squad, I am doubtful.

Sorloth left a broken man. Shorn of confidence, after being overlooked for a misfiring Benteke, he was given piecemeal oppotunities to deliver.

Alex Meyer showed creative glimpses of what he could do but didnt fit into The Hodgson Way. Now seemingly frozen out, again after being shorn of confidence, of team crying out for creativity in Wilf's absence.

Instead, we are offering another year's extension to Benteke. At least we know what we get for £100k a week here.

I hope Im proved wrong and Hodgson enables a succesful transition but like I said, I am doubtful


Edited by GujiMadDog (01 Dec 2020 2.12pm)

Edited by GujiMadDog (01 Dec 2020 2.21pm)

Nice to see you back Guji, hope all is well, miss our drinking episodes, tho, time & circumstance change things. Stay safe my friend.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 3.15pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Those players cost roughly £100m to assemble and will cost £150m to replace.

Benteke's contract renewal isn't too bad considering an unproven replacement will be £20m on the same wage.
Although I can see us signing Bats too.

We need to keep Benteke, Reidewald, Townsend and Guiata to avoid a hole in the first team.

Given Dann and Cahill's age I'd opt for keeping Sakho.

Would like to keep Meyer, but doubt he wants to stay, and we have a lot of poor midfielders.

I am questioning the rationale of extending the contract of a 30 year old striker who has constantly failed to deliver in front of goal season on season and rewarding his dismal and failed efforts with an extension to a lucrative contract.
He has scored just 6 PL goals since the start of the 2017-18 season and supporters just don't expect him to score anymore.

We will be a 'Laughing stock' in football if Benteke's contract is extended.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Dec 20 3.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am questioning the rationale of extending the contract of a 30 year old striker who has constantly failed to deliver in front of goal season on season and rewarding his dismal and failed efforts with an extension to a lucrative contract.
He has scored just 6 PL goals since the start of the 2017-18 season and supporters just don't expect him to score anymore.

We will be a 'Laughing stock' in football if Benteke's contract is extended.

I will Boycott attending matches until the New Year if Benteke's contract is renewed. I urge others to follow.

 


Red and Blue Army!

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Dec 20 3.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am questioning the rationale of extending the contract of a 30 year old striker who has constantly failed to deliver in front of goal season on season and rewarding his dismal and failed efforts with an extension to a lucrative contract.
He has scored just 6 PL goals since the start of the 2017-18 season and supporters just don't expect him to score anymore.

We will be a 'Laughing stock' in football if Benteke's contract is extended.

Should have ditched him last time round. I truly believe that Sorloth could have amassed a greater total, Benteke is that useless! Talk of keeping him must be Stockholm Syndrome associated.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 3.22pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I will Boycott attending matches until the New Year if Benteke's contract is renewed. I urge others to follow.

Serious questions will be asked.
Benteke offers precious little and he drains the club's finances.
Let us not forget his contract has already been extended and he has not delivered.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 Dec 20 3.25pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I will Boycott attending matches until the New Year if Benteke's contract is renewed. I urge others to follow.

WOW, thats a tad harsh, cant you a least relinquish & attend 1? You could at least have a 'Tekkers Out' flag/scarf on show, nes par.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Dec 20 4.00pm

If ben went to Sheffield u or fulham he would bag up I'm sure. Ball in the box early from both.
Fulham have mitrovic and Sheffield have mcburnie.
Double those up and goals will flow.
Sadly our style doesnt allow him the chances.
Most strikers get 4 or 5 a game and pop 1 or 2 goals. He gets 2 chances a game and is expected to get a double. We use inverted wingers purely because if they come inside and shoot it's on their good foot. Who cares just get it in the box ffs.

 

cantrbury eagle Flag Canterbury 01 Dec 20 5.09pm

Oliie Mcburie has no goals this season Mitrovic has 2 goals hardly prolific

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Dec 20 6.41pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

WOW, thats a tad harsh, cant you a least relinquish & attend 1? You could at least have a 'Tekkers Out' flag/scarf on show, nes par.

'Get your Tekkers out' T-shirt sounds cool.

 


Red and Blue Army!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Dec 20 6.42pm

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

Oliie Mcburie has no goals this season Mitrovic has 2 goals hardly prolific

Our next two signings should fit right in then.

 


Red and Blue Army!

jeeagles Flag 01 Dec 20 6.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am questioning the rationale of extending the contract of a 30 year old striker who has constantly failed to deliver in front of goal season on season and rewarding his dismal and failed efforts with an extension to a lucrative contract.
He has scored just 6 PL goals since the start of the 2017-18 season and supporters just don't expect him to score anymore.

We will be a 'Laughing stock' in football if Benteke's contract is extended.

Its a fair question. Lots of people on here are claiming that we need a huge clear out, failing to realise that a high turn over of players ie expensive and risky.

We don't want to end up without a recognised striker. £5m for an extension isn't that much when you consider we paid £4m for Jordan Mutch.

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Dec 20 7.37pm

While I understand the emotional debate around Benteke as a high profile signing on high wages who has largely disappointed, the issue is wider than just him.
The club has a decision to make on others who have featured in the first team more than Benteke.
PVA and McCarthy are interesting clubs apparently and I would imagine we could sell for a collective sum of in excess of £7 million in January - lower than their value because of the few months left on their contracts.
Now the club could take a decision that we have to retain them as to sell them would weaken the squad too much.
But it does mean they could walk for free in the summer if we don’t extend.
In the normal course of events I wouldn’t be disappointed if we sold Townsend in January to release some value, but obviously this would be crazy if we didn’t have a ready made replacement as we’re short of wingers as it is.
But it does mean again we could lose him for free in the summer.
If we were to buy Sarr (unlikely) or Bright Samuel and get say Bolassie on loan it would allow us to consider selling Townsend in January.
I feel it’s a dangerous game to have seven players of the 25 man squad with contracts ending in the summer and think it would be sensible to start the rebuilding process in January.

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 01 Dec 20 8.35pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

While I understand the emotional debate around Benteke as a high profile signing on high wages who has largely disappointed, the issue is wider than just him.
The club has a decision to make on others who have featured in the first team more than Benteke.
PVA and McCarthy are interesting clubs apparently and I would imagine we could sell for a collective sum of in excess of £7 million in January - lower than their value because of the few months left on their contracts.
Now the club could take a decision that we have to retain them as to sell them would weaken the squad too much.
But it does mean they could walk for free in the summer if we don’t extend.
In the normal course of events I wouldn’t be disappointed if we sold Townsend in January to release some value, but obviously this would be crazy if we didn’t have a ready made replacement as we’re short of wingers as it is.
But it does mean again we could lose him for free in the summer.
If we were to buy Sarr (unlikely) or Bright Samuel and get say Bolassie on loan it would allow us to consider selling Townsend in January.
I feel it’s a dangerous game to have seven players of the 25 man squad with contracts ending in the summer and think it would be sensible to start the rebuilding process in January.

Renewing Benteke's contract is like having a semi-delapidated Sierra Cosworth in the garage which you're always "buying parts" for - in the hopeful expectation you'll find the time to restore it.

But in reality, at some point it will be taken down the scrappy unfulfilled - good money having chased bad money down the drain.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Dec 20 8.35pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Why don’t you try getting your facts right. Where have I slaughtered the manager? I don’t agree with his approach as is my right and I believe his tactical set up and substitutions hinder our progress, again as s my right.

As for the rest, it was suggested by numerous posters that our players are too old to press the opposition and play on the front foot so I merely suggested a way of getting the most out of our older midfielders by getting them to maximise their effort early on and replacing them earlier in the game.

You refer to it as Sunday League or kids football. Well in rugby it’s referred to as impact substitutions for exactly the reason that players have run their balls off and need to be replaced.

You also simplified your point to suit your agenda. What I suggested doesn’t need to be inflexible and with the advent of 5 substitutions is exactly what most teams will be doing.

You are quick to ridicule and protect your precious Roy. Try thinking about the benefits of a different approach that maximises the ability of the limited squad we have.

Here's a little clue. Describing those that don't think the manager should be sacked as idiots isn't exactly complimentary to either.

With regard to my precious Roy, results and performances over the last few months mean his job is close to being on the line and if they continue to slide then a change will be necessary. As has been said many times, any manager is only six or seven games from the sack. However, given our prior record with managers and their integrity we have been bloody fortunate to have him for the last three years and he's deserving of a bit more respect than he's been afforded on here for much of the last eighteen months.

My comments about the substitutes were relatively polite and my view hasn't changed.


 

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?